Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give up breastfeeding 3 week old?

110 replies

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 06:29

Every time I breastfeed my 3 week old he spend the next few hours crying, spitting up and wriggling in pain.

On days where I exclusively breastfeed he also has had bad diarrhoea (12 poos a day vs his normal 5/6) and a red face and body.

When he has formula (when i was sick in hospital and when my supply had been too low for his appetite) he is much more content. He drinks, he can be burped nicely, no vomiting or spitting up and no diarrhoea or red blotchy skin.

I am so upset because I wanted to breastfeed and I feel like I can do it, I have a good latch and good supply now!

The doctor said there's no way he can be allergic to breast milk end of. I am coeliac and don't eat wheat and I gave up milk in case there was a dairy allergy.

I am seriously thinking I should switch to formula but I don't want to make him miss out on the benefits of BF and I'm afraid I will be judged.

Anyone been through similar? Or got ANY advice?

OP posts:
CinnamonJellyBeans · 07/10/2023 20:35

Trust your own instincts.

What type of milk a baby drinks is a tiny, tiny part of being a parent. It's a stupid thing people get hung up on.

Stop feeling guilty and put the shoe on the other foot: Keeping on with the breast-feeding because of a misplaced sense of duty is preventing your child from being contented and enjoying his food.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/10/2023 20:29

Blessedbethefruitz · 06/10/2023 07:19

If pumped milk in a bottle causes the same sickness, it's clearly something in your milk, but not dairy if it's regular formula you're feeding. If you want to continue, I'd start strictly removing other allergens until you find the cause. But there's nothing wrong with stopping either. I couldn't breastfeed my cmpa baby beyond a week or so. Whatever keeps you both happy, healthy and sane :)

This is good advice

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 07/10/2023 20:26

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 07:06

Also, what are the lifelong benefits of breast feeding? I always hear it's better but why?

There are loads of benefits overall population level wise like slightly less risk of cancer and diabetes (for mum and baby) and it's very good for their gut and immune systems.

bUT if your baby is sick from breastmilk he won't get many of these benefits!

I would seek support from health visitor. And perhaps experiment with a bottle that's half an half formulA/breastmilk to see if that's better? If you're going to stop You might also want to express and freeze some
Breastmilk and built up a little stock to see if he can handle it better in a few weeks - if he can then you'll have this handy for when he catches a cold etc.

Tiredbehyondbelief · 07/10/2023 15:19

I am so glad to hear you are beginning to see some light at the end of the tunnel. First few weeks and months with a newborn baby are crazy, well done for persevering for so long! I didn't realise you were switching breasts. As a former BF network and infant feeding volunteer our advice has always been to feed on my breast for as long as baby is suckling. Then if they are still hungry offer the other breast. If you latch does not hurt, your nipples won't get "tired". Your can try feeding skin to skin or changing nappy after 30 mins to encourage longer feeds. (Feeds will get a lot shorter once your baby's suck gets stronger) Poo spilling out of nappies is normal for breastfed babies, I remember it very well. (Also, going for a few days or even a couple of weeks without pooing after 2 months is also normal in exclusively BF babies). Well done you, you are doing amazing!

Octosaurus · 07/10/2023 13:27

These are all very helpful messages guys thank you so much for your help.

I think the core milk hind milk might be something to do with it. I was told to switch breasts before they get tired by the lactation consultant! I had so much conflicting advice from the professionals it's crazy!

And perhaps it's not diarrhoea but there does seem to be actual yellow liquid alongside the solids that soak into the nappy that isn't there with formula. Perhaps a forenilk issue still.

I will report back! Thank you again

OP posts:
Banrion · 07/10/2023 11:42

I couldn't believe the diarrhoea like nappies of my second baby from breastfeeding. I thought there was something wrong with her as I thought she had constant diarrhoea. My friend who had breast fed 3 assured me that this was normal for her breast fed babies so I wouldn't worry about that.

Maluki · 07/10/2023 11:29

If poo is green or fizzy, he may not be getting enough of the hindmilk. Breast milk behind as a drink and the fatty "food" comes later. Babies who suckle frequently but not for long get too much foremilk and not enough hindmilk and this can also make them gassy. A feed with a newborn can easily take 40 min. Don't switch breasts if he has just had a quick guzzle on the previous feed.

Summermeadowflowers · 07/10/2023 09:18

I think whether you’re pro or anti breastfeeding (and yes, some people are) telling the OP what she should do isn’t on. The most important thing here is the OP makes a decision she has reached independently.

@Octosaurus I have a very tricky history with breastfeeding. I don’t mind admitting I am pro breastfeeding, but being pro breastfeeding isn’t being anti formula. I cried at 5 days because it just wasn’t working and I thought I was going to have to switch to formula. I had a lactation consultant and the full works but nothing worked.

As it is I express breast milk. Like you, I just can’t bear to let my milk dry up. I think one of the big things with pregnancy and birth is that our bodies want to revert to normal long before our minds do! I was bizarrely upset when I thought my period had come back (it hadn’t.) Maybe that’s crazy but it’s my body and I’m allowed to be crazy Smile

Whatever choice you make ensure it’s one you’re going to be happy with Flowers don’t let anyone pressure you either way.

OCDmama · 07/10/2023 08:10

I'm very pro-breastfeeding but I think you should stop!

If you're seeing this clear difference between breastfeeding/formula go for it. Maybe just try combi first, to double check he won't have the same reaction to formula before you leap, but if it works it works. He's had three weeks of breast milk, which will have included the colostrum.

It's awful watching them in pain, it's really not worth it if breastfeeding isn't working.

mrssunshinexxx · 07/10/2023 07:03

@Octosaurus I wouldn't give up just yet if you personally want to continue once you crack it is is so so easy and convenient. Do you always feed him in the same position ? Have you tried rigby ball hold, laid back feeding, side feeding ? It sounds like he's getting too much air at the breast x

HaveIlostIt · 07/10/2023 06:57

I wouldn't feel guilty about using formula if breast feeding isn't for you or just isn't working.

If you WANT to continue breastfeeding definitely see if you have a local support group, breastfeeding or lactation consultant. This was crucial for me.

I combi fed for first 4 weeks due to supply not coming inand baby is fine. Plenty exclusively formula fed. No shame on those who do, personally I couldn't afford to stay on ready made formula and I just couldn't deal with the faff of the powdered stuff because my baby was always hungry and it was never ready on time. But I guess if you ff exclusively you probably get in a rhythm. I think getting the nutrients on the baby is way more a priority than the supposed benefits of BF. I am always v suspicious when it says "reduce your baby's risk " because they don't put any numbers to it and it could make very little difference ( you don't see loads of adults walking round today saying If only I was breastfed)

We are 3 months now and EBF and I am actually happy doing it! I even pump a bit spare ( used fenugreek and power pumping to increase supply)

I'm not sure the poo and sick are too unusual tbh but you do say he seems uncomfortable. I'm not sure why GP said can't be an allergy - definitely is a thing! Kept being suggested for me. My baby had similar reactions before we started mix feeding also alot of time seemed to have trapped wind but it turned out all of that was due to a low supply. So she was constantly feeding but not getting much milk out.

Do what feels right for you. Its so hard worry about what's best and judgment from others. You just have to block out the other voices and think about what's best for baby and you.

GameOverBoys · 07/10/2023 06:40

Personally I think you know best. Your child clearly isn't tolerating breast milk well. Believe the evidence of your own unique experience.
When my second child struggled to breast feed everyone told me to continue and he would be better off etc etc. I contacted breastfeeding support through the nhs and privately. My son lost more and more weight until he was nearly hospitalised. I eventually gave up and bottle fed and he was a healthy weight again in 6 weeks. I don’t know why I listened to all these well meaning professionals and not my own experience.

Parker231 · 07/10/2023 06:39

Mamai90 · 07/10/2023 00:50

Some women are fanatical about breastfeeding to the point of encouraging you to continue even though your child is in pain. It's bizarre to me.

My mother breast fed me and I still had allergies and was a obese young adult. I know that's anecdotal but the pressure women put on themselves is crazy, even I did in the early days.

OP, fed is best. If your baby is happier with formula then that's what I'd do in your position.

I agree - there are posters encouraging the OP to continue with bf even when she has said her DC is in pain.

Formula is amazing and gives babies a brilliant start in life.

PureAmazonian · 07/10/2023 06:25

Also i disagree with the cmpa, my dd had exactly your babies symptoms; the curdled spit up, the mucusy poos, her poos were green sometimes as well, crying in pain when pooing, he stomach would regularly look round and swollen from too much gas. I'm vegan so didn't consume any dairy and I cut out soy in case that was it. That didn't make much difference.

Summermeadowflowers · 07/10/2023 06:24

@Mamai90 it goes both ways. There are definitely some people with a formula ‘agenda’, for want of a better word.

PureAmazonian · 07/10/2023 06:21

@Octosaurus
I feel your pain with this thread. My dd had awful reflux, and colic in the first 7 weeks she just screamed and arched on the boob and then cried for hours after, and would want the boob again only to be in the same pain as before! Explosive poos 10+ times a day. She always seemed so uncomfortable. But I just didn't want to give up ebf so I persevered. I had a constant battle of wanting to give up, even bought some formula but I knew in my heart that I couldn't give up yet.
I can honestly tell you that after week 6, she started feeding a lot better. And then by week 7 she completely stopped all the screaming and seemed so much more comfortable. Her digestive system just needed time to catch up. She's now 1 and still ebf, and I'm so grateful I didn't give up!
If you need to go your own sanity (the guilt is so tough) then by all means don't suffer through unnecessarily. But just know it does get better! ❤️

Tiredbehyondbelief · 07/10/2023 06:02

Hi there, in relation to your latest post..... Your diet seems to be pretty bland at the moment, I don't see any problem there. Just as precaution, I would avoid take aways and ready meals (I remember 2 horrendous nights with DS1 after Chinese buffet and DS2 after a plateful of curry - I was much more careful with my diet after that). I have checked the NHS website on reflux - your baby's symtoms don't match (I would avoid general googling on reflux - anyone can post anything on internet). As others said and it has been my experience too - breastfed babies poo A LOT in the early weeks (then it goes in reverse after 2 months). The poos are definitely very loose. I can definitely tell both my breastfed children wriggled a lot as if in pain in early weeks. My take on it- surely Mother Nature knew what she was doing when she created babies and breastmilk. What formula are your using? NHS recommends First infant formula (unless advised differently by a midwife or HV). If you are using Hungry baby formula this might explain the difference in stools. As I have mentioned earlier, there is no right or wrong way forward here. However, it's my gut feeling you might regret it later if you stop now. 3 weeks is a tricky age and what you are seeing in your baby's behaviour might still be a coincidence. I remember both my babies went through spells of unsettled behaviour for no discernible reason. I suggest you try seeing your local infant feeding support group. They are usually staffed with very experienced people, they won't judge and they will support your choices. Failing that, try Breastfeeding Network helpline (sometimes it's difficult to get through - it's managed by volunteers). I used to volunteer for BF Network - we support women in their choices, without agendas of our own. I hope it helps

BeverlyBrook · 07/10/2023 02:27

Bf is a two way relationship. It has to work for you both. Do what's right for you and your baby.

TrailingLoellia · 07/10/2023 00:59

My babies got fussy if I ate or drank anything acidic- tea, coffee, milk, orange juice, tomatoes, spices, lemon/citrus, ginger, chocolate.

They did grow out of it around 6mos once they started solids.

WTF99 · 07/10/2023 00:59

If youve got good latch and good supply you are pretty much there! Keep going....3 weeks is still early days By start of week 7 it will all be so much easier.
I breast fed my son for 2 and a half years. Could easily given up at week 3

Mamai90 · 07/10/2023 00:50

Some women are fanatical about breastfeeding to the point of encouraging you to continue even though your child is in pain. It's bizarre to me.

My mother breast fed me and I still had allergies and was a obese young adult. I know that's anecdotal but the pressure women put on themselves is crazy, even I did in the early days.

OP, fed is best. If your baby is happier with formula then that's what I'd do in your position.

bigshort · 06/10/2023 23:51

TMess · 06/10/2023 18:01

Sounds like CMPA honestly; it takes quite a while for traces to be completely out of your breast milk and you have to watch for hidden dairy pretty closely - it’s in a lot of sauces, flavorings etc. One of mine was severely CMPA and I did successfully bf for two years - was a lot of work initially but worth it imo.

yes it definitely sounds like a dairy issue when the child is fine on a dairy formula.

Not.

Octosaurus · 06/10/2023 23:47

Tiredbehyondbelief · 06/10/2023 19:24

Hi there, I am a registred NHS midwife with an interested in infant feeding. I used to volunteer with the infant feeding team for 2.5 years every Friday for 3 hours. We would see babies up to 2 months old, usually at 2-3 weeks of age. Firstly, I would like to reassure you there is no right or wrong way of going in your situation. I am however worried you might regret your decision if your stop breastfeeding now. 3 weeks is a notoriously tricky age. Most babies are quite sleepy for the first couple of weeks, then they suddenly wake up and are very demanding. This is normal baby behaviour. Additonally, reading from your post, I would try to make your diet as bland as possible at this stage. Avoid beans, cabbiage, spices, coffee. Avoid any foods you didn't eat in pregnancy. An occasional glass of wine is OK. Try to get as much rest as possible during the day. Try to breastfeed at least once between midnight and 6 am as this is when milk hormones are at the highest. Do bare mininum of housework, focus on yourself and your gorgeous baby. The benefits of breasfeeding over formula feeding are huge. I am really surprised someone insinuated you shouldn't trust NHS. We are not out to make money by forcing women to breastfeed! Breastfeeding reduces (not eliminates) the risk of your child developing asthma, type 1 and type 2 diabetes, obesity in later life, all sorts of infections, certain childhood cancers etc. It also reduces your risk of developing breast cancer, ovarian cancer and osteoporosis in later life. The benefits are dose dependent - i.e. a bit of breastfeeding is better than none. (See NHS, UNICEF, Lancet magazine on breastfeeding). With so many benefits why it not everyone doing it? Because it's so difficult in the early weeks, as you are discovering now! From a personal experience, the first 10 weeks were the hardest (I exclusively breastfed). Then all of a sudden my babies started taking their feeds in 20 minutes rather tna 1 hour at a time. Unlike most of my friends, I didn't need to take formula and flask of hot water when going out. I didn't need to sterilise anything when I got home. This has been my journey. Yours will be your own. I always say to new mums it's not worth getting a postnatal depression over breastfeeding. I would also say every drop of breastmilk counts. On a practical side, if you start giving lots of bottles now, your milk supply will probably start drying up. Babies can put on quite a convincing show when they are feeding at the breast. However, mix fed babies might not suckle as hard as they should - bottles are much easier to drink from. Reading from your post, I am not convinced you are ready to give up breastfeeding yet. Why not persereve for a bit longer and try to find a local breastfeeding support group? I hope it helps

Hi Tired, very interesting in your pov and experience!

My diet is extremely plain and pretty healthy (I get mocked by DH for the "lack of flavour". I don't eat garlic and onions frequently at all it really is just meat and veg and water and decaf tea.

I just notice a massive different in the baby when I breastfeed versus formula. The spitting up seems really painful for him, often it occurs for hours afterwards and is curdled so it clearly is sitting in his stomach going nowhere. 12 poos a day can't be normal frequency can it? It's more mucusy too.

I don't want to give up breastfeeding but I know something is wrong and it's none of the usual stuff. It seems obscure?

OP posts:
Maluki · 06/10/2023 23:35

Of my 4 kids,
One never spilled a drop (he was 19 lb at 12 weeks on pure breast milk!)
One vomited huge quantities regularly (she was born at 36 weeks and I just feel like her system wasn't quite ready).
The other two were ordinary spitty up babies. I had a white stripe down my shoulder a lot that first year!

Maluki · 06/10/2023 23:32

He cried - a lot - was pretty unsettled. But I would be saying to DH 'he can't be hungry, I fed him 2 hours ago' (he was!). My nipples bled. It was agony when he latched on. Somehow - once I offered the breast every time he cried when he was 3 weeks old and after - it stopped hurting, he stopped being inconsolable....we just learned how to feed.

Wrt poops, He grunted, went red in the face, squirmed, farted a LOT, bore down while going purple, and then pooped such huge poops they would go up his back and down to his socks. My friend with the bottle fed baby did a small playdoh-like lump every other day. My boy pooped up his back multiple times a day! That settled a bit but it's completely normal for EBF babies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread