Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I complain about this?

162 replies

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 12:25

I know this has already been done recently but my year 7 ds came home from school with a letter yesterday regarding toilet use. From this week, only children with a pre approved toilet pass will be able to leave lessons to go to the toilet. And in order to get one of these parents will need to provide medical evidence of a long term health issue.

They have generously said that children suffering from temporary issues such as infections or periods (?!?!) can get a pass but these will also need to be approved.

I feel outraged to be honest. Of course there will be kids who take the piss (no pun intended) but there are a hell of a lot of shy, genuine children who are probably going to feel really uncomfortable about this blanket ban on toilet use. What if someone has an accident in class? Can you imagine the shame? Surely teachers are able to quite quickly determine the kids who are trying to skive and those who are genuine? Is it worth complaining about this?

OP posts:
Hercisback · 06/10/2023 15:17

If you get 3-4 kids a lesson asking, multiply that by the 40 - 50 classes on at the same time and suddenly there's a lot of people with a 'legitimate' reason to be walking around school.
Most of them don't need the toilet.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 15:16

As a class teacher, if the policy is they can go, I can't stop them.

It's not unfair. The overwhelming majority of the population don't need toilet access more than every 2 hours.

This gives teachers more backing to say no, and allows for discretion when required.

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 15:10

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 14:54

How can you penalise them though?
If the rule is they can go to the toilet, then their argument is that they're not doing anything wrong.
Wheras you can stick to a policy of no toilet and use discretion as needed. Bit like most other school rules.

If it's the same people every time then tell them no or make them present a medical pass. Don't make it an issue for all the kids. It's unfair.

OP posts:
lilsupersparks · 06/10/2023 14:55

I work in a school with a similar rule. My kids attend there. I tell my kids that if they are desperate/feel sick/might have an accident then they are to just leave.

my kids are pretty stoic and sensible. I have taught them not to say ‘Miss, I feel a bit sick’ which can be mis interpreted but to say in a panicky voice ‘Miss! I’m going to be sick!!’ and leave. When my daughter reaches an age when she has periods I will teach her a similar phrase and tell her to walk out.

as a teacher I have to apply the policy. I say ‘you know that you are not allowed to use the toilet during class time - I will have to… (insert consequence here)’ but I would never stand in a student’s way. Then it gets recorded and if it is the same kids time and time again we can prove it.

It’s sad that this has to be done. But we literally do not have staff numbers to supervise corridors and toilets during lesson time. Kids arrange times to meet with their mates. They bully and harass others. Yes, they can be disciplined for this, but by the time they are disciplined their actions have already happened.

i also have to wait for break and lunch (well apart from the days I am on duty when I can be working from 8.30-1.30 with no break at all). Yes, if I thought I would have an accident I would have to leave the classroom and notify the teacher ne t door and leave the door open.. that hasn’t happened to me in 20 years but it might. My friend who suffered from hyperemesis did have to do this a few times.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 14:54

How can you penalise them though?
If the rule is they can go to the toilet, then their argument is that they're not doing anything wrong.
Wheras you can stick to a policy of no toilet and use discretion as needed. Bit like most other school rules.

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 14:41

Hankunamatata · 06/10/2023 13:49

I never understood this until my dc were in school. It's a huge problem kids going to the toilet especially if they disappear for 20mins plus. Then you have to get cover and try and find them. Then there's the kids who do it every lesson or use it as an excuse to be late for every lesson

So surely the answer is to penalise those kids. Not make every other child have a medical pass so they can go to the toilet.

OP posts:
fetchacloth · 06/10/2023 14:08

Eileen101 · 06/10/2023 12:30

I can't imagine many shy girls wanting to have to get a pass for their period!

Nor me. That's barbaric 😡

Hankunamatata · 06/10/2023 13:49

I never understood this until my dc were in school. It's a huge problem kids going to the toilet especially if they disappear for 20mins plus. Then you have to get cover and try and find them. Then there's the kids who do it every lesson or use it as an excuse to be late for every lesson

Testina · 06/10/2023 13:42

“It's necessary to police it so kids don't use it as an excuse to skip class. It's not ok to say a blanket no to all kids”

But it’s not a blanket no. You said in your OP that short term reasons can also get approved for a pass.

Now might say, “how does Sophie know she needs the loo until her period comes 3 days early and she gets a suspicious wet feeling in Geography?”

If Sophie hasn’t spent the last 6 months whining to go to the loo (to vape, or to be destructive) every time her teachers gets stuck into the middle course of rivers, she’ll be allowed to go.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 13:03

Some work places do have policies like this.... See being a teacher!

Or surgeon.

Some prison staff. Amazon warehouse workers.
I'm sure there's more.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 13:02

In reality it isn't a blanket no though. It's a 99% no with a bit of discretion.

But school won't openly say that. This will cut most of the time wasters.

I can think of two times I've needed to leave a class for the toilet over a 15 year career. Hardly a regular occurrence for a bathroom.

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 12:58

LakeTiticaca · 06/10/2023 12:47

A year 7 child should be capable of using a toilet at break/lunch and not have to disruption lessons. They are not 5 year olds.

Anyone of any age can be susceptible to a sudden onset of diarrhoea or vomiting or a sudden period that they might not fancy discussing with their teacher in front of the class.

Imagine having to explain yourself. In that time an accident could occur and a self conscious teen is hardly likely to live that down for a very long time.

It's necessary to police it so kids don't use it as an excuse to skip class. It's not ok to say a blanket no to all kids. Imagine if they tried enforcing something like this in a workplace.

OP posts:
TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 06/10/2023 12:47

Testina · 06/10/2023 12:45

Oh and info from my teen is that kids in different classes agree in advance what time they’re all going to, “need the toilet” so that they can meet up for a vape and a social. Every day.

Absolutely.
Happens in every school until there's a policy.

LakeTiticaca · 06/10/2023 12:47

A year 7 child should be capable of using a toilet at break/lunch and not have to disruption lessons. They are not 5 year olds.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 12:47

Girls are suffering UTIs and avoiding school during menstruation because of this culture. Kids with mental health problems and additional needs are struggling to learn because these policies drive their stress levels up

Students are suffering sexual abuse in open unsupervised toilets.

Students meet to vape in unsupervised toilets.

Students trash unsupervised toilets.

Schools can't put cctv in toilets and cannot supervise them all day.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 06/10/2023 12:46

sprigatito · 06/10/2023 12:42

Unfortunately some of you are indeed both cruel and daft, and this fashion for authoritarian blanket policies in schools is damaging and dangerous.

Girls are suffering UTIs and avoiding school during menstruation because of this culture. Kids with mental health problems and additional needs are struggling to learn because these policies drive their stress levels up (that's when they aren't in isolation, or "reflection", or "reset" or whatever Orwellian euphemism for solitary confinement is in vogue this week)

I know of an autistic teenager who wet himself during an exam, in front of the entire year group, because a draconian policy like this was applied by a staff member who lacked the brain power to apply common sense. It triggered a breakdown which that young person is still recovering from.

Go on then.
What should we do.
Because if every child in my class went to the loo when they asked, they'd not come out of school having learnt very much.

And since 1994, nobody has ever wet themselves or had blood seeping through their clothes in any of my lessons.

Testina · 06/10/2023 12:45

Oh and info from my teen is that kids in different classes agree in advance what time they’re all going to, “need the toilet” so that they can meet up for a vape and a social. Every day.

JustFrustrated · 06/10/2023 12:44

I would and have.

My DDs school lock all the toilets outside of first break and lunch.

First break is 10 minutes. Lunch is half an hour. The school has 900 students and 16 toilets for the girls.....

(Also 15 for the boys obvs)

I wondered why my DD kept bleeding through a pad, tampon and period pants and I finally got to the bottom of it. She had no fucking time to use the bathroom.

I'm in with the school next week to discuss this, along with other issues, further.

A toilet is a basic human right, and as an adult I don't have to provide evidence, tell my boss, or request permission - even during meetings, to use the bathroom.

And I'm an adult that has quite a good handle now on her bathroom needs.

whosaidtha · 06/10/2023 12:44

Kids in y7 are not going to wet themselves. If they get that desperate they can walk out and explain later. I have a job where I can't go to the toilet whenever I like so I make sure I try before I start. Kids will learn to go at break.

Testina · 06/10/2023 12:43

I cannot imagine what the teachers are dealing with.

This week we had a letter home to say there had been four interrupted lessons from smoke alarm evacuations so far this term, all from a build up of vape fumes in the toilets. They are currently converting all toilets to ones where individual cubicles open directly into the corridor.
Money that is needed for education.

Last term they put CCTV into the hand washing area of the enclosed old toilets (photos home to show no view into cubicles) because of vandalism. Not just a mess, but cisterns ripped from walls.

It is not even considered a bad or rough school!

I have a child in Y11 who frequently mentions her human rights, around these toilet passes. But in 4 years she also has to admit she’s never seen a teacher persistently refuse a child or anyone soiling/wetting/blooding themselves.

So whilst my gut feel is this is madness, just let them quietly get up and go as needed… I actually think that I (and most parents) have no idea how bad it is in schools.

sprigatito · 06/10/2023 12:42

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 06/10/2023 12:34

Teachers apply common sense.

If someone is ill, they are allowed to go.

When Child X, in Year 7, disrupts every single lesson because he feels like it, maybe not.

Imagine every single kid going to the toilet whenever they fancied 10 minutes in the corridor.

That's what happens when there's no policy.

We aren't daft. Or cruel.

99.9% of kids can wait until break. The ones that take the piss (pun intended) are the ones that mean that .1% need a pass

Unfortunately some of you are indeed both cruel and daft, and this fashion for authoritarian blanket policies in schools is damaging and dangerous.

Girls are suffering UTIs and avoiding school during menstruation because of this culture. Kids with mental health problems and additional needs are struggling to learn because these policies drive their stress levels up (that's when they aren't in isolation, or "reflection", or "reset" or whatever Orwellian euphemism for solitary confinement is in vogue this week)

I know of an autistic teenager who wet himself during an exam, in front of the entire year group, because a draconian policy like this was applied by a staff member who lacked the brain power to apply common sense. It triggered a breakdown which that young person is still recovering from.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 06/10/2023 12:42

Boundoverbyacat · 06/10/2023 12:40

A period isn’t ‘an issue’, it’s a normal bodily function like others the toilet is used for. This would enrage me

That's exactly why girls on their periods get to go.

You'd be surprised how many have about 6 periods a month though.

Out of curiosity, what do non teachers suggest we do to stop 26 out of 30 kids going to the toilet in every lesson? Seriously?

Bwessed · 06/10/2023 12:41

My sons school have this. He said all the 'naighty/disruptive' kids have them and noone else is allowed to go.

They also lock the toilets during lessons and don't always unlock them all at break/lunch. So there's just a couple in use that are absolutely packed /stink.

He's come home on the verge of peeing himself several times.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 12:41

What's your solution OP?

Pre this system in our school we had 100ish kids out of lesson. Wandering corridors, all under the "I need the toilet" guise.

Boundoverbyacat · 06/10/2023 12:40

A period isn’t ‘an issue’, it’s a normal bodily function like others the toilet is used for. This would enrage me

Swipe left for the next trending thread