Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:54

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2023 14:52

find it upsetting to talk about that experience, but I also find it upsetting to have people claim that all women are perfectly bloody happy sharing loos with a man if he 'thinks he's a woman'.

People who claim that are either clueless or they are deliberately pushing an agenda. It isn't true. Women don't want male people in female spaces, unless they have surgery to invert their penis. And many not even then.

I wouldn't want them even if they had been through genital surgery. Not all sexual assaults are rape, just because he can't penetrate doesn't mean he can assault.

Sueveneers · 08/10/2023 14:53

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:49

Statistically that's true it's more likely to be relatives. But That doesn't mean TW are safer than any other males. TW are statistically not that common, so very few women will have been assaulted by someone trans or NB.

I don't see any evidence to suggest TW are statistically more dangerous than men but neither is there any evidence to suggest they are or would be was dangerous than men. Why would they be a lower risk of offending? They are genetically men, they have the personalities attitudes and privileges of men, the muscular strength and hormonal profiles of men. They are just like other men except they wear ladies clothes or have had surgery.

I don't see any evidence to suggest TW are statistically more dangerous than men

They are per capita. Statistically, they are more dangerous than so-called 'cis' men. https://fairplayforwomen.com/criminality/

Study suggests that transwomen exhibit a male pattern of criminality • Fair Play For Women

When looking at ANY CRIMES committed by all trans people there is a slightly higher risk of crime compared to the general population.

https://fairplayforwomen.com/criminality

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2023 14:52

find it upsetting to talk about that experience, but I also find it upsetting to have people claim that all women are perfectly bloody happy sharing loos with a man if he 'thinks he's a woman'.

People who claim that are either clueless or they are deliberately pushing an agenda. It isn't true. Women don't want male people in female spaces, unless they have surgery to invert their penis. And many not even then.

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:51

Sorry that is meant to mean less dangerous than men not was dangerous

Sueveneers · 08/10/2023 14:51

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:43

It's not ideal that TW don't feel safe in the men's but a TW who gets aggro from a man in the men's has a bigger chance of defending himself in a fight than a woman would against a TW.

I think cubicle loos are best for all. Let's not have ladies or men's just unisex individual loos.

Unisex spaces harm women. Women need these spaces where they can congregate safely. So many assaults in unisex spaces proves they most definitely are not the answer.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2023 14:49

My partner is lovely. AFAIK he hasn't assaulted anyone, so he can use female spaces, right?

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:49

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/10/2023 14:44

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 14:32

As I know only too well from personal experience.

Yes, so do I and I imagine many of the women on this thread.

Sadly, you’re probably right. It’s not a competition, though. I don’t suppose that many of the women on here subjected to abuse were assaulted by TW, though. Most would be by relatives, I imagine.

Statistically that's true it's more likely to be relatives. But That doesn't mean TW are safer than any other males. TW are statistically not that common, so very few women will have been assaulted by someone trans or NB.

I don't see any evidence to suggest TW are statistically more dangerous than men but neither is there any evidence to suggest they are or would be was dangerous than men. Why would they be a lower risk of offending? They are genetically men, they have the personalities attitudes and privileges of men, the muscular strength and hormonal profiles of men. They are just like other men except they wear ladies clothes or have had surgery.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2023 14:48

I don’t suppose that many of the women on here subjected to abuse were assaulted by TW, though.

It's not relevant to whether I am intimidated by random men in my female spaces, I don't subscribe to the idea that these males are any less risk to women, or that they aren't violating my boundaries.

ArabellaScott · 08/10/2023 14:47

HettyWainty · 08/10/2023 14:38

Nope.

But excellent aggression and implication that you're being silenced or people want you to STFU when that was never said.

All of my posts have said TW shouldn't be in women's spaces. End of.

But i can care about that and also not believe for a second that the Tories really care about women. And also, look at the whole rather than individuals and see that more women are suffering under a Tory Government as NHS workers, rape, CSA or DV victims, working Mums, single parent Mums, carers who are usually women, minimum wage earners and UC claimants who are usually women.

Nobody said you STFU, just that maybe, maybe you shouldn't attempt to influence people's voting using an emotive example of something that happened to you when millions of other women are suffering in many different ways under a Tory Government and shouldn't be made to feel like they're failing as a feminist or a woman for not giving priority to the 'trans issue' and vote for a party that will effect more women directly on a day to day basis and literal 'life or death situations' or for a second be obtuse enough to believe that the Tories give a shit anyway.

I could not give the slightest fuck who anyone votes for. I hope that's clear.

I find it upsetting to talk about that experience, but I also find it upsetting to have people claim that all women are perfectly bloody happy sharing loos with a man if he 'thinks he's a woman'. I'm not. That's why I spoke up.

To suggest that I am trying to use that experience to influence other people's voting is utterly bizarre, as well as hurtful. How on earth would you think that my recounting a sexual assault is going to encourage people to vote Tory?! Or any other party? Good god.

MargotBamborough · 08/10/2023 14:47

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:43

It's not ideal that TW don't feel safe in the men's but a TW who gets aggro from a man in the men's has a bigger chance of defending himself in a fight than a woman would against a TW.

I think cubicle loos are best for all. Let's not have ladies or men's just unisex individual loos.

Lots of reasons why enclosed cubicles aren't great from a safety perspective either.

The safest thing for women is a room full of cubicles with gaps at the top and the bottom, for women only.

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/10/2023 14:46

**
I think cubicle loos are best for all. Let's not have ladies or men's just unisex individual loos”

👏👏👏

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2023 14:46

@ArabellaScott isn't a Tory, @HettyWainty. She's just sharing her experience of being sexually assaulted, to explain her own view. It's not for you to decide whose experience is valid.

MargotBamborough · 08/10/2023 14:46

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:44

What happens if they don't get validation? do they turn into pumpkins or something ? Nobody likes feeling invalidated but they don't get to be validated at the expense of a vulnerable group (women).

Nothing happens.

There is no evidence that they are actually at risk of harm in men's spaces either.

MargotBamborough · 08/10/2023 14:45

Thinking about it, it must be a sad, miserable existence. Knowing deep down that you can never be who you believe you are and having to worry all the time that other people are fearful of you or going to attack you. Not a life someone would choose lightly, I think.

I'm only being slightly flippant when I say, they could choose to believe us when we say that nobody else actually has a gender identity that matches their penis or their vagina either.

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:44

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/10/2023 14:41

Third spaces is the answer but we know TW won’t accept those because of the lack of validation

as has been said before, it’s not the space, it’s the women in the space

What happens if they don't get validation? do they turn into pumpkins or something ? Nobody likes feeling invalidated but they don't get to be validated at the expense of a vulnerable group (women).

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/10/2023 14:44

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 14:32

As I know only too well from personal experience.

Yes, so do I and I imagine many of the women on this thread.

Sadly, you’re probably right. It’s not a competition, though. I don’t suppose that many of the women on here subjected to abuse were assaulted by TW, though. Most would be by relatives, I imagine.

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 14:43

Thinking about it, it must be a sad, miserable existence. Knowing deep down that you can never be who you believe you are and having to worry all the time that other people are fearful of you or going to attack you. Not a life someone would choose lightly, I think.

I completely agree. It must be dreadful.

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:43

EmotionSickness · 08/10/2023 14:40

I believe the argument from a TW point of view is that they don’t feel safe in men’s toilets.

The argument then is, well if women don’t feel safe with TW in their spaces, where do they go?

Individual cubicles with their own sinks etc seems to be the logical answer, but not viable to do in reality.

The issue is that women shouldn’t lose their right to their own spaces, but TW should also feel safe themselves. So what’s the solution here?

It's not ideal that TW don't feel safe in the men's but a TW who gets aggro from a man in the men's has a bigger chance of defending himself in a fight than a woman would against a TW.

I think cubicle loos are best for all. Let's not have ladies or men's just unisex individual loos.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/10/2023 14:41

Third spaces is the answer but we know TW won’t accept those because of the lack of validation

as has been said before, it’s not the space, it’s the women in the space

MrsSkylerWhite · 08/10/2023 14:40

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 14:32
**
On what grounds are they not actually men? It's bizarre magical thinking. A male puts on a skirt and somehow I have to be ok with him in women's space?”

I don’t think anyone has said they are?

Haven’t really given it much headspace because it’s never affected me negatively. That’s the way most of us form opinions, I think.

Men can’t be women, that’s pretty obvious to me. Just as women can’t be men. I do think though that most believe fervently that they are and what I don’t understand is the logic in believing someone who sees themself as a woman would want to harm another woman? Clearly, there are predators in all guises but surely most aren’t?

Thinking about it, it must be a sad, miserable existence. Knowing deep down that you can never be who you believe you are and having to worry all the time that other people are fearful of you or going to attack you. Not a life someone would choose lightly, I think.

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:40

Look, I don't wish to harm TW. I wish them no harm, I don't believe they should face employment or housing discrimination or abuse or anything. No decent human would.

But I cannot put their hurty feelings of TRA above the PTS D actually experienced by sexual abuse survivors. I just can't. It's insulting for the TRAs to claim that being misgendered or denied a right to use the ladies' comes anything close either to real discrimination like I mentioned above (which many LGB, Black, travellers, Jews or Asians experience day to day) or the trauma caused by being sexually abused. It just doesn't come close.

They want to be women but they have no idea of our suffering .

EmotionSickness · 08/10/2023 14:40

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 14:18

@ArabellaScott I'm so sorry that happened to you.

What I find disturbing is that no one person has ever been able to find a reasonable justification as to why a TW (whether they be dysphoric or AGP) cannot use the mens'. Not one.

I believe the argument from a TW point of view is that they don’t feel safe in men’s toilets.

The argument then is, well if women don’t feel safe with TW in their spaces, where do they go?

Individual cubicles with their own sinks etc seems to be the logical answer, but not viable to do in reality.

The issue is that women shouldn’t lose their right to their own spaces, but TW should also feel safe themselves. So what’s the solution here?

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 08/10/2023 14:40

Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/10/2023 14:37

Polling is very clear. The majority of women in England and in Scotland do not want intact males in their female only spaces, regardless of gender identity.

I don't want "non intact" males in women's spaces either, tbh.

What they have chosen to do with their genitals is of no concern of mine and certainly doesn't make them a woman.

HettyWainty · 08/10/2023 14:38

ArabellaScott · 08/10/2023 14:24

What? You're saying it's 'shameful' for me to explain why I don't want to share a loo with men? When others were talking about it?

I should shut the fuck up and not cause problems? I shouldn't talk about it?

Nope.

But excellent aggression and implication that you're being silenced or people want you to STFU when that was never said.

All of my posts have said TW shouldn't be in women's spaces. End of.

But i can care about that and also not believe for a second that the Tories really care about women. And also, look at the whole rather than individuals and see that more women are suffering under a Tory Government as NHS workers, rape, CSA or DV victims, working Mums, single parent Mums, carers who are usually women, minimum wage earners and UC claimants who are usually women.

Nobody said you STFU, just that maybe, maybe you shouldn't attempt to influence people's voting using an emotive example of something that happened to you when millions of other women are suffering in many different ways under a Tory Government and shouldn't be made to feel like they're failing as a feminist or a woman for not giving priority to the 'trans issue' and vote for a party that will effect more women directly on a day to day basis and literal 'life or death situations' or for a second be obtuse enough to believe that the Tories give a shit anyway.

MargotBamborough · 08/10/2023 14:38

BIossomtoes · 08/10/2023 14:37

I think you’ll find that’s not the way the world works. I was taking issue with the assumption that virtually every woman shares that poster’s views. They don’t.

Why should the less than 1% of the male population who want to use women's spaces matter more than the (a lot more than) 1% of women who don't want them to?