Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up breastfeeding 3 week old?

110 replies

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 06:29

Every time I breastfeed my 3 week old he spend the next few hours crying, spitting up and wriggling in pain.

On days where I exclusively breastfeed he also has had bad diarrhoea (12 poos a day vs his normal 5/6) and a red face and body.

When he has formula (when i was sick in hospital and when my supply had been too low for his appetite) he is much more content. He drinks, he can be burped nicely, no vomiting or spitting up and no diarrhoea or red blotchy skin.

I am so upset because I wanted to breastfeed and I feel like I can do it, I have a good latch and good supply now!

The doctor said there's no way he can be allergic to breast milk end of. I am coeliac and don't eat wheat and I gave up milk in case there was a dairy allergy.

I am seriously thinking I should switch to formula but I don't want to make him miss out on the benefits of BF and I'm afraid I will be judged.

Anyone been through similar? Or got ANY advice?

OP posts:
Isthisexpected · 06/10/2023 14:52

I don't really understand. It hasn't been long enough to get the allergens out of your system to even see?

Also my siblings and I were all formula fed and we are all healthy, very fit and "successful" (by some superficial standards at least) so I can say it hasn't done us any harm at all.

^ it won't have harmed you. It just won't have given you any of the benefits of breastfeeding, none of which you can see with your eyes, they're all inside the body.
.

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 11:38

I wonder why the NHS would have an agenda?

I see it as encouragement because maybe people give up for things they see as problems that are actually normal. But as someone else said, my case seems to be very individual and I am lumped in with the general view by the GP and the lactation consultant group.

They just don't see the full picture because I don't stay with him for a couple of days where I try EBF for two days and he's really struggling and then I formula feed him for a couple of bottles and he's a whole new baby.

I just wish I could pinpoint it and could carry on but it seems hopeless as none of the usual culprits are at fault here :((((

OP posts:
HannahsLife · 06/10/2023 10:57

Switch to FF.

There's nothing that could make me put my baby in pain like that when there's a perfectly good and safe alternative.

I can't tell you what's causing it, but clearly something is. The benefits of BF are not worth a new baby being put through pain.

MariaVT65 · 06/10/2023 09:32

Amidlifecrisis · 06/10/2023 09:14

@MariaVT65 you’re obviously not a scientist so it’s probably best not to speculate about the relationship between breastfeeding and obesity.

The reason the NHS has a “massive agenda” to encourage breastfeeding is because it will ultimately save them money down the line because of the health benefits for children and mothers. When comparing bf and ff it’s easy to forget that in addition to the benefits for the baby, bf significantly reduces the chance of the mother getting breast cancer, ovarian cancer and type 2 diabetes among other things.

The NHS is absolutely shit at supporting bf, and I’m sorry you had a bad experience, but that does not mean they are wrong about why it’s a good thing to do, if you can. Most people need proper support to breastfeed successfully, especially at the beginning, and most of the usual problems that people experience are surmountable with the proper support.

Since OP has said she wants to breastfeed, it’s worth fully exploring ways to make it work before deciding to stop. But of course I agree that she doesn’t need to feel guilty if she does decide to stop.

Yes the NHS is shit at supporting breastfeeding in a positive way, but also go too far the other way and fail to acknowledge when it’s just not going to work, and actively refuse to give women advice on bottle sterilisation or stopping breastfeeding safely. The way they approach things is quite harmful I think.

Amidlifecrisis · 06/10/2023 09:14

@MariaVT65 you’re obviously not a scientist so it’s probably best not to speculate about the relationship between breastfeeding and obesity.

The reason the NHS has a “massive agenda” to encourage breastfeeding is because it will ultimately save them money down the line because of the health benefits for children and mothers. When comparing bf and ff it’s easy to forget that in addition to the benefits for the baby, bf significantly reduces the chance of the mother getting breast cancer, ovarian cancer and type 2 diabetes among other things.

The NHS is absolutely shit at supporting bf, and I’m sorry you had a bad experience, but that does not mean they are wrong about why it’s a good thing to do, if you can. Most people need proper support to breastfeed successfully, especially at the beginning, and most of the usual problems that people experience are surmountable with the proper support.

Since OP has said she wants to breastfeed, it’s worth fully exploring ways to make it work before deciding to stop. But of course I agree that she doesn’t need to feel guilty if she does decide to stop.

Sapphire387 · 06/10/2023 09:01

I have lately had my third baby.

I bf my first two for over two years each.

My third, I have just given up after two months. She was born with terrible tongue tie, took WEEKS to get it sorted out, and what with the older kids (I also have a stepdaughter so it is three older kids), I couldn't manage, either physically or mentally, to sit there 24/7 with my boobs out trying to recover my supply.

So she is now ff. She is doing just fine. Actually sleeps better than the others did - might be a coincidence.

You have to do what you have to do. If it is making your baby miserable, it is ok to stop, you need no one's permission.

If you want to persevere, of course that is also ok, you need no one's permission. It does sound like a possible allergy to something you are eating so that would be worth investigating.

kamboozled · 06/10/2023 08:31

Don't stress about it. x

MariaVT65 · 06/10/2023 08:26

gotomomo · 06/10/2023 07:24

@MariaVT65

I'd be skeptical about information I get from random individuals on the internet!

The benefits of breastfeeding are firmly established internationally, it's also the natural way of feeding babies and free. More likely that baby is gulping air whilst feeding because the latch isn't correct causing wind and and possibly simply isn't feeding enough. Reflux is common and easily treated in most. It tss as lea 4-6 weeks to establish breast feeding after which it far easier than bottles.

All that said a baby needs feeding most of all, combi feeding is a great compromise.

If a baby is reacting to breastmilk, unless you have a specific thing in your diet eg a product in the coeliacs friendly foods then it could be just wind. When my dd2 was being sick I was advised to cut huge amounts from my diet and add back in - it was bananas!

So, OP has clearly come here with the exact purpose of getting advice from strangers on the internet. And I absolutely don’t blame her. I had my first baby during the pandemic and mumsnet was so much more useful than any NHS source.

As a PP said, the benefits are based on population level, not individuals and it’s more to do with a person’s welfare, upbringing and lifestyle. Oh and genetics.

Someone has quoted the NHS saying breastfeeding reduces the risk of obesity. I personally believe a person is more likely to be obese because they eat crap and don’t exercise, not because they were formula fed 25 years ago.

I was formula fed as I was unable to latch due to birth injury. I am very healthy, not obese, no asthma/eczema etc. My brother was breastfed and there is no difference between us.

The NHS as a whole has a massive agenda to breastfeed, in a way that causes harm to people. I had issues with supply and their advice was to eat lots and pump 12 times a day. They gave absolutely zero fucks about my wellbeing. All this did was not increase my supply, but make me put on weight and plummet my mental health to the ground from exhaustion and lack of sleep.

My best friend is a midwife and she said the NHS is very good at making women feel guilty, and that many midwives are changing their attitudes once they give birth themselves and then experience problems with breastfeeding.

The NHS also doesn’t give advice in classes about formula or sterilising bottles, despite it being needed in cases where a woman physically can’t breastfeed. It also doesn’t have any information for women who wish to give up breastfeeding in a safe manner while reducing the risk of mastitis.

In a nutshell, OP has no reason to feel guilty. Breastfeeding doesn’t work for many women, for many different reasons.

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 07:38

gotomomo · 06/10/2023 07:24

@MariaVT65

I'd be skeptical about information I get from random individuals on the internet!

The benefits of breastfeeding are firmly established internationally, it's also the natural way of feeding babies and free. More likely that baby is gulping air whilst feeding because the latch isn't correct causing wind and and possibly simply isn't feeding enough. Reflux is common and easily treated in most. It tss as lea 4-6 weeks to establish breast feeding after which it far easier than bottles.

All that said a baby needs feeding most of all, combi feeding is a great compromise.

If a baby is reacting to breastmilk, unless you have a specific thing in your diet eg a product in the coeliacs friendly foods then it could be just wind. When my dd2 was being sick I was advised to cut huge amounts from my diet and add back in - it was bananas!

I'm less sceptical because mums have experience. Doctor just says impossible based on textbook!

It's not the latch because he's still in agony with expressed breast milk in a bottle. Whereas formula he's fine with.

I don't eat that much and my diet is very boring. It consists of potato, veg meat and rarely any sauces. I'm wracking my brains here.

Also my siblings and I were all formula fed and we are all healthy, very fit and "successful" (by some superficial standards at least) so I can say it hasn't done us any harm at all.

I don't believe it is cheaper because I eat way more food while BF and that is just as, if not more expensive than formula!

I was really hoping to breastfeed and bought loads of nursing clothes but this reaction is just so confusing. I wish I knew how to fix it?!

OP posts:
gotomomo · 06/10/2023 07:24

@MariaVT65

I'd be skeptical about information I get from random individuals on the internet!

The benefits of breastfeeding are firmly established internationally, it's also the natural way of feeding babies and free. More likely that baby is gulping air whilst feeding because the latch isn't correct causing wind and and possibly simply isn't feeding enough. Reflux is common and easily treated in most. It tss as lea 4-6 weeks to establish breast feeding after which it far easier than bottles.

All that said a baby needs feeding most of all, combi feeding is a great compromise.

If a baby is reacting to breastmilk, unless you have a specific thing in your diet eg a product in the coeliacs friendly foods then it could be just wind. When my dd2 was being sick I was advised to cut huge amounts from my diet and add back in - it was bananas!

Blessedbethefruitz · 06/10/2023 07:19

If pumped milk in a bottle causes the same sickness, it's clearly something in your milk, but not dairy if it's regular formula you're feeding. If you want to continue, I'd start strictly removing other allergens until you find the cause. But there's nothing wrong with stopping either. I couldn't breastfeed my cmpa baby beyond a week or so. Whatever keeps you both happy, healthy and sane :)

icantchangetime · 06/10/2023 07:17

I couldn't produce the required milk so quickly went onto bottle fed. DD is now 19, at university and perfectly healthy!

I also spent hours and hours puréeing organic vegetables when she was weaning at six months. All home made fresh food for my girl. No fizzy juice and no chocolate. Probably doesn't eat any veg at all as an adult and lives off Twirls. She is super fit and fine. Confused

You can worry yourself into the ground with this sort of stuff. Don't be a martyr. It makes zero difference. Honestly.

Dessertinthedesert · 06/10/2023 07:15

He can be allergic to breast milk or at least react to some of the food you are eating. Having had two babies with allergies I would say if you suspect an allergy keep breast feeding so much easier.

MariaVT65 · 06/10/2023 07:15

I would also be really sceptical about any info you get about breastfeeding benefits from the NHS.

Magenta82 · 06/10/2023 07:13

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 07:06

Also, what are the lifelong benefits of breast feeding? I always hear it's better but why?

The benefits seem to be on a population level rather than an individual one, there is some evidence that breastfeed babies have fewer infections and lower instances of obesity later in life. However, once you control for other factors, especially wealth and class, the clear benefits become less so. Opportunities and upbringing have a much larger effect.

MariaVT65 · 06/10/2023 07:13

Op many of us were formula fed or have formula fed our children and we’re all fine. I was given a big a colustrum as a baby and then straight to formula and i’m a very healthy adult. If it’s clear your baby is suffering whatever reason, just give formula. No need to feel guilty. I am pregnant with my second and will be goinf straight to formula (after colostrum) x

TheSandgroper · 06/10/2023 07:13

Little babies often don’t take well to breastfeeding. They wriggle, scream and do lots of poos. And often don’t like to let go. If you can hang in there, often they learn how to do it and grow through it.

Vomiting. My DM said both my brother and I through up until we were 8 months old. My dd stopped vomiting st 8 months and three days. It was like magic. Her weight dropped after leaving hospital to the 10th percentile but then she tracked on that line well so I didn’t worry.

You need to take care of yourself. You need to drink water until you float. You need plenty of protein. You need to rest. Your energy is needed to make milk. If you think you need more milk, I found fenugreek invaluable. 2 teaspoons 4 time per day. It took a couple of weeks but by the time dd was 7 weeks, the horror times were getting easier.

Have you had a let down yet? It’s like a tingling and then a rush of production with dc suddenly sucking away like mad. Honestly, a woman's body is amazing. It can take time and management but, if you can do it, it’s wonderful.

However, a fed baby is best. If you hate it, if it hurts and doesn’t stop, if you think dc is just hating it, if your life just doesn’t allow you the time (I was stuck at 45 minutes per side with a nappy change at half time so I know that pain), don’t ever be ashamed of just going to the bottle. Make your decision and hold your head high that you have put baby first.

Congratulations on your new baby. You’re an amazing mum.

scrantonelectriccity · 06/10/2023 07:11

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 07:06

Also, what are the lifelong benefits of breast feeding? I always hear it's better but why?

From NHS

Any amount of breast milk has a positive effect. The longer you breastfeed, the longer the protection lasts and the greater the benefits.
Breastfeeding can help to reduce your baby's risk of:
• infections, with fewer visits to hospital as a result
• diarrhoea and vomitingg_, with fewer visits to hospital as a result
• sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS))_
• obesityy_
• cardiovascular diseasee_ in adulthood

•	breastfeeding provides health benefits for you

Formula milk does not provide the same protection from illness and does not give you any health benefits.

Ronnii · 06/10/2023 07:11

My baby was the same, such a shame as latch and feeding was fine. I tried to cut things from my diet but I combo fed and then just formula as I couldn't solve it.

One thing I do wish I'd done is pump and freeze. My baby is 2 now with no allergy's, eats well.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 06/10/2023 07:08

I gave up feedback my DS after about 2 weeks. He was fussy, it hurt and I had a toddler and just found the whole thing stressful and upsetting. I felt guilty at the time but he's now a healthy, bright 11 year old. Do what's right for you, anyone who judges isn't worth knowing and in a couple of years time it just won't matter.

Mariposista · 06/10/2023 07:08

stop today OP. Happy baby is fed baby and BF is no way worth being miserable over.

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 07:06

Also, what are the lifelong benefits of breast feeding? I always hear it's better but why?

OP posts:
Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 07:06

He has the same problem when I express and bottle feed the breast milk.

I don't eat eggs or nuts.

The breastfeeding consultant team just say it's normal for a baby to spit up but it's clearly distressing him. He has a pained expression and a painful cry when doing his pops and when spitting up. It's like it causes him heartburn and reflux it's a bad reaction.

OP posts:
lizzaliza · 06/10/2023 07:05

Don't give up! If you get through another 2-3 weeks honestly it suddenly becomes so much easier. If you stick it out now, you'll be thankful for months after! I'd Google IBCLC in your area and book a consultation. They're worth their weight in gold

PurBal · 06/10/2023 07:04

Breastfeeding is hard. Establishing it is hard. If you want to breastfeed, persevere. But there is nothing wrong with saying “this isn’t for me/my baby”. I think health visitors would be more helpful than the GP at this point. Have you tried the National breastfeeding helpline. They’re open daily. http://www.nationalbreastfeedinghelpline.org.uk/

National Breastfeeding Helpline – Helpline

http://www.nationalbreastfeedinghelpline.org.uk/