Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Most traumatic Jacqueline Wilson book?

212 replies

Msblueskies · 05/10/2023 13:54

Lighthearted… those who grew up on JW books in the 90s and 2000s which book was the most traumatic for you?

In my early 30s now and I absolutely adored all my JW books. But looking back a lot of the content was pretty dark 😅 I think for me Dustin Baby wins the prize for darkest and most traumatic at all. I read it at age 10!

OP posts:
CostelloJones · 08/10/2023 19:51

Excellent idea for a thread by the way @Msblueskies

MrsDoylesLastTeabag · 08/10/2023 19:51

I did love JW but agree that many of them from the 1980s wouldn’t get past today’s “sensitivity readers”.

Does anyone remember the Stevie Day books? Nobody ever seems to when I mention them, but they were my favourites by her. SD was a kickass teenage tomboy detective. There were some dark themes - I seem to remember drugs and badger-baiting in one - but she was such a refreshingly confident and self-possessed female protagonist.

CostelloJones · 08/10/2023 19:51

Ok I admit it. I am 32 years old and I still have to buy the latest Jacqueline Wilson, it makes me feel so cosy. When I’m feeling miserable I’ll read one in an evening.

growing up, Dustbin Baby and the Suitcase kid really stuck with me - I was about 10. I was an awful sleeper and the image of the girl keeping herself up all night was burned into my brain

as a teen - Love Lessons or Lola Rose…

after that - my sister Jodie. honestly it’s just absolutely traumatic 😅

Luddite26 · 08/10/2023 19:43

Off topic a bit but has anyone read the TB follow on books?

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 19:37

purpleme12 · 08/10/2023 19:34

I'm not what this response is about.
I haven't said it was trauma?!
I asked a question and someone answered.

That's true @purpleme12 you didn't say it was trauma, I think I got confused because the thread was about people finding some JW books traumatic and I wondered ? I have seen some threads on MN where posters claim their 10 year old still believes (I always think they're trolls personally but that's me 😁)

No offence intended at all @purpleme12 .

purpleme12 · 08/10/2023 19:37

@salamithumbs thanks

purpleme12 · 08/10/2023 19:34

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 19:24

@MargaretThursday i think I wouldn't have an issue with it if the quality of the reimagined classics was decent. I just think her own ideas are so much better. I love her original books. Except Midnight , for some reason I didn't enjoy that one.

@purpleme12 I'm not sure I would call that trauma, because by the time children are old enough to be reading even the younger age Jacqueline Wilson books they are usually aware Santa isn't real. I can't imagine a child of 7 upwards not knowing the truth about Santa. I daresay it must happen, but I can't see it happening on a large scale.

I'm not what this response is about.
I haven't said it was trauma?!
I asked a question and someone answered.

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 19:24

@MargaretThursday i think I wouldn't have an issue with it if the quality of the reimagined classics was decent. I just think her own ideas are so much better. I love her original books. Except Midnight , for some reason I didn't enjoy that one.

@purpleme12 I'm not sure I would call that trauma, because by the time children are old enough to be reading even the younger age Jacqueline Wilson books they are usually aware Santa isn't real. I can't imagine a child of 7 upwards not knowing the truth about Santa. I daresay it must happen, but I can't see it happening on a large scale.

MargaretThursday · 08/10/2023 19:15

@Terfosaurus
Of course you're right. I felt it wasn't quite right, but couldn't think what it was.

Terfosaurus · 08/10/2023 19:03

MargaretThursday · 08/10/2023 18:32

I'm not sure it's really ripping off the classic books. She's reimagining them for the modern day, which is quite popular.

But I'm not really sure why she's doing it. I would have suggested someone doing that was trying to piggy back on the classics names to try and get better known, but she has no need to do that.

The one I really did feel irritated by is the sequel to "The faraway tree". I had a quick look and... oh dear.
She has not got Enid Blyton's imagination for the fantasy. I think the best she managed to come up with was "The land of unicorns". Compare that to the "land of goodies" with the inside of the flowers being jelly etc.
She also changed things, I thought not for the better. The original, the children's parents knew about the Faraway Tree and the children did their chores and asked to go. She had it a time slip (like Narnia) so the parents didn't know. Surely in today's world the parents knowing is better? And that's actually not in keeping with the original.
Then she uses it as a way of lecturing. Something along the lines of: (can't remember the new children's names so I will use the originals)
Mum: Betty, will you do the washing up?
Betty: You are only asking me because I'm a girl. Boys can do washing up too.
Jo: Don't worry I will do it because I'm a modern man...

If she wanted to break into Fantasy, then she's a big enough name to try it on her own stories, and people would buy it.

Off topic but the girl in The Faraway Tree was Bessie, not Betty.

Jo, Bessie and Fanny. I think they are Jo, Beth and Fran now.

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 18:59

@BertieBotts yes. I am guessing the reasons why children may be in care have changed since 1992, as the definition of abuse has widened quite considerably, thankfully. I know that's not the only reason children and up in care, of course.

I liked TB and also The Dumping Ground tv series' but I think the Tracy in the books was more likeable and had more depth as a character. The book Tracy was quite funny in between having understandable tantrums and tears. I loved the outrageous dares between her and Justine Littlewood! I don't think I could ever eat a worm! I don't think the tv Justine has as much spunkiness about her somehow.

salamithumbs · 08/10/2023 18:57

purpleme12 · 08/10/2023 18:38

Which is the book that says that Santa isn't real?

Clean break. And the suitcase kid kind of alludes to it since the mum says she bought a toy rabbit for the girl's stocking, but doesn't explicitly say he's not real

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 08/10/2023 18:40

Dustin Baby and Vicky Angel were overtly sad, but having re-read The Bed and Breakfast Star and The Illustrated Mum as an adult, I see how sad they both were too. Even Tracy Beaker!

MankyMinge · 08/10/2023 18:39

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 08/10/2023 10:38

I don't really approve of the JW ripping off classic books - Katy, 4 children and It, The Primrose Railway children etc. It's not really on!

Yes I must admit I much prefer when she writes her own historical novels. I loved Opal Plumstead, Rose Rivers and Baby Love. Katy wasn't one of her better ones, it was too similar to the original Katy. It's like she ripped off the whole book but changed it to modern times. I hate when authors do this.

I didn't like Midnight much. But she has done some absolute gems and I consider her a favourite writer of mine.

purpleme12 · 08/10/2023 18:38

Which is the book that says that Santa isn't real?

MargaretThursday · 08/10/2023 18:32

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 08/10/2023 10:38

I don't really approve of the JW ripping off classic books - Katy, 4 children and It, The Primrose Railway children etc. It's not really on!

I'm not sure it's really ripping off the classic books. She's reimagining them for the modern day, which is quite popular.

But I'm not really sure why she's doing it. I would have suggested someone doing that was trying to piggy back on the classics names to try and get better known, but she has no need to do that.

The one I really did feel irritated by is the sequel to "The faraway tree". I had a quick look and... oh dear.
She has not got Enid Blyton's imagination for the fantasy. I think the best she managed to come up with was "The land of unicorns". Compare that to the "land of goodies" with the inside of the flowers being jelly etc.
She also changed things, I thought not for the better. The original, the children's parents knew about the Faraway Tree and the children did their chores and asked to go. She had it a time slip (like Narnia) so the parents didn't know. Surely in today's world the parents knowing is better? And that's actually not in keeping with the original.
Then she uses it as a way of lecturing. Something along the lines of: (can't remember the new children's names so I will use the originals)
Mum: Betty, will you do the washing up?
Betty: You are only asking me because I'm a girl. Boys can do washing up too.
Jo: Don't worry I will do it because I'm a modern man...

If she wanted to break into Fantasy, then she's a big enough name to try it on her own stories, and people would buy it.

BertieBotts · 08/10/2023 18:24

I used to love her books, I think I read the illustrated mum, Vicky angel and the suitcase kid plus the second Tracy Beaker the most because those were the ones I owned. But I used to get the others out of the library and read those too. I didn't find the illustrated mum scary or traumatic at the time. I think because it has a happy ending - they all sort of do, don't they? I probably just naively thought everything would get better. It's with an adult viewpoint you can "see" into the future and guess what life is like going forward for the characters.

I mostly read them from about 11-16 and tended to see them from the point of view of showing you what it was like to have a different life experience. I think they did help me have empathy and see a different perspective. I also think they do a really good job of illustrating that even when parents aren't ideal in terms of providing stability, security, financially, routine etc that a lot of the time that doesn't mean that the parent and child don't love each other. In fact, that can often be very strong. I think that's the most important message I got from the books really, and this is sometimes picked up on too, directly by the characters, like when Dolphin goes into foster care, and the foster mother washes her black witch dress because she thinks it's dirty and ragged, but Dolphin is devastated because it fades the black and it smells like washing powder, not its "magic witchy spell". And I think JW is very good at observing and illustrating this kind of thing, where adult concerns override what is really important to children. There were parts of Tracey Beaker that touched on this kind of thing as well. I think it was always clear why the characters act "bratty" but maybe that was me being that much older when I read the books to realise that.

The only one that really upset me was the Diamond girls, I remember being really shocked and upset by the force feeding scene, and I'd forgotten the nail cutting but yes, that as well. I found that one really really hard to read specifically because of the scenes with that neighbour.

Tracy Beaker the TV series was nothing like the books. But I think you couldn't really do a TV series about a children's home like in the book version of Tracey Beaker and have it be actually suitable for children. There are bits in the books where she just alludes to things where as an adult you fill in the blanks, but children wouldn't, and you couldn't show that on TV. I have no idea how realistic JW's portrayal of being in care is, but I suspect it's a bit out of date compared to when the books were released and certainly in comparison to today.

RedHelenB · 08/10/2023 10:40

Msblueskies · 05/10/2023 13:54

Lighthearted… those who grew up on JW books in the 90s and 2000s which book was the most traumatic for you?

In my early 30s now and I absolutely adored all my JW books. But looking back a lot of the content was pretty dark 😅 I think for me Dustin Baby wins the prize for darkest and most traumatic at all. I read it at age 10!

My sister Jodie

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 08/10/2023 10:38

I don't really approve of the JW ripping off classic books - Katy, 4 children and It, The Primrose Railway children etc. It's not really on!

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 08/10/2023 10:35

The Illustrated Mum was my favourite. I re-read it sometimes. It's very tragic and moving, but ends on a more hopeful note than some of them though!

Did anyone ever read Midnight? That was just plain dark and disturbing!!

Luddite26 · 08/10/2023 10:30

As a mum of JW readers she used to pee me off for giving them ideas and not behaving /conforming to my word. That's meant in a light hearted way!
Being a child reading them and the adult is different perspectives

RandyAndTheRainbows · 08/10/2023 00:49

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 07/10/2023 17:22

I don't love the later ones for younger readers, but Waiting for the Sky to Fall made a big impression on me as a teenager in the early 80s. Bits of it still come back to me even now - like when she chose a subtle blue material for her one annual summer dress, and her mum went to the market and bought yards of cheap fabric patterned with huge cabbage roses instead. I can feel the teenage frustration and injustice of it all, although 40 years later I have a better understanding of what might have been going on for the poor mother.

I loved that book and remember that bit about the fabric very well.

I think this is why Jacqueline Wilson is so popular, she is so brilliant at portraying teenage (or preteen in the case of many of her newer books) angst. Whether a child comes from a bad or a sheltered upbringing, those little bits of angst are relatable to most of us.

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 07/10/2023 17:22

I don't love the later ones for younger readers, but Waiting for the Sky to Fall made a big impression on me as a teenager in the early 80s. Bits of it still come back to me even now - like when she chose a subtle blue material for her one annual summer dress, and her mum went to the market and bought yards of cheap fabric patterned with huge cabbage roses instead. I can feel the teenage frustration and injustice of it all, although 40 years later I have a better understanding of what might have been going on for the poor mother.

BabyofMine · 07/10/2023 17:10

Wow! I’ve just realised something from this thread. I have an absolute ton of JW books from childhood and absolutely loved her, but I’m sure from this my Mum must have been carefully checking which of her books to buy me because I didn’t have any of the ones that sound really dodgy! The worst was probably The Suitcase Kid but I was from a divorced family and it really helped me process it tbh.

Beezknees · 07/10/2023 17:04

I think I might borrow some of these from the library for a bit of nostalgia. I miss them!