Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I complain about this?

162 replies

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 12:25

I know this has already been done recently but my year 7 ds came home from school with a letter yesterday regarding toilet use. From this week, only children with a pre approved toilet pass will be able to leave lessons to go to the toilet. And in order to get one of these parents will need to provide medical evidence of a long term health issue.

They have generously said that children suffering from temporary issues such as infections or periods (?!?!) can get a pass but these will also need to be approved.

I feel outraged to be honest. Of course there will be kids who take the piss (no pun intended) but there are a hell of a lot of shy, genuine children who are probably going to feel really uncomfortable about this blanket ban on toilet use. What if someone has an accident in class? Can you imagine the shame? Surely teachers are able to quite quickly determine the kids who are trying to skive and those who are genuine? Is it worth complaining about this?

OP posts:
WillyWonkaBlues · 07/10/2023 01:43

Teaching has become a leftist institution in and of itself. We know the left love control and schools are a fantastic place to exert that power on voiceless young children. Look at the way they control lunchboxes, question absences and force sick children in attending and now natural bodily functions are up for grabs. And let’s not even think about the mind bend undermining traditional family values. No way would I send an innocent child into one of these gulags.

makingforwardprogress · 07/10/2023 01:35

You are being totally unrealistic OP

By your account, you would simply let children go to the toilet if you liked them and not if you didn't.

Rude, untrustworthy obnoxious piss takers are just as likely to have a genuine need as your precious little snowflake. You expect teachers to say no to them, then can equally just as fairly say no to your child too.

And no, there is absolutely no staffing to supervise lesson time toilet use. Maybe you would like to volunteer to do it?

Loub55 · 07/10/2023 01:33

When I was in middle school, year 5 I think it was, we had a rule that we were not allowed to go to the toilet in lesson time. I was too scared to plead my case to the teacher and I wet myself, I remember the feeling now. I was only 9 ish and i think back and what an awful thing to stop a child going to the toilet when they need to!

hollywally54 · 07/10/2023 01:10

avenue1 · 06/10/2023 21:46

Children need to learn basic body management. That includes preempting toilet trips and going at breaks or between lessons. I really shouldn't be that hard for the majority of kids the majority of the time. Illness, sudden periods etc, of course are a concession. My daughter (age 9) has a medical need to toilet hourly, but as a teacher I know how disruptive to her education and others that could be. So she goes at appropriate times between lessons. Following school rules works better for everyone.

This is such a mechanical answer. No empathy.

You can't 'learn' body management ffs. Sometimes our bodies act out. Maybe not often but occasionally. Get a grip on reality.

OP posts:
hollywally54 · 07/10/2023 00:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MumOfTheNorth · 06/10/2023 22:02

hollywally54 · 06/10/2023 16:40

Do you have any statistics to back up your 'overwhelming majority' comment? Just because people don't talk about their bowel and bladder issues doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Maybe not as prevalent in young people granted, but I object to anyone in any social setting (be it school, work or other) being denied access to a toilet if they need it.

Just think about the alternative ffs.

I went to a very strict school and you weren't allowed to go to the toilet in lessons. I think I only ever asked to go once and was denied - almost wet myself. There was a girl in sixth form so we were 17 who was also denied and ended up not making it to the loo, sitting down on the steps and pooping herself - this is on the main staircase between lessons so surrounded by students. She never lived it down.

I think if I had a well behaved kid I trusted I would tell them to ignore the teacher and go to the loo anyway if denied and in an emergency situation and we can deal with consequences later. My partner is a teacher and he said he assumes if a kid it super desperate he'd be able to tell but I think that's underestimating how embarrassed kids can be sometimes.

CatamaranViper · 06/10/2023 21:55

Can you imagine the uproar if a typically disruptive student kept saying they need the toilet and the teacher decided to use their 'judgement' and said no and said student shat themselves, wet themselves or bled through their pants when they genuinely needed to go?

It's everyone or no one, you can't cherry pick based on the students who you probably just dislike...

Wrongsideofpennines · 06/10/2023 21:52

When I was at school we didn't have a policy on this. Just teachers using their common sense when someone asked to go to the toilet. Usual suspects that they knew would mess about would have been told no, and anyone they thought was genuine was allowed. There were a few people who had passes that were for a variety of reasons which meant the teachers weren't allowed to question it.

Throughout secondary school I had hideously heavy and painful periods. I didn't have a medical condition, I was just an 11 year old trying to figure out how to manage periods. Sometimes that meant that I overestimated a pad's absorbancy, and having to stand in front of a class and explain to a male teacher that I think my pad had leaked in order to leave the classroom would absolutely have meant I would have been off sick instead of being at school for a week a month.

avenue1 · 06/10/2023 21:46

Children need to learn basic body management. That includes preempting toilet trips and going at breaks or between lessons. I really shouldn't be that hard for the majority of kids the majority of the time. Illness, sudden periods etc, of course are a concession. My daughter (age 9) has a medical need to toilet hourly, but as a teacher I know how disruptive to her education and others that could be. So she goes at appropriate times between lessons. Following school rules works better for everyone.

OliveWah · 06/10/2023 21:36

I have 2 teen DDs and their senior school has the same rule. I have told them that if they are ever desperate enough to need to go to the loo during a lesson, they are to ask the teacher and if they are refused permission, they are to go anyway. Dealing with a phone call from school about disobedience or them having to complete a detention are far less of a concern than having a toileting accident, or bleed in class.

My girls are Yrs 10 and 12, and neither have ever needed to ask to use the toilet during lessons, but I would be happy to stand up for them if they got in trouble because they did need to.

ThrallsWife · 06/10/2023 21:29

Not this again.

Of course a policy like that is needed.

We have found children in our toilets who had disassembled sharpeners and cut themselves or tried to take their lives.

We have had students hide drugs in roof tiles of toilets for others to later on take - dealing on premises.

We have found numerous students vaping, smoking (setting off fire alarms regularly, even during official bloody GCSE exams!).

We have found one particular couple having full on sex, and a few others where blow jobs were being dealt for money.

In each case, the teachers who let the kids out were held to account, because at the end of the day, they were in loco parentis.

That is not even mentioning the hundreds of students disrupting the flow of lessons regularly. You're explaining something, ask a question and get hands up, only to get a "can I go to the toilet". You get children leave lessons (with permission or without), creating disruption to those who have to move their seats, those who get distracted, both on the way there and back. You get hundreds of children arriving late to every lesson because they spend 10mins finding a toilet between every lesson. You get bullying, popping heads into other lessons to chat to mates.

If you think I'm exaggerating, please visit an average large town comp.

Toilet passes are a pain in the arse, too, because I have to check every time, because the kid will inevitably not have theirs and I have to look their name up every time. But they're still preferable to the disciplinary I could face if a kid comes to serious harm and I let them out.

I have girls on their periods all the time, too. I apply discretion and I never allow more than 3 kids to go in any one lesson (and yet I have one class where I will have 3 asking to go every lesson, and try to be the first of my 3 max). I make them wait, too. I insist on work being done, because I will often get asked when they have to write something or think independently.

Please do provide an alternative. I'd love for the issue to be solved.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 21:19

You can pee before and after school too. Or is not being able to pee on a bus a human rights infringement too?

FudgeSundae · 06/10/2023 21:16

Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 20:45

Yes obviously a 500 ml bottle is enough for 9 to 3! Presumably they have juice or milk or tea at breakfast, a proper drink with lunch and then can refill at the end of school / drink normally of a evening. 2l a day including liquid in food. Max 3l. And there is a fair amount in a lot of foods!

Some children will have long journeys to school. I was out of the house 7-6 when I was in senior school, and we had the same water bottles at lunch. It’s completely unreasonable to expect another 1.5l to be drunk before 7/after 6 because you don’t want the bother of a normal bodily function.

waterlego · 06/10/2023 21:08

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:28

@waterlego We do that, but have the policy too. Because I'd phone parents who'd say they didn't see a problem with their kids being out of 5 lessons per day.

It also doesn't solve the meeting and vaping issue.

Yes, that’s what I was thinking- this system alongside the ‘no loo breaks’ policy (which can of course be implemented at the teacher’s discretion)

MathsTeacherandLoveit · 06/10/2023 21:03

belgiumchocolates · 06/10/2023 20:50

So if you are a teacher and during a lesson you feel a poo coming on. Do you stand there and shit yourself because of the policy No of course not and neither should the children. I agree with OP

Oh ffs.
The utter bollocks that's being spouted on here.
I despair.
God only knows how I've not shit myself in front of a class over the last 30 years?!

I have though farted in a store cupboard/empty corridor many a time.
Right back to the wine.......

Moonwatcher1234 · 06/10/2023 21:00

Testina · 06/10/2023 12:43

I cannot imagine what the teachers are dealing with.

This week we had a letter home to say there had been four interrupted lessons from smoke alarm evacuations so far this term, all from a build up of vape fumes in the toilets. They are currently converting all toilets to ones where individual cubicles open directly into the corridor.
Money that is needed for education.

Last term they put CCTV into the hand washing area of the enclosed old toilets (photos home to show no view into cubicles) because of vandalism. Not just a mess, but cisterns ripped from walls.

It is not even considered a bad or rough school!

I have a child in Y11 who frequently mentions her human rights, around these toilet passes. But in 4 years she also has to admit she’s never seen a teacher persistently refuse a child or anyone soiling/wetting/blooding themselves.

So whilst my gut feel is this is madness, just let them quietly get up and go as needed… I actually think that I (and most parents) have no idea how bad it is in schools.

Gosh - what is happening in our schools and why? It’s worrying.

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 21:00

I regularly shit myself when teaching. It's the only way to make it through the day.

belgiumchocolates · 06/10/2023 20:50

So if you are a teacher and during a lesson you feel a poo coming on. Do you stand there and shit yourself because of the policy No of course not and neither should the children. I agree with OP

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:50

Ahh we're back to teachers choose it.

If we're playing that game, students can be homeschoooled. The responsibility is on parents to get children an education.

Dramatic · 06/10/2023 20:48

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:39

@Swiftsmith What like teachers have to?

@Iamnotastick Have you been into a secondary school recently? The level of control is required due to the appalling behaviour which is often supported by parents.

Teachers choose to be in that profession. I certainly would not go in to a profession where I couldn't use the toilet. Kids have no choice but to be there.

Dramatic · 06/10/2023 20:47

Serendipitoushedgehog · 06/10/2023 20:20

I remember one school I worked at, where a year 7 was asking to go to the toilet EVERY SINGLE lesson. Bless her, it turned out she was really academically behind and struggling to access the curriculum so just absented herself. It took the school an embarrassingly long time to work this out, by which time she'd basically missed a half term of content.

A simple solution is... if someone needs to go to the toilet during lesson times, teacher stamps their planner. That way, if they're going every day of every week, or for the same lesson every week, parents or tutor can pick it up.

This is what my daughter's school does and I think it's a really good system

Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 20:45

Yes obviously a 500 ml bottle is enough for 9 to 3! Presumably they have juice or milk or tea at breakfast, a proper drink with lunch and then can refill at the end of school / drink normally of a evening. 2l a day including liquid in food. Max 3l. And there is a fair amount in a lot of foods!

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 20:39

@Swiftsmith What like teachers have to?

@Iamnotastick Have you been into a secondary school recently? The level of control is required due to the appalling behaviour which is often supported by parents.

HauntedPencil · 06/10/2023 20:37

RubyRubyRubyRubay · 06/10/2023 20:20

I've told my boy to piss in the bin in the classroom if he's desperate. In the corner facing away from the rest of the room of course.

Gosh.

Swiftsmith · 06/10/2023 20:36

Absolutely complain. It’s a human right to go to the toilet. I even think it’s weird to have to ask to go, never mind not being allowed without pre-approved permission. Appalling treatment of young people. IMAGINE that was the case in a workplace. Why is it different because they’re younger?