Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’d work or stay home?

240 replies

StiffUpperNip · 06/10/2023 00:32

I am in my thirties, have two postgrad degrees and a career that I enjoy and in which I have invested a lot of time and passion. I recently (pre-baby) started working for myself/contracting. My day rate is £450. It’s unlikely that I will earn more than this in the near future.

DH earns about £200K a year (including bonus). This is likely to rise. He’s securely employed in a famously recession proof industry.

We have one DC. I am considering staying home until she starts school, as we don’t need my income. However, a quite large part of me feels like that would be a waste of my…I don’t know, mind? Prior efforts? Being a bad feminist? It’s also not going to help my fledgling consultancy at all. I was just gaining momentum.

Also, we want more DC. So, if I stayed home with each of them, that’s a pretty solid chunk of time.

On the flipside, I recognise that the opportunity to spend this time with DC is a privilege and that I might regret it if I don’t.

DH is completely unfussed, either way. I think he might have a very slight preference I stay home, but nothing pronounced.

What would you do?

OP posts:
OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 06/10/2023 07:49

Simonjt · 06/10/2023 05:49

Work, I personally don’t think being a stay at home parent (why aren’t we able to call it what it is, unemployed) sets a good example to children. There are of course exceptions, sometimes a childs additional needs means there is little choice.

Because being a carer* isn’t unemployed. If you did want someone else to do that role you would have to pay a lot of money for a housekeeper and a nanny.

*doesn’t matter is that caring is for a young child or an ill relative or a relative with disabilities or an elderly parent.

ahtred · 06/10/2023 07:41

What do you WANT to do? You are in the enviable position of having the choice, your DH's salary is enough to ensure you have a pension etc. I chose to work because I wanted to work, I could have stayed home, but I felt I was a better mum not being a SAHM because I wasn't a very good one, and I am career orientated. I genuinely believe the best situation for baby is whatever best suits the household.

cooldarkroom · 06/10/2023 07:40

Whilst there are many successful marriages. There are So many that aren't, the number of affairs rockets.
Most if the SAHM end up finding themselves in financial strife when their husband holds all the cards (and the OW)
Please dont allow this scenario.
It sounds like you are finding yourself ready to go back to work. So get a nanny & work part time

WAC1 · 06/10/2023 07:38

Like you, my partner earns enough for us to get by. I have a good salary £50k, he earns £150k (no bonuses in his industry).

I have a 18 month old and work full time. He is in nursery full time. We have no family nearby. My husband is very pro working and thinks it's unfair that I should have to 'give up' my career as this affects my career opportunities and pension. He is right and I'm glad I work, but I wish I didn't work full time. Nursery is more than 1/2 my monthly salary (although husband says it's from OUR salaries), we split everything by income so I pay 1/4 he pays 3/4 of all bills. He is very hands on with our son.

We are expecting another baby and I think I will drop down to 30 hours a week and have the children with me for 2 days and work 3 days (while they're at nursery). I think this is a good compromise Smile

Ggttl · 06/10/2023 07:31

I did it for 2yrs with my second as I my eldest hated nursery when she was under 2.

pros: undoubtedly better for the kids (if you are a half decent parent). Much less stress for the whole family on all fronts. Great for seeing your own family midweek without having to factor in DH or other weekend plans.

cons: everyone from the plumber to your dh, to you and to your ex colleagues respects paid work more. The person with money has the power. They get to choose how easy going, generous, fine with it they are. being dependent on someone else is not easy when you are not used to it.

arintingly · 06/10/2023 07:29

The other thing is - how much does your take home pay differ? Given that you're self employed so likely pay a lot less tax overall (obviously depending on your business expenses etc)

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 06/10/2023 07:28

At 4 months, I also found maternity leave boring. It gets a bit more interesting as they become more interactive but it’s also harder. I was desperate to go back to work at 9 months and it made a huge difference to me, not least because it actually gave me the chance to miss DC. I’m a much better mother for working.

As you’d gone self employed, you’ve got the best of both worlds really. You can go back 3 days a week and if you find your non-working day too much, you can go up the days at nursery to 4 or 5. Your day rate more than covers a day at nursery. You could also start with 5 and dial back to 3 if you find you aren’t coping. In your situation, I would put DC in nursery for 4 days a week and you work 3. This will give you a day to yourself to get on top off things or just have a bit of time but also a day to make up work when DC has picked up a big from nursery.

MidnightOnceMore · 06/10/2023 07:27

You are in a good position because you are wealthy enough as a family to choose whichever option you want.

The starting point is that the feminist option is whichever you choose so long as you are able to choose freely - and being wealthy is a big part of being free to choose.

It is just a matter of what you would like to prioritise at this particular time. You're not making a forever decision, you're making a 'for the time being' decision. You are wealthy enough to change your mind.

It is really tough for parents who would like to go back to work but can't afford or find suitable childcare. It is also hard for parents who would wish to be SAHP but can't afford not to work full time.

It is great you have so much freedom to choose.

W0tnow · 06/10/2023 07:25

I stayed at home and had all my kids very close together. I went back 4 days when they started school.

Embarrassednamechangeadoddle · 06/10/2023 07:22

If it were me I’d stay home while the baby was so small, simply because I found managing baby and work hard and that time goes so quickly. However as the baby got older I’d find a half way house, maybe 2-3 days per week working or 4 short days working.

A lot depends of the wonder context -
*Do you love being at home
*Do you have independent money a pension etc if you don’t work?
*Do you need a challenge outside or motherhood to keep you stimulated
*Do have good childcare options?

ColonelSpondleClagnut · 06/10/2023 07:15

Perhaps try not to think of it as a "forever" decision; rather what do you want to do now, and what will keep options open for later.

I think in your position I'd do part time (or more) while DC is small. Nursery hours can be more flexible than school, so it can actually be simpler to drop them off and get a full day of work in, than when they're at school.

Also think towards how responsibilities for running the house will happen if you stay at home FT. I know we as a society use the term SAHM but the reality is that women often become a Housewife with sole responsibility for running the household. This can be very hard to change to a more equal split if you want to go back to work later.

I wouldn't be putting a fledgling consultancy on hold for any length of time though. 🙃

bakedbrain · 06/10/2023 07:08

HeddaGarbled · 06/10/2023 01:26

It’s just that guys who earn that sort of money tend to start treating you like staff if you don’t have any independence from them. Maybe a year or so, you might get away with it, if he’s not a total dick, but you just watch that power imbalance kick in.

While absolute/relative earning potential and industry culture probably are factors, I'm inclined to think the person's nature is the primary defining factor, not salary level.

A shitty, superficial person is still going to take their SAHP spouse for granted whether they work on the Tesco shopfloor or is earning at c-suite level.

Meanwhile, any human being who doesn't generally treat anyone like staff likely isn't going to start doing so. Speaking from experience, btw.

I always feel genuinely sorry for people whose worldviews are defined by arbitrary superficial factors which they genuinely believe to be a primary determinant (rather than merely symptomatic) of everyone's human nature.

I suppose they might think this viewpoint sophisticated but I genuinely view it as a form of naivety, child-like in its one-dimensionality.

Ginger1982 · 06/10/2023 07:00

I stayed home for 2.5 years after DS was born. By that point, I needed something more so went back to work full time in a job that I really enjoy. I had worked hard for my qualifications so didn't want to lose the 'flow' of working forever. It worked out well for us. I work from home full time and DS is now in school literally round the corner.

LDA123 · 06/10/2023 07:00

I would definitely continue to do contract work on a part time basis (if possible) to keep your foot in the door. Doesn’t have to be excessive hours - 10/15 per week? Is that an option? And definitely pay into your own pension. Speaking as someone currently going through divorce with little pension as gave up work to be a SAHM…. Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Equally, I loved being a SAHM when the kids were little and it’s definitely more of a balancing act working even if part-time. Working also allows you to continue being “you” and not get lost in the child care side of things, sounds like you worked hard. Could you do some hours at weekend when Dad home to allow him to takeover the childcare? That’s super important to

arintingly · 06/10/2023 07:00

Go back to work, it sounds like that's what you want. Also make sure your DH picks up some childcare responsibilities despite his big job

The advice that I give every new parent (if asked, obviously!) is to figure out what is your tipping point for when time with your children becomes draining and unhappy. Like the Emily Oster quote describes.

Some women don't seem to have a tipping point and genuinely enjoy every minute - but I think most do.

My happy place is working 4 days a week - it leaves me looking forward to time with the kids at the end of the week and happy to go back to work at the start.

I also echo the points about toddlers made by PP. One of the hardest things about toddlers is that there is just no let up - best way to keep them happy is to be out and about and they talk totally non stop, no chance to be alone with your thoughts.

LabradorLoveSausages · 06/10/2023 06:58

I’ve never needed to work for the family finances. But while I loved my maternity leave, I am so glad I kept up a part time role in a job I love. My business has thrived and now I have older kids I’m really glad I kept going. It’s harder (and you’ll spend much of your £450 on a nanny/ cleaner etc.) but if you are career-minded, it’s really worth it for you mental well-being and independence. You day rate is good, even 2 days a week would make a decent contribution to family finances, and certainly worth working for.

Many of my friends gave up work when their children were young. And used all the lines about ‘previous time’, ‘easy to get back’ etc. So many of them have never returned to their professional role because ‘it’s not worth it’ with a CEO partner, Truro partners have become used to a stay at home partner and can’t cope with now sharing the load, because their profession has moved on without then, and because they’ve lost so much confidence. I know this is a source of sadness and regret for several of them. It’s fine with primary aged kids, but after that they’ve started to feel aimless. It’s easy to assume you can just hit the ground running in five years time, but I know many women in a similar position and none that have.

Marchitectmummy · 06/10/2023 06:57

Can you balance work to balance home life. Is your contracting deliverables based or can you choose a programme?

It sounds like 100% stay at home might not be the solution but if you can reduce your work a bit maybe both together is the next step see how that feels then go from there.

I found babies incredibly dull, and that didn't change even when at my 5th! Toddlers are more rewarding but hard work and personally I think ifs good for the parent and child to have a break from each other at that stage and nurseries are so positive for them - in my experience.

Then they hit 3.5 where you can sit and talk and boom amazing for the rest of their lives in my opinion.

You might find similar, so I would balance a but now and review as you go.

Parakeetamol · 06/10/2023 06:54

My dh earns similar. I have always worked full time. I have invested a lot in my education and want to actually apply that for a good few years. If I came out of my line of work for more than the 10 month mat leave there is no way I'd be able to get back in so I kept going. Now DC are mid primary, happy to do their own thing after school, I think I'd be quite bored if I hadn't stayed at work!

misskatamari · 06/10/2023 06:54

It’s very individual but my advice would likely be - can you work part time..?

I was a SAHM for 7 years (left a very stressful job I hated after having DS). I did enjoy it, especially when he was small, but I did find by the end I felt like I was missing some sort of purpose. I’m someone who goes out and sees friends and I have loads of creative hobbies too, so it’s not that I’m not capable of entertaining myself, but I’ve gone back to work part time now and I’m so glad I have. It’s good having something where I’m out, being me, not defining by my role in the home. And having my own income feels good again. DH was never funny about money and always appreciated my role at home, so I was lucky in that respects but it feels good to have some independence again.

Being a SAHM was great a lot of the time so if it’s something you want to do, then take the time and enjoy it, but id say, if you can keep your foot in the door with sOme sort of work, that could be win win

HernesEgg · 06/10/2023 06:49

Work, of course. It’s weird you think your husband’s salary is relevant.

itsmeafterall · 06/10/2023 06:47

Deffo do some part time work.

I would have been a rubbish SAHP. It just didn't let me use my busy brain enough.

I'm far out the other end now it's kids in their 20s. Tried to early retire last year but was craving a bit of work after a few months. I'm now back pt and my DD commented that I'm a much nicer human for it.

My kids always say that they saw me as a good role model too and it helped me to have a better relationship with them I think.

Everyone is different though and I'd say to be honest with yourself and follow your heart. Feminism is about having choices, not doing it all or fitting into an expected norm. It's about freedom to do what makes you tick, and to be respected for that choice. And to be enabled to make the choice that works for you. So you are not letting the sisterhood down if you choose not to work for a while. Equally if you do work, then that's OK too.

All that aside, go with your heart and you probably won't go far wrong. can always change your mind later on.

A lot of the very bright women I met at ante natal gave up work as they had high earning husbands. I used to be jealous of them sometimes, but then realised that a lot of,them were on anti depressants and bored shitless. Their kids became a chore and a project. I think somewhere between is probably the answer for many.

Sparehair · 06/10/2023 06:46

I did it the other way around. Worked when they were pre-schoolers but have just had a few years off- more circumstance than planned ( planned study break but then prolonged covid school closures and home schooling, international move etc,). I have just started picking up some freelance for a former employer and will go back next year when dc are in years 9&8. I know some people don’t see the benefit of being a SAHM to secondary age kids but i kind of subscribe to the “little kids, little problems….” adage. Although we couldn’t have predicted covid etc it’s probably benefited the family to have one person not working now rather than earlier on. So if you’re not sure I’d consider keeping your powder dry in case you need time off later.

Rainbowqueeen · 06/10/2023 06:40

can DH go part time too?

Id continue with 3 days either way. My DC are older and you need to bear in mind that when they are older it’s you they want. Pre-school any competent adult can attend to their needs but when they are older it’s you who they want at the school assembly etc. So I would continue to work and have both you and DH aim to get the flexibility to be able to go to all the school and other events they will want you at.

rwalker · 06/10/2023 06:38

Works not just about money it’s who u are and what you have achieved

whilst 200k sounds an enormous amount you’ll practically kissed goodbye to half of that in tax and NI you won’t get anything free

coronafiona · 06/10/2023 06:38

@Happyhappyday please tell me what you do for 100k and PT hours, I need a job like that! And OP what does your partner do?