Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DW insistent that everyone has 'childhood trauma'

117 replies

AugustSlipsAway · 07/10/2023 11:14

Been married to DW (we're both women) for 5 years and I feel like this issue is driving us apart.

DW has been NC with her parents since she was in her early 20s.

My mum is one of my best friends. Once every 1-2 weeks, usually during my lunch break, my mum and I would meet at this lovely cafe 10 minutes walk from my house catch up and try out their new coffees/pastries. Once a month we will go hiking together on Saturday or Sunday.

DW hates leaving the house (it used to be less extreme but now she is basically homebound and would rather spend all day watching YouTube) which I don't mind that much if it weren't for the fact that she doesn't like it when I go for these lunches or hikes with my mum. She's invited but she doesn't want to go as there will be noise/crowds. She hates the outdoors. She says she has nothing to say to my mum.

We got into an argument a few times, and she's insisted that she doesn't understand how a grown adult can be so close to their parents and that it's obsessive. She also insists that everyone has childhood trauma and it's stupid and naive if someone doesn't realise they have it because it's impossible for anyone to make it out of childhood without having some sort of trauma.

Asked her to give me some examples and she brings up heated arguments/debates we had during periods of stress. I cry when I'm stressed. 10 minutes after the issue is over, it's settled and I'm happy again. DW thinks this is her 'gotcha' point about how I have unresolved childhood trauma. It's irritating and quite insulting, actually.

AIBU to think that not everyone has childhood trauma? I just enjoy spending time with my mum ffs and every week I have to sit through this lecture with DW instead.

OP posts:
SchoolQuestionnaire · 07/10/2023 12:38

Aquamarine1029 · 07/10/2023 11:34

No your wife is totally wrong there. Not everyone has had childhood trauma and I find it incredulous that she actually thinks this is true.

The op's wife knows full well this isn't true, she just saying this to control and gaslight the op. It's a tactic of a garden variety abuser. She's trying to alienate the op from everyone else in her life.

This.

Op you know yanbu spending time with your dm or anyone else. She doesn’t want you to so she’s trying to make it seem odd or strange. It’s really not, it’s perfectly normal to spend time with your dm.

It is not normal to think spending time with your parents is obsessive or to believe that everyone has unresolved childhood trauma. The only one causing you trauma here is your batshit dw with her ridiculous opinions. Please don’t listen to her. I would give anything to have my dm back and meet her for lunch or a coffee. You and your dm have a lovely relationship, make the most of it.

Sparkletastic · 07/10/2023 12:34

She sounds very mentally ill but that is not a problem for you to solve.

Mummy08m · 07/10/2023 12:32

Op have you ever heard of hikikomori? It's a Japanese word for a person who withdraws from social life, stays at home and spends most of the time on the Internet, for years. Usually a young person, and nearly always financially supported/housed in a stable way by someone else (eg parents or in your case spouse). Often men but over 40% women. It can be caused by trauma but it often isn't. They cause untold worry and misery to their loved ones.

It's not a self limiting behaviour, it usually just gets worse and worse. Depending on the bits of the Internet they use, they can become radicalised politically, or by the incel community, or eating disorders, etc. Other behaviours can include hoarding.

Your dw might not have this/be like this. It's just a thing I've read about that you've reminded me of.

In any case, though, if I were you, I'd leave. I'd only put up with this from my own child, not from a spouse or anyone else. A spouse should enrich your life and ease your burdens.

Anonymouseposter · 07/10/2023 12:28

She sounds mentally unwell and is feeding it by reading too much pop psychology and negativity on the internet. I think most people have some upsetting experiences in childhood but that not everyone has experiences that are so out of the ordinary that they would be termed traumatic. Your relationship with your Mum sounds normal and pleasant. Don’t let her pull you down with her. Either detach a bit and do your own thing while encouraging her to get help or make a decision to walk away.

Conkersinautumn · 07/10/2023 12:25

I definitely have childhood trauma, and costly therapy to move forwards. I don't think everyone does but I think a lot of people normalise / have normalised very damaging behaviour and have poor boundaries when it comes to their families.

Nn9011 · 07/10/2023 12:22

I don't think this is her getting sucked in by social media - she probably is using it to disassociate which is making her feel worse. This is probably burnout/depression from not dealing with her trauma. I've experienced this myself and the only way she'll get better is if she wants to. I'd recommend she speaks to her gp and looks at meds to help with the immediate feelings and then counselling to deal with it. Please be patient but explain your concerns clearly and constructively.

Willyoujustbequiet · 07/10/2023 12:20

It's offensive to those who have experienced actual trauma to suggest everyone has.

Bit like the everyone's a little bit autistic/OCD/depressed etc brigade.

She sounds like she's projecting/jealous

EmmaEmerald · 07/10/2023 12:19

SausageinaBun · 07/10/2023 11:35

Trauma is a bit of a fad at the moment. Of course some people have experience childhood trauma. But if you look around, it's being used to explain all sort of stuff. Schools are full of "trauma informed behaviour" approaches and quite a lot of it is complete bollocks.

Has your DP picked this up from social media?

I'd wonder this too

I increasingly come across this idea that everyone has trauma. Makes a lot of money for therapists.

I'm pleased to see the vote on here. I thought a lot of MNers would agree with her.

Kilminchy123 · 07/10/2023 12:18

She just can’t imagine herself having a lovely bond with her parents like you do as that isn’t a possibility for her due to her childhood and NC with her parents - so to her it seems a bit mad which is unreasonable for her to not open her eyes to the reality that everyone’s bond with their parents are different. I personally had a very f’d up childhood and am now realising even more so as an adult and parent myself, but my partners seemed like something out of a lovely movie ! Which can seem mad to me (only because I can’t believe some people are so lucky lol) but I would never dismiss that as that is his reality and we strive to have that reality for our own children. How mean of her to make you question your bond honestly

RockStarship · 07/10/2023 12:18

She sounds like a very unhappy person, with issues from her past which are affecting her deeply now, made worse by constantly watching drivel on the internet which is most definitely exacerbating the problem.

Social media is dreadful for people's mental health for a number of reasons but one of them is that in places like TikTok there are huge numbers of supposedly knowledgeable people taking umbrage at all sorts of silly and minor issues as well as major ones, and it all rolls into this idea of the world and humanity being doomed. The people preaching to others are all messed up in their heads as well, so this idea of knowledgeable people who can lead you out of the doom and into the light if you just follow their (usually ridiculous) advice is nothing more than illusion.

Your DW needs to cut herself off from it all, leave the house and get back to the real world. I did this a month ago and I can't tell you the sense of relief and lightness I now feel away from the social media whiners and manipulators.

CopperLion · 07/10/2023 12:15

No OP, your relationship with your mum sounds lovely. Your marriage maybe less so. It sounds as though your DW would benefit from some help working through her own stuff.

Createausername1970 · 07/10/2023 12:14

I think she sounds in a bad head space. Jealousy? Depression? Unresolved trauma? A bit of all three and more?

You loved your wife enough to marry her and saw a future for you both. I think you need to try to resolve this if you can. See if she will acknowledge this is an issue and is open to support etc. If she remains adamant this is what she wants going forward, then you should consider your options and tell her how you feel.

As you go hiking with your mum most weekends, could you arrange to stay overnight at your mum's. Have a conversation with your DW and then give her time and space to consider what's been said?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 07/10/2023 12:14

I'd venture that most, if not all, people have experienced some Adverse Childhood Experiences. However, many have protective factors that mean those experiences are dealt with in ways that increases resilience and do not result in unresolved trauma.

For example, somebody may experience a close relative dying. With strong protective factors, such as one or two loving parents, a supportive wider family, good, caring, well resourced school, a secure and good condition home and adequate income to meet their physical and emotional needs, it becomes a sad bereavement that they come to terms with.

However, add in the loss of that person meaning a parent was unable to care adequately for them, abuse, poverty and insecure or inadequate housing, a long drawn out and painful demise or a sudden death in the child's presence, lack of support from school, bullying, illness, disability, SEND not being identified and handled adequately, a loss of friends, further bereavements, experiencing systemic discrimination such as for ethnicity/faith/now being in a single parent or no parent family, etc - and the continuing tally of ACEs result in unhealed trauma wounds that can carry into the next generation as well as throughout adulthood.

Sounds like your DW cannot see beyond her own trauma, which is what multiple ACEs can do to somebody. And instead of gaining insight that whilst most people do have sad or unpleasant things in their childhood, some don't (lucky them - and I mean that, that's great) and some do, but they are adequately supported to develop that resilience, possibly because they experienced a smaller number in all.

At the moment, she's using the accusations possibly because she cannot imagine that somebody can't have experienced everything or because she's looking for reasons to justify her continuing exactly as she is whilst you facilitate her not making that scary change to how she sees and responds to life. And she's probably at best envious of what you do have whilst being resentful that she doesn't, so it's safer in her mind to denigrate it because then it's not such a stark difference between what the two of you experienced. 'I didn't want it anyway, it's shit and all fake, anyhow' when it's something she desperately craved as a child and still as an adult.

It could also be that she thinks if you realise from your support that this is not a healthy situation - where she controls things - that you'll stop enabling her, which is a threat; your positive relationships are a threat to her position.

Do you have to remain in that situation if it's making you unhappy? No, not at all. You're not her therapist and you don't owe anybody that. You also don't owe her practical, physical, financial or emotional support to stay as she is - or to change. If you look closely at the exact dynamics in your relationship, could they be one of rescuer and victim or controlled by the fear of reactions? Could they, if you take out the sex of both of you and look at it purely in terms of behaviour, not sex, be interpreted as an abusive and coercive relationship such as described in Why Does He Do That? Does she only stop once you cry and then say it's your fault and you're reacting wrongly because of your 'failure' to accept your loving parent is actually not loving? Looking at it dispassionately, does she benefit from you losing the external support and care if you reject your mother? Is your relationship with your Mum an obstacle for her to overcome?

notfeeblebutPhoebe · 07/10/2023 12:13

I remember that 20 or 30 years back, hypnotists were 'releasing' memories of past lives.
Everyone's fantasy, Russian daughter of a Tsar, housemaid country house like Downton.
Someone has been persuading your DW and making her fearful. Has she paid money to anyone for 'therapy' you are not sure of?

Lookatmytoes · 07/10/2023 12:10

My partner has a poor relationship with his family and rarely leaves the house. These things and the accompanying MH conditions are probably linked. I have a wide circle of friends and good relationships with my family. He never wants to undermine these relationships and never begrudges my time with them. That is what I would expect if someone able to put me first instead of making everything about them.

Lentilweaver · 07/10/2023 12:10

The problem here is not the OP's relationship with her parents. The problem is that her wife is seriously mentally ill. The title should have been "Is it reasonable for my wife to spend 15 hours a day on the net and never leave the house?"

MidnightOnceMore · 07/10/2023 12:05

Every child experiences negative emotions such as anger, frustration, worry, jealousy etc. These feelings come even if you are very lucky overall - they are part of human life.

But of course not everyone suffers actual childhood trauma.

I do think more people suffer trauma than we like to acknowledge as a society - because if we did acknowledge it we might have to do something about it!

It sounds like your wife is projecting and may be struggling with the juxtaposition between her family situation and yours. You're allowed to have these positive interactions with your mum. Your wife needs help with her feelings about them. If she won't accept help, you may need to set very clear boundaries (no more discussion of this, no lectures). If the boundaries are not respected, you've got a problem.

ladyvimes · 07/10/2023 12:04

My grandad sat on my a La crate kitchen and broke it to pieces. That was definitely traumatic!

Chocolatepeanutbuttercupsandicecream · 07/10/2023 12:04

I think it’s a very rare person who had a truly idyllic childhood, most (if not all) people will have experienced some kind of adverse event. However, for the majority who had mostly positive experiences, that won’t necessarily manifest as what we would describe as childhood trauma. FWIW I don’t think it sounds remotely like you spend an unreasonable amount of time with your mum, and it’s lovely you have such a good relationship.

PerspiringElizabeth · 07/10/2023 12:03

DW seems extreme for sure.

I used to feel kind of guilty by being scarred by minor (in my adult view) things that happened to me as a child. But then my therapist friend told me that when you’re a kid, the worst thing that has happened to you is still the worst thing that has happened to you.

If you are traumatised by being laughed at in a whole-school assembly for example, that is still huge and formative to your little 8 year old brain. And thank GOD that’s the worst you’d been through! We can still carry these things through to adulthood.

Beachwalker66 · 07/10/2023 12:03

She sounds very mentally unwell.

I had an abusive childhood. People probably wouldn’t believe some of the things my mother did to me. I’m NC.

I am slightly envious of friends who have “normal “ relationships with their mums. The relationship you describe with your mum doesn’t sound enmeshed or abnormal to me, it sounds absolutely lovely and healthy. It’s not right that your wife is trying to paint it as odd. Even more concerning that she thinks everyone has had an abusive childhood.

Only you know if this marriage is salvageable or not, but keep your mum close.

IslaWinds · 07/10/2023 12:01

Toxic or damaged, could be either. It’s not your job to fix her though, and you can’t that’s what professionals are for. If she won’t get help, it’s perfectly fair to end the marriage.

DarkWingDuck · 07/10/2023 12:01

This doesn’t sounds like it’s about whether or not everyone has childhood trauma at all. This sounds from your post like an emotionally abusive relationship. Sorry OP.

Childhood often is difficult, most people have adverse experiences, the schooling system hasn’t got enough funding to help kids flourish. Most people will have some negative experiences as children. Many people do go on to have great relationships, okay relationships and good enough relationships with their parents. Whether you do or do not have “childhood trauma” has nothing to do with this she is just using the trauma topic to berate you and cut you off from your family.

AugustSlipsAway · 07/10/2023 12:00

Lentilweaver · 07/10/2023 11:49

She really needs help. She is not well. This is not just incompatibility. It's very easy to get sucked into You Tube and Tiktok, and then get very depressed. She needs to go out and touch the grass.

I hate to blame social media but this definitely started when she began spending all day on social media. She was unemployed for 4 months before she started her current PT job, and 10-14 hours of scrolling was the norm.

Everyday there was a new grievance and I even started hearing full-on rants about American social and political issues that were completely unrelated to us!!

I tried to be understanding because I've been unexpectedly laid off too so I know how hard it is but there's a limit and these days I feel like I'm at that limit.

OP posts:
IslaWinds · 07/10/2023 11:59

AugustSlipsAway · 07/10/2023 11:47

No intentions of having kids together. That's what I've been thinking these days too. She didn't use to be like this. These past few months she just seems to be getting more and more negative and hateful and her whole days are now just filled with her 'doom-scrolling' on YouTube/reddit/TikTok for hours on end.

Sadly I can see the end of the relationship as we behave more like roommates most days but it's a massive upheaval. I know this can't go on forever though.

That does sound like depression as well. It can be painful if you have had an abusive childhood to see your partner/friends interacting with their loving parents. Especially if you cannot fully face how bad your childhood was. You go into grieving for the child you were and what you should have had, but never got. So depression and denial sets in.

I think your DW needs some help for her mental health. She’s put a shell around herself. Facing an abusive childhood, talking about it, being validated that it was horrific and not normal almost retraumatises because it’s reopening old psychic wounds that you might have thought you had left behind you and got over. So that’s what is meant by therapy is hard work. You have to poke at that deep hurt and feel it while with a therapist to truly process it. She will know that it will hurt to talk about it, so she distracts herself by doom scrolling and avoiding situations that would remind her of how bad her parents were such as seeing a happy mother-daughter relationship.