Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Diamondcurtains · 11/10/2023 17:04

Yes although I’m not sure I’m even going to vote because neither party will make anything better.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 17:04

"It’s complicated and I’m trying to see it from everyone’s point of view which clearly you aren’t interested in".

Who is not interested? Or is it that many of the people replying to your posts have deeply thought about it and are pointing out the flaws and the issues in your own thinking that you frame it as 'people not listening to everyone's point of view'?

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 17:02

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:51

I am not arguing that trans women should have access to all the same places and things that other women should have. I think there should be safeguards and equality considerations. But I do think we should figure out a way for them to still be an able to comfortably live as the gender they want. My point is to just say ‘women are women’ doesn’t say anything meaningful about how trans people can live without causing unfairness to other women. They say it because they want votes from GC people without putting the work into solving this complicated problem

Edited

"But I do think we should figure out a way for them to still be an able to comfortably live as the gender they want."

Again, do you realise the hypocrisy in what you are posting here.

You are supporting single sex spaces, safeguarding and sports, while YOU are denying some trans people exist by your very own discussion points. Extreme trans activists do not want to listen to your points because it denies them the very thing that they demand. That the only way to 'live comfortably as the gender they want', is to deny that sex cannot change, to deny their sex and demand to be treated as if they were natal females in every aspect of their lives. Check out some of the most prominent trans spokespeople if you don't believe me.

You say you don't know the answers, yet, you don't seem to see the hypocrisy in your posts.

Also are you really claiming that the Tories have just said this because they want votes from 'GC people' and are those people you referred to on this page as the people with this statement -"they want to dog whistle their homophobia base enough to get more votes without actually doing anything".

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 16:47

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:51

I am not arguing that trans women should have access to all the same places and things that other women should have. I think there should be safeguards and equality considerations. But I do think we should figure out a way for them to still be an able to comfortably live as the gender they want. My point is to just say ‘women are women’ doesn’t say anything meaningful about how trans people can live without causing unfairness to other women. They say it because they want votes from GC people without putting the work into solving this complicated problem

Edited

I believe out of all parties, they ARE working on solving this complicated problem. They have sponsored the Cass report, they have made statements about sports though the UK sports body, they have actually allowed women's groups to participate in committee hearings and consultations (unlike the SNP or Labour - because Labour didn't allow Women's Labour Declaration to even have a stall at conference).

They ARE looking into the guidance for schools. The hold up is the wording of the Equality Act 2010 which I believe was passed by a Labour government, please correct me if I am mistaken. There is little point making legal guidance on an issue if that guidance is illegal. Or do you think that they are just holding out after delaying it for months because they just don't care?

Would you like to tell us what you think Labour would have done up to now please? I really would like to hear people's opinions, considering that Keir Starmer, Jess Philips and Lisa Nanny have simply used ambiguous language at conference to leave everyone guessing what they mean. But up to mid this year, Starmer was very clear that legally male people could be female and should access everything that was female single sex provisions. Oh... except for prisons after the massively huge public pushback on that in January.

Please do be specific in what other parties would have done, in your mind, regarding female single sex spaces and sports for a start. And regarding the guidance to schools.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 16:39

doesn’t say anything meaningful about how trans people can live without causing unfairness to other women

Male trans people are not "other women". Accommodating their wishes requires consideration of what rights women need. If they actually were women, these problems wouldn't arise.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 16:35

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:41

The more accurate analogy would be denying people can be Christian’s and saying people can only be Jewish.

No. This is not accurate at all. It is a false analogy. Because you are claiming that a male can be a female and this is simply not material reality. You have positioned this as being two belief systems comparatively.

Please can you tell us how a human can change sex? Because to date not one single human has ever done so.

Helleofabore · 11/10/2023 16:31

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:31

You might think that. Trans people don’t. So the government saying they aren’t the gender they want to be is denying a key part of who they think they are. Surely you understand the effect a statement like that would have on a trans person. Even if you don’t agree with them.

You seem to be ignoring the many transwomen who don't agree with you. They know that they are both male AND that they are not women. So, you seem to be speaking for some trans people and not others. Do you ever listen to trans people who don't agree with you?

Ofcourseshecan · 11/10/2023 16:07

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:51

I am not arguing that trans women should have access to all the same places and things that other women should have. I think there should be safeguards and equality considerations. But I do think we should figure out a way for them to still be an able to comfortably live as the gender they want. My point is to just say ‘women are women’ doesn’t say anything meaningful about how trans people can live without causing unfairness to other women. They say it because they want votes from GC people without putting the work into solving this complicated problem

Edited

Cornflakes, it’s not a question of ‘transwomen’ and ‘other women’. Once you start talking like that you’ve been defeated before you even start to fight for your rights.

If’s about men and women. Some men want to be seen as women, and that’s fine as far as wearing frocks and high heels and make-up.

But no one should collude with the delusion that they are women. Because then they claim the right to enter women’s spaces, such as changing rooms, hospital wards and prisons, which are segregated by sex for women’s safety. They take women’s sports medals and jobs that need to be done by women, such as in rape crisis centres and domestic violence shelters, or providing intimate care to disabled women.

All of this stems from allowing the pretence that they are women, just a different kind of woman. That’s not true, and you’re not being kind to anyone pretending it is.

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 16:01

unsurprisingly I don’t have all the answers. It’s complicated and I’m trying to see it from everyone’s point of view which clearly you aren’t interested in. This is why this who issue is so toxic.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 15:53

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:51

I am not arguing that trans women should have access to all the same places and things that other women should have. I think there should be safeguards and equality considerations. But I do think we should figure out a way for them to still be an able to comfortably live as the gender they want. My point is to just say ‘women are women’ doesn’t say anything meaningful about how trans people can live without causing unfairness to other women. They say it because they want votes from GC people without putting the work into solving this complicated problem

Edited

OK, let's unpick this a little.

If you don't think trans women should have access to all women's single sex spaces, which spaces do you think they should not have access to, and why not?

If they are, as you seem to believe, women, why should they not have unfettered access to all women's spaces?

And if they do not have unfettered access to all women's spaces, what does "living as the gender they want" actually look like, as far as you are concerned?

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:51

I am not arguing that trans women should have access to all the same places and things that other women should have. I think there should be safeguards and equality considerations. But I do think we should figure out a way for them to still be an able to comfortably live as the gender they want. My point is to just say ‘women are women’ doesn’t say anything meaningful about how trans people can live without causing unfairness to other women. They say it because they want votes from GC people without putting the work into solving this complicated problem

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 15:51

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:41

The more accurate analogy would be denying people can be Christian’s and saying people can only be Jewish.

No, it would not be even remotely similar to that.

For a start, you can follow any religion you want, or none at all.

You can be a committed Christian, or atheist, and convert to Judaism.

But no human has ever changed sex.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 15:46

To recap:

People are free to believe in the existence of innate "gender identity"

No one else should be required to do so, especially when it affects other people's rights

ArabellaScott · 11/10/2023 15:46

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:41

The more accurate analogy would be denying people can be Christian’s and saying people can only be Jewish.

No. A more accurate analogy would be saying that anyone can call themselves Christian, but that does not mean they are entitled to dress up like a Bishop and try to take over the CoE. Or wear a dog collar and claim a council tax exemption.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 15:44

The more accurate analogy would be denying people can be Christian’s and saying people can only be Jewish.

No, it would not.

ArabellaScott · 11/10/2023 15:43

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:31

You might think that. Trans people don’t. So the government saying they aren’t the gender they want to be is denying a key part of who they think they are. Surely you understand the effect a statement like that would have on a trans person. Even if you don’t agree with them.

If a person with delusions claims to be Napoleon, it is not 'denying their existence' to disagree.

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:43

That’s what they are hinting at. Without actually doing anything legally or with legislation about it. They haven’t actually said it

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:41

The more accurate analogy would be denying people can be Christian’s and saying people can only be Jewish.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 15:34

You might think that. Trans people don’t. So the government saying they aren’t the gender they want to be is denying a key part of who they think they are.

Has the government said that trans people "aren't the gender they want to be"? What does that even mean? They're entitled to "identify" how they want. It is a scientific fact that sex is immutable, that's the issue.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 15:34

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:31

You might think that. Trans people don’t. So the government saying they aren’t the gender they want to be is denying a key part of who they think they are. Surely you understand the effect a statement like that would have on a trans person. Even if you don’t agree with them.

Saying that a trans person is not the opposite sex, as much as they might want to be, is not denying that they exist. This is hyperbole.

Just like saying that God isn't real is not the same as denying that Christians exist.

I'm sorry if saying these things is hurtful to trans people, but not saying these things is harmful to women.

WickedSerious · 11/10/2023 15:31

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:25

To say trans women aren’t women, which is what they are hinting at and what GC people what to hear, does deny trans peoples right to exist.

Of course it doesn't,they're men and men exist.

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:31

You might think that. Trans people don’t. So the government saying they aren’t the gender they want to be is denying a key part of who they think they are. Surely you understand the effect a statement like that would have on a trans person. Even if you don’t agree with them.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 15:27

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:25

To say trans women aren’t women, which is what they are hinting at and what GC people what to hear, does deny trans peoples right to exist.

How is it denying their right to exist?

ArabellaScott · 11/10/2023 15:26

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:25

To say trans women aren’t women, which is what they are hinting at and what GC people what to hear, does deny trans peoples right to exist.

In what way? It's a statement of fact.

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:25

To say trans women aren’t women, which is what they are hinting at and what GC people what to hear, does deny trans peoples right to exist.

Swipe left for the next trending thread