Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler in ft nursery even though I don’t have to?

275 replies

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 05:05

Initially I went back to work when ds was 9 months and he started nursery FT, up until he was 19 months. Then I got work to agree to three days a week. He still does this.

I don’t want to go back ft - I have another child now. Equally though it doesn’t seem that things are working well having ds home with me/us 4 days a week. I know this is partly our fault but he just doesn’t eat. Nursery he eats everything. Breakfast, snack, hot lunch, pudding, tea. Home he barely touches anything. Today after refusing two breakfasts he finally ate a banana after a lot of persuasion, had a biscuit at a toddler group and an apple, refused lunch and then had maybe three mouthfuls of macaroni cheese. He then demands yoghurt and biscuits. He has been awake half the night and I’m sure it’s hunger related.

I know people will say he won’t starve and I’m not so sure! He might not starve but he doesn’t eat anything near enough and this affects behaviour and sleep. So - AIBU to have him in nursery FT? It’s expensive but worth it for peace of mind.

OP posts:
NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 13:42

You always do, although you get nice ones too. I do wonder if it’s a form of self abuse to post here at times Smile I just don’t seem to have a grip at all, and kids are everywhere so it can’t be that hard except somehow it is

OP posts:
June628 · 06/10/2023 13:20

OP you have had some really silly and some totally crap comments on here! I have a 3.5yo and a 7mo. It’s hard, it’s really hard! Do what you have to do to survive would be my advice! You are not a shit parent, you’re thinking of the best interest for your child and exploring options - if you were shit you wouldn’t be doing that would you? I wish I could just give you a big hug! Do you have friends in a similar situation to you who you can chat with? I always find it really helpful for someone to just nod and say yeah, it’s shit. Everyone is different, some people may thrive in your situation, others may not. I don’t have any practical advice but please take the shit comments with a pinch of salt and don’t let them upset you. You will get through this, just remember everything is a phase!

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 12:01

I don’t think anything will ‘work’ with ds at this moment. He’s clearly not going to eat at home, so I need to ensure he’s fed elsewhere. It is not just DH, I think ds is best away from me.

OP posts:
Muststopeating · 06/10/2023 11:47

Yes actually I would... if he was undermining me to that extent then I'd treat him like a child because he was acting like one.

You clearly don't want advice and have decided what you want/need to do. Which is fine, it is your life and your child.

You do sound very negative and defeated though so I genuinely hope you are looking after yourself and asking for help if you need it. I am generally pretty negative and defeatist when I'm knackered so it is probably entirely normal but if it starts to feel more than that then please get help. Like you said earlier, your emotional health is important too, for you and for your children.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/10/2023 11:45

I think if you can afford it, more hours in nursery is a great solution to maternal mental health: the sleep deprivation and work of parenting two made me shouty, impatient, chaotic, out of control; and if I got a handle on all that, I burned out completely and ended up panicky and insomniac in the evenings/nights. I’m much happier and parent better now my older child is in school. And she was absolutely given tea in preschool!

You really do need DH on board with food issues, though. He needs a come to Jesus talk about the implications, and to come up with solutions to his forgetfulness around it: eg crisps in a lockbox on a high shelf, so when he goes to have some, he has to consciously get them and thus think “why are the crisps locked up? Oh, because I’m not meant to eat these in front of DS” instead of mindlessly grabbing a bag.

Some things that helped us:

Don’t use food as bribery, reward or punishment. No “eat your broccoli if you want pudding”: all that teaches is that pudding is a desirable thing that you have to earn by suffering through something else, then the next time they see broccoli all they think is “oh, there’s the yucky food”. Treat all food equally.

If everyone’s having pudding, everyone has pudding. Regardless of if they’ve eaten their main course.

Ice cream in the park? Totally fine, what a nice idea, it’s sunny. Not because DS has been so good, or whatever. It’s good, not a reward for behaviour.

At nearly 3 he can help prep food: DD got into avocados because they’re fun to mash. Even if they don’t eat something, they’re exposed to the food and the idea of it.

Serving dishes. DP comes from a “plating up” family and I hate it, I don’t want someone else deciding my portion for me and I think kids are the same: big bowls of everything on the table, the rule is help yourself to what you want and you never have to try something you don’t want. It made DD less afraid of new things because they were just there, no pressure. You have to play the long game. (This goes against the War and Peas advice, which I otherwise agree with, but I bloody HATE being plated for unless at a restaurant and my children hate it too.) I think we were also offering DD far too much food: after that incredible growth spurt they go through from birth to two, and all the brain development, later on their calorific needs slow and stabilise and they stop doing that mad thing where they eat five baked potatoes or a whole melon. DD serves herself much smaller amounts, has seconds if she needs, generally sleeps through and only wakes hungry if she’s missed food for other reasons – ie starting school meltdowns, a birthday party where she filled up on crisps.

No praise for “good” eating, like “well done on eating all your spaghetti bolognese!” You’re supposed to eat your dinner! Praising it lets your DS know what you want, and kids are clever: he’ll know he’s got your attention and that he’ll get even more of it by not eating than by eating. Definitely talk about food (“yes, I like how green peas are, it’s a nice colour”), just don’t attach good/bad behaviour around it.

Make food attractive! I don’t mean Pinterest bullshit like smiley face pancakes. But at nearly 3 they’re discerning in a way babies, who are human compost bins, aren’t. I don’t want to eat soggy broccoli dumped willy nilly on top of my roast dinner, why would a kid?

Follow nursery timings for snacks and meals, and don’t overfill on snacks. Be led by appetite basically: being hungry is a good thing at mealtime. A snack like a rice cake or an apple is enough to stave off hunger til lunchtime, generally. By mimicking nursery’s timings we met DD where she was, hunger wise, and got to her before she was too tired to eat.

But none of this will work if your husband wanders in with a bag of crisps! You need to read him the riot act really: you’ve just had a baby, still in the fourth trimester, the exhaustion is unreal, the food/sleep stuff is a real issue, WHY is he not on board with making your life easier and his DS’s food intake healthier?

hedgehogsunflower · 06/10/2023 11:44

NewShoes · 06/10/2023 11:11

I have a four year old and a baby - I’m afraid to say I don’t think it gets easier once the baby gets slightly older. They become more demanding of you and the sleepy newborn stage is actually easier in many ways. So I think the idea of nursery as a short term solution is not ideal as home life will continue to be busy and often stressful with two little ones.
You and your husband are going to have to face lots of issues as your children grow up. Now it’s the food problem but later it might be academic or friendship problems, bullying, self esteem, who knows what their lives will throw up? When there are two of you at home you’re a parenting team and need to find a way to deal with things effectively together. Otherwise this pattern of agreeing a solution only for one partner to suddenly change tack/ go against what’s been agreed will keep causing problems for a long time to come.

I think people are often divided on this but for me, it absolutely got easier as time went on. Toddler + newborn was absolutely the hardest stage for me (and it didn’t help that this was during the early days of lockdown!)

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 11:17

Oh come on. I take a packet or crisps out of his hands while he’s eating it? No - that’s ridiculous.

@NewShoes no. But as ds gets older bribery and punishment are both more effective. Just now they are not.

OP posts:
NewShoes · 06/10/2023 11:11

I have a four year old and a baby - I’m afraid to say I don’t think it gets easier once the baby gets slightly older. They become more demanding of you and the sleepy newborn stage is actually easier in many ways. So I think the idea of nursery as a short term solution is not ideal as home life will continue to be busy and often stressful with two little ones.
You and your husband are going to have to face lots of issues as your children grow up. Now it’s the food problem but later it might be academic or friendship problems, bullying, self esteem, who knows what their lives will throw up? When there are two of you at home you’re a parenting team and need to find a way to deal with things effectively together. Otherwise this pattern of agreeing a solution only for one partner to suddenly change tack/ go against what’s been agreed will keep causing problems for a long time to come.

Everydayimhuffling · 06/10/2023 11:10

Did you miss @LaviniasBigBloomers saying bin it if it comes in the house? DH would perhaps do better with a clear rule like these things don't come in the house. If not, you can make it clear that they will be thrown away.

Of course you can put him in nursery 5 days a week. It was hard at home with both mine when the youngest was a baby. It is a hard time.

However, you still need to deal with the actual problem. Kids don't magically grow into a routine or out of bad eating habits at 5. They don't magically get through weekends fine without being parented at all. So take the break, but you'll still have to find a different way to manage the rest of the time.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 10:55

@LaviniasBigBloomers i don’t. Men do go to shops Smile

Thanks all. If ds didn’t eat and that was that it would be one thing but it’s not eating having a knock on effect on other things as well that makes it very stressful. It’s easy to be chilled about non eating kids if you’re not the one up repeatedly in the night/morning.

OP posts:
Ladyj84 · 06/10/2023 10:47

Stop the junk and he will eat his meals..we have 3 under 3 and they eat all meals and the only snack is a biscuit mid afternoon

LaviniasBigBloomers · 06/10/2023 10:40

Honestly, I think you sound completely overwhelmed and I'm anxious that a bit of PND is creeping in.

In which case, I think do everything you can to make your life easier - get DS into nursery but as pps have said, work towards picking him up earlier so it isn't 5 full days.

(Note, I don't know if they still do this but when they move up into the pre-school rooms they stop feeding them tea so doing this to solve his eating won't work long term)

Stop buying biscuits and shit. Just stop buying them. If they come into the house, bin them.

Once you've had a bit of breathing space, you can tackle the eating thing better, with some support.

But as long as you can see nursery as a short term fix until you all catch your breath a bit, I think it's better than pushing yourself to the edge. 3 years and 3 months and a dickhead DH is hard.

BogRollBOGOF · 06/10/2023 10:29

Adjusting to life with a new baby and toddler is exhausting, and it's exhaustion that's ringing through OP's posts. If increased nursery time helps ease the pressure and gives OP more energy to focus on key issues consistently, that's no bad thing. Nursery where he's already settled is hardly sending him up chimneys.

Take pressure out of mealtimes. Keep boundaries of where food can be eaten and how long a meal time is. That's harder if DH isn't on board, but if the exhaustion in the equation is reduced, that helps.

BananaPalm · 06/10/2023 10:18

You sound very logical OP. And firm (despite what you think of yourself). Meaning that you have what it takes to get things under control eventually.

However (!) for the time being I'd just put him in FT if you can afford it AND work on yours and your DH's (!) parenting skills at the weekends for starters. Then in the evenings after nursery, slowly building it all up.

I also don't know what I'm doing with my toddler half of the time so give yourself a break by putting him in FT and use this time to build back some energy/strength and go from there.

Flowers
VivaVivaa · 06/10/2023 10:13

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 09:51

@VivaVivaa thanks for saying that. I love him and I genuinely am motivated by what is in his best interests and I just don’t feel at the moment that’s me.

No sweat. I’m exactly the same. Theoretically I’d love to have DS1 at home all day everyday. He’s far more interesting and funny than the baby. But I just can’t meet both of their needs to a level that keeps us all in check, including me. I’d be shouty mum very quickly I think as I know I get quite easily overwhelmed. You have to accept where your limits are. Currently your limit is not being able to manage DC1s eating and behaviour whilst also caring for tiny baby. That’s fine. You know you need to address this but now isn’t the time. If FT nursery solves this problem now and gives you headspace to plan how to address this say, after Christmas when dust from baby has settled then don’t feel bad about it at all.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 09:51

@VivaVivaa thanks for saying that. I love him and I genuinely am motivated by what is in his best interests and I just don’t feel at the moment that’s me.

OP posts:
PinkRoses1245 · 06/10/2023 09:50

I think it's more important you and DH are being consistent with food at home. And being stressed around food is the worst, DS will sense that and associate food at home with stress. You can't rely on nursery to replace that. I'd keep him in nursery a couple of days or a few mornings.

VivaVivaa · 06/10/2023 09:48

I have a 3 yo and an 11 week old. I only have them on my own 1.5 days a week and it’s honestly hell. Im not ashamed to admit that. Im exhausted and Ive gone from a calm, responsive parent to my 3 yo to stressy mum who often parents with bribes and/or threats of not doing nice things. I adore my 3 yo and would actually much rather be around him than the baby, but the 3 days he has at pre school are an absolute godsend. We don’t have the eating issues either - that must be really stressful. If FT nursery works for you currently then do it. You could do it until baby is in more of a routine and sleeping better then re-asses. That’s likely only to be 3 or so months. Be kind to yourself. Newborn and toddler has been exponentially harden then I could have imagined.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 09:41

why offer him multiple meals like breakfast

I don’t need to answer that, surely?

@Zanatdy

We are, but what I’m obviously not getting across particularly well is that in the moment we both have a tendency to panic . In addition to this, DH has a very annoying trait where you’ll talk to hum about something, he agrees to it or days that’s a good idea … then doesn’t do it. And you can’t make somebody. I do think at times he’s genuinely scattterbrained and will come through munching crisps when ds then takes and he’ll agree oh shit yes shouldn’t have done that. But he’s still done it. That’s one example but it’s illustrative of how things are.

I am really not loving being a mum to a toddler at the moment and I think that anything I can do to keep us both sane, healthy - emotionally as well as physically - is good. Laying into me and saying do this and do that - not helpful. Yes, shit parents are frustrating but people’s frustration isn’t going to stop me being shit.

OP posts:
PinkMoscatoLover · 06/10/2023 09:34

hoglets · 06/10/2023 07:31

i think YABU. A 19 months old won't benefit from a full time nursery place developmentally/socially. It appears he is in full time as you struggle to parent him effectively and decided the easy option is nursery due to his eating issues. I think you need to crack the eating at home. I think it's a bizarre reason for putting a toddler into nursery full time when you only need 3.

OP’s DS is 3 years old not 19 months old

jannier · 06/10/2023 09:01

I think you would benefit from a parenting course he's going to be out of nursery soon and unless you can afford boarding school what are you going to do?
Why offer multiple meals like breakfast? He's playing you that's breakfast nothing else....I'm hungry well you should have eaten breakfast, snack is fruit at 10.

Zanatdy · 06/10/2023 08:40

I don’t understand why you and your DH aren’t willing to work on your parenting as believe me it’s going to get a whole lot worse as he gets older if you don’t get a grip now. Out sourcing parenting isn’t the answer but you seem determined to do it anyway. Short term fix yes. But ignore the bigger issues at your peril. He’s not even 3. Far easier to start addressing where you think you need help with your parenting now than when he hits the teens and is ruling the roost.

hedgehogsunflower · 06/10/2023 08:38

GoodlifeGlow · 06/10/2023 08:30

Your attitude to this is odd, you have a problem with your child and you just want to push it onto someone else and not make any changes yourself.

This is your child who you need to look after and give the best start in life. You say you are a teacher? Well if you are not equipped with the skills to parent, learn! Do what other active, involved parents do, read the books learn about child psychology. Then teach your husband the strategies you’ve learnt so you can both be consistent.

I get you have a baby, but that doesn’t mean giving up on the one you have because they aren’t behaving how you think they should. Most of this behaviour is probably related to having a new baby in the house. You need to address the issues at home.

Oh for goodness sake. The OP is clearly struggling and all parents know that the first few months with a newborn and toddler are tough. Try being a bit kinder, it doesn’t cost anything.

christinarossetti19 · 06/10/2023 08:38

A newborn and a toddler is tough. Winter is coming, so the faff of getting out of the house multiplies. You'd feel better if ds was in nursery five days a week and, at this point in time, you think ds would too.

Do it if you can afford it. The cost will go down after he turns three anyway. You can review it in a few months. Lots of young children enjoy the routine of a nursery setting and it may give you and dh a bit of headspace to rethink your parenting approaches.

Neither of you sound like 'shit parents' but being consistent yet flexible is bloody tough and much easier navigated when you're not overwhelmed and sleep deprived.

Codlingmoths · 06/10/2023 08:37

You’re tired and have a 3 month old. Put him in nursery, revisit in a couple of months. If dh objects to the costs you jump up eagerly and say THATS SO GREAT you want to work with me on effective parenting him at home! I think we both need a bit of help so we’ll remove temptation. And you grab a bag and bin ALL the unhealthy food Dh snacks on and feeds him. Every bit of it. That’s the cost of Dh wanting to save money and keep him home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread