Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why say thank you?

267 replies

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 21:17

A man stopped on the wide pavement and stood to the side to allow me to pass. He didn't need to. I didn't say thank you, as it was a pointless act. I heard a very British mumbled sarcastic comment "Well THANK you".

Yesterday, a woman pulled the very long lead on her dog in so that there was no longer a cable across the width of the path. I didn't say thank you to her either.

I'm done saying thank you to people who either do something pointless which was never needed, or who are correcting incorrect behaviour.

AIBU?

OP posts:
MrsMiddleMother · 06/10/2023 23:33

OMG YES! YANBU. It annoys me so badly when someone stops when there is plenty of space, either forcing me to say a thank you that is unnecessary or don't say anything and leave myself open to abusive comments. I have, on multiple occasions, turned round and said well you didn't have to stop? There's loads of space to get past'.
But most people will say yabu but honestly, fuck them.

Somanycats · 06/10/2023 23:33

So op, pretty much everyone has told you that you are wrong and a bit unpleasant. None of them have had to do this, but everyone has given up their time to help you learn. I haven't seen any thank yous from you. So it's not just prats you don't like thanking, but pretty much everyone!

Whalewatchers · 06/10/2023 23:31

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 23:28

Had they shown consideration in the first place by keeping the dog on a short lead, then they would have got a good morning from me as is often the way with walkers on that path. 😉

Something which I try and do is to excuse other people's less than ideal behaviours at times. Give them the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps their mind was elsewhere, perhaps they are having a bad time at the minute with a sick relative, an abusive partner, a stressful job, and they aren't really in the moment and concentrating in the same way as they might ordinarily be. I find this forgiving outlook, where I look for the best in everyone, really helps me stay positive and helps my own mental health. Anyway, maybe that's just me! :-D

BBQchickensalad · 06/10/2023 23:30

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 23:28

Had they shown consideration in the first place by keeping the dog on a short lead, then they would have got a good morning from me as is often the way with walkers on that path. 😉

It's possible to be considerate with a dog on a long lead. Maybe not in busy places, but in quiet places. I walk mine where I might see one person pass the entire time, if anyone at all. They are on a long lead and called back and restrained with the lead shortened while passing someone else. Works for everyone. I normally get thanked for doing what should be normal. Probably because too many don't or have them off lead with no recall.

MiniBossFromAus · 06/10/2023 23:29

OP - you are no doubt one of those who wouldn't smile at a stranger or pass the time of day with another human just because you can.

There are no prizes for being professionally miserable. It's ok to be nice.

KookyAndSpooky · 06/10/2023 23:29

I agree OP. I also think it's very different to a car giving way to you if you have right of way as they are actually being forced to be 'put out' by you being on the road. It might be their obligation but they are still losing time to you. There was no reason for the man to be put out as he didn't need to move.

I always thank people that have given way for good reason or greet people that greet me. However, I'm not going to thank pointless actions from silly people seeking out golden stars from strangers. I'm very happy and friendly in general though!

PeggyPiglet · 06/10/2023 23:29

Wow OP.

You were rude..end of.

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 23:28

Whalewatchers · 06/10/2023 23:23

And it's considerate to recognise when other people are being considerate of you and to respond appropriately, for example, by thanking them ;-)

Had they shown consideration in the first place by keeping the dog on a short lead, then they would have got a good morning from me as is often the way with walkers on that path. 😉

OP posts:
Lostcotter · 06/10/2023 23:27

And another issue with thanking everyone for anything even slightly resembling being vaguely OK/decent/doing what they should be doing…they start thinking they’re doing something great rather than just the bare minimum like moving a leash so it’s not covering the pavement. Just do what you’re meant to do if someone thanks you fab! If not carry on - You didn’t do anything extra or special.

MiniBossFromAus · 06/10/2023 23:27

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 21:17

A man stopped on the wide pavement and stood to the side to allow me to pass. He didn't need to. I didn't say thank you, as it was a pointless act. I heard a very British mumbled sarcastic comment "Well THANK you".

Yesterday, a woman pulled the very long lead on her dog in so that there was no longer a cable across the width of the path. I didn't say thank you to her either.

I'm done saying thank you to people who either do something pointless which was never needed, or who are correcting incorrect behaviour.

AIBU?

Feel free to be a rude fucker.

Whatever floats your boat.

Costs nothing to be pleasant and have manners.

Ffs.

Rosebel · 06/10/2023 23:27

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 22:12

I don't agree that it is common courtesy to thank someone for being a prat. There was no need for the man to stop. 2 people abreast could have comfortably walked in the space between us.

Extendable dog leads should not be on full extension when others are using the path. Again, they were being a prat.

Another one which doesn't get a thanks. Prats who leave their trolley perpendicular in supermarket aisles. Who then don't hear/ignore your "excuse me", and get cross with you when you deign to move their trolley yourself.

And if it's British culture to thank them for their prattish behaviour, or say hello if you don't feel you can thank them, then I'm very happy to be counter cultural. I'll save my hellos for the people and thanks for the people who are being courteous and considerate.

I'd expect to be treated the same way if I were being a prat.

You already sound like a prat so you won't be getting any thanks. Still I guess that won't bother you.

BBQchickensalad · 06/10/2023 23:27

I'll thank someone who steps aside on a narrow path, as people do to me.

If I am on a country path with little foot traffic, maybe occasional cycle traffic if more formed paths, I will have my dogs on full extension. That's the whole point of taking them to isolated country paths. I see a cycle or other person coming, I call them in and stand aside while I hold them next to me. The cyclist almost always says thank you. I figure this is because they appreciate that I am being considerate and giving them room and controlling my dog for them, when I'm sure they come across a lot of the opposite. It's actually quite pleasant to have that little exchange too, where we smile at each other with a smile. Just a little social interaction.

I thank people who hold doors for me. People usually thank me for holding doors for them. I think people who don't hold doors are rude.

It brings a little warmth to the world when people are considerate and there is acknowledgement. It costs nothing.

DNLove · 06/10/2023 23:26

Pretty simple, the less people show appreciation for people carrying out a kind, respectful or considerate act the less they will do them. Then we get to a situation where we all complain about why people aren't kind, respectful or considerate.
A smile in recognition costs nothing.
Honestly you're looking for agro where there is none.

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 23:25

whatwasthatt · 06/10/2023 23:16

I'm guessing you realise you were unreasonable, because you've clearly thought about it enough to want to write a thread about it.....

You're guessing wrong.

It was the sarcastic thank you I got from the man who stopped on the 4 person + wide path that prompted the thread.

OP posts:
Whalewatchers · 06/10/2023 23:23

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 23:19

I disagree.

It's considerate to recognise you're using a shared path, therefore your consideration extends to not allowing the lead to cross the width of the path, as others are using it.

And it's considerate to recognise when other people are being considerate of you and to respond appropriately, for example, by thanking them ;-)

honkersbonkers38 · 06/10/2023 23:23

The point is you are signalling that you think he is a prat and that you are more important than him. You are showing that you think you have more right to the space than he does. All the space. So what if two people "could have" got through the gap - he obviously thought he did need to move so as not to be too close. He conceded the space to you.

The "thank yous" that we say are constant little signals that we don't think we are more important than others, that we are not up for a challenge or a fight, that we respect the other person as having an equal right to the space so there's no need to fight. It's primal. When that goes you get a continuous tension, a sense of threat, we don't concede ground, the biggest dog gets all the space.

Most people see that. Animals know it.

Lostcotter · 06/10/2023 23:22

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 06/10/2023 23:19

They have considered you and that is what you should thank them for. Whether it was needed or not, they took your needs into consideration. Miserable people who scoff at this 🙄

No they didn’t consider the person they supposedly stepped aside for . They were considering their own ego and desire to get a thanks to feel as if they’ve been nice.

The same people who do this are often he last ones to step up if someone is in actual need eg. A woman looking for someone to help her carry a pram upstairs.

ThinWomansBrain · 06/10/2023 23:21

Oh well, here's looking forward to you having to step around someone that can't be arsed to move aside for you, tripping over a dog lead and maybe breaking something when you fall.
Have a lovely weekend.

lifeofsty · 06/10/2023 23:21

Why should she say thank you for a man completely needlessly standing to one side or a woman unblocking the path she blocked with a dog lead? That's ridiculous.

I always say hello / good morning and smile but I certainly wouldn't say thank you.

There is a special place in hell for those walking three abreast on a path. They always move as I tend to speed up so it probably looks like I'm taking a run at them.

phoenixrosehere · 06/10/2023 23:20

I see your point.

To be honest, if someone stopped on a wide pavement where I wasn’t near them, I wouldn’t automatically assume that they did so for me or notice, especially with my earphones in. I’m often in my own head and keeping a steady pace and will manoeuvre out of the way of people who walk slower than me and groups where I don’t have the patience to practically beg them to let me through (often having to say excuse me 3-4 times before they budge).

I do recall having some guy say a sarcastic thank you to me before I could thank him which irks me and it’s always men that do this when I don’t say it quick enough or not in the order they require. I was too busy concentrating on making sure my double pram with my sons in it didn’t tip onto a main street since the path was narrow (barely 3 ft wide on a slight hill). To get past me with the pram, they would have to step into the street for a few seconds or wait until I got to where the path widen and it was safe. I definitely wasn’t going to say thank you after their sarcastic remark. Any smart, sensible person would have gone around me seeing that I couldn’t move off the pavement safely while they could have done so and gone on their merry way.

With the woman with the long lead, I would say thank you but would also shake my head and say to myself how pointless a long lead is and about too many irresponsible dog owners.

Lostcotter · 06/10/2023 23:19

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 22:12

I don't agree that it is common courtesy to thank someone for being a prat. There was no need for the man to stop. 2 people abreast could have comfortably walked in the space between us.

Extendable dog leads should not be on full extension when others are using the path. Again, they were being a prat.

Another one which doesn't get a thanks. Prats who leave their trolley perpendicular in supermarket aisles. Who then don't hear/ignore your "excuse me", and get cross with you when you deign to move their trolley yourself.

And if it's British culture to thank them for their prattish behaviour, or say hello if you don't feel you can thank them, then I'm very happy to be counter cultural. I'll save my hellos for the people and thanks for the people who are being courteous and considerate.

I'd expect to be treated the same way if I were being a prat.

I agree with you. A friend of mine actively felt a man was having a dig at her when he moved to the side because she was a bit chubbier and the pavement was wide so she felt as if he was saying she needed all the space. Either way there’s just no need for it, it’s performative attention seeking. and the fact he commented on you not saying thanks, shows he was doing it to get a thank you 🙄

definitely wouldn’t have thanked the dog lead woman.

I will say thank you for some holding a door open though.

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 06/10/2023 23:19

Fullfatandfortyplus · 06/10/2023 21:34

Agree. Have had same situation people stepping aside on wide paths when they didn’t need to then expecting a thank you and a sarcastic ‘thank you ‘. It’s like they spend their days walking round for thank yous.

They have considered you and that is what you should thank them for. Whether it was needed or not, they took your needs into consideration. Miserable people who scoff at this 🙄

OfcourseitsaNC · 06/10/2023 23:19

Whalewatchers · 06/10/2023 23:16

The thing is OP, it's not illegal to use an extendable dog lead on a footpath. It is considerate to retract the lead for an oncoming pedestrian, so therefore I think that consideration merits a thank you. They could have just ignored you which meant you might have had to step into the road to avoid the lead. Then you would have had a valid complaint.

I disagree.

It's considerate to recognise you're using a shared path, therefore your consideration extends to not allowing the lead to cross the width of the path, as others are using it.

OP posts:
TotalOverhaul · 06/10/2023 23:18

The problem with saying thank you to strangers who do something thoughtful for you is that a chunk of your soul dies every time you give thanks.

No. Wait. Nothing at all is taken from you when you express gratitude and notice small kindnesses.

I know people who think thanks should be meted out in tiny stingy, hard earned portions and I just don't understand them at all.

Notsuredontknow · 06/10/2023 23:17

You come across as so miserable Op. Your example about the lady who thanked you for stopping at a red light, and the man who moved out of your way on a wide path - perhaps they are just both so polite that they do these things without thinking. I think that’s a good thing, I hope I will raise my children to be polite and consider others as second nature. I’d choose that over unnecessary negativity.