Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’d work or stay home?

240 replies

StiffUpperNip · 06/10/2023 00:32

I am in my thirties, have two postgrad degrees and a career that I enjoy and in which I have invested a lot of time and passion. I recently (pre-baby) started working for myself/contracting. My day rate is £450. It’s unlikely that I will earn more than this in the near future.

DH earns about £200K a year (including bonus). This is likely to rise. He’s securely employed in a famously recession proof industry.

We have one DC. I am considering staying home until she starts school, as we don’t need my income. However, a quite large part of me feels like that would be a waste of my…I don’t know, mind? Prior efforts? Being a bad feminist? It’s also not going to help my fledgling consultancy at all. I was just gaining momentum.

Also, we want more DC. So, if I stayed home with each of them, that’s a pretty solid chunk of time.

On the flipside, I recognise that the opportunity to spend this time with DC is a privilege and that I might regret it if I don’t.

DH is completely unfussed, either way. I think he might have a very slight preference I stay home, but nothing pronounced.

What would you do?

OP posts:
Mariposista · 06/10/2023 06:37

Definitely work

SUCkythings · 06/10/2023 06:32

Work but as flexibly as you can. Pt. You can’t depend on a man and it’s best to pay NI’s etc

BBQchickensalad · 06/10/2023 06:31

caniaskfor · 06/10/2023 06:20

No kids yet, but my plan has always been to do contract work when they do come along. It strikes me as a way to tick all the boxes you named but with more flex (presumably with some wfh?) and minus the drudgery of a permanent role. I know it's not a bed of roses either, but the contractors I know tend to maintain a better emotional distance and boundaries (although this might be tough when you're just starting your business).

We currently have similar income/educational backgrounds as you but clearly a few years behind, so I'm watching with interest rather than giving advice!

I find contract work great with an unpredictable family situation at present. I can take short term contracts and say no for a time if it doesn't work in. It keeps your foot in the door too.

caniaskfor · 06/10/2023 06:20

No kids yet, but my plan has always been to do contract work when they do come along. It strikes me as a way to tick all the boxes you named but with more flex (presumably with some wfh?) and minus the drudgery of a permanent role. I know it's not a bed of roses either, but the contractors I know tend to maintain a better emotional distance and boundaries (although this might be tough when you're just starting your business).

We currently have similar income/educational backgrounds as you but clearly a few years behind, so I'm watching with interest rather than giving advice!

BettyMacdonald · 06/10/2023 06:12

I have 3 DC (all at secondary school now) and I’ve worked part time (2 days / week, HCP) since the first was born.

I love my DC and I love my job. I wouldn’t want to either be a SAHM or work FT so I consider myself to be very lucky with the best of both worlds although the early years could be a bit of a juggling act. Now that they’re a bit older I’m doing more in my job and I get a lot of satisfaction from that.

MinnieMountain · 06/10/2023 06:11

You sound bored, so being a SAHM clearly isn’t for you.
I’m another’s part-timer (3 days a week). It works well for our family.

whiteroseredrose · 06/10/2023 06:09

@StiffUpperNip I always liked friends' children and enjoyed playing with them. So I enjoyed it from the beginning.

I was also definitely an out and about person. I went to a number of groups ; NCT, mother and baby, playgroups etc and got a group of friends. I also had my mum round the corner and my grandmother nearby that I spent a day a week with.

That was while I was on Mat leave. I did go back to work briefly but everyone was miserable. My job involved long days and several weeks a year at various meetings. I really resented it.

However I had never really enjoyed my job. It was well paid but that is it. Many of my colleagues were mums and chose to return to work because they loved it.

Honestly, in your situation, I'd make the most of mat leave, then go back to work. You enjoy it. And if you find that you don't, you can give up at any time.

Tohaveandtohold · 06/10/2023 06:07

In your shoes, I’ll work part time so maybe 3 days a week. That way, your business is not dead as you can still keep your clients so it’s easier when you want to go full time in future as you’re not starting all over.
You make a good daily wage to allow you buy lots of help if needed and spend 4 days with my child.

Usedtobecool · 06/10/2023 06:06

@EachPeachPearNectarine
Love Emily Oster!

I work because I want to. I like the comfort of being financially self sufficient and I need the routine in my day. I think my children have benefitted from nursery. Oldest has just started reception and she slotted in nicely with minimal fuss, she is used to the routine and confident socialising with a group of children.

If the option was open to me I would definitely reduce my hours/days a little. I find 8-5 working really full on with 2 DC under 5 that need to be fed and in bed by 7pm. But unfortunately the nature of my job means I can't do that. OP if you are self employed and want to continue working would you be able to find a balance that suits you?

Ladyj84 · 06/10/2023 06:05

Never found a minute boring with any of my 4 always something to do. 3 are under 3 and adored every minute of there growing. Gave up career till they go to school and and was always the plan I was never going to miss the years I can't get back regardless of wether rich or poor. Careers come and go children's years can't be got again

PepsiMaxandPringleStacks · 06/10/2023 06:00

If would've loved to stay at home when my kids were that small, it's such a privilege! And with all your qualifications etc it shouldn't be too hard to get back into a career.

Coffeaddict · 06/10/2023 06:00

Another vote for part time if possible. It means you keep your foot in the door. Also like you I have a job that required quite alot of training and I love it. As much as I love my kids I would go crazy being a SAHP.

I would go part time if we could afford it but unfortunatly not on the cards for me

Daffyaboutdaffs · 06/10/2023 05:57

I think that part time is the best option when the kids are little. Best of both worlds for you and the kids IMO. I went back when kids were 9months and kept my career going in this way and went back full time when they were all at secondary school. I have an excellent career. My kids are very sociable and I think early years at nursery helped this. It also took the financial load off DH and we both have a pension. I am now mid fifties and considering a drop to part time working again.

G5000 · 06/10/2023 05:53

Seems like a no-brainer. You are bored. You enjoy your job. Staying home in this situation does not sound like a reaonable choice.

Flyhigher · 06/10/2023 05:52

You aren't enjoying it now. And you say you love your job. £450 is a huge amount of money. Go back to work. Part time maybe. You don't enjoy being a Sahm. You have to like being with other mums a lot at groups. And you don't.

Simonjt · 06/10/2023 05:49

Work, I personally don’t think being a stay at home parent (why aren’t we able to call it what it is, unemployed) sets a good example to children. There are of course exceptions, sometimes a childs additional needs means there is little choice.

Summerslimtime · 06/10/2023 05:47

Looking back, it's all about balance, so part time would have been the ideal. Sounds like you have a good thing going on career wise with flexibility which is key with children.

AmsterdamCruising · 06/10/2023 05:37

i think there is a lot to be said for working part time if you can and keeping your career, if not progressing, at least ticking over.

It can be the best of both world as you can be fulfilled at work and have time with your children, and your children get the benefits of nursery.

however, most importantly, you don’t know whet the futures holds for your relationship or husband’s health and stopping your career makes you very vulnerable should you have to go back to supporting yourself (plus children as well).

My mum thought she would be a sahm /housewife for ever and stopped her career when she had children. My dad suddenly left her after 15 years (mid life crisis) and quite frankly she was screwed as she never got her career back to the level it was. Seeing her go through that made me really try to keep myself as capable of being being financially independent because you never know what happen.

mjf981 · 06/10/2023 04:37

I'd work if I were you. You can earn good money and have what sounds like a decent career. It'll give you security. You can't put a price on that. You never know whats down the road.

BBQchickensalad · 06/10/2023 03:48

I have no regrets from being a SAHM. I like working just fine but I got to share so much with the children. I was never bored because I wouldn't let myself be. I kept busy with outings and projects and made the most of it. Not that some days aren't just plain hard work or don't go well (isn't working like that as well?) but looking back, I think it was best for the family overall. I didn't find it hard to get back into work, though I was then forced to quit to care for a sick older child anyway.

PositiveThoughts11 · 06/10/2023 03:28

Can you look at picking up one or two days if you are self employed? Best of both finding a balance :)

Tourmalines · 06/10/2023 03:17

HeddaGarbled · 06/10/2023 01:26

It’s just that guys who earn that sort of money tend to start treating you like staff if you don’t have any independence from them. Maybe a year or so, you might get away with it, if he’s not a total dick, but you just watch that power imbalance kick in.

Really? That’s a very baseless generalisation .

LadyHester · 06/10/2023 03:15

I’ve done both and I know that I am happier, more fulfilled, and a better parent when I’m doing something that plays to my strengths. I am a rubbish SAHM.
Now I’m parent to a teen, I have a lot of friends who gave up high-flying careers when their children were born and are now struggling to find something to do that will give them a focus once the nest empties.
On the other hand, you don’t need to work for money so you can afford to take some risks - experiment and explore what you love. It will all add to your experience, skill set, and self knowledge.

EachPeachPearNectarine · 06/10/2023 03:11

This Emily Oster quote sums it up for me:

I work because I like to. I love my kids! They are amazing. But I wouldn’t be happy staying home with them. I’ve figured out that my happiness-maximizing allocation is something like eight hours of work and three hours of kids a day. It isn’t that I like my job more than my kids overall—if I had to pick, the kids would win every time. But the “marginal value” of time with my kids declines fast. In part, this is because kids are exhausting. The first hour with them is amazing, the second less good, and by hour four I’m ready for a glass of wine or, even better, some time with my research. My job doesn’t have this feature. Yes, the eighth hour is less fun than the seventh, but the highs are not as high and the lows are not as low. The physical and emotional challenges of work pale in comparison to the physical and emotional challenges of being an on-scene parent. The eighth hour at my job is better than the fifth hour with the kids on a typical day. And that is why I have a job. Because I like it. It should be okay to say this. Just like it should be okay to say that you stay home with your kids because that is what you want to do. I’m well aware that many people don’t want to be an economist for eight hours a day. We shouldn’t have to say we’re staying home for children’s optimal development, or at least, that shouldn’t be the only factor in the decision. “This is the lifestyle I prefer” or “This is what works for my family” are both okay reasons to make choices! So before you even get into reading what the evidence says is “best” for your child or thinking about the family budget, you—and your partner, or any other caregiving adults in the house—should think about what you would really like to do.

EachPeachPearNectarine · 06/10/2023 03:08

I'd work three days a week. For me it's not so much about money, it's about doing something I enjoy, the intellectual challenge, and being able to focus on something else. I'm a much better parent when I'm working.