Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reporting my neighbour?

37 replies

Disillusionedthesedays · 05/10/2023 12:24

I live next door to a barking dog. It's driving me nuts. It's certainly not all day. But at least 7 to 10 times a day, it gets set off and barks almost constantly for between 5 and 15 minutes.

I used to brush it off, but recently it's been annoying me more and more. I think the reason I'm increasingly annoyed by it is because of the dog's situation. My neighbour lives in a small flat, with a small yard. She has 3 large dogs, including a rescue doberman (doing the barking). She works out of the home during the day, and sometimes lives away from home for several days to help manage the family business. Last month she was living at the bedsit for 2 weeks while her family were away, before going on holiday herself for a week.

When she is out of the house, she has a family friend come over and sit with the dogs. He is an old man whose only counter is to shout "stop barking!" To which the dog invariably shouts back. I understand she takes him to dog training once a week but he is upset by any outdoor noise.

I don't see her walk the dogs and as far as i know they are walked rarely, and left to run in circles round the small yard (barking). We walk our cockapoo 4-5 times a day so know most of the local walkers and don't see our neighbours out walking.

So while the noise is annoying, I'm also annoyed by the dogs' situation, which I suspect worries me more. The trouble is I actually really like my neighbour. She is very sweet, with various health issues herself. She has no kids and has told me that her dogs are her babies and she seems to love them lots.

We've discussed the barking. She asks me to let her know when they bark, but I would be literally messaging her several times every day. And when I do message her, she just calls the old man and he squirts water at the dog or takes him inside. I tend to call her when it's been going on for more than 10 minutes or if it is after 10pm when it wakes my kids. It often starts early, before 7am and last week he was barking c. midnight.

So my question is - should i be taking action? Reporting her or forcing the issue, even if it affects our good relationship? Or should I let (barking) sleeping dogs lie?

OP posts:
Droppit · 05/10/2023 13:59

This sounds horrendous, you have my sympathy. I would lodge a complaint with the council. The noise level alone is unacceptable and antisocial.

First, keep a precise log of timings and duration and try to record the noise (is there an app which tells you the decibel rating?).

Retrievemysanity · 05/10/2023 13:45

We’ve had issues in our neighbourhood with 2 barking dogs. The council have recently issued the owner with an abatement order and it’s been much better (touch wood). RSPCA not bothered. The council were mainly concerned with the noise between 7pm-8am and they had to send inspectors out to witness it to check it constituted a statutory noise nuisance. I’m definitely a live and let live kind of person but draw the line if it stops or interrupts sleep. In our case there were loads of people who complained as the dogs were kept outside. Do you have other neighbours who are affected?

Disillusionedthesedays · 05/10/2023 13:34

Thank you for this perspective, that's really helpful. You're right in saying that it works both ways and my children can be noisy in the garden sometimes and our dog only barks when the doorbell rings, but then she really goes for it, so we are not whiter than white.
I do think I'd notice her walking the dogs though. Our back entrances go straight to the promenade (sea front), where we walk, and I can see both her front and back entrances clearly. I think in the 2.5 years I'd notice the big dogs going out regularly. We also have a camera doorbell and they never go out the front.
It's interesting that you say we walk our dog too much. It's only a 10 minute route that we do 4 to 5 times a day because she doesn't use the garden much for toilet so we try to take her out when she looks desperate. But maybe a longer walk and less often might be better for her? Thank you for your response

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 05/10/2023 13:06

x2boys · 05/10/2023 12:28

Report to.who?

RSPCA?

Council?

Dog warden (if they have one)

Puffinsandcreeks · 05/10/2023 12:55

I'll happily be the odd one out here and say I think YABU to report her.

A dog barking 7/10 times a day for maybe 5 minutes is not a great deal and would be considered within the realms of normal across the day.

You may not see her walking it because she might walk it at different times of day or choose quiet routes. Many people have dogs who don't want to be around unknown dogs, for example, and walk their dogs during unsociable hours or on quiet routes. It probably doesn't look like we walk our dog a lot, but he gets plenty of exercise, we just avoud busy areas or predictably busier times. 4 - 5 times a day is way too much, by the way (speaking as an animal professional, unless these were gentle, shorter, sniffy strolls). Dogs can also skip days walking without an issue as long as they have enough mental stimulation, toilet access, and there are reasons that might contribute to less walks (behaviour management or health). Sometimes a reduction in walks is actually recommended for welfare reasons depending on the animal.

She takes them to training weekly.

She provides care for them when she is away. The old man isn't doing any of the right things (squirting them with water) but she isn't ignoring your requests when you contact her. You might suggest discussing with her the way the barking is handled and perhaps she could work with somebody to stop them being as sensitive to whatever it is causing them to bark.

If you asked a welfare professional if these dogs were not having their welfare needs met, the likely answer (from what you have said here) is that the dogs are receiving appropriate care.
If you report her, brace yourself to destroy your relationship with your neighbour and for her to make your life hell if your dog so much as makes a peep, because that will probably be what happens.

Disillusionedthesedays · 05/10/2023 12:51

I did mention recently that doberman dogs suffer acutely with separation anxiety and also need 2 hours of exercise, including walks, each day. I suggested this might be why he is barking so much. But she hasn't replied 😕 . I guess I'm worried about our relationship deteriorating as I would find it hard to live next door to animosity and bad feeling.

OP posts:
hennaoj · 05/10/2023 12:49

MariePaperRoses · 05/10/2023 12:39

If you know her well enough to speak about barking why have you never asked about their exercise and the fact they are getting no mw gal stimulation that a walk brings as well as no physical exercise?

Ask her if she was confined to a back yard would she not descend into madness?

You won't get anywhere with RSPCA as sadly the dogs are fed and 'cared' for.

It's heartbreaking.

If she doesn't have CCTV, I'd be inclined to nab them and take to the pound and say you found all three loose.

Once she has to pay to get them back a few times she may not be able to get them back and they will be rehomed to people who can look after them properly.

'Nab', 3 large dogs, including a Dobermann from their own property? Are you nuts? Op would be liable to get bitten, or killed.

MariePaperRoses · 05/10/2023 12:39

If you know her well enough to speak about barking why have you never asked about their exercise and the fact they are getting no mw gal stimulation that a walk brings as well as no physical exercise?

Ask her if she was confined to a back yard would she not descend into madness?

You won't get anywhere with RSPCA as sadly the dogs are fed and 'cared' for.

It's heartbreaking.

If she doesn't have CCTV, I'd be inclined to nab them and take to the pound and say you found all three loose.

Once she has to pay to get them back a few times she may not be able to get them back and they will be rehomed to people who can look after them properly.

CalistoNoSolo · 05/10/2023 12:38

She's not sweet and she had no business owning dogs when she's not capable of giving them adequate care. The dogs are there as her emotional crutch, poor things, and she clearly doesn't see them as her babies because a mother that neglectful would have her children taken away. I think you should tell her every time the dog barks. I would also get in touch with the rescue as they won't be happy the dog isn't walked. Unless of course, she 'rescue' it from gumtree.

Disillusionedthesedays · 05/10/2023 12:34

Dog warden with local council

OP posts:
ImMrsNesbitt · 05/10/2023 12:33

I absolutely loathe irresponsible dog owners like your neighbour. She has no business having dogs if she can't provide basic care. I don't know if reporting her to the council for the barking issue or the RSPCA for the neglect issue will get you anywhere though 🤷‍♀️

x2boys · 05/10/2023 12:28

Report to.who?