Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
purplesky18 · 06/10/2023 11:13

I see comments daily denying that trans women exist so it’s not an odd comment at all. I see comments saying they are a he not a she, using their male name before transitioning and that’s without delving into the few batshit comments I’ve seen on trans based articles inciting violence towards them. So don’t pretend this level of hatred and erasing doesn’t exist because it does and it’s naïve to think it doesn’t.

Do I believe trans women are women no I do not but I think they are in their own category that shouldn’t tarnish them automatically as men when they choose not to live that way, it’s not my business to tell people how to live their lives as themselves. This is the debate we need to find a middle ground for trans women and women to co exist together but separately without the hate that comes with it, how we do that I don’t know but I do believe the Tory party isn’t the answer.

blameless · 06/10/2023 11:12

purplesky18 · 06/10/2023 10:14

Il preface by saying I agree trans women should not be in female prisons/compete in women’s sport etc but there are ways to discuss this without denying the existence of trans women. To add I also recognise the rights trans women have to live as themselves without persecution, I think a lot of trans women actually agree other provisions should be made it’s only the very few nutters that believe they are superior to biological women that get heard because they shout the loudest which then gets spun into a media campaign to stir up emotions.

The hateful rhetoric the Tory party are sprouting for votes is disgusting, if people believe 0.5% of the population is a threat to women’s rights more than the Tory party themselves they need to give their heads a wobble and come off the internet for a while. Trans people are HUMAN the same as us women are and deserve to live in peace, we need to remember that sometimes while the media are trying to pit two marginalised communities against each other.

That less than 0.5% of the population who are biologically male but identify as female can bully, de-platform and stigmatise 50.8% of the population with the full support of the major political parties and MSM is more concerning.

DeadButDelicious · 06/10/2023 11:05

All Sunak has done is latch on to an issue that evokes a strong reaction from both sides and simply picked the one he thinks will benefit him most.

The Tories do not give a shiny shit about women. Their record speaks for itself. Doesn't care about women starving does he? Or victims of rape? Domestic violence? Nah. But sure he 'knows what a woman is'. All the better to continue throwing them under the bus.

I have never and will never vote Tory. There is nothing he could say, no promise he could make that would make me vote for a party that has caused such devastation. The sooner we can get rid of this hideous government the better.

RobynRB · 06/10/2023 11:03

theDudesmummy · 06/10/2023 10:42

I am a socialist, but the Socialist Party has come out for the alphabet and explicitly against WPUK. No-one to vote for at all now.

I must admit I was considering voting for Labour next time because I think it's not good for any party to be in over and over again. But between the ULEZ and the letter people I'm not sure I can. But then again my vote won't make a blind bit of difference where I live in Toryland anyway.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 10:54

so true- the amount of abuse on here is unreal

If you can get a thread going with enough posts telling women they are transphobic or bigots AIBU it is

Too many requests for single sex spaces and off you go

Tiddlywinkly · 06/10/2023 10:52

I'm GC and will never vote Tory, but is it too little too late with Keir's eventual concession in July that women are biological females? I don't trust him at all.

dianamoonyan · 06/10/2023 10:51

theDudesmummy · 06/10/2023 10:42

I am a socialist, but the Socialist Party has come out for the alphabet and explicitly against WPUK. No-one to vote for at all now.

The Communist Party of Britain are pro-women's rights but I doubt they will field many candidates, it's very difficult to be a feminist and a socialist at the moment given that the parties that the left in general is choosing to centre men's desires over women's needs and rights. Very depressing indeed.

SerendipityJane · 06/10/2023 10:46

RobynRB · 06/10/2023 10:42

I wonder what happens if Labour get in and people suddenly realise nothing really changes, thousands of council houses don't appear and we're all in more or less the same situation as we were. It's easy to talk a good game when you're not actually responsible for steering the ship.

Meet the new boss ?

However, no matter how corrupt, venal and immoral Labour may want to be, they can't equal the Tories from day one. It takes years (13 years to be precise) to become as mired in murk as the Tories have. And I will take the 4 years breather gladly.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 10:45

TheShellBeach · 06/10/2023 10:40

Of course they haven't.

Tories would prefer for women to stay at home and do the housework and cooking.

There is no way they want to protect women or women's rights, or women's need for safe, single-sex spaces.

And as far as your original question goes - no, I would rather stick pins into my eyes than vote Tory.

I found it easier to work with 30 free childcare hours not 15. Probably one of the few state policies that immediately helped. That got upped for my last dc

TheShellBeach · 06/10/2023 10:43

..................but there are ways to discuss this without denying the existence of trans women

Eh? Who is denying that transwomen exist?

Odd comment.

theDudesmummy · 06/10/2023 10:42

I am a socialist, but the Socialist Party has come out for the alphabet and explicitly against WPUK. No-one to vote for at all now.

RobynRB · 06/10/2023 10:42

bemorelemmy · 06/10/2023 09:40

so true- the amount of abuse on here is unreal

I wonder what happens if Labour get in and people suddenly realise nothing really changes, thousands of council houses don't appear and we're all in more or less the same situation as we were. It's easy to talk a good game when you're not actually responsible for steering the ship.

Iamnotastick · 06/10/2023 10:40

CheshireCat1 · 06/10/2023 10:38

A huge red flag for me was the dehumanising language used by Suella Braverman in her conference speech. No, I definitely won’t be voting Conservative regardless of what Sunak said. Sunak’s words were empty, Braverman’s words were frightening.

Very reminiscent of Thatchers speech against gay people.

I am fine to have discussions around women-only spaces and the issues with self ID, but I am not here for demonising people. The Tories are nothing but Daily Mail hate fodder.

TheShellBeach · 06/10/2023 10:40

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:36

I wonder if the tories have any plans to actually protect women (and not just the definition of one).

Of course they haven't.

Tories would prefer for women to stay at home and do the housework and cooking.

There is no way they want to protect women or women's rights, or women's need for safe, single-sex spaces.

And as far as your original question goes - no, I would rather stick pins into my eyes than vote Tory.

CheshireCat1 · 06/10/2023 10:38

A huge red flag for me was the dehumanising language used by Suella Braverman in her conference speech. No, I definitely won’t be voting Conservative regardless of what Sunak said. Sunak’s words were empty, Braverman’s words were frightening.

QOD · 06/10/2023 10:35

i saw a tiktok of a trans man who had accidentally fallen pregnant and wanted to be treated as a man throughout his pregnancy.
I mean I get that completely but "getting pregnant accidentally" means he was having hetorosexual sex so ... it all baffles me?

Be who you want to be, sleep with whoever and however you want, but if you have a functioning penis I am not comfortable with sharing changing space.

PomRuns · 06/10/2023 10:30

I can’t vote for either at the moment but I’m glad he’s said it and I hope it prompts others to speak up.

Iamnotastick · 06/10/2023 10:24

Nah this is pure show to get headlines.

If they actually actually cared about women, where is the funding for DV services? Why has the childcare funding conversation stalled?

There are more reports of male politicians assaulting women than trans women attacking women.

All of the changes that have happened with respect to gender-neutral spaces happened under THEIR GOVERNMENT.

chaosmaker · 06/10/2023 10:21

ViolettaVonVargon · 06/10/2023 07:33

No one ever admits to voting Tory on mumsnet, it’s just a klaxon to get abuse. Obviously lots do though otherwise they wouldn’t have spent the last 13 years in power

FPTP doesn't mean they win though, it's all a big con, along with boundary changes to keep them in power. Not fiddling the count, just other things.

Starlightstarbright2 · 06/10/2023 10:20

I mean last election they were going to help the poverty areas in the north - there are more people in poverty than ever before .. so no I don’t buy any bullshit out there mouths

Cowlover89 · 06/10/2023 10:20

AccountantMum · 06/10/2023 09:22

Yes - Not because this has changed my mind but because I think they are the better option

You're ridiculous wanting to vote for them. I won't be voting at all. They're all the same.

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 10:18

@purplesky18 I don't think anyone 'denies the existence of transpeople'.

Helleofabore · 06/10/2023 10:17

LadyWithLapdog · 06/10/2023 09:52

@Helleofabore How was it open to interpretation? He used the exact words people have wanted to hear. I hope he does clarify further, if needed. I don’t know the internal workings of the party, but let’s hope they’ve learnt something after the Corbyn debacle, such as living in reality.

When you consider it in light of his previous statements he has made it is not quite as clear.

On the radio, as per your article he declared that a woman is an 'adult female'. When he has defined woman in the past he included people who had transitioned. He has said "trans women are women, and that is not just my view - that is actually the law".

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12341781/Keir-Starmer-finally-accepts-woman-adult-female-Labour-leader-confirms-party-U-turn-gender-self-identification-admits-policy-not-right-way-forward.html

Well under that 'law' those male people can describe themselves as 'female' on their documents etc. So, if Starmer, a lawyer, says 'a woman is an adult female', I remain sceptical about what he means. I am suspicious enough because it has not been clarified by him and he has used ambiguous wording to this effect before. Speaking of 'safe spaces' being protected, but never stating they were single sex, and it turned out that at those times, the shadow ministry were still making statements that allowed males with GRC or the intention of getting one to use those spaces.

I am all for Starmer coming out and being very clear and would celebrate that.

I mean, what a situation where we have doubts because of the language being used. But that language was carefully curated by a team who could see what was happening in the majority of the population, but who need to keep other factions on side.

It sounded great. However, from talking to women in my local Labour Party trying to get motions to get that would provide that clarity tabled is being rejected still. The women's labour declaration were still rejected from having a table at conference and I am very keen to see just how many women who support single sex spaces are given a voice.

I hope that I have explained it well enough. I am tired so I expect that I won't have.

Keir Starmer finally accepts a woman is an 'adult female'

After months of struggling to say whether a woman could have a penis, Sir Keir Starmer yesterday tried to clear up the confusion.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12341781/Keir-Starmer-finally-accepts-woman-adult-female-Labour-leader-confirms-party-U-turn-gender-self-identification-admits-policy-not-right-way-forward.html

TeenDivided · 06/10/2023 10:16

Let's say this issue was about something else.

Suppose Labour was going to solve every current issue under the sun, but was also going to remove the right to vote from women.

How would people balance it? Vote Tory to keep the right to vote, even though they were going to mess up education or health? Or vote Labour, give away one of the fundamental rights of women, but know that under the benevolent patriarchal system we'd all be looked after.

Everyone balances up different issues and weighs them differently. That is our right in a democratic society. Calling people names does no good.

How people weigh keeping women's single sex rights against all the other issues is up to them. But it is not 'transphobic' to want them protected.