Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I complain about this?

162 replies

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 12:25

I know this has already been done recently but my year 7 ds came home from school with a letter yesterday regarding toilet use. From this week, only children with a pre approved toilet pass will be able to leave lessons to go to the toilet. And in order to get one of these parents will need to provide medical evidence of a long term health issue.

They have generously said that children suffering from temporary issues such as infections or periods (?!?!) can get a pass but these will also need to be approved.

I feel outraged to be honest. Of course there will be kids who take the piss (no pun intended) but there are a hell of a lot of shy, genuine children who are probably going to feel really uncomfortable about this blanket ban on toilet use. What if someone has an accident in class? Can you imagine the shame? Surely teachers are able to quite quickly determine the kids who are trying to skive and those who are genuine? Is it worth complaining about this?

OP posts:
Nellle · 06/10/2023 20:34

waterlego · 06/10/2023 20:23

A simple solution is... if someone needs to go to the toilet during lesson times, teacher stamps their planner. That way, if they're going every day of every week, or for the same lesson every week, parents or tutor can pick it up.

This seems like a very good idea.

We've done this for years. Still have a massive internal truancy/toilet meet-up problem.

Iamnotastick · 06/10/2023 20:32

The level of control is SO bizarre. I still have the traumatising memory of shitting my knickers in primary school when the teacher said I wasn't allowed to use the toilet as it was almost home time.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:28

@waterlego We do that, but have the policy too. Because I'd phone parents who'd say they didn't see a problem with their kids being out of 5 lessons per day.

It also doesn't solve the meeting and vaping issue.

Aria999 · 06/10/2023 20:27

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:15

I suppose the point is that if any policy is unreasonable or unethical then 'we can't afford pencil's' isn't an excuse for having the policy. How far along that slippery slope do you go?

What's unethical about stopping people who don't need the toilet from going to the toilet?

Nothing at all.

It seemed like the policy was potentially stopping people with unexpected periods or medical needs from going to the toilet.

BooksAndHooks · 06/10/2023 20:24

Toilets are locked outside of break and lunch, but they are so disgusting and without basic supplies most refuse to use them and restrict their fluid and food during school.

Even those with a pass have to show their pass, go to student office to get a key then go to another part of the building to access the toilet. So no way of accessing it quickly which is the point of needing a pass.

waterlego · 06/10/2023 20:23

A simple solution is... if someone needs to go to the toilet during lesson times, teacher stamps their planner. That way, if they're going every day of every week, or for the same lesson every week, parents or tutor can pick it up.

This seems like a very good idea.

Serendipitoushedgehog · 06/10/2023 20:21

donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2023 20:20

Imagine if they tried enforcing something like this in a workplace.

There are lots of jobs where you can't just go to the toilet whenever you want.

Ha yes, like teacher for example!

RubyRubyRubyRubay · 06/10/2023 20:20

I've told my boy to piss in the bin in the classroom if he's desperate. In the corner facing away from the rest of the room of course.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2023 20:20

Imagine if they tried enforcing something like this in a workplace.

There are lots of jobs where you can't just go to the toilet whenever you want.

Serendipitoushedgehog · 06/10/2023 20:20

I remember one school I worked at, where a year 7 was asking to go to the toilet EVERY SINGLE lesson. Bless her, it turned out she was really academically behind and struggling to access the curriculum so just absented herself. It took the school an embarrassingly long time to work this out, by which time she'd basically missed a half term of content.

A simple solution is... if someone needs to go to the toilet during lesson times, teacher stamps their planner. That way, if they're going every day of every week, or for the same lesson every week, parents or tutor can pick it up.

donquixotedelamancha · 06/10/2023 20:19

Standard policy in every school I've ever worked at. A (healthy) 11 YO should be able to go to the toilet at break and lunch. Of course teachers aren't going to say no to a child who is desperate.

YABVVU, OP.

Nellle · 06/10/2023 20:18

All this policy states is that being allowed to go to the toilet in lessons will be the exception, not the rule.

If there was more trust in teachers' professional judgement, we wouldn't be having stupid hyperbolic conversations about kids pissing themselves in lessons.

mumof1or2 · 06/10/2023 20:18

I'm a teacher and I disagree with most of the teachers who've commented on this post! We simply have a rule that you only let one student go to the toilet at a time from each class. When someone else asks to go, we simply say "yes you can go as soon as Jack gets back". I find it very hard to believe that some schools have "hundreds" of kids roaming the corridors at all times pretending to go to the loo.

Some of the more draconian staff at my school have tried to bring in toilet rules but there was uproar amongst the majority of staff, as we understand that children are human too and might sometimes need the loo outside of break and lunchtime

I think it's outrageous that schools still think they can do this. There will be many students with continence/stomach/IBS issues who don't want or need to tell anyone about it. They just need to be allowed to use the loo.

Our SLT so regular sweeps of the toilets and anyone caught with a vape in school gets a two day fixed term exclusion. We punish them rather than the entire school!

HauntedPencil · 06/10/2023 20:18

This seems to be pretty standard and to avoid violence and vaping and mucking about in the loos.
My DD has a pass but it's still a bit embarrassing to pull that out.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:15

I suppose the point is that if any policy is unreasonable or unethical then 'we can't afford pencil's' isn't an excuse for having the policy. How far along that slippery slope do you go?

What's unethical about stopping people who don't need the toilet from going to the toilet?

lanthanum · 06/10/2023 20:14

Dramatic · 06/10/2023 19:45

As long as teachers do understand that some kids will have undiagnosed issues. My parents never let the school know I was having problems, they didn't even care to take me to the doctor's so would never have bothered. I'm sure most people can last a couple of hours without needing the toilet but I used to need to go at least once or twice a week during a lesson and there must be a fair amount of kids like that.

I taught a lad who kept asking to go in our double-lesson before lunch. He was a quiet lad, no trouble, and I let him go, but when it kept happening, I had a word with the school nurse to ask if there was a medical issue. She had him in to ask him - and he never asked to go again! I suspect in his case he just wanted a bit of quiet time-out.

ShermansSherberts · 06/10/2023 20:13

I don't doubt it's tough for teachers. But I still stand by what I said, I would fully support any child of mine that genuinely needed to go and walking out and going having been refused. I've been a bullied child. The scars from bullying last a lifetime just like with any other kind of abuse. A child having an accident in class at secondary school age is highly likely to become a bullying target and I couldn't let that happen if it could be prevented. The opinions of your peers matters more than anything else at that age, being bollocked by a teacher is nothing in comparison.

Aria999 · 06/10/2023 20:12

I suppose the point is that if any policy is unreasonable or unethical then 'we can't afford pencil's' isn't an excuse for having the policy. How far along that slippery slope do you go?

If it isn't unreasonable or unethical then you don't need an excuse.

Nellle · 06/10/2023 20:05

This thread really reveals how little people understand what secondary schools are like at the moment.

And I always wonder why people think a policy would be implemented for any reason other than that the professionals who actually work in schools know that it will make things better for the majority.

Discretion is used. Buildings are kept safe.

Why do parents think they know better about the workings of teachers and school buildings than teachers themselves?

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:05

don't see why the policy can't just be 'it's at the teacher's discretion'

Because then you get all manner of parental phonecalls about X was allowed and Y wasn't. Can. Of. Worms.

That or hire a toilet attendant

🤣🤣🤣🤣 We can't afford pencils.

Badaba · 06/10/2023 20:03

Aria999 · 06/10/2023 19:59

I don't see why the policy can't just be 'it's at the teacher's discretion'

That or hire a toilet attendant

All good if parents are directly funding this.

Aria999 · 06/10/2023 19:59

I don't see why the policy can't just be 'it's at the teacher's discretion'

That or hire a toilet attendant

ShermansSherberts · 06/10/2023 19:59

Dramatic · 06/10/2023 19:43

I can remember two kids wetting themselves in class when I was at school, one in my year and one in the year below, both were year 7s

Interesting I don't remember any kids having issues at secondary school age. Mind you my generation (80s/90s) definitely didn't drink enough! It wasn't encouraged rhen, I'm glad to see children can take water into their classes at school. Drinking lots throughout the day causes fewer problems at night with excess urination, constipation or bedwetting.

MuggleMe · 06/10/2023 19:56

My DD had a UTI within a week of starting middle school (y5) She has autism, was worried about getting lost, it was busy and noisy at break times so she avoided going by not drinking during that heatwave in sept.

Dramatic · 06/10/2023 19:54

ExperiencedTeacher · 06/10/2023 19:52

Funnily enough, it is enforced in my workplace.

Also kids are not choosing to be there, I'd never go in to a profession where I'd have no access to a toilet for 2+ hours because it wouldn't be possible for me to do that. Kids have no choice.