Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be concerned? School safeguarding issue?

54 replies

ANONforthisone67374 · 05/10/2023 16:08

So my daughter is additional needs and has a 1-1. She is a flight risk and gas on three separate occasions got out of the school during mornings when everyone is coming in (after being dropped off in the morning directly to her classroom)

Today I walked into the school and my daughter came down the stairs on her own without her 1-1. It seems she went off on her own. I kept her with me expecting to see her 1-1 but no one came. It was end of the day and both gates were open. I kept her with me while waiting for my eldest. She was with me for 10mins and not one single teacher/caretaker etc was looking for her.

Now I know she is a flight risk I get that she manages to evade me so I'm not upset she evaded her 1-1 who was the only one searching for her. My concern is how long she was effectively missing for. If I didn't walk round to collect her other sibling no one would have known I had her. Aibu to make a complaint?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 05/10/2023 22:23

You need to have a meeting with the SENCO and raise this as a safeguarding issue, not necessarily a complaint. Is the TA properly trained, does she know what to do when she goes missing and when to raise the alarm, is there a clear plan in place, is there a risk assessment in place (if not there should be), what are they doing to keep your daughter safe and what do they plan to do to avoid this happening again? For example, you pick her up early and the TA does the handover st the classroom fire door or school office so no traffic or open doors.

I'm a TA and I have lost a child a few times(mostly because they hid and I walked past them and then they ran in the opposite direction). I've also been asked to help when other TA's couldn't find a child.However, I know who and when to call for help, when we had several serial runners we had radios , there are clear procedures and protocols in place etc. If we see a child that we know is at risk , we always ask where their adult is and kind of hover until we see them.

It's completely nerve wracking and terrifying when it happens, and yes it can happen but there are things that can be put in place to mitigate the situation.

ANONforthisone67374 · 05/10/2023 21:52

LIZS · 05/10/2023 20:28

If it weren't the 121 who would you expect to be looking? Teacher cannot really abandon the other 29 pupils. Is there a secure entry door? Do other doors have alarms? Perhaps focus on how your dc gave them the slip in class time and check security of the building to prevent future attempts to leave.

Just to clarify a few points. I am not mad or upset with the 1-1 for losing her. She gets away I know this the school knows this I am not upset with her at all. She has additional needs I cannot control how my daughter gave them the slip her mind doesn't work like a neurotypical child of her age. My concern and anger is no one other than the 1-1 was looking for her. I should clarify that I meant no one other than the 1-1. Most if not all of the teachers are aware of my daughters flight as she frequently runs out of her class into other classrooms etc so they are aware of this.

My concern is that during the time she was effectively 'missing' no one else was alarmed. The gates weren't being manned to make sure she didn't exit. The school gates open at 15.05 no one stands at the gates to see who is entering/exiting, they finish at 15.15. I entered the school gates at 15.08ish and just by chance saw her on her own walking down the stairs near the gates that exit into a busy car park. Between the time I had her and the time I spoke to the teacher 11minutes later I saw no other staff looking for her. No I didn't expect all the teachers to abandon their class/children and look for her but there are support workers, caretakers, 3 receptionists etc no other teacher bar her own and the 1-1 was aware she was missing as such. At what point after not being able to locate a child who is a known flight risk was they going to raise the alarm? Or even call me to say they cannot find her have it seen her or got her? Yes I could have made the 1-1 aware I had her but how many times does this need to happen before more plans are put in place? Do I need to wait for her to have an incident or accident after escaping before I'm taken seriously? In fact just 2weeks ago there was a fight outside where an apparent pedophile was siting outside the school yes this could be hear say but what if it wasn't? What if she was taken? What if she was run over? At what point do I ask for more things to be in place?

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/10/2023 21:48

Passepartoute · 05/10/2023 21:35

We know there wasn't a secure entry door, or, presumably, alarms given that OP's daughter has managed to get out on three separate occasions.

As for who anyone would expect to be looking, frankly every adult who could be spared should have been looking. This is a child who has been known to run out of school before, she could be in serious danger, at a time when she is 100% the school's responsibility.

How many spare adults do you think the average primary school has, especially at home time? School budgets have been cut more and more so there is often no slack at all in the system.

I do think it would be helpful for the 1:1 to have a radio to try to get additional help and support, but at this time there may be no one available to help.

I also agree that dropping her off a little bit later and picking her up a little bit earlier may be a good solution?

IgnoranceNotOk · 05/10/2023 21:42

I’m most concerned that the gates are just open and not being monitored. When the gates are open then there should be staff standing by them to make sure no children do slip out.
If this was the case then they would at least always know she is on the school premises and safer this way.

Passepartoute · 05/10/2023 21:35

LIZS · 05/10/2023 20:28

If it weren't the 121 who would you expect to be looking? Teacher cannot really abandon the other 29 pupils. Is there a secure entry door? Do other doors have alarms? Perhaps focus on how your dc gave them the slip in class time and check security of the building to prevent future attempts to leave.

We know there wasn't a secure entry door, or, presumably, alarms given that OP's daughter has managed to get out on three separate occasions.

As for who anyone would expect to be looking, frankly every adult who could be spared should have been looking. This is a child who has been known to run out of school before, she could be in serious danger, at a time when she is 100% the school's responsibility.

LIZS · 05/10/2023 20:28

If it weren't the 121 who would you expect to be looking? Teacher cannot really abandon the other 29 pupils. Is there a secure entry door? Do other doors have alarms? Perhaps focus on how your dc gave them the slip in class time and check security of the building to prevent future attempts to leave.

Shinyandnew1 · 05/10/2023 19:56

no one was looking for her

her 1-1 who was the only one searching for her.

Those statements can’t both be true?!

Yes, the 1:1 should have been looking for her (was she?).
Yes, you should have gone back in the 11 minutes that you had her with to tell the poor 1:1 that you had her with you.

volunteersruz · 05/10/2023 19:51

weefella · 05/10/2023 17:02

The whole set-up sounds like a safeguarding nightmare:

  • A parent walking into the school unaccompanied by a member of staff.
  • Children able to leave the building alone.

At the very least I would be expecting an adult to stand at every open exit so that no one can get in or out. I would also hope that there was a system in place to notify SLT that a child was missing.

i would highlight with school that this is the issue....over my kids primary years (and in 2 different schools) there has been a total ramping up of security measures after both schools had incidents of kids taking themselves home during the school day...we used to be able to enter both schools fairly easily and now there are inner security gates as well as beefed up external gates and parents can't access school unless via the locked reception with an escort. If you have a kid with SEN that gives rise to this incident you need to have more than 1 layer of keeping them safe.... as it may be understandably possible to evade their 1 to 1 but they shouldn't be able to easily leave the premises.

Woush · 05/10/2023 19:00

Does your child have an EHCP @ANONforthisone67374?

Ratfinkstinkypink · 05/10/2023 18:53

The school need a clearly laid out emergency plan in place for when/if she goes missing. The alarm should've been raised long before the 10 minutes she was in your company.

Soontobe60 · 05/10/2023 18:24

ANONforthisone67374 · 05/10/2023 16:28

They weren't frantically looking for her when I went to her classroom her teacher said she went off with the 1-1 but she got away and they haven't seen her since. I got her at 15.08 and I went to her classroom at 15.19 and was told her 1-1 alone is looking for her. So for those 11mins no one knew where she was at all.

What time does school end? How did you get into school, and how did she get out?

Dramatic · 05/10/2023 18:14

I think rather than your DD evading her 1:1 being the issue, the real issue here is how she managed to get out of the door, or you managed to get in (it's not clear if you found her inside or outside the building) all doors should be locked, or manned at pick up time. No one should be able to get in or out without a staff member knowing

Dramatic · 05/10/2023 18:10

Why are so many people saying no one was looking for her? The op clearly states her 1:1 was looking for her

Dramatic · 05/10/2023 18:07

Hummingbird233 · 05/10/2023 16:47

@Dramatic whether the teacher was alone or not is irrelevant. The child has a 1-1 that is supposed to be watching OPs daughter at all times to ensure she's accounted for and safe.

Staffing levels are completely irrelevant. If the school ever don't have the right staffing to ensure each child is safe, then the parents should be informed so they can collect their child.

You couldn't leave a child with additional needs unaccounted for, just because the teacher is with the class. Someone would have to be looking for the girl, which OP says no one was.

These are basic steps to keep children alive and well.

I was talking about the class teacher, the child's 1:1 teacher was actively looking for her

Shopper727 · 05/10/2023 18:04

That would’ve worried me too, I have a child who is a flight risk and I used to worry all day that he was safe, he was fast too. No 1:1 either so I had to hope someone had eyes on him at break times etc just in case.

they need a plan, 1:1 needs to be on it with supervision at home times or as you say transition times so that they know where she is. What if something had happened to her in the time op found her. It’s not even about taking her back, it’s just lucky that’s who found her I wouldn’t accept that at all. They have a duty of care whilst she is there.

cansu · 05/10/2023 18:00

I thought you said they were searching for her.

mathanxiety · 05/10/2023 17:48

Agree with @weefella

School doors should be locked during school hours. Entry and exit should be possible only through one door, and all visitors should have to ring a bell for someone to open the door manually or by a buzzer. Anyone entering should have to sign in, and if children are being taken out during school hours they should be signed out.

whatsappdoc · 05/10/2023 17:27

You don't run after a child in flight mode whoever suggested that. Besides a 1 to 1 isn't employed on the basis of their ability to outrun a child more on the fact they have a pulse and are willing to do the job.

A chat about what needs to happen is in order. Definitely picking up a few minutes early before the gates open in the afternoon seems a good bet and also handing over after the gates have closed in the morning.

Somaliwildass · 05/10/2023 17:03

It wasn't her teacher's job (or any of the other teachers) to supervise her or stop what they were responsible for to look for her. She had left with the 1:1 TA, who was looking for her. Ideally, she'd also report to the office, who could put out a call for anyone who had seen her to return her to reception, but surely most people would start looking in the first instance before doing this.

weefella · 05/10/2023 17:02

The whole set-up sounds like a safeguarding nightmare:

  • A parent walking into the school unaccompanied by a member of staff.
  • Children able to leave the building alone.

At the very least I would be expecting an adult to stand at every open exit so that no one can get in or out. I would also hope that there was a system in place to notify SLT that a child was missing.

Singleandproud · 05/10/2023 16:59

At Secondary the TA would have had a radio and been able to radio to staff that your DD was wandering and other staff would have been able to go and look for her. If her Primary school is anything like DDs was it's far too small and has far to few staff to have search as they are with other children.

The gates to the playground were open but could she exit the building? If so then other teachers that are not familiar with her need to know who she is and to not allow her out of the doors. Don't complain as such but go in solution based with some ideas of how to solve the issue - it'll go down better and theyll be more open to the suggestions. So as previous poster said, a separate drop off and pick up routine is an easy adjustment to make.

Passepartoute · 05/10/2023 16:59

Hummingbird233 · 05/10/2023 16:50

@Softnatural the OP has said multiple times that no one was looking for her.

Not the 1-1. Not the teacher. No one.

A child can go a long way in 11 minutes. But equally if your sole job is to look after a child, known to be a flight risk, then surely if you're walking with them and they run away, you run after. It's not good enough to simply say they ran away and that's that.

This is a very pertinent point. The fact that OP's child has managed to get away from her 1:1 a number of times without the 1:1 apparently having any idea where she is is strongly suggestive of the fact that the school is using the 1:1 for other children - otherwise the 1:1 would have been aware as soon as the child escaped and the likelihood is that she wouldn't even have got down the corridor before being found. You need a serious conversation about how it can possibly be that this keeps happening, OP.

Hankunamatata · 05/10/2023 16:58

I'd be thinking perhaps about a school that can meet her needs better. Perhaps a mainstream with a unit so smaller class that's used to escape artists

PhantomUnicorn · 05/10/2023 16:57

I agree with requesting different pick up/drop off times for her.

My DS was walked to the office door 5 mins before the main school doors were opened for the other kids. It meant i had him firmly in my hands before i went to get DD from her classroom around the corner.

Drop off was the same routine in reverse. DD to her class, then DS was walked around to the Office and handed directly to his 1:1

Passepartoute · 05/10/2023 16:55

Softnatural · 05/10/2023 16:47

The 1-1 was looking for her though and other staff would have had to leave other children to join the search.

I'm not sure what you were expecting but collecting early seems like a good solution going forward.

OP was expecting her child to be kept safe, which is the minimum that all parents are entitled to expect when they leave their children in school.. When there is a danger of a vulnerable small child escaping into the road, saying that "the 1:1 was looking for her! on her own just isn't good enough. There would have been TAs and others without direct responsibility for a class who could at least have closed the gates.