Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
ilovesooty · 06/10/2023 13:20

Clavinova · 06/10/2023 13:12

Patineur
None of this nonsense persuades me to change my view. Sunak's been caught out lying yet again over HS2. Why would I believe him on this? If he means it, why has he done nothing about it over the last year?

Did you miss this?
UK government to block Scottish gender bill
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64288757

I don't believe anything Keir Starmer says - I was listening to LBC last year when Starmer said there were 'about 6 people' with him at the beer and curry evening - in fact there were 16 other people there, not 6. Starmer also lied (some months later) when he said his 'hotel wasn't serving food' that evening - the hotel was serving food on the terrace until 9pm. Then he said 'all the restaurants and pubs were shut' - that was a lie - restaurants and pubs were serving food outside, Starmer ate at a restaurant (outside) the evening before, in Hull. Starmer wasn't fined but he clearly told a string of lies to cover his tracks.

Then there's the fact that Keir Starmer thinks 1 in 1000 women has a penis;

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/rishi-sunak-transgender-penis-b2319675.html

I see you're at it again. This thread is about what Sunak said and your whataboutery has been discredited already.

RobynRB · 06/10/2023 13:17

Not to be pedantic, but if you still have a penis you clearly aren't a woman, whether you believe you are a women once you've lopped it off is a different argument. Surely.

Clavinova · 06/10/2023 13:12

Patineur
None of this nonsense persuades me to change my view. Sunak's been caught out lying yet again over HS2. Why would I believe him on this? If he means it, why has he done nothing about it over the last year?

Did you miss this?
UK government to block Scottish gender bill
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64288757

I don't believe anything Keir Starmer says - I was listening to LBC last year when Starmer said there were 'about 6 people' with him at the beer and curry evening - in fact there were 16 other people there, not 6. Starmer also lied (some months later) when he said his 'hotel wasn't serving food' that evening - the hotel was serving food on the terrace until 9pm. Then he said 'all the restaurants and pubs were shut' - that was a lie - restaurants and pubs were serving food outside, Starmer ate at a restaurant (outside) the evening before, in Hull. Starmer wasn't fined but he clearly told a string of lies to cover his tracks.

Then there's the fact that Keir Starmer thinks 1 in 1000 women has a penis;

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/rishi-sunak-transgender-penis-b2319675.html

Helleofabore · 06/10/2023 13:11

chaosmaker · 06/10/2023 13:00

there is another way https://www.womensequality.org.uk/

No. A hard no. They believe that males can become women.

ilovesooty · 06/10/2023 13:10

chaosmaker · 06/10/2023 13:00

there is another way https://www.womensequality.org.uk/

No realistic chance of being elected in any seat they stand in anyway.

Until we have electoral reform a vote for minority parties is a wasted vote.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 13:04

chaosmaker · 06/10/2023 13:00

there is another way https://www.womensequality.org.uk/

No unfortunately they firmly believe that trans women are women and should be in our spaces.

Such a disappointment when I found that out.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 12:59

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 12:55

I just have no idea how it is has got to this stage.

I've no doubt people will say that pointing out that trans women are male and pose the same level of risk to women as any other male is transphobic.

But it isn't, it's just speaking the truth.

And as for all this denying the existence of trans people, well if that means that some people won't lie about the reality of the situation, well I won't. I don't think women come second to trans women. Why should we? If trans women feel unsafe in facilities for their own sex then that's something they need to address with males, it's not our issue to fix. Otherwise all we are doing is saying that putting some women at risk of harm is OK. I just don't think it is. A woman was raped by a trans woman in an NHS hospital on a women's ward. I seriously don't see how anyone can know that and still think that we should remove single sex spaces by putting trans women's wishes above women's safety.

I just have no idea how it is has got to this stage.

Men prioritise men and so do many women.

The laws and institutions prioritise men to make it even harder for women.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 12:55

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 12:48

Orwellian at this point. With plenty of transphobic and bigot abuse at women thrown in for good measure

I just have no idea how it is has got to this stage.

I've no doubt people will say that pointing out that trans women are male and pose the same level of risk to women as any other male is transphobic.

But it isn't, it's just speaking the truth.

And as for all this denying the existence of trans people, well if that means that some people won't lie about the reality of the situation, well I won't. I don't think women come second to trans women. Why should we? If trans women feel unsafe in facilities for their own sex then that's something they need to address with males, it's not our issue to fix. Otherwise all we are doing is saying that putting some women at risk of harm is OK. I just don't think it is. A woman was raped by a trans woman in an NHS hospital on a women's ward. I seriously don't see how anyone can know that and still think that we should remove single sex spaces by putting trans women's wishes above women's safety.

ilovesooty · 06/10/2023 12:52

dianamoonyan · 06/10/2023 12:20

Many people who are not single issue voters still care a great deal about women's rights and the harms to children and young people done by gender ideology, it remains a serious issue.

Not one that I think most of the electorate are likely to prioritise above other issues.

PomRuns · 06/10/2023 12:49

A lot of people are discussing (work/ friends) and are pleased, relieved that a leader in a political part has finally said this.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 12:48

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 12:38

I mean imagine thinking that saying that there are only 2 sexes could be considered contrary to the Equality Act by a flipping news reader.

That's absolutely astounding.

Humans can't change sex.

The one thing that every trans woman has in common and that they don't share with women is that they are male.

Society has historically recognised that women need safeguarding in certain circumstances from all males, this is not because all males pose a safety risk but it is in recognition of the fact that some males harm women. This should include trans women, otherwise we are saying that some males should have special rules, why? Especially now when there is a raft of evidence of actually harm to women done by allowing that group of males to enter our spaces. What I am not saying here is that all trans women harm women, they don't. But a proportion of them do and have.

What is/ or should be contrary to the Equality Act is removing women's rights and protected character of SEX in favour of gender.

Otherwise what we are saying is that women are not as important as males.

That's hideous.

Orwellian at this point. With plenty of transphobic and bigot abuse at women thrown in for good measure

OvaHere · 06/10/2023 12:47

Ostryga · 06/10/2023 12:32

Yes that’s exactly what I said - women shouldn’t be allowed to vote 😂

Your reading comprehension is lacking if that’s what you’ve garnered from my opinion.

I think it's yours that is lacking.

The phrase I used was 'who should be allowed to vote based on their perceived interests'.

This is not the same as me accusing you of saying women shouldn't vote.

It was a comment on whether single issue votes are only acceptable on one side of the debate.

ButterflyBitch · 06/10/2023 12:43

Yeh and weirdly enough after all his previous TWAW rhetoric, I don’t believe he is being honest with us.

Patineur · 06/10/2023 12:41

Clavinova · 06/10/2023 11:39

SerendipityJane
However, no matter how corrupt, venal and immoral Labour may want to be, they can't equal the Tories from day one

You have a selective memory: four or five Labour MPs from Gordon Brown's government were convicted of fraud/false accounting and sent to prison after the expenses scandal - Keir Starmer had three 'sex scandals' to deal with (in the same week) earlier this year.

Cumulatively that still leaves them way behind the Tories. The sheer level of blatant favouring of Conservative party donors and friends, to say nothing of the daily lies and the criminal convictions, is absolutely eye-watering.

None of this nonsense persuades me to change my view. Sunak's been caught out lying yet again over HS2. Why would I believe him on this? If he means it, why has he done nothing about it over the last year?

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2023 12:38

I mean imagine thinking that saying that there are only 2 sexes could be considered contrary to the Equality Act by a flipping news reader.

That's absolutely astounding.

Humans can't change sex.

The one thing that every trans woman has in common and that they don't share with women is that they are male.

Society has historically recognised that women need safeguarding in certain circumstances from all males, this is not because all males pose a safety risk but it is in recognition of the fact that some males harm women. This should include trans women, otherwise we are saying that some males should have special rules, why? Especially now when there is a raft of evidence of actually harm to women done by allowing that group of males to enter our spaces. What I am not saying here is that all trans women harm women, they don't. But a proportion of them do and have.

What is/ or should be contrary to the Equality Act is removing women's rights and protected character of SEX in favour of gender.

Otherwise what we are saying is that women are not as important as males.

That's hideous.

Beowulfa · 06/10/2023 12:38

PosterBoy · 06/10/2023 10:03

It's more the other way round.
I can't vote for a party that thinks men can become women.
So that only leaves the Tories or no vote

This is exactly my position. I'm hoping for an independent candidate strong on local issues on my ballot paper.

But I'd rather Labour or the Lib Dems just woke the fuck up and declared that respect for trans people does not come at the expense of women's sex-based rights. Why is this so hard?

Passepartoute · 06/10/2023 12:37

ButterflyBitch · 06/10/2023 12:02

This. I don’t know who I will vote for or if I will spoil my ballot. They’re all shit. I won’t vote for anyone who pretends men can become women but I also can’t vote Tory in good conscience.

But they don't all pretend that. Starmer has said directly the contrary.

Ostryga · 06/10/2023 12:32

OvaHere · 06/10/2023 12:02

I imagine a large percentage of LGBTQ+ activists will vote based on this single issue from the other side of the debate.

Are they in the wrong too or is it only women who are not allowed to do that?

Choosing to vote LD, Green or SNP purely because they are anti women is hardly some great moral stance but a lot will do just that. Would you also tell them they are wrong for prioritising their core activist beliefs?

I don't think the Tories are necessarily going to fix this mess at all but it seems there's a lot of hypocrisy on the subject of who should be allowed to vote based on their perceived interests.

Yes that’s exactly what I said - women shouldn’t be allowed to vote 😂

Your reading comprehension is lacking if that’s what you’ve garnered from my opinion.

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 12:30

Clavinova · 06/10/2023 12:25

ilovesooty
The Sky news poll indicates that the speech fell flat with the wider electorate. His "a woman is a woman" soundbite got no coverage at all in the news phone ins I heard yesterday

Is that because Sky's Kay Burley wrongly suggested that Rishi Sunak had broken the law with regards to the Equalities Act?

Blimey. I don’t bother with Sky news but that’s bad. Glad I don’t waste time on it

Clavinova · 06/10/2023 12:25

ilovesooty
The Sky news poll indicates that the speech fell flat with the wider electorate. His "a woman is a woman" soundbite got no coverage at all in the news phone ins I heard yesterday

Is that because Sky's Kay Burley wrongly suggested that Rishi Sunak had broken the law with regards to the Equalities Act?

EasternStandard · 06/10/2023 12:24

ilovesooty · 06/10/2023 12:13

The Sky news poll indicates that the speech fell flat with the wider electorate. His "a woman is a woman" soundbite got no coverage at all in the news phone ins I heard yesterday.

Outside Mumsnet and the single issue voters here I doubt if it will be prioritised by many voters at the ballot box.

What people view on the electorate depends on what you’re looking at too

Eg listening to various programmes or speaking to people it may represent a Brexit loss. But in the end it won

SerendipityJane · 06/10/2023 12:22

Clavinova · 06/10/2023 11:39

SerendipityJane
However, no matter how corrupt, venal and immoral Labour may want to be, they can't equal the Tories from day one

You have a selective memory: four or five Labour MPs from Gordon Brown's government were convicted of fraud/false accounting and sent to prison after the expenses scandal - Keir Starmer had three 'sex scandals' to deal with (in the same week) earlier this year.

And you have a comprehension problem (amongst others).

None of that happened on day one.

dianamoonyan · 06/10/2023 12:20

ilovesooty · 06/10/2023 12:13

The Sky news poll indicates that the speech fell flat with the wider electorate. His "a woman is a woman" soundbite got no coverage at all in the news phone ins I heard yesterday.

Outside Mumsnet and the single issue voters here I doubt if it will be prioritised by many voters at the ballot box.

Many people who are not single issue voters still care a great deal about women's rights and the harms to children and young people done by gender ideology, it remains a serious issue.

Helleofabore · 06/10/2023 12:20

purplesky18 · 06/10/2023 12:04

@Helleofabore if you want an honest answer I truly believe in my experience anyway that many trans women are painfully insecure due to the years of internal hate they’ve had towards themselves, they are not loud and don’t wish to get so directly involved with wider debates that could open them up to even more hate from the few in the community that hold extreme views. Most just want to get on with their lives.

Do I agree with this stance no I do not but do I truly blame them for sticking their head in the sand probably not either. It’s such a difficult topic and a fine line to cross. I just try to present the view point that trans people as a whole really do not wish to erase women’s rights as much as most women do not wish to erase trans rights. We need to truly open a dialogue with each community and just come up with something better.

I always want an honest answer. I never ask where I don’t want an honest answer.

I recollect you saying this before I believe.

I understand. However, there must be a way for them to get their message out to these groups who are supposedly working for them. Even if it means membership to an alternative lobby group.

For instance, would they write into consultations? I find it very hard to reconcile that they would simply leave women to be abused for campaigning for our needs when they agree with those needs being met and the activists doing the abuse are doing so effectively in your friend’s names.

As I say, I do understand how hard it is for them and how they could be treated. It is all such as mess.

We need to truly open a dialogue with each community and just come up with something better.

Yes. And I believe it needs to be cross party led. Otherwise it will never get the support it needs and may become a ball thrown between intraparty factions and political parties alike.