Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’d work or stay home?

240 replies

StiffUpperNip · 06/10/2023 00:32

I am in my thirties, have two postgrad degrees and a career that I enjoy and in which I have invested a lot of time and passion. I recently (pre-baby) started working for myself/contracting. My day rate is £450. It’s unlikely that I will earn more than this in the near future.

DH earns about £200K a year (including bonus). This is likely to rise. He’s securely employed in a famously recession proof industry.

We have one DC. I am considering staying home until she starts school, as we don’t need my income. However, a quite large part of me feels like that would be a waste of my…I don’t know, mind? Prior efforts? Being a bad feminist? It’s also not going to help my fledgling consultancy at all. I was just gaining momentum.

Also, we want more DC. So, if I stayed home with each of them, that’s a pretty solid chunk of time.

On the flipside, I recognise that the opportunity to spend this time with DC is a privilege and that I might regret it if I don’t.

DH is completely unfussed, either way. I think he might have a very slight preference I stay home, but nothing pronounced.

What would you do?

OP posts:
HippeePrincess · 06/10/2023 12:04

personally I’d prefer to do 2-3 days at work a week

LabradorLoveSausages · 06/10/2023 12:00

G5000 · 06/10/2023 11:55

I on the other hand find part time the worst of both worlds. Often you are still expected to do all the work, just for less money. Your company thinks you're not interested in career, so promotions unlikely. At the same time, as you have all the 'free' time, you will become default parent and household manager.

I found similar when employed. But running your own business or working freelance, as OP, is completely different. You make your own terms of ‘employment’ and I earn so much more working freelance so can pay for lots of household help. I’ve luckily never fallen into ‘default parent ‘ role, we both pull our weight on that front.

G5000 · 06/10/2023 11:55

I on the other hand find part time the worst of both worlds. Often you are still expected to do all the work, just for less money. Your company thinks you're not interested in career, so promotions unlikely. At the same time, as you have all the 'free' time, you will become default parent and household manager.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/10/2023 11:54

@SouthLondonMum22

Statistically, the opposite is actually true so a SAHM is more likely to have a daughter who grows up to be a SAHM and a working mother is more likely to have a daughter who grows up to be a working mother.

This is really interesting. You would expect, as you say, that the daughter of a working mother is more likely to work and vice versa. I'm more like the PP in that my mum basically never worked after my sister and I were born.

We were comfortably off financially and my parents marriage was (for the most part) functional but my mum was desperately unhappy as a SAHM; she was bored, trapped and unfulfilled. The general sense I had that her life was a disappointment to her left a very strong impression on me and I was absolutely determined not to become dependent on another person financially for my family's security. It's still my worst fear.

It's funny how much this colours our approach: I see posts on here quite often from women who say they feel they "ought" to work but clearly don't want to. I find this very alien but I can see how what was expected of you can become a burden, in either direction.

Ultimately I don't think it very much matters whether you work or stay at home as long as as a) your kids are provided for and happy b) you're not desperately unhappy yourself and c) you aren't wholly reliant upon the good will of another person for your financial security for the rest of your life.

The "shoulds" and "ought tos" are mainly just a combination of guilt, ideology and projection.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/10/2023 11:46

Nonplusultra · 06/10/2023 10:36

Motherhood choices feel morally loaded.

There is so much to be said for a mother who is content and regulated. When your own needs are met, it’s easier to meet other’s needs.

Some women are drawn to stay home, some to careers, some to a bit of both. Some need intellectual stimulation. Some need social stimulation. Some thrive on solitude.

And lots and lots of women get no choice. And social, economic and legal reasons can make some choices precarious. But my point is that there’s no morally superior version of womanhood or motherhood.

It very much sounds like you’re strongly drawn to your work. If it matters to you don’t give it up easily, so think carefully about which thoughts have a “should” attached.

Absolutely. What's optimal for a family is usually what's optimal for the mother and that's a combination of financial circumstances, family shape, temperament, background, interest in work, type of work and all sorts of other factors.

What may be an obvious choice for one woman would be a nightmare for another.

There is no "should" about any choice that a woman makes in relation to working vs not working, as long as she is financially secure and happy and her children are properly cared for.

But generally speaking avoiding extremes (ie not working at all ever after the children are born and being entirely reliant on her husband OR working at full pelt in an office 10 hours a day six days a week) are a good idea. Not because either will inherently damage the children but because neither are great for the mother's health, wealth or wellbeing.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/10/2023 11:37

Teachingteacher · 06/10/2023 11:11

I agree with PP that part-time can often be the best of both worlds, especially since you can command such a high hourly rate. But ultimately, this decision is highly personal and no one can tell you what is the 'right' or 'wrong' decision to make.

Just an observation: It seems that what our own mothers/parents did affects the decision that we make. In my case, my mother always put her career first, worked long hours (7am-8pm) and I barely saw her throughout my teenage years. It really affected me and my sister, and so I'm definitely working towards staying home with my DC as much as possible. It will probably look like working part-time in my case.

I see other posters who have shared about their SAHMs who got trapped in a financially dependant relationship and were unable to leave, so they really value financial independence.

Just an interesting observation.

Statistically, the opposite is actually true so a SAHM is more likely to have a daughter who grows up to be a SAHM and a working mother is more likely to have a daughter who grows up to be a working mother.

Exceptions happen of course like yourself and I grew up with a SAHM but work FT.

WaltzingWaters · 06/10/2023 11:36

I’d stay at home because that times when they’re little passes so quickly and is so precious. But then I don’t have a big career anyway and I spent years working as a nanny, so being home for my own children is what’s most important to me. I know it’s very different for others.

If PT work is an option that definitely seems the best one to keep momentum with working and have plenty of time with your child also.

travellingwithatoddler · 06/10/2023 11:30

@5foot5 yes, my child is disabled so this is what works best for our family

Superscientist · 06/10/2023 11:20

I chose to work part time. I was originally going to go back full time but I was too unwell to do so.
My career was a big driving force. It took 11 years and two degrees to qualify and being out of the lab for 5 years would have had a very detrimental impact on my career.

Me and my partner earn about the same depending on my bonus. Our household finances are built around being able to survive on one salary so we wouldn't necessarily need my salary but my job is a positive contribution to my wellbeing and returning to work helped to improve my wellbeing

I do have Wednesdays off and these days are just for me and my daughter, minimal chores and no to do lists. I love these days. We often see my mothers who missed out on seeing her during my mat leave as she was the full time carer to 3 85+ year olds.

What every you decide to do, do book at least a day a week that is just driven by your toddler!

Teachingteacher · 06/10/2023 11:11

I agree with PP that part-time can often be the best of both worlds, especially since you can command such a high hourly rate. But ultimately, this decision is highly personal and no one can tell you what is the 'right' or 'wrong' decision to make.

Just an observation: It seems that what our own mothers/parents did affects the decision that we make. In my case, my mother always put her career first, worked long hours (7am-8pm) and I barely saw her throughout my teenage years. It really affected me and my sister, and so I'm definitely working towards staying home with my DC as much as possible. It will probably look like working part-time in my case.

I see other posters who have shared about their SAHMs who got trapped in a financially dependant relationship and were unable to leave, so they really value financial independence.

Just an interesting observation.

Pugfin · 06/10/2023 10:58

There honestly isn't a right or wrong answer, everyone is different. Personally I enjoyed going back to work after maternity leave as enjoyed the balance, it's also meant I've been able to keep my career going and if me and DH ever split I'd be financially secure rather than having just facilitated him moving up the ranks in his job. I know it sounds doom and gloom but I always promised myself after seeing my mum stuck with my dad as she couldn't afford to go it alone that I'd always want to be financially independent. Its early days for you really, I'd see how you feel in the coming months and explore whether you can find a balance of hours etc. Often when they start school you actually need more flexibility, I would work towards building this flexibility now.

G5000 · 06/10/2023 10:53

I’d stay at home or work part time. I think it would be best for the kids and for you.

Because...? OP has already said she is bored at home, so what makes you deduct it would be best?

Nonplusultra · 06/10/2023 10:36

Motherhood choices feel morally loaded.

There is so much to be said for a mother who is content and regulated. When your own needs are met, it’s easier to meet other’s needs.

Some women are drawn to stay home, some to careers, some to a bit of both. Some need intellectual stimulation. Some need social stimulation. Some thrive on solitude.

And lots and lots of women get no choice. And social, economic and legal reasons can make some choices precarious. But my point is that there’s no morally superior version of womanhood or motherhood.

It very much sounds like you’re strongly drawn to your work. If it matters to you don’t give it up easily, so think carefully about which thoughts have a “should” attached.

Thinkbiglittleone · 06/10/2023 10:33

In your situation it is nice that it boils down to your choice. It's not "unfeminist" or a waste of anything to choose to stay at home with your DC, but equally it is absolutely fine to go back to work.
Also there is no right way to feel, everyone feels different and that's ok.

For me, I knew as soon as we had him, I wanted to stay at home with him, I also had the choice of either and have a wonderful husband who pulls his weight and it was never going to be about staying in and doing chores. But I did become an outdoorsy person and I found it wonderful, but if that's not you, I can see how staying in with a baby/toddler could be harder work.

My job never defined who I was, so it made no difference to me in that respect, I never "lost myself" or struggled to "find things to talk about" as we never really speak about work anyway, but you sound like you love your job and enjoy doing it, so if it's possible, I think in your shoes I would look at going part time and go from there.

The thing is, no decision is final. You could start off by going back and if you feel to rushed or stressed ,miss your DC, you can go part time, or you could start off with staying at home and then see how you feel and slowly return to work with a balance that suits you.

PinkRoses1245 · 06/10/2023 10:31

I'd work but not full time. If you contract can you do a few days a week? You'll keep your hand in, you can keep paying into a pension for yourself. i think it sets a good example to kids to have both parents working, and you keep financially independence as honestly, the worst can and does happen.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/10/2023 10:28

Siameasy · 06/10/2023 10:23

I’d stay at home or work part time. I think it would be best for the kids and for you.

How can you know what's best for the OP better than she does? Or for her kids, for that matter.

Bature · 06/10/2023 10:24

£450 a day is £117,036 a year. It seems like most posters aren’t doing the maths. It’s hardly insignificant. Half of that isn’t insignificant.

Siameasy · 06/10/2023 10:23

I’d stay at home or work part time. I think it would be best for the kids and for you.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/10/2023 10:18

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/10/2023 10:08

@Coffeaddict

The OP said she wants to stay at home and the family unit has the means to do this.

I'm all for lowering the pay gap but saying a woman ( or man) has to return even if they don't want to is not the way to do it.

That's not how I read the OP at all. I got from it that the OP feels that she ought to want to stay at home because its a "privilege" but actually is quite ambivalent about it.

I don't think anyone is suggesting she has to return: a lot of people are suggesting a hybrid approach which gives her the best of both worlds.

That's how I read it too. Like because her husband is a high earner, she should want to stay at home because she doesn't ''need'' to work.

Earning my own money is great and is a reason why I work but it's also because I enjoy it and it's a shame that it often isn't a positive thing for a woman to enjoy her career because it is always thrown out there that staying home is a 'privilege'.

Earning my own money enjoying the career I worked incredibly hard for is the privilege in my eyes.

wildwestpioneer · 06/10/2023 10:13

I thought I'd want to stay at home, but in reality I couldn't stand it. I initially went back 3 days a week which was perfect when my dd was young, but once she was about 6 I went back full time. I'm so glad I did as my marriage broke down and this meant I was financially independent and could support myself and my dd. Plus it kept my mind busy and active. My dd is a very social lie girl (teenager now) and nursery and child minders didn't do her any harm

Do what's best for you, but also with one eye on the future and protecting you and your dc

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/10/2023 10:08

@Coffeaddict

The OP said she wants to stay at home and the family unit has the means to do this.

I'm all for lowering the pay gap but saying a woman ( or man) has to return even if they don't want to is not the way to do it.

That's not how I read the OP at all. I got from it that the OP feels that she ought to want to stay at home because its a "privilege" but actually is quite ambivalent about it.

I don't think anyone is suggesting she has to return: a lot of people are suggesting a hybrid approach which gives her the best of both worlds.

MrsBobo · 06/10/2023 09:58

@travellingwithatoddler @5foot5

Why is this extreme? She said it was different circumstances, and you don't know them!

Like the PP I am a SAHM, looking after a 3 year old and have a 6 year old in school. I have no plans to return to work when they are both at school. I have some 'side hustles' which are fully tax declared, but I don't get taxed on them. We save so much money with me being at home, cooking and looking for bargains for Christmas etc.

For context I'm a fully certified accountant, very good with money management and after enrolling on a refresher course would be able to jump back into the work force with ease. My eldest also has additional needs, so I need to be around for the foreseeable future.

Until you know an individuals circumstances, you cannot comment. Some women enjoy being SAHM or even Housewifes. And some, like my sister, need a break from the house and kids, and need to return to work.

Whatever floats your boat. Its your own life, you choose.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/10/2023 09:53

If you can do it part time, that would be the best of both worlds.

I’ve never really had the choice as there wasn’t enough money for me to be a SAHM, so I haven’t been in your shoes.

However, I later decided to divorce my exh and then was glad I’d kept my own income and independence.

clarebear111 · 06/10/2023 09:49

HeddaGarbled · 06/10/2023 01:26

It’s just that guys who earn that sort of money tend to start treating you like staff if you don’t have any independence from them. Maybe a year or so, you might get away with it, if he’s not a total dick, but you just watch that power imbalance kick in.

Agree that this is a big risk. Unless you have independent wealth of your own, I would keep your hand in with working where possible.

Anything could happen - your DH could suffer with his health (I sincerely hope that doesn't happen of course!) etc and you would be in what may be quite a vulnerable position.

Do what is best for you and DC.

5foot5 · 06/10/2023 09:45

travellingwithatoddler · 06/10/2023 08:28

I'd stay at home. Different circumstances but I'm not planning on working until my son is 16/18+.

Wow that's an extreme position. Are there special circumstances which make you think that is for the best?