Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate London

83 replies

rainbowsinthemorning · 07/10/2023 08:49

I've lived in London my whole life, right now I'm living very central. My current partner (not the father of my dc) loves London. I feel like I'm drowning in the sound of traffic, don't want to leave my windows open as I'm worried about how the pollution will effect my DC, hate the school run for the same reasons. I'm so so desperate to leave the city, I crave the sound of nature and the fresh air but he just doesn't want to leave. We don't live together right now. AIBU to think it's never going to work with us as I can't see myself ever being happy here and he doesn't want to leave. All I can think about is what harm it's doing to my DC and it's sending my anxiety through the roof.

OP posts:
MariaMeringue · 07/10/2023 10:58

I would definitely recommend moving out of London, but not too far away.

I absolutely loved living in London and couldn't imagine ever being happy anywhere else. I thrived on its busyness and energy - until I had my first DC and went on maternity leave and then I started to feel differently. By the time I had my second DC (they're just under a year a half apart), London had completely lost its appeal and felt too busy and polluted. I started to feel stressed and anxious all the time, as getting anywhere further than walking distance away was such a hassle with two very small children, even though I was very fortunate to live in a lovely part of London (next to the river in Putney). I always seemed to be either stuck in traffic or trying to get a double buggy on and off the bus. And parking outside my home was always difficult as the residents' permit zone covered about ten streets, so I'd often have to park on the next street and struggle to my front door with shopping bags in one hand and carrying my DD in her car seat in the other, while trying to stop my toddler DS from running into the road.

We moved to a town 20 miles away, that's now on the Elizabeth line. The lifestyle change was unbelievable. We could afford a house with a driveway and a proper garden and not just a maisonette with a tiny dark courtyard. There are so many green spaces and parks everywhere, a choice of lovely primary schools with big playing fields and a proper feeling of living in a community. And in less than half an hour I can be in central London.

I knew no one here when we moved, and it took about six months to feel settled and to stop constantly driving back to Putney to see my old friends. But it's such a friendly place and having young DC made it easy to make friends with local parents ( I volunteered to be on the committee at toddler group, joined the PTA, helped out at Brownies etc.).

Now my DC are late teens and pretty independent, I've rediscovered my love for London and go there often, but it's such an easy train journey I feel like I have the best of both worlds living here and would never want to move back.

Bruisername · 07/10/2023 10:55

Isometimeswonder · 07/10/2023 10:51

Why should he? You could say if she loves him she'd stay!

The difference is that she has a child to consider

Isometimeswonder · 07/10/2023 10:51

DustyLee123 · 07/10/2023 08:51

You need to do what you want. If he really loves you he’d follow you. Put yourself and your kids first.

Why should he? You could say if she loves him she'd stay!

Lamelie · 07/10/2023 10:45
Flowers I’m currently in leafy zone 2 and love it. 3 up to end of primary in zone 1 and also loved it- but I did notice a really pull to get out of town at the weekends which vanished when we had a garden. One thing that did help in zone 1 was a whole house hepa filter. Obviously that’s not feasible but look into a smaller unit. I’ve got one arriving today as chesty dh is moaning about the open fire and I’d rather get rid of him than it 😬 It does sound as if you don’t need to be in London and should move- don’t worry about moving schools. I literally can’t think of one child from my DCs peers who went reception- yr13 in the same or even feeder schools. The disadvantages of moving school (losing friends and disruption to learning) are one thing that social media and the internet fixes. And the advantages- not being stuck as the whatever one, learning to adapt and make new friends are massive.
Usernamen · 07/10/2023 10:44

rainbowsinthemorning · 07/10/2023 09:08

Currently renting (at an extortionate rate) which leaves nothing left over to save but I do have some savings set aside from before ds was born (not much but something for a rainy day). I work full time. I have no family or friends left in London as all have bought in cheaper areas. Tbh I'd probably have a better support network outside London. I feel so trapped and just want to do wants right for my ds. I also don't want to move/change schools more than once so want to get it right.

OMG, just go for it, OP!

I love London beyond comprehension, always have, but you sound so unhappy in your situation. You really owe it to yourself to live where you want to live. Good luck.

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/10/2023 10:41

Good advice, especially if you have always lived in London.

Mr Monkey has no idea about living in places with minimal public transport or very few restaurants. It completely freaks him out that my dad's village has no pavements and we have to take a torch when we go to the pub.

Crikeyalmighty · 07/10/2023 10:40

@rainbowsinthemorning could you look somewhere like Ham or Teddington or Hampton or north kingston- still easy to get in but bushy and Richmond park and hampton lido plus riversides are great for that lots of space and nature feel

VestaTilley · 07/10/2023 10:34

Could you live in a quieter, greener part of the city? Eg Greenwich or Brockley where there are a lot of parks (would need to be well away from main roads though as air pollution still bad there).

Or a suburb out in Bromley towards Orpington? Technically London but right near Kent countryside, and cheaper than Surrey or Herts direction? Or Herts itself - St Albans or Harpenden?

What do you do for work and how old is your DC? If they’re healthy and don’t have asthma and are happy at school I wouldn’t leave unless you absolutely hate it.

If you do leave please don’t go properly rural at first - it’s a huge change which you may find very isolating.

RedHelenB · 07/10/2023 10:34

You can be just as anxious anywhere. I'd start with sorting the anxiety and then see how you feel.

1month · 07/10/2023 10:32

I live in Cornwall surrounded by fields.

My dream is to live in central London.

I can’t think of anything better than being able to walk out of your door and go for a walk around the block, walk to a park, walk to a shop, go and see a show, join a hobby etc.

It just sounds so much more convenient and I think my quality of life would improve.

I will probably move in a couple of years time once my DC have finished school, but I’ve not looked into it properly yet as I probably wouldn’t be able to afford it.

My concern for both of us, is that the grass isn’t always greener.

I know lots of people who have moved down from London.
Some of them absolutely love it but many hate it and move back or try and move back.

If I was you I would look into living just outside of London if possible.
So you can keep your relationship and be close to your home town but still more rural.
Your kids will also be able to see their friends and do the things they’re used to, as well as having a more country lifestyle.

I assume this would cost more than living in central London but I’m not sure.

ChaosAndCrumbs · 07/10/2023 10:29

I love London and it was fun having my DS early childhood there. However, I do think lots of factors play into this. We loved the museums and parks, we were in easy reach of woods and there are plenty of events held in London suitable for all ages. It can be easier to get a Saturday job for teenagers and has great transport links. But someone trying to have 3 children in a squashed flat with no garden in a high crime area next to a main road will have a very different experience to someone in a garden flat or terraced house in a lower crime area with more space and outside access.

Equally, since moving to the countryside I’ve not missed the traffic noise - which I found stressful. We don’t regret our move, but both of us felt ready for it. We were similar in only wanting to move once but our settling in period was a bit screwed up by COVID and prior to that my husband was staying half the week in London to work, which was pretty stressful. For us, it was a financial decision based around the life we wanted, which didn’t end up being possible in London due to high rents and high house prices.

What has your partner said when you explain how much you feel it’s affecting you? We live in Wales and have two cities within driving distance (one only 20 mins away in good traffic), but our house is up a mountain in a village and we can see the sea. Is it London specifically your partner wants or could he compromise living in the countryside and working in a city?

Just editing to add, I think you added in a subsequent post about high rental price etc. which is why I haven’t suggested suburbs, which are pretty expensive. We couldn’t afford the south of England at the time so looked in far cheaper areas all over the UK before settling on Wales. If you can afford the south of England, Hertfordshire could be a good bet. I lived there for some of my childhood and it was easy reach of London, but had plenty of countryside.

Butterfly898 · 07/10/2023 10:17

I am in the same situation, live in zone 2/3 border and desperately want to leave because of my DD and my partner says no. I want to move back up north, it just feels so unsafe and polluted here. Just sending solidarity really, I totally get it.

theduchessofspork · 07/10/2023 10:14

Well move if you want to - or maybe try a leafy bit of zone 4 first? That might allow you not to ditch your partner / your child’s father figure.

Kitkatcatflap · 07/10/2023 10:12

Be careful what you wish for ...... I lived in London, not central zone 3. We moved back to DH's country and now I live in rural Sweden. I live in a huge house but it is SO BORING. The locals are cold, not just me was talking to a woman from Eritrea the other day - she has been here 10 years and does not have one Swedish friend despite working and children in school. I would move back to London in a heartbeat but have been out priced.

Is there some compromise? Can you move to the outskirts? Commuting distance for your partner. It shouldn't be too hard if you don't live with your partner. It doesn't have to be Devon or Isle of Skye.

Saschka · 07/10/2023 10:10

Gettingbysomehow · 07/10/2023 09:37

I was brought up in London, I hated it. I wanted to live in the country with my grandparents.
Now I live in deepest rural Somerset and love every day of my life. If you want something you have to make it happen. Don't bother trying to persuade your boyfriend just go.

See, I was brought up in a village in Sussex and was bored rigid - nowhere to go, no buses, roads not safe for cycling, couldn’t even see my friends unless DM gave me a lift.

Moved to London and life is great! 🤣

Ginmonkeyagain · 07/10/2023 10:06

Good advice @Pinkdelight3

I grew up rurally, have lived in London for 20 years but increasingly value space and greenery as I get older Mr Monkey was born here and always lived centrally (his parents ran pubs so they lived above them).

When we were looking for a place together I knew I wanted somewhere leafier. He was sceptical of leaving the very central zone 1/2area he lived in. We settled for a leafy suburban area of zone 3 and are both happy - we have space but an easy commute to the centre. It helped that I was happy living in London.

The next issue may be my increasing hankering for the sea (I grew up in a coastal area) 🫣

Pinkdelight3 · 07/10/2023 10:00

This is quite odd, to feel so extreme about the place when you've lived there all your life and chosen to live centrally, and pay extortionate rents for the privilege. You're in literally the most expensive and sought after parts of the UK (and the world!) and it's a no-brainer not to live there if you hate it.

However you don't have to have this calamitous angle on moving either - that your relationship and DC's father figure is at stake and you can't risk another school move and so on. People make compromises all the time when they can't have either the central London lifestyle or the bucolic rural dream. This is why the suburbs and commuter towns exist. Not because they're anyone's dream location, but because they make practical sense for most families as a place to raise kids with more green/fresh air and still have access to London.

Surely there are places - on the zillion 'moving out of London or not' threads on here that mean you'll be happy, you'll keep you DP and your DC will thrive. Hitchin is one that comes up constantly but there's loads of places in the outer zones and the home counties and loads of intell on it. No doubt your friends and family who've moved out have already been through it and can advise. It's what parents have to do unless they're super-rich or very lucky with HA homes. So don't waste any more energy on hating central London or any more money on paying to live there. Figure out the way forward and live happily (enough as the next person) ever after.

Lovethatforyouhun · 07/10/2023 09:53

Cliche but you only have one life.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 07/10/2023 09:52

I lived in zone 2 and worked in central london in my early/mid twenties. I was SO done by the time I left. Samuel Johnson may have said tired of London, tired of life. But he didn’t have to use the northern line 5 days a week. He didn’t have someone getting stabbed on his street and likely didn’t live next door to some folk that had the police round dealing with their drug and DV issues every other fucking day

TrashedSofa · 07/10/2023 09:49

I wouldn't base big life decisions like whether to move or not on a partner I didn't live with.

Westfacing · 07/10/2023 09:47

London is huge - so many leafy and quiet areas to choose from, you don't have to live so centrally if you don't like traffic!

I'm central, near the river and parks, and lots of birdsong from my little garden right nowSmile

Yes, YABU to hate London!

reluctantbrit · 07/10/2023 09:45

I live in zone 5, basically on the Kent border. It's 30 minutes by train to Charing Cross and we are in Central London a lot on weekends.

For me it's the best of both worlds, easy access but not the mayhem.

Zebedee55 · 07/10/2023 09:43

Orangebadger · 07/10/2023 09:15

Would you move to the suburbs instead? I am born and bred London and I have always had a love/ hate relationship with it! In my heart I would love to live more rurally but for various reasons had to stay in London. I'm now in SW suburbs, lots and lots of green open spaces, lovely riverside, not chaotic at all, not crazy amount of congestion like central London and good schools. For me it's a good compromise.

Same here. I live in a London suburb on the borders of Kent, so plenty of green spaces, but only half an hour to central London.

It's a good compromise.🙂

PerspiringElizabeth · 07/10/2023 09:42

DustyLee123 · 07/10/2023 08:51

You need to do what you want. If he really loves you he’d follow you. Put yourself and your kids first.

By that logic, if OP really loved DP she's follow him (I.E. stay in london)

I'd move to a cheaper area where your family live, for sure. Everything will be better - space, support, air quality. I do love London but not for family life.

ThinWomansBrain · 07/10/2023 09:40

I live in zone 1, and love it here - occasionally think about "moving out" for more space and fresh air, but probably wouldn't go beyond zone 3 or 4 - lots of options without leaving London.
WHat areas have your friends relocated to?

Swipe left for the next trending thread