Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why my almost 3 yo is so mean?

61 replies

Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 18:57

My nearly 3 yo (next month) is so unkind and it really worries me. What’s prompted this post is I was just eating dinner on the sofa and he came and sat with me and started deliberately jerking my arm trying to get me to spill hot soup oh myself. He also kicks and pulls my hair. He can be very aggressive and pushy with other children and punch too although not a lot.

I know toddlers can just be like that but it worries me I don’t seem to have any control over him, usual strategies of moving away etc don’t seem to make any difference. Yesterday he was trying to hit his brother with a toy over and over and when I took the toy off him he genuinely didn’t seem to have a blue why. Can anyone advise? At my wits end.

OP posts:
EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 05/10/2023 15:16

DS went through a phase of hitting other children - mortifying, obviously. Could never do time out with him as he would not co-operate, and constantly returning him ended up feeling like he was getting a lot of attention for bad behaviour. If we were at toddler group, he'd get one warning, then if it happened again we left immediately. At home the only thing that ever had an impact was putting away whatever his favourite toy was, for a set amount of time.

The hitting phase did end, and that seemed to have little to do with anything we did. One day he just didn't do it anymore.

caringcarer · 05/10/2023 12:56

TaIkingShite · 04/10/2023 19:09

And what happens when you put him in timeout and he just comes back? You let him come back? You try telling him no? Hard for us to know if it's parenting and being too soft with him, or if it's something more without kind of knowing how you handle these things.

When he was hitting his brother with a toy what was his consequence for that behaviour?

I'd take away something he likes every single time he hits someone, pushes someone, tries to make someone spill hot soup over others etc. If you don't stamp it out now when he's 3 he'll become the boy no one likes or wants to play with. I'd tell him no. Tell him why it's a no. Then tell him you are disappointed he is behaving badly and that means he will lose X for a set amount of time. If he wants X back he must behave for Z amount of time first. You need to be consistent and when issuing a punishment it must be done immediately it's no good trying to issue it 30 mins later.

Defiantjazz · 05/10/2023 12:23

I would imagine a 3 year old genuinely lacks the ability to judge whether they are being mean or not. Maybe don’t think of it that way?
As pp have said make sure he gets the message that it’s no ok to behave like this.

Janieforever · 05/10/2023 11:54

My first thought was also he was trying to get your attention. At 2 any attention is good attention. I also wonder if he’s jealous of his brother and feels he gets the attention and that’s why he hits him. Is his brother younger?

yellowclover · 05/10/2023 11:41

Personally, at still 2 with a younger sibling I would put it down to attention seeking and insecurity, which is very common at this stage.
Keep disciplining bad behaviour, but don't take it personally.

Changethenamey · 05/10/2023 07:46

im sorry I missed he was still 2, it could well just be looking for attention then. Eg - mummy is eating so not talking to me. If I poke her arm she talks to me yay! At that age he wont care if it’s positive/negative attention, he just wants you. Especially if there is a small sibling around taking up your time.

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 07:32

He isn’t quite 3 yet, I have wondered about adhd but hard to tell at this age. No one’s given up on time out but it makes no difference to his behaviour. I have to admit I’m puzzled by this S this is the third time I’ve said this. His room has a baby gate as it is top of steep steps and when he went into a bed we were worried he could come out in the night and fall. So it I need to he does two minutes in there. He cries and gets upset but never changes his behaviour.

OP posts:
Changethenamey · 05/10/2023 07:25

My DS was like this, he is now 5 and school think adhd. He is very impulsive and doesn’t seem to have the ability to think ahead to the end result of his actions, even if he or someone else will get hurt. He attention seeks all the time (class clown) and when he ‘loses it’ he is violent and loud.

I’m not saying this is your son, as he could just be being 3! Is he closer to 4 or 2? As this makes a massive difference at that stage. Does he got to preschool and how is he there? You need to choose a consequence and stick to it, if he knows you will give up on time out if he keeps walking back in laughing then of course he will do that.

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 07:12

I think he does understand I’m angry but finds it funny. @Ladyj84 really not being rude but what does “They know no they know it's a sit down for bad behaviour so we very rarely have to tell them off” mean? And I’m not sure how you have extrapolated that I am “taking piss with half hearted telling offs”? I’m here looking for advice and have been for months, nothing has made any difference and I’m disheartened and worried. I seem to be doing all the ‘right’ things and for that matter some of the wrong but nothing has any effect at al.

OP posts:
Confrontayshunme · 04/10/2023 22:13

Laughing at people with angry faces CAN be a sign that he doesn't interpret emotional expressions well. Get on twinkl and work on matching emotions cards. Also, if he is angry say "You are angry." And if he is calm say "You are calm." Toddlers need lots of help with emotional literacy. Then he will understand better when you or his brother are angry or sad or disappointed.

And ask nursery if they notice or have any recommendations. Most are in a better place to help if there is a chance things aren't normal.

always2tired · 04/10/2023 22:06

It does get better and it's nothing to do with your parenting some children are like this and have such strong personalities. I have raised all my children the same and he is the only one to act like this. He is also the most loving,wonderful cutest little boy when he wants to be. My husband jokes that if he was born first we wouldn't of had anymore.

Ladyj84 · 04/10/2023 21:53

Erm we have 3 under 3 and not one acts anything like this. They know no they know it's a sit down for bad behaviour so we very rarely have to tell them off. In sure new issues will appear tho lol. It's not a case of trying you either put your foot down early on or don't bother then of course they will laugh and take the piss as your doing the same taking piss with half hearted telling offs.

Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 21:51

Thank you @always2tired

OP posts:
Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 21:51

Definitely I don’t think he’s being purposefully malicious but it’s still so hard, he has lovely qualities too but it’s upsetting when you feel your child wants to hurt you even though they don’t really?

OP posts:
always2tired · 04/10/2023 21:48

My youngest son was exactly the same he is getting a lot better now that he is 3.5 but he still has his off days that he goes back to his bad behaviour. I think it's his personality mixed with his age and he is extremely cleaver and needs constant attention that going to nursery for longer has helped so much.

BethTalk2thehandpodcast · 04/10/2023 21:47

Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 21:39

His brother was born @BethTalk2thehandpodcast but I’d be lying if I said he wasn’t a tricky customer before. The being mean has been going on ages, I thought it was a phase but it’s been so long it’s feeling less like a phase and more like a personality trait tbh.

It’s not unusual for their behaviour to get worse after a sibling is born. We were warned about this in advance of the youngest being born so we spent a lot of time engaging with the eldest, making sure she felt included in the responsibility… you know, it’s the three of us together and we all have to help look after this little one. Have you tried buying a little treat for the 3 year old and saying it’s from the baby? There will naturally be so getting used to the fact that he had all of your attention and now he doesn’t have it all to himself. That is a significant change for him and it takes time to adjust. Most kids do horrible stuff at some points of their development, a lot of parents won’t tell you that theirs do, but there is always something. What you’ve described sounds more like the seeking of attention than anything more malicious. Try not to worry too much, even the behaviour before the baby suggests he is pushing boundaries to see how far he can go, which is completely normal x

Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 21:39

His brother was born @BethTalk2thehandpodcast but I’d be lying if I said he wasn’t a tricky customer before. The being mean has been going on ages, I thought it was a phase but it’s been so long it’s feeling less like a phase and more like a personality trait tbh.

OP posts:
Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 21:37

@FarmGirl78 it depends what it is, where we are and so on. For example at the park a few weeks ago he was climbing up on some wire fencing and I couldn’t get him down. It was awful.

OP posts:
BethTalk2thehandpodcast · 04/10/2023 21:32

I have two older kids, 14 and 11. Something that I was told when one was playing up when they were younger is that everything is a phase. Some phases are bad, some are good, but they are phases. Has there been any change in circumstance that may have triggered the behaviour?

FarmGirl78 · 04/10/2023 21:28

Why isn't it always possible to physically stop him doing something?

Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 21:05

Yes, he goes to nursery two days a week. On the other days I don’t see how he can be bored: we do lots of things.

@Lifeofasd1 see this is where I stress. He doesn’t have a tablet. He doesn’t watch TV. Stern firm tone of voice just makes him crack up laughing. I have nothing I can do that he cares about and that’s what worries me so much, that ultimately he will do what he wants unless physically stopped and that’s not always possible.

Thanks @amispeakingintongues

OP posts:
Lifeofasd1 · 04/10/2023 20:50

You surely know know your child well enough to know whether removal of a toy is going to be a serious enough consequence for what he did. Maybe look at your discipline methods. At three he may not know the severity of his actions and what a burn could do but he know it would spill and he know what hot is and he knows what pain is.
To me, that is bad enough behaviour that warrants suitable consequences. I don't think I would have been so polite in asking him like you did to stop.
Stern, firm tone of voice is needed, expressing your hurt and disappointment at his behaviour. Get him to tell his actions to his father or similar role model in your child's life, into pyjamas and zero tv, zero tablets, zero games untill bed time, zero tolerance
Taking a toy away seems a little non effective and he will just have forgotten the whole incident by teatime. It's the perfect age to teach him consequences but you need to be harsher.
Just remind yourself that you are doing this out of love so that he can grow up with friends and around people that like him because he will only push people away if you let this continue

amispeakingintongues · 04/10/2023 20:50

He just sounds like a normal toddler trying to get your attention. Anytime i'm focussed on something else- especially if i'm eating my toddler will do anything to get my attention even if he knows it's naughty behaviour.

It's just normal. Keep explaining why he shouldn't do X, and reassure him that you will read him a book / sing a song / play with him once you're finished.

Flyhigher · 04/10/2023 20:35

He needs more stimulation. 3 year olds are bright. He's bored. Needs other kids.

Flyhigher · 04/10/2023 20:33

Does he go to nursery?

Swipe left for the next trending thread