Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most traumatic Jacqueline Wilson book?

212 replies

Msblueskies · 05/10/2023 13:54

Lighthearted… those who grew up on JW books in the 90s and 2000s which book was the most traumatic for you?

In my early 30s now and I absolutely adored all my JW books. But looking back a lot of the content was pretty dark 😅 I think for me Dustin Baby wins the prize for darkest and most traumatic at all. I read it at age 10!

OP posts:
Snowinjulyy · 05/10/2023 20:40

I remember the diamond girls, they moved into an empty house and had to sleep on the floor I think. ?

I looked up the biscuits character that I can remember and he's from buried alive.

BigTedLittleTedCardboardBox · 05/10/2023 20:39

We listened to an audiobook of The Longest Whale Song on a long car journey and found it quite harrowing but also very predictable. The mum ends up in a coma and the daughter must bond with her step dad.

I quite liked Lily Alone though, it had a less formulaic plot that most.

Robotik · 05/10/2023 20:33

I’ve googled and can’t find the sequel to lola rose but if anyone has more info please let me know. I’m desperate to read it.

AngryBirdsNoMore · 05/10/2023 20:29

Msblueskies · 05/10/2023 20:27

Ooh Sleepovers and The Lottie Project were pretty nice and unproblematic as far as I can remember! Read sleepovers many times.

The Tracey Beaker CBBC series is iconic!

Does anyone remember The Diamond Girls by JW? The mum has 4 daughters all different dads, she has her fifth baby and lies to everyone about it being a boy, which is only discovered by the main character when she is changing her ‘baby brother’ 🤣

…but why?!

Msblueskies · 05/10/2023 20:27

Ooh Sleepovers and The Lottie Project were pretty nice and unproblematic as far as I can remember! Read sleepovers many times.

The Tracey Beaker CBBC series is iconic!

Does anyone remember The Diamond Girls by JW? The mum has 4 daughters all different dads, she has her fifth baby and lies to everyone about it being a boy, which is only discovered by the main character when she is changing her ‘baby brother’ 🤣

OP posts:
Titicacacandle · 05/10/2023 20:27

Was there one about a mulberry tree and a child going between her parents. That one made my cry a lot as I was also going between mine.

Robotik · 05/10/2023 20:27

A short story sequel to Lola Rose??? Can anyone direct me to it please!!!

Lessstressedhemum · 05/10/2023 20:23

The illustrated Mum is awful. So traumatising. Lola Rose, too. My 23 year old DD is still haunted by Dustbin Baby.

Chiaseedling · 05/10/2023 20:20

^ the cat mummy one

Chiaseedling · 05/10/2023 20:20

This really freaked out my DD (now early 20s!).

MargaretThursday · 05/10/2023 20:18

I have to be honest and say, I think she's a very good writer, but I don't really enjoy her books. Dd1 hated them, dd2 loved them.

They feel rather like misery lit for children, or some of the Catherine Cookson books. You can guarantee that the main child has significant issues, a good number of the adults have issues, and it's not necessarily all resolved by the end.
The main child is normally a girl (can't think of any where they aren't but I might be wrong) but is also rather gobby and rarely would I think they're someone I'd have liked to be good friends with. They might "get together" with a boy they initially didn't like who's normally either geeky or fat.

She's the only author I've removed books from dd2. I removed one of the "Girls in Love" series where I think JW crossed the thin line between informing readers about anorexia and giving them a manual, or even glorifying it. I'm a bit sensitive on that because I've lost a friend to anorexia, but with dd2 who is definitely impressionable and a bit of a tendency for going overboard on things, I could see it definitely giving her ideas.
The other I removed was "Love Lessons" as mentioned before. I was astonished to find it was published in 2005. I thought it would be 80s at the latest. I'm sure she wishes she hadn't written it, but it is still published today. I would have expected one written at that time would have been far more about the teacher as a groomer, rather than the child leading him on, which is definitely the impression got from the book.

Some of the books I like. "Double Act" is good. "The Lottie Project" also has a lot for it and there's others of those type which to me work well. I think they're the only two I'd pick up again though.
I mostly like the first "Hetty Feather". I'm not very keen on Hetty Feather as a character; at times it felt like she'd picked Tracy Beaker up and dumped her in a historic setting. Thing is, for me, whereas Tracy could get away with her behaviour in the modern world because people would have tried to understand her, Hetty wouldn't have been given that leeway. I feel the same about Harry Potter in the first book when he answers Snape back-he has been bullied and disliked all his life, he would not have the confidence to do that at that point.

The later Hetty Feathers feel like they're stretching a very long point, to a point where she feels a bit Mary-Sue to me. She wants it, she gets it, even if the chance of a young girl getting her own way in that era is probably less than unlikely.
And the last book featuring HF that dd got, ("Diamond"?) felt like she lost confidence in Diamond's character halfway through. I liked Diamond (if that was her name). She was a quiet unassuming child, unlike most of JW's characters, but she was getting things done in her own way. The book was going really well, when Hetty Feather appears. And from then on, Diamond is really a backstage character to Hetty; even when they escape, it's Hetty who does it all while Diamond passively does as she's told. Its Diamond's book-she should have been the one to plot their escape!

I was trying to think if the books I read at that sort of age were similar. I know I read a lot of teen-anxy type books, but my memory is that things were generally resolved by the end.
I think I'd describe reading one of her books as going into a cold rough sea. You don't really enjoy it but you may come out feeling a sense of accomplishment.
And tbf to her, what I want from a book is more the feeling of dozing happily in the warm sun. Comfortable and peaceful. So I don't think I'm the chosen audience!

Terfosaurus · 05/10/2023 19:34

Vicky Angel. Mainly because I had a friend die at a similar age and he never "visited" me.

I always found The Illustrated Mum really upsetting too, although worry about how much I identify with the mum as a parent now Blush

I gave most of my JW books to a charity shop a couple of years ago and almost immediately regretted it.

salamithumbs · 05/10/2023 19:34

I think the Illustrated Mum upset me the most, both the image of the mum pouring bleach all over herself, but also how unpredictable and erratic she was, all happy and manic one minute and talking about dying the next..I remember thinking I'd be so scared if my mum acted like that. And I hated when the sister went off with her dad so the main girl was alone with the mum, not knowing what to do. In hindsight I think I read it at too young an age (8ish?) and couldn't cope 😬
I also found The Diamond Girls kind of upsetting because of the mum next door secretly abusing her daughter, and Dustbin Baby because of the mum slitting her wrists, but not as much because I was older, 10 or 11. Vicki Angel freaked me out though.
Books that did not traumatise me:
Sleepovers, cliffhanger, buried alive, the bed and breakfast star, double act, the cat mummy

Orangetattoo · 05/10/2023 19:28

Clean Break!

Sunnydays41 · 05/10/2023 19:27

JanS17 · 05/10/2023 19:26

The mulberry tree was in the suitcase kid!

Ah, thanks!

JanS17 · 05/10/2023 19:26

Sunnydays41 · 05/10/2023 19:25

Oh wow, I've not heard of most of these. I think I read a few, but the only ones I really remember reading (and really 'enjoying' if that is the right word!) are The Story of Tracy Beaker and The Suitcase Kid. And was there one about a Mulberry tree or was that in The Suitcase Kid?

They all have very heavy themes. I have started reading Tracy Beaker with my nearly 7 1/2 year old; she is really enjoying it, but I am wondering if she is a little too young. I can't remember how old I was when I read it, but it was completely independently so maybe a bit older. She probably could read it herself, though some of the language is a bit old-fashioned so needs some decoding!

I have since seen that JW has subsequently written sequels to TB, so I am looking forward to finding out what happens next (I was very frustrated as a child that the story wasn't finished!).

The mulberry tree was in the suitcase kid!

Sunnydays41 · 05/10/2023 19:25

Oh wow, I've not heard of most of these. I think I read a few, but the only ones I really remember reading (and really 'enjoying' if that is the right word!) are The Story of Tracy Beaker and The Suitcase Kid. And was there one about a Mulberry tree or was that in The Suitcase Kid?

They all have very heavy themes. I have started reading Tracy Beaker with my nearly 7 1/2 year old; she is really enjoying it, but I am wondering if she is a little too young. I can't remember how old I was when I read it, but it was completely independently so maybe a bit older. She probably could read it herself, though some of the language is a bit old-fashioned so needs some decoding!

I have since seen that JW has subsequently written sequels to TB, so I am looking forward to finding out what happens next (I was very frustrated as a child that the story wasn't finished!).

SoCalLiving · 05/10/2023 19:24

I'm pretty sure JW wrote a short story sequel to Lola Rose and it has a very sad ending.

For me I couldn't deal with Vicky Angel, the whole concept of death freaked me out in that way.

Love Lessons made me feel very uncomfortable but I also may have tried to read it when I was too young.

verabarbleen · 05/10/2023 19:23

Oddly I loved watching Tracey beaker the tv she but was never a fan of the books!

verabarbleen · 05/10/2023 19:21

@riotlady Lola rose? I think?

verabarbleen · 05/10/2023 19:21

My sister Jodie and Vicky angel!
I loved the suitcase kid. I was a child
Of divorce and split my time between parents /had step siblings etc . It was so nice to read someone else had a similar lifestyle! Do girls like them now? I have a few I was thinking of giving to my niece but are they a bit too much now? 😂

JanS17 · 05/10/2023 19:18

Vicky Angel, for me. I lost a close friend when I was 11 so it really spoke to me.

IsabelaYourBoyfriendsHere · 05/10/2023 19:16

I love Jacqueline Wilson! I read a lot of books but The Illustrated Mum will always be my favourite book of all time. I found it sad and strange when I was little but its absolutely heartbreaking reading it again as an adult. I always wanted to be Dolphin's friend. ❤️

I reread Lily Alone only recently and I was surprised at how upsetting that one was, it didn't really register much when I read it as a child. My own kids are the same ages as the younger children in the story right now so I found it hard to read in some places.

Girasoli · 05/10/2023 19:15

Was The bed and breakfast star star the one where there was a fire at the bed and breakfast and she saved everyone because she woke up from the smell of the fire thinking it was someone cooking chips? I loved that one.

I found The illustrated mum really upsetting, I kept my copy and occasionally re-read it though.

I'd love to get DS to read them but he can't even get past the cupboard under the stairs in Harry Potter so they are probably not for him!

chatelai · 05/10/2023 19:03

The Illustrated Mum - I was only thinking of that yesterday. Lots of complex stuff there, including Dol's sister's boyfriend - that bit made me uneasy.

Shattered. It's beautiful, and messed up, and sad. Made me go and learn about Chihuly glass too.

The Cat Mummy gave me the horrors. I was an adult when I read it!