Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
OlizraWiteomQua · 06/10/2023 09:19

"A man is a man and a woman is a woman" is just as meaningless as "Transwomen are women". Circular definitions are meaningless.

No that doesn't make the tories any more electable.

A woman is an adult human female and has the personal freedom to express her personality however she chooses, including trying to follow the stereotypes of what men are supposed to conform to, in which case she might also be a transman and ask people to use "he/him" pronouns as a courtesy, but equally might prefer not to be considered a transman and may embrace another term eg "butch"

A man is an adult human male and has the personal freedom to express his personality however he chooses, including trying to follow the stereotypes of what women are supposed to conform to, in which case he might also be a transwoman and ask people to use "she/her" pronouns as a courtesy, but remains male for the purposes of any situation where males and females are separated for reasons of privacy, dignity or safety.

Trans status should never be grounds for discrimination or disrespect. Acknowledging physical reality is not discrimination or disrespect.

Any political party that doesn't have the above as their policy is just as misogynistic and gaslighty as the rest and as none of them have the courage to make such a declaration I will just have to make my vote based on other issues in line with my broadly socialist and liberal outlook.

SquirrelFeeder · 06/10/2023 09:19

Watchitsunshine · 06/10/2023 07:43

Yes. I will.

Biscuit
NeedToChangeName · 06/10/2023 09:18

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 08:08

I agree it happened under them.

But I don't think it happened by them.

Stonewall et al played a very clever game. They set themselves up as EDI experts, infiltrated at the top level of organisations such as the NHS, trained people in 'Stonewall law' rather than actual law, pretended there was no conflict.
Everyone trusted Stonewall because of their history in LGB rights.

By the time people woke up to what was happening too many organisations were captured, and people blindfolded by the 'be kind' mantra. Not helped of course by there being more men (who are less impacted by all this) in positions of influence.

@TeenDivided Yes, Stonewall played an absolute blinder. How many other campaign groups manage to be paid handsomely for promoting their cause?

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 09:18

TomeTome · 06/10/2023 09:12

I think the idea that the Tories have hijacker’s a really emotive issue for political gain is a bit blinkered. If a particular issue drives a political party to power then those voting based on that issue believe it is crucial going forwards or it wouldn’t be worth hijacking. We live in a democracy. That means chosen by the electorate based on the things THEY care about. If half your population are expected to put their own safety last and prioritise everything else ahead of that then they are right to say “no” and forced to vote with their feet. It’s not bigoted to want my daughters and mother to be able to go to the toilet, or a hospital or a jail or a changing room or compete in sport in a single sex environment.

Agree with all this and yes to

It’s not bigoted to want my daughters and mother to be able to go to the toilet, or a hospital or a jail or a changing room or compete in sport in a single sex environment.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 09:18

Graciebobcat · 06/10/2023 09:10

I'm not disagreeing with you. I said in my original post you quoted that I agreed that transwomen should not have carte blanche access to women's spaces.

Right so what do you think Labour are going to do about it?

Because I'd be on at them about their stance, afaik they are under the thumb of lobbyists who want any male to be able to enter women's single sex spaces?

Look at how they treated Rosie Duffield as well.

I get that you won't vote Tory, I won't either but the Labour Party do need to do better on this.

femfemlicious · 06/10/2023 09:17

As a black pastor said...a woman is your MAMA...not your daddy😂

Passepartoute · 06/10/2023 09:17

Theeyeballsinthesky · 06/10/2023 07:49

I’m hugely GC but I’d rather cut my arm off than vote Tory. However can’t vote labour, libdem or Green either as they all pretevd men can be women

so like many women on MN I’m politically homeless

But they don't pretend that. Starmer's statement on it is linked on this thread, you don't have far to look.

AngelinaFibres · 06/10/2023 09:16

AngelinaFibres · 06/10/2023 09:14

This. I love mumsnet .It is my safe space. I am surrounded by women who absolutely feel that if a man says he's a woman then that's that, he is now a woman . Not a transwoman, a woman in the same way that I am a woman. Its as if they are sniffing glue and it enables them to see things I just cannot see. The inside of my head just screams " That's a MAN". It's exhausting.

Surrounded IRL . On mumsnet you are allowed to think that you cannot change sex.

VicToryA · 06/10/2023 09:15

I'm another 'politically homeless' one after only ever voting Conservative. I swore after Brexit and lockdown that I would never vote Conservative again. But recognising that women and men can't change sex is a point in their favour. The prospect of VAT on school fees under Labour would be enough to make me vote Conservative after all.

In the end, it won't make any difference what I vote as I'm in such a massively Conservative constituency. But on balance, of all the shitty choices, I would have to choose them because the alternatives are even worse.

AngelinaFibres · 06/10/2023 09:14

Theeyeballsinthesky · 06/10/2023 07:49

I’m hugely GC but I’d rather cut my arm off than vote Tory. However can’t vote labour, libdem or Green either as they all pretevd men can be women

so like many women on MN I’m politically homeless

This. I love mumsnet .It is my safe space. I am surrounded by women who absolutely feel that if a man says he's a woman then that's that, he is now a woman . Not a transwoman, a woman in the same way that I am a woman. Its as if they are sniffing glue and it enables them to see things I just cannot see. The inside of my head just screams " That's a MAN". It's exhausting.

maximumcarnage · 06/10/2023 09:14

Hard no for me.

Sehenswürdigkeiten · 06/10/2023 09:14

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 09:06

Why, the SNP is fully committed to removing women's rights in favour of males who identify as trans?

To be fair I think the Labour swing in this area is not simply to do with the SNP policies on gender, and more to do with the fact that they have also been in power in Scotland for a long time and while they are doing better than the Tories in some ways a lot of people also feel they are making empty promises. Rutherglen would traditionally have been a Labour/Scottish Labour area, and the swing is partly due to people there feeling jaded with both the Tories (Westminster) and the SNP (Holyrood). The new labour leader is also probably more likeable than the new SNP one, imho.

BaileySharp · 06/10/2023 09:13

It's all well and good him saying it but how things are now has largely happened under a Conservative government so I think it's too late.
Labour are worse on this but are better on other things. I couldn't ever bring myself to vote Conservative anyway I don't think (I'm not loyal to Labour but have always felt quite strongly anti tory!)

loislovesstewie · 06/10/2023 09:13

No, because I have never voted Tory. I think there needs to be a proper grown up discussion, by which I mean no insults, about how women are protected but others are also given safe spaces and the way of competing in sports etc that doesn't cause issues for women. And less of the TWAW stuff too.

countrygirl99 · 06/10/2023 09:13

Thisusernamenotavailable · 06/10/2023 08:51

Yes. If Tories are the only ones who dare to recognise women and women’s sex based rights, they are the only ones who get my vote.

I'd believe it if they did something to advance women's lives. I suspect the awful state of social care and the costs of housing, whether rented or bought, has a far bigger impact on far many more women yet where we're the announcements around those issues?
And what have they done in the last 13 years to mitigate the impact of trans issues on women's safe spaces?

ArabellaScott · 06/10/2023 09:13

We need that speech backed up by action.

TomeTome · 06/10/2023 09:12

I think the idea that the Tories have hijacker’s a really emotive issue for political gain is a bit blinkered. If a particular issue drives a political party to power then those voting based on that issue believe it is crucial going forwards or it wouldn’t be worth hijacking. We live in a democracy. That means chosen by the electorate based on the things THEY care about. If half your population are expected to put their own safety last and prioritise everything else ahead of that then they are right to say “no” and forced to vote with their feet. It’s not bigoted to want my daughters and mother to be able to go to the toilet, or a hospital or a jail or a changing room or compete in sport in a single sex environment.

Cowlover89 · 06/10/2023 09:12

I won't be voting

WestwardHo1 · 06/10/2023 09:12

No. Way

Mummyoflittledragon · 06/10/2023 09:11

Graciebobcat · 06/10/2023 09:05

Yes, exactly. That's what also annoyed me about the speech - who has been in government and able to influence these things for the last 13 years, let me see now? 🤔

It was as if they are coming in as a new administration and are not the ones who have been fucking the country up for over a decade.

In fairness to the tories and on this one soul issue alone, the world believed what they were being told. There has been a worldwide push so it’s not as though they realised what was happening 13 years ago.

CoteDAzur · 06/10/2023 09:10

" so you think the Conservatives are the answer?"
"I rather resent being told that i'm not feminist if I dont vote Tory because Rishi Sunak said something"

I didn't say who you should vote for.

I said that as feminists, this issue needs to be at the forefront when we consider who to vote for. It is up to you to judge which party or candidate will work in the direction that serves the feminist cause.

And I said that in opposition to the person who said "If you choose to base your vote on that, you are not a feminist."

She is wrong. This is the most important, existential issue in feminism at present and it is entirely normal for feminists to focus on it when choosing who to vote for.

If this debate goes against us, women will not be able to define ourselves as the female of our species and fight against women's issues, campaign for equality and safety in many contexts such as education, careers, sports, shelters, prisons, any many others.

Graciebobcat · 06/10/2023 09:10

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 09:08

Ok but why should some males have laws that entitle them to use spaces for females?

It's a legal fiction, it's impossible for a human being to change sex and this is what has led directly to women being harmed in single sex spaces by trans women.

Why do the trans women (males) count more in this scenario than the women they have harmed?

Why should we have laws which support harm to women?

I'm not disagreeing with you. I said in my original post you quoted that I agreed that transwomen should not have carte blanche access to women's spaces.

Graciebobcat · 06/10/2023 09:09

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 09:07

Emerged under, not done by, there is a difference.

At the moment there is a fight back via various tribunals etc because what has been happening in various places / to various women is not enshrined in law.
If labour / lib dems / greens get in it may well become enshrined in law....

Fuck them. If they disagreed with it they've had THIRTEEN YEARS to enact different legislation, and they have had majority governments who would have been able to do that easily.

Only now they are bothered, when they likely won't be in power soon so won't actually have to do anything.

The entire speech was just pissing in the wind.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 09:09

ElleCapitaine · 06/10/2023 09:01

All this gender nonsense emerged under Tory rule. Why would we want more of it?

What has Labour or Lib Dems said that makes you think we’ll get less of it?

Do you think they’ll provide single sex spaces. How?

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 09:08

Graciebobcat · 06/10/2023 09:06

I was referring to the legal position, not the biological one.

Ok but why should some males have laws that entitle them to use spaces for females?

It's a legal fiction, it's impossible for a human being to change sex and this is what has led directly to women being harmed in single sex spaces by trans women.

Why do the trans women (males) count more in this scenario than the women they have harmed?

Why should we have laws which support harm to women?