Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 14:52

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 13:36

It means absolutely nothing. There's lots of ways the government could make a real statement. I.e provide guidance to schools about transitioning children would massively help schools deal with the situation. Make a statement about trans women in sports, or women only hostels. But they don't want to actually get their hands dirty with what is a really complex situation. Legally and morally they would be in hot water totally denying the rights of trans people to exist but they want to dog whistle their homophobia base enough to get more votes without actually doing anything.

Why would they be denying people’s right to exist? have they so far? Has any mainstream UK political party even indicated this?

There is a great deal of hypocrisy in using ‘deny trans people’s right to exist’ and ‘dog whistle’.

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 13:36

It means absolutely nothing. There's lots of ways the government could make a real statement. I.e provide guidance to schools about transitioning children would massively help schools deal with the situation. Make a statement about trans women in sports, or women only hostels. But they don't want to actually get their hands dirty with what is a really complex situation. Legally and morally they would be in hot water totally denying the rights of trans people to exist but they want to dog whistle their homophobia base enough to get more votes without actually doing anything.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 11:05

But apparently women wanting to discuss strengthening ALL loopholes that mean male people can access single sex spaces are the problem to be shamed and female experiences are to be dismissedIn favour of privileged women who deny there are issues. Not only because female toilets are used for more than just getting in and out for a quick pee, but because some women have very valid reasons for wanting any male excluded. Any male above the age of a child of about 8 that is. All because ‘they are alright Jack’ and cannot see an issue.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 10:21

CorylusAgain · 11/10/2023 09:57

No one is "ignoring" any attacks!

The point is that safe, single sex spaces are one of the few measures actually in place that protects women and girls! Losing those safe spaces increases the risk to women and girls. Change that and any man claiming to be a woman will have access. How is that going to reduce the number of attacks?

Like Hippocrates said in relation to doctors "First do no harm".

We are campaigning to stop the harm that losing safe spaces will cause.

Yes. It is a really warped logic that suggests that to prevent further attacks to women and children we should have reduced levels of safeguarding for one group of males based on no evidence, just a philosophical belief which seems to be easily demonstrated to be false based on conviction rates.

But that is the logic. That some posters believe that keeping women and children safe involves allowing one group of males into female single sex spaces while also attempting to deal with all male violence and sex crime. So on one hand declaring one group of male people ‘safe‘ based on not one shred of evidence, while insisting that all other male people are to be kept out. Like that this has never happened before with disastrous results.

And the other part is that in dealing with violence against women and children by male people in general, we should ignore a clear loophole that has been opened. Because some people believe it is unkind to close that loophole.

And I need to mention that we are told that many male trans people also support law changes to exclude all male people. So even male trans people support strengthening female single sex spaces that exclude them. This means it is an even smaller group of the small group of male people that some posters are supporting to access female single sex spaces. Because those male trans people who fully respect the needs of female people are not those who are using the female single sex spaces.

nanodyne · 11/10/2023 10:12

I haven't read the full thread, but I'll judge by what they do not what they say. The Tories have made life harder and harder for women in this country, and I'm sure with the direction they're going abortion rights will be up for grabs in the near future. So no, virtue signalling/dog whistling on the trans agenda wouldn't sway my vote.

CorylusAgain · 11/10/2023 09:57

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 08:41

@ArabellaScott Shouldn't we be reducing these attacks and assaults?

I find it incomprehensible we focus on the extremely rare attacks on women by TW, ignoring the rapes and murders carried out by non trans men.

No one is "ignoring" any attacks!

The point is that safe, single sex spaces are one of the few measures actually in place that protects women and girls! Losing those safe spaces increases the risk to women and girls. Change that and any man claiming to be a woman will have access. How is that going to reduce the number of attacks?

Like Hippocrates said in relation to doctors "First do no harm".

We are campaigning to stop the harm that losing safe spaces will cause.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 09:48

BIossomtoes · 11/10/2023 08:00

I never do. Shoot in, use the loo, wash my hands, shoot out again. I don’t tend to scrutinise people - places to go, things to do.

That is great. Some women have more complex needs for toilets, and those will make privacy away from male people very important.

Have you dismissed those needs, or do you not have any idea of what those needs are?

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 09:39

BIossomtoes · 11/10/2023 08:00

I never do. Shoot in, use the loo, wash my hands, shoot out again. I don’t tend to scrutinise people - places to go, things to do.

I don't scrutinise people. I just sort of acknowledge their presence. Sometimes I say hello, which is considered polite where I live.

Not once have I ever needed to scrutinise someone in order to figure out what sex they were. Except recently, in a photograph, where I knew that someone in the group was a trans woman but I couldn't work out which out of two people was the trans woman. It turned out both of them were.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 09:28

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 09:10

Of course, i ve not said otherwise but these are threads about Trans women and how women are at risk, losing rights etc.

@Helleofabore Strange how we don't get loads of threads on womens safety, abuse, rape stats, the DV murder rate now almost 3 women per week murdered, all this by "normal" men, not a thing, not even a thread.

But mention of a trans women in a toilet and you'll quickly get 40 pages.

I fear an attack (on me or my DD) by a non trans man and the subsequent complete lack of action by the Police.

I don't think anybody is suggesting that violence against women and girls committed by men who do not identify as transgender is fine. It's just that there are no simple solutions to combatting it.

Keeping all male people however they identify out of women's spaces is a blanket rule which is easy to apply and provides women and children with some protection, freeing up more time and energy to focus on more difficult problems.

But because some people want women's spaces opened up to any male person who wishes to access them, we have to waste time and energy opposing that, which takes away time and energy which could be better spent tackling the more difficult stuff.

And as others have pointed out, it's not just about safety, but about women's comfort and dignity too. Why is it so important for trans women to be able to feel that their comfort and dignity and identities are being respected, but when women want exactly the same thing their needs are deemed unimportant and expressing them is considered bigotry?

What is it about trans women that makes them more important than biological women? Because if it's the fact that they were born with a penis, that looks like good old fashioned misogyny to me.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 09:24

Why are these male people seeking access to female single sex spaces?

Is it safety? Can any poster please post the statistics of how many male trans people have been sexually abused in the male toilets used by all male people ?

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 09:21

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 09:10

Of course, i ve not said otherwise but these are threads about Trans women and how women are at risk, losing rights etc.

@Helleofabore Strange how we don't get loads of threads on womens safety, abuse, rape stats, the DV murder rate now almost 3 women per week murdered, all this by "normal" men, not a thing, not even a thread.

But mention of a trans women in a toilet and you'll quickly get 40 pages.

I fear an attack (on me or my DD) by a non trans man and the subsequent complete lack of action by the Police.

How many women and girls do you believe is acceptable to be subjected to harm each year before we can discuss single sex spaces and seek changes?

1 ? 3? 10? 25? 100?

We had poster the other day declare that when over 100 girls and women each year have been sexually abused in female single sex spaces we could talk about it being an issue. Until then it was hateful to do so. Do you agree with them?

Is that your number? Or is your number the usual n+1. ie maybe the next one harmed…

CharlotteRumpling · 11/10/2023 09:20

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 09:10

Of course, i ve not said otherwise but these are threads about Trans women and how women are at risk, losing rights etc.

@Helleofabore Strange how we don't get loads of threads on womens safety, abuse, rape stats, the DV murder rate now almost 3 women per week murdered, all this by "normal" men, not a thing, not even a thread.

But mention of a trans women in a toilet and you'll quickly get 40 pages.

I fear an attack (on me or my DD) by a non trans man and the subsequent complete lack of action by the Police.

We have had loads of threads on male violence. Usually they are taken over by women saying that their sons and husbands- the normal men- are absolutely lovely.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 09:20

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 09:10

Of course, i ve not said otherwise but these are threads about Trans women and how women are at risk, losing rights etc.

@Helleofabore Strange how we don't get loads of threads on womens safety, abuse, rape stats, the DV murder rate now almost 3 women per week murdered, all this by "normal" men, not a thing, not even a thread.

But mention of a trans women in a toilet and you'll quickly get 40 pages.

I fear an attack (on me or my DD) by a non trans man and the subsequent complete lack of action by the Police.

So, more tone policing about what women discuss, probably many who are actively involved directly in caring for abused women and girls. More dismissing that women can discuss and work on multiple fronts all based on what? MN thread numbers ? About changes that open safeguarding loopholes and increase risk?

Can you produce the evidence on the reduction of risk any male person has of committing sex crimes vs the UK male population? Yes or no? What have you based your analysis on? Numbers of MN threads?

ArabellaScott · 11/10/2023 09:16

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 09:10

Of course, i ve not said otherwise but these are threads about Trans women and how women are at risk, losing rights etc.

@Helleofabore Strange how we don't get loads of threads on womens safety, abuse, rape stats, the DV murder rate now almost 3 women per week murdered, all this by "normal" men, not a thing, not even a thread.

But mention of a trans women in a toilet and you'll quickly get 40 pages.

I fear an attack (on me or my DD) by a non trans man and the subsequent complete lack of action by the Police.

Do feel free to start these threads on things you want to see discussed. Suggest actions. Bring it. Be the change!

PosterBoy · 11/10/2023 09:10

I suppose you could base it on sex offender prison rates.

When the percentage of male sex, transwomen sex offenders in prison who are trans is greater than that of male sex, sex offenders who are not transwomen (obviously adjusted to reflect their actual % of the population), then we can talk.

Oh shit

Better start talking I guess

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 09:10

Wilkolampshade · 11/10/2023 08:51

But attacks on women by trans women ARE attacks on women by men. There's not some new third sex.

Of course, i ve not said otherwise but these are threads about Trans women and how women are at risk, losing rights etc.

@Helleofabore Strange how we don't get loads of threads on womens safety, abuse, rape stats, the DV murder rate now almost 3 women per week murdered, all this by "normal" men, not a thing, not even a thread.

But mention of a trans women in a toilet and you'll quickly get 40 pages.

I fear an attack (on me or my DD) by a non trans man and the subsequent complete lack of action by the Police.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 08:54

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 08:41

@ArabellaScott Shouldn't we be reducing these attacks and assaults?

I find it incomprehensible we focus on the extremely rare attacks on women by TW, ignoring the rapes and murders carried out by non trans men.

This is another fallacy being used. One that relies on all or nothing.

Women can work on multiple fronts at the same time and focus on different objectives relating to the safety of women and girls at the same time.

Not only that, this type of argument then seems to keep dealing with safeguarding loopholes reduced to the priority level of only discussing it when numbers of women and children are high enough.

The issue is allowing a particular group of males to access female single sex spaces when there is absolutely no evidence to support those male people having reduced risk of committing sexual offences than any other male in the UK. If you, or any poster, cannot provide that evidence why are claiming that a special group of males should be treated as having that lower risk?

Also, just how many women and girls do you believe is acceptable to be subjected to harm each year before we can discuss it and seek changes?

1 ? 3? 10? 25? 100?

We had poster the other day declare that when over 100 girls and women each year have been sexually abused in female single sex spaces we could talk about it being an issue. Until then it was hateful to do so. Do you agree with them?

Is that your number? Or is your number the usual n+1. ie maybe the next one harmed….

Wilkolampshade · 11/10/2023 08:51

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 08:41

@ArabellaScott Shouldn't we be reducing these attacks and assaults?

I find it incomprehensible we focus on the extremely rare attacks on women by TW, ignoring the rapes and murders carried out by non trans men.

But attacks on women by trans women ARE attacks on women by men. There's not some new third sex.

ArabellaScott · 11/10/2023 08:43

Aye, great. Once you've fixed male violence, come back and talk to me about mixed sex spaces.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 08:43

It doesn’t matter whether you are a person who makes eye contact with others as you pass in the toilet, are someone who needs the toilet for activities that involve more than just a quick per, or can recognise male cues better than other people, a woman who doesn’t care whether they share female single sex spaces with a male person doesn’t get to dismiss the concerns of those who do.

Bananasandcorn · 11/10/2023 08:41

@ArabellaScott Shouldn't we be reducing these attacks and assaults?

I find it incomprehensible we focus on the extremely rare attacks on women by TW, ignoring the rapes and murders carried out by non trans men.

ArabellaScott · 11/10/2023 08:38

At least one in four women have a history of being assaulted/abused*. Some may have lasting effects, including PTSD, anxiety, or even what could be called paranoia in some cases, it's true.

This may mean that their risk assessment is extra cautious. Or it may mean that they quite logically have looked at the statistics and decided that on balance, they'd just prefer not to share spaces with strange men, given that men have their own perfectly good spaces to use.

A sensible way to approach balancing rights is to weigh up benefits and risks.

What benefit is there to women, opening up single sex spaces to men? Against what risks? What do we lose, if we lose single sex spaces? What do we gain from mixed sex spaces?

There are also just women who prefer not to share with men for reasons of privacy and dignity, and/or religious reasons.

I don't think trying to suggest that women should just 'man up and get over it' really cuts it as an approach, tbh.

*https://criminalinjurieshelpline.co.uk/blog/sexual-assault-data-stats/

Sexual Assault & Rape Statistics - 2023 UK Data | CIH

Find the latest UK stats and information relating to Sexual Assault here. Gender, reporting/conviction % ratios & more.

https://criminalinjurieshelpline.co.uk/blog/sexual-assault-data-stats

PosterBoy · 11/10/2023 08:22

There probably should be additional open gender spaces anyhow as there are so many genders to accommodate that the binary toilet option was never going to work

I'd quite like to subdivide some spaces by horoscope sign, just to mix things up. Or, if that's too many, at least by their elements.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 08:17

Yes, me neither. Happy for there to be additional "gender" spaces.

EasternStandard · 11/10/2023 08:14

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 08:11

It's a basic human instinct for women to be able to perceive men, not "paranoia".

Tbh I don’t care if others want to do their own thing and be around males

As long as those who don’t consent get single sex spaces