Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
venus7 · 06/10/2023 10:16

NotTerfNorCis · 06/10/2023 07:58

I think genderism is slowly fading away anyway. It's a fad for the kids and it'll become untrendy. Genderism isn't just about tolerance for trans people, it's an irrational belief system which tranforms 'gender' into personality.

This......I agree, it seems to be diminishing slightly. I certainly hope so.
And no, I couldn't vote Tory, not in a thousand years.

Cecilisacaterpillar · 06/10/2023 10:14

I genuinely don't feel I can vote for any of the available options so, for the first time ever, I probably won't vote at all. I hate that that's where we are but I would have to hold my nose whoever I chose and my conscience would trouble me either way so abstention seems my only option. That said it is Labour's stance on the 'what is a woman' question which stops me voting for them, I would support them if they did a u-turn on this issue. I can't vote Tory irrespective of this issue though, 13 years of this shit is enough for anyone.

purplesky18 · 06/10/2023 10:14

Il preface by saying I agree trans women should not be in female prisons/compete in women’s sport etc but there are ways to discuss this without denying the existence of trans women. To add I also recognise the rights trans women have to live as themselves without persecution, I think a lot of trans women actually agree other provisions should be made it’s only the very few nutters that believe they are superior to biological women that get heard because they shout the loudest which then gets spun into a media campaign to stir up emotions.

The hateful rhetoric the Tory party are sprouting for votes is disgusting, if people believe 0.5% of the population is a threat to women’s rights more than the Tory party themselves they need to give their heads a wobble and come off the internet for a while. Trans people are HUMAN the same as us women are and deserve to live in peace, we need to remember that sometimes while the media are trying to pit two marginalised communities against each other.

LadyBitsnBobs · 06/10/2023 10:13

No it’s not enough. He hasn’t addressed the fundamentals at all - it’s another slimey attempt to look like they have answered a question when they haven’t.

The Conservatives lack values and principles. Their ideology is broken and unsuitable for modern Britain, for the modern world, for our younger generations. There are plenty of young people who are gender critical who might respect a party that tackled these issues head on. That party is not the Conservatives.

charlertin · 06/10/2023 10:10

LOL...Sunak and his crew knows exactly what they're doing. The Christians and other religious groups are eating it up. He's got their votes.

Whereforartthoudave · 06/10/2023 10:10

They are absolutely fucking deluded. But it most be hard for them to really gauge the mood of the nation from their millionaire estates.

Whereforartthoudave · 06/10/2023 10:09

Our mortgages are through the roof. Our health service is on its knees and our schools are crumbling.
But for some reason the Tories think screaming about trans people, small boats, car speed limits and denying any responsibility despite being in power for 13 years will somehow win them an election.

Ostryga · 06/10/2023 10:08

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 10:04

Why would it be transphobic to want to support a party that understands women's sex based rights?

There are lots of reasons not to vote Tory, but saying it is transphobic to support women's sex based rights does not make sense.

Because the only reason people are voting Tory is due to trans rights. That in itself is transphobic.

If you’re so worried about women’s rights, not just the ones in relation to trans women then you’d never even consider voting Tory.

Trans is a very small percentage of the actual issues women face on a daily basis, and the Tories aren’t going to do a thing about it. Just make it worse and worse. But at least you can call a trans woman a man right!

Finteq · 06/10/2023 10:08

No

KissKiss29 · 06/10/2023 10:07

I was always pro-labour and have voted for them all my life but now I am politically homeless. I don't believe a word from any of them.

I am glad he made the statement though as it opens up a wider conversation that needs to happen.

Graciebobcat · 06/10/2023 10:07

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 10:04

Why would it be transphobic to want to support a party that understands women's sex based rights?

There are lots of reasons not to vote Tory, but saying it is transphobic to support women's sex based rights does not make sense.

It's not too far a stretch to think that a lot of people in local Conservative associations will be transphobic though. And also sexist, racist, disablist and homophobic. Their own MPs and local councillors often come out with comments along these lines too.

Chonkadoodle · 06/10/2023 10:07

I’d rather stick my head in a deep fat fryer than vote Tory.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 10:05

Ostryga · 06/10/2023 09:58

I’m as GC as they come, but would never vote Tory.

If you’re voting Tory just because they say a woman is a woman then you’re throwing millions of women under the bus, far more will suffer at the hands of the Tories than any trans rights would ever cause.

It would come off as pure transphobia to me to vote Tory based on one policy.

If you are ‘GC as they come’ why do you find the statement transphobic?

LadyWithLapdog · 06/10/2023 10:05

@dianamoonyan https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/keir-starmer-woman-adult-female-trans-labour-party/ here’s another link and let’s hope there’ll be more over the coming months. Meanwhile, have a look at what the Tories have done. Not in a whataboutery way but because they truly have shat on everything: sewage in rivers, NHS waiting lists, the poverty, corruption, “culture wars” they so love to stoke and an endless list of other things.

Keir Starmer insists a woman is an ‘adult female’ as he says gender self-identification is not ‘right way forward’

The Labour leader has said that he believes a woman is an ‘adult female’ as he was quizzed on gender during a recent interview.

https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/keir-starmer-woman-adult-female-trans-labour-party/

blameless · 06/10/2023 10:05

longwayoff · 06/10/2023 07:59

As if. I'd be more reassured if he knew what the duties of a PM are, thus developing policies that ensure the population has adequate access to housing and enough food to eat. Not interested in any statement he cares to make about genitalia.

This appears to sum up everything about modern politics, worldwide.
Just over half of the UK are biologically female, yet no party seems interested in this demographic.
No politician of any stripe gives a damn about what voters want, they just want to be less unpopular than the competition, every four or five years - after which they don't even have to show up at the workplace.

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 10:04

Ostryga · 06/10/2023 09:58

I’m as GC as they come, but would never vote Tory.

If you’re voting Tory just because they say a woman is a woman then you’re throwing millions of women under the bus, far more will suffer at the hands of the Tories than any trans rights would ever cause.

It would come off as pure transphobia to me to vote Tory based on one policy.

Why would it be transphobic to want to support a party that understands women's sex based rights?

There are lots of reasons not to vote Tory, but saying it is transphobic to support women's sex based rights does not make sense.

Chesq · 06/10/2023 10:04

SeptemberSuns · 06/10/2023 08:46

Yep utterly tedious, ill-informed, transphobic attitudes. Go back to the 1950s where you could live your best racist, misogynistic, homophobic lives too.

Everyone is entitled to their own beliefs and opinions. Just because someone doesn't agree with your opinion does not automatically make them a bigot or transphobic. Many people, including myself, have religious beliefs which conflict with this issue and denying them that or persecuting someone for hold a religious belief is racist. Have your opinion but don't force it on others though.

PosterBoy · 06/10/2023 10:03

It's more the other way round.
I can't vote for a party that thinks men can become women.
So that only leaves the Tories or no vote

Fran2023 · 06/10/2023 10:02

No.

And actually if you interrogate the statement it is not actually saying what some think it is. All it says is ‘a woman is a woman.’ It is not giving any definition of what a woman is, so Sunak retains plausible deniability when challenged.

Willing to be proved wrong if he talked in greater detail in his speech, as my tolerance of wind bagging politicians is so low that I haven’t listened to the whole speech.

Ostryga · 06/10/2023 09:58

I’m as GC as they come, but would never vote Tory.

If you’re voting Tory just because they say a woman is a woman then you’re throwing millions of women under the bus, far more will suffer at the hands of the Tories than any trans rights would ever cause.

It would come off as pure transphobia to me to vote Tory based on one policy.

SoShallINever · 06/10/2023 09:58

BadBarry · 06/10/2023 09:37

So far they are the best on offer, that's not to mean I wouldn't choose another party if I could I just don't see a better option right now.

Jesus wept.
They have crashed the economy. There needs to a public enquiry into the billions they have wasted in the HS2 debacle. Housing crisis, NHS in absolute tatters, kids in utter poverty.
Water companies pouring sewage into waterways without any consequences.
Backhanders to their mates running oilfields when actually our country is already running mainly on renewables and renewable energy is cheaper
Partying when I couldn't see my own dying relative. Handing contracts to friends of friends.

They are the biggest group of self serving bastards this country has ever had in charge.

Ask yourself why Rishi the billionaire wants to work full time in a job that pays £160k if it isn't to protect his own wealth.

How the fuck can you say there is no alternative? A group of sixth form politics students could do a better job.

dianamoonyan · 06/10/2023 09:56

I don't tend to vote on a single issue and I don't support the conservatives at all but unless Labour make it clear that they understand that women don't have a penis and pledge that they will secure women's single sex spaces and prevent the medical abuse of children then I won't be voting for them either.

MargotBamborough · 06/10/2023 09:55

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 06/10/2023 09:52

This. This is my whole feelings on the matter.

As a woman I want safe spaces, but honestly-when was the last time you felt unsafe in a bathroom? I never have.

The NHS is on its knees and I work in it, the choice of schools my 11 year old had to start year 7 in were shit, shitter and shittiest (there were 3). The junior school he just moved up from had its funding slashed again. They couldn’t even take them on a trip to the local attraction as an end of year 6 treat. The cost of living crisis meant they refused to ask the parents to contribute because they have several families who are relying on food banks and the local community swap shop to clothe their children. I’m refusing to put my heating on until the temp goes below 5 degrees.

These are the issues affecting me. Not whether John wants to wear a dress and call himself Brenda

Lucky you, you've never felt unsafe in the women's toilets.

That's because you've never met Katie Dolatowski in there.

Bedbouncer · 06/10/2023 09:54

ahtred · 06/10/2023 07:36

No, as much as the trans issue infuriates and worries me, it's not the key issue I will be voting over, allowing the Tories back in over what is actually quite small issue (especially now I feel common sense might actually prevail) would be giving the issue more gravitas than it deserves. I won't let my vote be swayed to this horrific government because of this intensely irritating situation.

I don't think it is "actually quite small issue". I think it's a huge matter whether or not people feel free to tell the truth about what they perceive, and is completely undermining confidence in various fields, including science, which frightens me.
I still won't be voting for this bunch of incompetent, money-grabbing, manipulative buffoons though. They've shown us how they run the country. To say I'm not impressed would be a massive understatement.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 06/10/2023 09:52

ElleCapitaine · 06/10/2023 08:30

Oh for heavens sake, the NHS is in meltdown, schools are stretched beyond coping, there’s raw sewage in our waters, we are living through the biggest cost of living crisis since WW2, and we are being shat upon from a great height by a corrupt government. I couldn’t give a flying fuck if a man wants to wear a dress and call himself Brenda. The gender issue is a sideshow in politics, not the main event. Something needs to change.

This. This is my whole feelings on the matter.

As a woman I want safe spaces, but honestly-when was the last time you felt unsafe in a bathroom? I never have.

The NHS is on its knees and I work in it, the choice of schools my 11 year old had to start year 7 in were shit, shitter and shittiest (there were 3). The junior school he just moved up from had its funding slashed again. They couldn’t even take them on a trip to the local attraction as an end of year 6 treat. The cost of living crisis meant they refused to ask the parents to contribute because they have several families who are relying on food banks and the local community swap shop to clothe their children. I’m refusing to put my heating on until the temp goes below 5 degrees.

These are the issues affecting me. Not whether John wants to wear a dress and call himself Brenda