Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find social work easy?

60 replies

hereforthecakeandwine · 05/10/2023 20:50

Will try and summarise for length sake -

Qualified 8 years ago in social work.

Have a job in adult mental health.

All through my degree people would try and warn me off of social work, too many caseloads, high burn out, too much responsibility.

I remember as a student on placement finding social work so enjoyable and also very 'easy' for lack of a better word. Not what I was expecting at all. However, I assumed that was because I was a student with a low case load and also protected.

However, 8 years in my job and I still find social work to be a fairly easy job. I love interaction with the clients and equally enjoy the paperwork/meeting side of things.

I have 33 cases at the moment and do duty once a week and am able to keep on top of it all. If not it just gets prioritised and pushed to tomorrow. I can only do what I can do. I find my job really enjoyable and low stress. However, I do find I am very organised and manage my time well. I don't do overtime or think about work outwith working hours. I see some colleagues really stressed and I sometimes question, am I doing something wrong? Am I not giving it my all if I'm finding it (and have done since being a student) so easy?

Anyone else think that they really scare people off of social work and perhaps the reality isn't as bad as they make out?

OP posts:
MrInbetween · 05/10/2023 22:13

@Hooplahooping oh I totally agree. There is totally a ‘badge of honour’ with working ‘20 hours over my contract’ etc. without much recognition that you also spent an hour having a good old moan in the office this morning.

Lavender14 · 05/10/2023 22:13

hereforthecakeandwine · 05/10/2023 20:58

I should have added this to my post. I am very, very fortunate with having a good team and great team leader. I know that makes a difference. I could NEVER imagine having the responsibility of a children and families social worker so I really take my hat off to them and realise it would be a completely different experience for me there, you're correct.

I think a lot depends on the staffing levels and having a good and supportive manager. If you've the right resources and support around you then yes it's manageable, but that varies from team to team. Even within children's services I've worked with teams who are evidently close knit, staffing retention is really good and the manager approachable and supportive and a good leader, and teams where the opposite is present. And the sad thing is that ultimately ends up affecting the people you work with. Resourcing staff is the best way to provide a quality service.

snackatack · 05/10/2023 22:12

I think it also depends on your capacity to 'switch off' .. if you carry the work with you - it would be far more challenging, than if you can 'box it' at the end of the day

Warriormum1 · 05/10/2023 22:10

Not to derail the thread, or put you down, but I am finding this really interesting to follow. I have had nineteen years of contact with children and families social workers, due to having a severely disabled child and I really think the system is broken. 90% of the social workers involved with my family have been ineffective at best, interfering at worst (and I've been through a lot due to the high turnover in this job sector). They often avoided me if when I needed help, (I assume this was because I was not in danger of harming my child) but hounded me whenever they needed to complete an assessment within a deadline at the last minute. 90% of the social workers I had interactions with would spend most of their time on extended leave - I assume on full or partial pay. I wished, as a carer who was left to look after my severely disabled dc for 24 hours a day seven days a week without a break, that I too could have had the luxury of taking time off whenever the stress was too much. At least you are paid for your job and have the option of taking time out when things get too much. In my experience, most social workers have been more about interference and box ticking than they have been about help. I personally, have only come across one who actually helped me. Interestingly the one time I really needed help during the first lock down when my husband and I both had covid and I was trying to look after him and my disabled child, and was unable to leave the house or access a supermarket online delivery order to get food, the social workers were nowhere to be seen! It was the local people in my community, and a local charity that reached out to me to make sure we were ok and offer me help. No one from social work even bothered to check in and see if we were ok. I understand you are up against it and doing a really hard, job but I just wanted to give you another perspective. If it were up to me, all social workers would have to look after a severely disabled child for a week or two without a break or be left to deal with a similar situation as part of their training, so they could have a genuine experience of what some families are actually going through. Not saying this to put you down, just sharing to remind you that there are plenty of people who don't have the option of breaking down, or going on paid leave when things get too much.

ballotspoiler · 05/10/2023 22:08

hereforthecakeandwine · 05/10/2023 21:23

I hear plenty about people's traumatic pasts, I guess I feel empathy for them and sad that they have experienced what they have, however, I don't continue to think about it any longer than I need to. Growing up, my dad would always speak openly about the sexual abuse he went through and so I'm not sure if that had an impact on me not finding things too shocking.

I guess the best way to describe it is that I have a wall up all around me - I know bad things happen. I know people go through awful experiences but I don't feel much. I will bend over backwards and am able to build really trusting and solid relationships with most of my clients.

Do I feel frustrated re mental health support? No I don't think so. Many of my clients are subject to CTO's and there is plenty support available to them if they choose to engage.

This might be a little off topic, but out of interest (as this was a big factor for someone I used to know) with respect to some people not engaging, do you ever come across cases where damage was caused by services themselves? For the person I knew (upheld major complaint etc) trust was irrevocably damaged and I wish workers after this had been a little more vigilant in trying to understand the barriers. As it was, the damage was never properly acknowledged and got watered down over time (records not kept updated etc). New workers didn't really explore reasons for non-engagement and I wondered if this is something that is commonly being missed, or if there are strategies or teams out there to work with people like that?

Zola1 · 05/10/2023 22:07

Belltentdreamer · 05/10/2023 21:59

Interesting to read a range of opinions. I’m hoping to apply for the Frontline social care masters programme but also slightly terrified if it’s going to be too much for me.

I absolutely love it and consider it a blessing and a privilege

Sometimes I hate it and want to scream into the abyss. It can be varied. But some of the most amazing friends I've got came from social work. And when you have a personal drama there's no one better to have around you than your little social work gang. Also when you have a win, oh my god, the best feeling. Like children going home because their parent made the changes, or a mum telling you she finally feels like her and the children are safe 🥰

Zola1 · 05/10/2023 22:04

mrsed1987 · 05/10/2023 22:00

I had an adult mental health sw ask me how I work in children's without crying. I said I don't, I've cried plenty of tears over the 13 years I've done it. She seems genuinely surprised, like she expected me to not have emotions

Yes to this! People who say ooo don't know how you do it, it'd upset me.
If I was hard as nails I wouldn't have gone into this ridiculous job with the misguided idea of 'helping'. (What we really do is just fight fires). Of course it upsets us and when people stop feeling anything about the work we do, it's time to go.

Canuckduck · 05/10/2023 22:03

I worked in child protection for 10 years, then with adolescents at risk of care. I could manage it and other than emergency situations I usually worked a regular 9-5/6 and rarely weekends. I could manage but it was emotionally hard and now even 15 years later I still think of some the cases and they make me incredible sad. No desire to return to it. High stress

I retrained and thought I’d go into HR but I ended up doing what I call social work light with adults with disabilities who are looking for work. It’s very easy and low stress. Even when it’s busy I don’t mind it.

mrsed1987 · 05/10/2023 22:00

I had an adult mental health sw ask me how I work in children's without crying. I said I don't, I've cried plenty of tears over the 13 years I've done it. She seems genuinely surprised, like she expected me to not have emotions

Belltentdreamer · 05/10/2023 21:59

Interesting to read a range of opinions. I’m hoping to apply for the Frontline social care masters programme but also slightly terrified if it’s going to be too much for me.

Hooplahooping · 05/10/2023 21:56

MrInbetween · 05/10/2023 21:50

@Hooplahooping bit i think the difference in doing something like CP work is that you’ve got the mixture of the high level of work (which is fine and as you say manageable) with the trauma of others and the real threat that one of the children you’re supposed to be caring for is seriously hurt.

It’s not simply about work load.

Oh I really didn’t mean to downplay the unique stresses of CP work - I can’t imagine having to prioritise when you are juggling multiple safety issues.

I suppose I do wonder though that, if there was more positivity about managing work / life around these intense roles, then there might be more people willing to step in to them. And more teachers in ‘rough’ schools and more social workers in general seems like a good thing… some of the narrative around the jobs must put people off

MrInbetween · 05/10/2023 21:51

I would say the same can be said for adult mental health work.

MrInbetween · 05/10/2023 21:50

@Hooplahooping bit i think the difference in doing something like CP work is that you’ve got the mixture of the high level of work (which is fine and as you say manageable) with the trauma of others and the real threat that one of the children you’re supposed to be caring for is seriously hurt.

It’s not simply about work load.

Hooplahooping · 05/10/2023 21:46

I also found this about teaching. It’s really easy to work yourself up into a froth of rage put-upon stress. But you can do that in any job. Good time management, being relatively organised + having some healthy boundaries mean that I mostly really enjoyed my teaching jobs. You’re never far from a couple of weeks off in a school!

there are undoubtedly some awful work environments / cultures that people can’t thrive in whatever they do. But I do think that a lot of people in public service roles don’t need to feel as beleaguered as they let themselves feel…

Coffeaddict · 05/10/2023 21:44

I think as highlighted the term social worker is far broader then people may realise. I know 2 people who are social workers. The first is my cousin in her late 20s. She works with the homeless in hostels while trying to rehouse ( ireland so not sure if same system here). Her job sounds tough at times but generally the families she is working with are trying their best but just really struggling in the housing crisis. They appreciated the help so generally have good relationships with the social workers.

The second was a neighbour who worked with children in need in the community. He got drunk one time and told us some horror stories but they are sworn to secrecy. I couldn't imagine dealing with the heartbreak he must have seen while simultaneously being told to fuck off by the people you are trying to help

MetaverseMavis · 05/10/2023 21:40

@zola1 Not othering, just observing and reporting what I saw in my cohort, but thanks for your opinion

MrInbetween · 05/10/2023 21:37

@Zola1 I agree the paper work is not hard as such. But it’s the decision making that is hard.

So many horrible memories. Poor kids.

Zola1 · 05/10/2023 21:36

MetaverseMavis · 05/10/2023 21:24

Recently-ishI finished my degree in SW. By Y3 when pathways were chosen, all the lazy learners, you know, those with poor attendance, least likely to engage in class discussions and getting low mark passes etc were choosing Adults.

Adult Pathway was known as the 'easy' option, with less law to learn, and families happy to see you because they want your help.

It's not ever us v them... adults isn't an easy option and plenty of workers cross back and forth. Please try not to 'other' our fellow SWs. I've some lovely EDT colleagues who work with adults and are super committed and talented. It's just different..mainly because of the capacity stuff I think.

Zola1 · 05/10/2023 21:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

hereforthecakeandwine · 05/10/2023 21:25

ApolloandDaphne · 05/10/2023 21:22

I also had the added difficulty of my own child having been killed some years earlier. I really wasn't equipped to deal with the death of other people's children. I felt
I had really failed them. I've had to do a lot of soul searching subsequently.

I am so sorry, that is horrendous. Honestly, I am in awe that you continued to help people after going through such a gut wrenching experience. I'm so sorry.

OP posts:
MetaverseMavis · 05/10/2023 21:24

Recently-ishI finished my degree in SW. By Y3 when pathways were chosen, all the lazy learners, you know, those with poor attendance, least likely to engage in class discussions and getting low mark passes etc were choosing Adults.

Adult Pathway was known as the 'easy' option, with less law to learn, and families happy to see you because they want your help.

hereforthecakeandwine · 05/10/2023 21:23

Khvdrt · 05/10/2023 21:17

What makes it very difficult is seeing children and adults in pain and being so restricted on what you can do. I’ve managed nearly 10 years in children’s but sometimes the sadness is a lot and I’m fortunate to have developed coping skills but still it isn’t always enough.
I’d be interested to know how you feel after knowing someone’s traumatic or abusive history and how you feel coming out of difficult visits? Or when people are in pain and you can’t help? Do you not feel frustrated at the lack of mental health support? I don’t really understand why it doesn’t bother you

I hear plenty about people's traumatic pasts, I guess I feel empathy for them and sad that they have experienced what they have, however, I don't continue to think about it any longer than I need to. Growing up, my dad would always speak openly about the sexual abuse he went through and so I'm not sure if that had an impact on me not finding things too shocking.

I guess the best way to describe it is that I have a wall up all around me - I know bad things happen. I know people go through awful experiences but I don't feel much. I will bend over backwards and am able to build really trusting and solid relationships with most of my clients.

Do I feel frustrated re mental health support? No I don't think so. Many of my clients are subject to CTO's and there is plenty support available to them if they choose to engage.

OP posts:
ApolloandDaphne · 05/10/2023 21:22

I also had the added difficulty of my own child having been killed some years earlier. I really wasn't equipped to deal with the death of other people's children. I felt
I had really failed them. I've had to do a lot of soul searching subsequently.

MrInbetween · 05/10/2023 21:21

@hereforthecakeandwine I’m really glad to read this, we desperately need well qualified, experienced and motivated social workers. So it’s great that you love your job.

However, your experience is your experience. And I’ve yet to meet a child protection social worker who isn’t extremely stressed. I did it for 7 years and it broke me. I seriously believe I came out of it with PTSD symptoms. I’m now working with children and families but in a different area.

In CP work you have:

  • unmanageable case load
  • distressing situations
  • angry aggressive clients
  • sad and anxious clients
  • your working hours can be utterly crazy - 70hours a week
  • making complex and life altering decisions
  • The constant fear that a child will die on your case load.
donquixotedelamancha · 05/10/2023 21:17

I have just started at a lovely school which is fairly low stress. That doesn't mean I don't know that I'm incredibly lucky and much of the sector is in crisis.

It suggests you are quite low on awareness of the world if you think everyone else is complaining about nothing or just worse at their job than you.