Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most traumatic Jacqueline Wilson book?

212 replies

Msblueskies · 05/10/2023 13:54

Lighthearted… those who grew up on JW books in the 90s and 2000s which book was the most traumatic for you?

In my early 30s now and I absolutely adored all my JW books. But looking back a lot of the content was pretty dark 😅 I think for me Dustin Baby wins the prize for darkest and most traumatic at all. I read it at age 10!

OP posts:
ShermansSherberts · 06/10/2023 21:01

riotlady · 05/10/2023 14:55

It was Lola Rose, I remembered the name when another poster mentioned it! She changes her name to Lola Rose when they all run away from the dad. Clean Break must be a different abusive dad 😂

Many of her books had an abusive dad or stepdad figure in them, I think that was Jacqueline writing on a topic she knew well, considering she mentions in her interviews that she had a scary dad. Off th e top of my head I can think of several with abusive dads ,stepdads, neglectful mums or other caregivers who were abusive

Cookie (domestic abuse)

Lola rose (ditto)

Secrets (also an emotionally invalidating and neglectful mother for the rich girl)

Clean Break

The Bed and Breakfast Star (Macks treatment of elsa would be considered abuse now, I say probably normal for early 90s but still could have had an effect. I couldn't see an adult Elsa wanting much to do with Mack unless things changed in the interim.)

Waiting for the Sky to Fall (father overbearing but also quite scary, bad temper, lashes out at mother for being fat, and also Katherine sister Nicola. Katherine is put under lots of pressure for being gifted and even considers suicide over fear of exam failure )

Deep Blue (emotionally abusive dad, another gifted child put under extreme pressure )

Nobody's Perfect (sandras boyfriend Michael has a bullying dad. Sandra herself mentions a brief stay in care where she was smacked for refusing her milk and wetting her bed)

The Story of Tracy Beake r mentions an abusive stepfather figure leading up to her being taken into care

Amber (Amber mother Jay raised by abusive nuns)

The Illustrated Mum (Marigold raised by abusive nuns)

The Other Side (mother not abusive as such but severely depressed, father and stepmother not cruel as such but don't understand Alison. But I think typical of 80s parenting back then. Mental health in kids just wasn't recognised except in cases where the child acted out very badly it seems, quiet kids were left to get on with it)

Falling Apart (more emotional neglect invalidation of a bereaved child)

Love Lessons (sexual grooming, blamed for it)

The Power of The Shade (inappropriate teacher and pupil relationship )

Wave Me Goodbye (teenager humiliated for wetting bed)

Ellie's father in the Girls series is a bit of a See You Next Tuesday calling Ellie's art "twee"

ShermansSherberts · 06/10/2023 20:41

I like her more recent historical novels the best out of her recent stuff. Opal, Queenie, Wave Me Goodbye.

purpleme12 · 06/10/2023 19:36

fortheloveofjamdoughnuts · 06/10/2023 18:47

Mine? I honestly have no idea!

Yes literally as soon as you posted it, it said post hidden by mn. I only know cos I could see the time.

Then not long after I could see it.

It was strange because it happened so fast it couldn't have been from someone reporting it?

I was just confused

fortheloveofjamdoughnuts · 06/10/2023 18:47

purpleme12 · 06/10/2023 12:04

Why was your post hidden by mn?

Mine? I honestly have no idea!

ShermansSherberts · 06/10/2023 18:22

MyMitMoo · 05/10/2023 22:20

There's one I vividly remember, where the next door neighbours little girl is abused by her perfectionist mum, she has to stay pristine like a doll and the mum cuts her nails too short that they bleed and then I think she tries to copy a bird and fly away so she jumps out of her bedroom window. She's ok in the end but the imagery always stuck with me.

Also as chubby pre-teen kid, the girls out late character Ellie feeling fat and it being the key theme that seemed to consume her and affect every aspect of her life - it honestly was a light-bulb moment that perhaps I too.should feel disgusting and hate my body as I was chubby, but it had genuinely never crossed my mind before that I shouldn't be happy and confident. Now I probably would have felt like that at some point anyway but I do remember those books (that I was probably too immature for) pulled a lot of issues to the surface for me.
I still loved her books though!

I think that was The Diamond Girls. I remember being quite disturbed by the little girls treatment by her horrible mother, the bit about force feeding and having head held back and nose pinched and food shovelled in. Thing is my childhood was abusive in many ways and I hated when I was force fed but I didn't automatically consider it abuse because I was born in the early 80s and this practice was actually considered normal parenting then! It happened at school as well as home , I think many of us Xennials/Gen X can relate. Compared to the other abuses I went through that one just seemed so "normal" when I look back. in hindsight I realise that child rearing in 80s UK was pretty appalling in some ways!

Sorry just realised I'm probably breaching the right hearted rule a bit here!

ShermansSherberts · 06/10/2023 18:15

@BeeHumbert @JanS17 @fortheloveofjamdoughnuts I think it can go either way with ED. For me I found that book validating because as well as anorexia and bulimia it also deals with the other common ED that is rarely ever talked about- that of Binge Eating. The book mentions Ellie's childhood and how after her mum died Ellie felt a constant emptiness inside that she filled by excessive eating of snacks. This describes how BED is for many people including myself, that void, that low level sadness and emptiness that never goes away, a hole needing filling. I was too old for the book when I read it aged 18 when it first came out (but loved JW, as I had grown up with the Tracey Beaker thing and was delighted to discover the old 70s/80s JWs in my school library (The Other Side, Amber, Waiting For The Sky to Fall etc) and suddenly I realised other people knew about this void and the constant need to eat and eat and eat. I'm now in recovery after many subsequent years of denial. Mine was caused by a chaotic abusive childhood, not bereavement like Ellie but the feeling of a void there just resonated.

JanS17 · 06/10/2023 12:57

@Dandelionchaser ive not read this one but it’s surprising given than JW is openly lesbian. Maybe it’s something she experienced growing up or has seen for other LGBTQ+ friends?

JanS17 · 06/10/2023 12:55

@fortheloveofjamdoughnuts i read it when I was already suffering with ED and it made me feel less alone or less abnormal for my illness. I guess it can go both ways unfortunately.

Dandelionchaser · 06/10/2023 12:55

Kiss - not traumatic as such but since we're just listing the problematic elements of the books!
The girl has a crush on her best friend who is gay. Towards the end of the book he tells everyone he thinks he's gay. The happy ending is 1. a lot of people tell him it might be a phase and he's very pleased to discover that it might just be a phase and 2. the two of them kiss in order to ward off the homophobic bullies. The boy character gets to convince everyone he's straight after all and the girl gets a kiss from her crush. Happy ending for all.

JanS17 · 06/10/2023 12:54

This thread has made me want to go back and re-read lots of JW books! And some of them that I never read.

I agree that they show trauma, but a lot of children experience trauma and I think it’s good to have this reflected in literature, first so that those children know they’re not alone and second so that other children who are more sheltered are aware that not all children are so lucky. I wouldn’t say that glamourise it, although the TV show Tracey beaker definitely did!!

I lost a friend when I was 11 (she was 12) and Vicky angel really helped me to feel less alone at that time.

purpleme12 · 06/10/2023 12:04

Why was your post hidden by mn?

fortheloveofjamdoughnuts · 06/10/2023 11:53

@BeeHumbert

'Girls Under Pressure' triggered my bulimia - I've never recovered sadly

OMGTTC · 06/10/2023 11:50

kaylangrish · 06/10/2023 11:09

I have been waiting for a thread like this,

As an aside, there are so many creepy undertones in a lot of her books, specifically around dads and the teenage friends of their daughters (specifically the dad in Vicky Angel - at one point he picks up a photo of Vicky "Like he's going to kiss it" and Jade mentions how uncomfortable it makes her. Ellie's dad in the girls series has a strange fixation with one of her friends), I think someone has also mentioned the relationship in Midnight between Violet and her brother.

I adored JW as a child, but looking back on her books some of them were not child-friendly. I think most have already been mentioned but here are the main things that stick in my mind from those books.

Vicky Angel - Not only is there the tragedy of her friend but her mum is cheating on her dad with a married man and Jade finds out about it.

Girls series - One of them gets catfished online by a much older man, one is sexually assaulted by her boyfriend and another develops an eating disorder. As a child, it was pretty much an instruction manual on how to lose weight, it never quite sat right with me that there were no resources at the end of the book for young girls who may have been struggling.

The Longest Whale song - has a moment where the main character is pretending to be a whale at her school swimming lesson (?) and everyone assumes she was trying to drown herself

The worst thing about my sister - actually quite tame as JW books go, however, there is a scene where the two sisters are arguing and one kicks the other off a bunk bed ladder and she falls (but is ok by the end of the book if I remember rightly)

Little Darlings - Two girls who are half-sisters and the daughter of an ageing rock star. The dad runs off with a 19 (?) year old, one lives on an estate in Manchester and her single mum has suspected cancer so is desperate for her daughter to meet her dad so she'll be looked after. The dad is also kind of emotionally abusive.

Kiss - Main character is in love with her friend, who is gay. He collects glass and after he is outed at school he smashes his entire glass collection and ends up in hospital. She also makes friends with one of the popular girls who sends a nude to someone and it gets leaked...I don't remember what the outcome of that was but it was pretty traumatic.

Most of the other books have been explained but yeah, some of these I haven't read but have seen the adaptations which have stuck with me (DUSTBIN BABY)

Wasn’t Ellie’s dad’s partner also an ex-student of his? 😬

OMGTTC · 06/10/2023 11:48

Titicacacandle · 05/10/2023 20:27

Was there one about a mulberry tree and a child going between her parents. That one made my cry a lot as I was also going between mine.

Was that the Suitcase Kid? Was there a lovely neighbour who whittled tiny furniture for the main character’s toy to live in the tree?

I think the stepmum in that book made orange jelly out of actual oranges and the character hates it because it’s not with the cubes from the packet - I’ve no idea why that sticks in my memory 😄

CapturedLeprechaun · 06/10/2023 11:43

ALL OF THEM

Vicky Angel - causes her best friend to die in a car accident while they were arguing, then hallucinates her best friend

The Cat Mummy - she mummified her own cat. Wtf.

My sister Jodie - sister falls from a tower and dies (and is also a 14yr old in a relationship with a 19yr old)

The illustrated mum - mum has a mental breakdown, covers herself in paint, kids are placed in foster care

The dustbin baby - dumped in a bin when she was a baby

Love lessons - a 14yr old in a relationship with her TEACHER

Queenie - she gets tuberculosis. Her nan gets tuberculosis.

Bed and breakfast star - is homeless and living in a motel with mum & abusive stepfather, which then burns down with them inside

Diamond girls - her friend jumps out of a window because she is being abused by her mum

Secrets - hides her abused friend in an attic

I'm sure there are more!

salamithumbs · 06/10/2023 11:42

Poudretteite · 06/10/2023 08:21

I loved JW books as I was going through a traumatic childhood myself and found them very comforting! I loved the one about the girl who befriends a girl across the street in foster care, can't remember what it's called.

Think that one was Bad Girls!

kaylangrish · 06/10/2023 11:09

I have been waiting for a thread like this,

As an aside, there are so many creepy undertones in a lot of her books, specifically around dads and the teenage friends of their daughters (specifically the dad in Vicky Angel - at one point he picks up a photo of Vicky "Like he's going to kiss it" and Jade mentions how uncomfortable it makes her. Ellie's dad in the girls series has a strange fixation with one of her friends), I think someone has also mentioned the relationship in Midnight between Violet and her brother.

I adored JW as a child, but looking back on her books some of them were not child-friendly. I think most have already been mentioned but here are the main things that stick in my mind from those books.

Vicky Angel - Not only is there the tragedy of her friend but her mum is cheating on her dad with a married man and Jade finds out about it.

Girls series - One of them gets catfished online by a much older man, one is sexually assaulted by her boyfriend and another develops an eating disorder. As a child, it was pretty much an instruction manual on how to lose weight, it never quite sat right with me that there were no resources at the end of the book for young girls who may have been struggling.

The Longest Whale song - has a moment where the main character is pretending to be a whale at her school swimming lesson (?) and everyone assumes she was trying to drown herself

The worst thing about my sister - actually quite tame as JW books go, however, there is a scene where the two sisters are arguing and one kicks the other off a bunk bed ladder and she falls (but is ok by the end of the book if I remember rightly)

Little Darlings - Two girls who are half-sisters and the daughter of an ageing rock star. The dad runs off with a 19 (?) year old, one lives on an estate in Manchester and her single mum has suspected cancer so is desperate for her daughter to meet her dad so she'll be looked after. The dad is also kind of emotionally abusive.

Kiss - Main character is in love with her friend, who is gay. He collects glass and after he is outed at school he smashes his entire glass collection and ends up in hospital. She also makes friends with one of the popular girls who sends a nude to someone and it gets leaked...I don't remember what the outcome of that was but it was pretty traumatic.

Most of the other books have been explained but yeah, some of these I haven't read but have seen the adaptations which have stuck with me (DUSTBIN BABY)

EllieQ · 06/10/2023 10:49

MyBigFatCapybara · 05/10/2023 23:46

Does anyone else like the older JW books that she wrote in the 70s/80s? I think Waiting For The Sky to Fall was my favourite. I enjoyed Amber, The Dream Palace and This Girl. So many of these can be found on ebay.

Yes, I really enjoyed these. Would like to reread them as an adult as I don’t remember much of them. There was one where the main character ends up going to auditions for a role in King Lear and ends up playing Lear - do you remember that one?

They seemed quite different from JW’s later books - more for older teenagers than pre-teens/ early teens.

Saschka · 06/10/2023 10:47

Beezknees · 05/10/2023 22:02

See, I had a fairly chaotic childhood that continued into adulthood and devoured JW books because I didn't want to read about perfect families, I wanted to read about kids like me. I lived in a hostel for a bit which reminded me of the bed and breakfast star! And my mum suffers with her mental health like the illustrated mum. Love Lessons was shocking to me though!

Oh yeah this is definitely an “I was sheltered and too emotionally young to understand what was happening without it being spelled out” issue, not an issue with the books.

Msblueskies · 06/10/2023 10:35

The Suitcase Kid.. not only did the parents divorce but pretty much immediately both shacked up with new partners who had their own kids full-time, the girl stayed alternate weeks at each house and no bedroom of her own.

OP posts:
Poudretteite · 06/10/2023 08:21

I loved JW books as I was going through a traumatic childhood myself and found them very comforting! I loved the one about the girl who befriends a girl across the street in foster care, can't remember what it's called.

Luddite26 · 06/10/2023 06:42

Illustrated Mum still haunting. I remember a proper treat morning when it came on TV and we should have been doing stuff and we watched that. It made me really like Michelle Collins she really set me on edge.
I will have to ask dd's there thoughts as I was an adult!
We are still massive Beaker fans and watch with the GCs.
I have read the new TB books too and when I finished I cried for about half an hour mourning poor Tracy's shit life ! But I hope who she seems to get with in the end she stays with and they all live happily ever after I really couldn't cope with it if she writes another and It doesn't work out.
I remember rushing to a book signing one evening and queueing in a huge line with youngest DD when she was probably about 8. I think the book she signed was Candy Floss!

Latenightreader · 05/10/2023 23:59

I’ve just read the sequel to The Sleepovers (The Best Sleepover in the World) where the older sister has learned Makaton and is a more active part of the story. I also enjoyed The Primrose Railway Children - a retelling of The Railway Children set on a heritage railway (having worked on one the details were good). I like Queenie too (1953, girl in a TB hospital) and thought the Katy book was very good once she had had the accident, a bit too derivative before.

I read a couple of her early books as a teen in the 90s and found them more traumatic, then rediscovered them as an adult.

I remember watching a tv film of Dustbin Baby a few years ago. I remember it being good but the casting didn’t fit with my image of the characters.

KeiraKnightley2 · 05/10/2023 23:58

Illustrated Mum

MyBigFatCapybara · 05/10/2023 23:46

Does anyone else like the older JW books that she wrote in the 70s/80s? I think Waiting For The Sky to Fall was my favourite. I enjoyed Amber, The Dream Palace and This Girl. So many of these can be found on ebay.