Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A woman is a woman

734 replies

EmotionSickness · 06/10/2023 07:29

For those who have been following the Tory conference and general themes of their speeches…

How do you feel about Sunak’s speech?

I know there has been a lot of discussion on here from those who didn’t want to vote for a party that didn’t know the definition of a woman.

Rishi has stated clearly that “a woman is a woman and a man is a man.” While I’d argue that still isn’t a definition, per se, he is appeasing this way of thinking.

So I’m just wondering. Is this enough for you to vote Tory at the next election?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
22
Grammarnut · 14/10/2023 19:45

Keir Starmer obviously does not do logic - or biology.

ErrolTheDragon · 14/10/2023 13:25

RobynRB · 14/10/2023 12:56

Without wishing to be overly simplistic about it.... they are called 'single SEX spaces', not 'single GENDER spaces'.

That's not overly simplistic, it really is that simple.

There are entirely valid reasons for needing single sex spaces.

There are none, that I've ever heard of, for needing a 'single gender' space. Indeed it's a meaningless concept as while there are 2 sexes, there could be as many 'genders' as there are people. If you changed mens and womens single sex facilities to 'masculine people' and 'feminine people', where's the androgynous 'nonbinary' or 'agender' person supposed to fit in. It's a nonsensical idea.

RobynRB · 14/10/2023 12:56

Without wishing to be overly simplistic about it.... they are called 'single SEX spaces', not 'single GENDER spaces'.

OvaHere · 12/10/2023 18:46

Holly60 · 12/10/2023 18:35

Even though he hasn't actually stated what he thinks a 'woman' is?

'A woman is a woman' means literally nothing. It means 'I will later define what a woman is depending on how the tide is turning'

He won't soundbite 'a woman is a biological female' just in case this doesn't work for the tories in years to come.

He's made himself very clear previously. Possibly he may want to walk this back in the future but more likely he just didn't want to discuss penises at the party conference so chose 'a woman is a woman' as the most PG rated option.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/rishi-sunak-transgender-penis-b2319675.html

https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1729985/rishi-sunak-piers-morgan-adult-human-femal-talktv

Rishi Sunak says 100% of women do not have a penis

It comes after Sir Keir Starmer said that ‘99.9 per cent of women’ do not have penises

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/rishi-sunak-transgender-penis-b2319675.html

Holly60 · 12/10/2023 18:35

Watchitsunshine · 06/10/2023 07:43

Yes. I will.

Even though he hasn't actually stated what he thinks a 'woman' is?

'A woman is a woman' means literally nothing. It means 'I will later define what a woman is depending on how the tide is turning'

He won't soundbite 'a woman is a biological female' just in case this doesn't work for the tories in years to come.

Holly60 · 12/10/2023 18:31

Immoralplant · 06/10/2023 07:37

I’ve never voted Tory.
I’m not keen on voting for them now, but I will only vote for a party whose leader knows what a woman is.

Currently it seems Rishi hasn't actually committed to saying what a woman is.

Would be good if he would answer the question 'what is a woman' without referring to the word woman.

'A woman is a woman' but unless we define what a woman is, the phrase is meaningless. Which is in no way a mistake from the Tories.

I will be voting labour.

chaosmaker · 11/10/2023 22:31

OK thanks :)

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 22:27

The Big Lie - how the WEP was always about gender rather than sex www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4058470-the-big-lie-how-the-wep-was-always-about-gender-rather-than-sex

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/10/2023 22:26

This is my thread from 2020 where I link to all the threads with WEP founders where they make it clear that they are TWAW.

chaosmaker · 11/10/2023 22:22

That's where the WEP looks interesting and I couldn't find anything specific about including TW in things like medical research as they wouldn't need to be factored in. I'm just not sure how TW fit into their manifesto except for the 'equality' bit which covers all humans.

Catiette · 11/10/2023 21:36

And yes, agree with that, too, Margot. I think this is where the current fashion of hierarchizing (?!) oppression can lead - a reductive "law" that someone can identify down into a "lower" group on the ladder (trans women into women), but not upwards (vice versa).

And I do find this growing tendency on the Left towards rather more extreme forms of social engineering concerning. To be a bit reductive, I see it as an attempt to force unpleasant realities into alternative, preferable shapes through language, law & the chilling effect (not more meaningful social change) - whereas the Tories are more about quite straightforwardly exploiting those unpleasant realities through unashamedly cynical self-interest (eg. capitalist forces). Devastatingly - and ironically - the latter can feel a bit more honest(!) and less sinister at times...

Both have huge potential to devastate women's lives. Both are having just that impact, right now. But one more more visibly & tangibly, & the other in a more abstract, existential, long-term sense: how do we address the concerns cited above in defence of Labour - "employment rights", health provision incl. medical research etc. - if we lose the ability to name, & measure, the 51% of the population they affect? I want to know that a survey on women in the top tiers of business is about women in the biological sense, but the proportions here mean that distorting the stats by including males will make women's progress less visible; ditto a desperately-needed recent study on the neglected issue of head injuries(? read about a while ago, can't recall specifics) in the female prison population whose data was corrupted by the inclusion of males.

It's easy to assume the more immediate issues - social infrastructure, tangible suffering - must come first, but is this short-sighted dismissal of even more significant issues - the loss of the measures (both in the counting sense, & in the sense of systems) that have enabled women to get as far as they have in the last hundred years, further down the line?

OK, so I guess the politics does interest me! 😂

No easy answers, as far as I'm concerned.

Catiette · 11/10/2023 21:09

FWIW, I've no interest in the voting aspect of this discussion - not at all certain what to do myself, or if I'll spoil my ballot. Hence an interest in the reasoning behind seemingly simple answers to difficult issues in a complex world. Honestly, Margot's answer's genuinely the only one I've been able to come up with myself after a heck of a lot of thought, but I keep searching for another explanation... Mad busy couple of days ahead, but will return to thread if poss.

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 20:38

Catiette · 11/10/2023 20:24

Extension question:

Is it not in trans people's interests to be respected as a distinct political class, too?

https://unherd.com/2023/04/how-the-trans-census-fooled-britain/

https://www.thepinknews.com/2023/08/07/nhs-wait-times-trans-healthcare-porterbrook/

It is, and they know this. But the same rules do not apply to both groups. This is why trans women can identify as women but women cannot identify as trans women.

But if you ask why biological women cannot identify as trans women, they will resort to circular explanations such as "because you're not trans, you're cis", rather than the truth, which is that you cannot be a trans woman unless you were born male. I think this has less to do with not wanting to acknowledge that trans women are biologically male and more to do with not wanting to acknowledge that there are groups you cannot simply identify into and can only be included in if you are the correct biological sex. Because then we would ask why that principle can't apply to "women".

WillowCraft · 11/10/2023 20:29

Nicole1111 · 06/10/2023 07:41

I can’t bear the incredibly transparent diversion techniques in an attempt get votes. We care about women. But not the ones starving. We care about women. But not the ones who can’t afford their rent. We care about women. But not the ones in the refuges we’re closing down. We care about women. But not the ones being raped who have a 1% chance of their rapist being convicted.

Edited

Exactly. It's a similar logic to the pro life activists who want save unborn babies but don't care about them once they're born

Catiette · 11/10/2023 20:25

(The point being that the current mangling of language makes it hard to assess and cater for their needs, too...)

Catiette · 11/10/2023 20:23

That's OK, I prepared an extension activity to keep the more confident kids busy... 😁

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 20:22

Sorry! 😅

Catiette · 11/10/2023 20:19

100%. Gold Star.

(But shhh - you've given it away for the students who are struggling. I was interested to see what they came up with.

Still am).

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 20:17

Catiette · 11/10/2023 20:12

  1. Some (not all) trans women want the definition of "women" to be expanded to include them. This is because they find the prospect of being called a man intensely distressing.

According to some posters, the correct response is: "To say trans women aren’t women, which is what GC people want to hear, does deny trans people's right to exist."

(Exist, in this sense, must logically refer to trans women's perception of themselves).

  1. Some (not all) biological women want the definition of "women" to be retained as "biological" only. This is because they find the prospect of losing the only word they have to describe themselves & advocate for their rights intensely disturbing.

According to some posters, the correct response is: "To say trans women are women, which is what trans people what to hear, doesn't deny women's right to exist."

(Exist, in this sense, must logically refer to biological women's perception of themselves, as well as their existence as a distinct political class).

QUESTION 1: Why is 1) correct & 2) incorrect? (10 marks)
QUESTION 2: How can anyone be sure of this? (50 marks)

Edited

Answer to Question 1: Because some people are more equal than others.

Answer to Question 2: Based on how the people who are more equal have treated the people who are less equal throughout human history.

Catiette · 11/10/2023 20:12

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:25

To say trans women aren’t women, which is what they are hinting at and what GC people what to hear, does deny trans peoples right to exist.

  1. Some (not all) trans women want the definition of "women" to be expanded to include them. This is because they find the prospect of being called a man intensely distressing.

According to some posters, the correct response is: "To say trans women aren’t women, which is what GC people want to hear, does deny trans people's right to exist."

(Exist, in this sense, must logically refer to trans women's perception of themselves).

  1. Some (not all) biological women want the definition of "women" to be retained as "biological" only. This is because they find the prospect of losing the only word they have to describe themselves & advocate for their rights intensely disturbing.

According to some posters, the correct response is: "To say trans women are women, which is what trans people what to hear, doesn't deny women's right to exist."

(Exist, in this sense, must logically refer to biological women's perception of themselves, as well as their existence as a distinct political class).

QUESTION 1: Why is 1) correct & 2) incorrect? (10 marks)
QUESTION 2: How can anyone be sure of this? (50 marks)

MargotBamborough · 11/10/2023 18:47

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 16:01

unsurprisingly I don’t have all the answers. It’s complicated and I’m trying to see it from everyone’s point of view which clearly you aren’t interested in. This is why this who issue is so toxic.

I'm going to be honest with you, it doesn't sound like you have any of the answers.

I hate to break it to you, but if you don't think trans women should have access to women's single sex spaces, you clearly don't actually believe they are women. You just think it's unkind to say so.

This kind of pussyfooting around isn't helpful to anyone.

Sueveneers · 11/10/2023 17:18

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 16:01

unsurprisingly I don’t have all the answers. It’s complicated and I’m trying to see it from everyone’s point of view which clearly you aren’t interested in. This is why this who issue is so toxic.

No, it is not complicated. At all. You're either male, or female. Very simple. You're making something that is not complicated, complicated. It's very straight forward. Male vs female. It's that simple.

Sueveneers · 11/10/2023 17:12

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:43

That’s what they are hinting at. Without actually doing anything legally or with legislation about it. They haven’t actually said it

No this is the more appropriate analogy: claiming foxes are hens -

A woman is a woman
Sueveneers · 11/10/2023 17:07

Cornflakes44 · 11/10/2023 15:31

You might think that. Trans people don’t. So the government saying they aren’t the gender they want to be is denying a key part of who they think they are. Surely you understand the effect a statement like that would have on a trans person. Even if you don’t agree with them.

Why is that up to women to solve? Women are not HUMAN SHIELDS for men in a dress. Transwomen are men. This is a fact. The majority of them - 92% to 97%, depending on what medical data you go by, retain their penis and testicles. Sorry to be vulgar, but if you have a cock and balls, you're not a woman, you're male, and you have no right being in female on safe single sex spaces. It's not up to women to figure out the problems of men. I really don't have the emotionally energy like most women, or care, what men think. Let them sort it out. They are men. And we don't want them in our spaces. I don't give a shit what TW think. Women don't have the headspace to sort out mens emotional problems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread