Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why my almost 3 yo is so mean?

61 replies

Badparentiam · 04/10/2023 18:57

My nearly 3 yo (next month) is so unkind and it really worries me. What’s prompted this post is I was just eating dinner on the sofa and he came and sat with me and started deliberately jerking my arm trying to get me to spill hot soup oh myself. He also kicks and pulls my hair. He can be very aggressive and pushy with other children and punch too although not a lot.

I know toddlers can just be like that but it worries me I don’t seem to have any control over him, usual strategies of moving away etc don’t seem to make any difference. Yesterday he was trying to hit his brother with a toy over and over and when I took the toy off him he genuinely didn’t seem to have a blue why. Can anyone advise? At my wits end.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Isthisexpected · 06/10/2023 07:08

What work are you doing to help label options and show him different ways of responding safely to them? I don't think he needs more or even different consequences. He needs a tweak to your repertoire.

ChaosAndCrumbs · 06/10/2023 06:51

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 19:52

He understands praise but immediate. He would not connect a sticker today with a present tomorrow for example. Punishment I’m not sure he understands really. @margotrose no I’m not saying that it does. What I am saying though is he hits it he’s angry. He is punished by taking a toy away, that makes him more angry so he hits even more. So then what do you do? That’s a rhetorical question by the way. There probably aren’t any easy answers here. I should add he isn’t like this all or even most of the time but it’s definitely a character trait and it does trouble me sometimes.

Youve probably tried this already, but do you count things out and make the whole experience about saving up for the end goal - whether that’s a day out or a toy. My dd is 2 and she really wants a specific toy, so every time we say ‘oooh we’ll done, let’s see how many tokens we’ve got now, 10, so you need 10 more and then you get ‘specific toy’. You can stick a picture of it on the jar etc and make the first one something small where he only needs a small amount making it easier to connect.

If that doesn’t work can the sticker itself be the praise? So put on him rather than a chart? Or have a little pot of ‘rewards’ he can choose from, just tiny really cheap bits and bobs, like a few marbles, a couple of cheap toy cars from a charity shop etc.

Do you have any other concerns around behaviour other than him finding it tricky to share and mange emotions? I noticed earlier you mentioned climbing around on a fence or similar and you struggled to get him down. My DS did this sort of thing and has ADHD, but I had other concerns that became increasingly clear as he grew.

Also in a situation where he’s cross and hitting and then gets more cross, I’d be inclined to take him out of that situation if he won’t listen to gentle hands encouragement and doesn’t respond to removal of toy.

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 20:35

Thank you for understanding @Chocolatehobnobs2948 , that’s exactly what it is! He was a sweet baby too, hopefully he will be again. He can be lovely don’t get me wrong. But I hate aggressive behaviour and find it hard to deal with rationally.

OP posts:
Chocolatehobnobs2948 · 05/10/2023 20:20

It sounds like you're doing all the right things. Try not to worry too much yet. I had similar thoughts to you because between the ages of 18 months-nearly 3, my toddler was really quite feral. She was a sweet baby and is now a sweet 3 and a half year old (although she has her moments!) but the terrible 2s hit us hard. Sounds like you're in the same stage. Like your son, she didn't really seem to understand consequences for ages but gradually it started to sink in. Just be consistent. I found that if we got into too much of a battle of wills, it was helpful to just walk away. When they get too worked up at this age they don't even remember the thing you're giving them a consequence for in the first place.

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 19:52

He understands praise but immediate. He would not connect a sticker today with a present tomorrow for example. Punishment I’m not sure he understands really. @margotrose no I’m not saying that it does. What I am saying though is he hits it he’s angry. He is punished by taking a toy away, that makes him more angry so he hits even more. So then what do you do? That’s a rhetorical question by the way. There probably aren’t any easy answers here. I should add he isn’t like this all or even most of the time but it’s definitely a character trait and it does trouble me sometimes.

OP posts:
margotrose · 05/10/2023 19:32

there is nothing he would care about so much that its disappearance would make him stop lashing out. In fact, it would make him angry rather than remorseful.

He's allowed to be angry. That doesn't mean you stop issuing consequences.

Thinkbiglittleone · 05/10/2023 19:27

When you say he wouldn't understand a star/reward chart, what elements would be struggle with ?

Does he understand the difference of praise and "punishment" ?

What does he like ?

Dishwashersaurous · 05/10/2023 19:14

Might be an idea to ask nursery for advice on what positive reinforcement they do, and which works with him.

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 19:02

I do think he may be a bit delayed - he wouldn’t understand a star chart or sticker chart. Anyway thanks. (No I’m not afraid of him, I do want him to grow to be kind and responsible and it feels very one step forward and three back, hopefully it will fall into place soonish.)

OP posts:
Jandob · 05/10/2023 19:01

Toddlers need boundaries especially when it is dangerous behaviour. It is ok to say no and have rules. Can try naughty step or can try rewards, or both. So star chart for good behaviour and reward if over a certain number. Can also try pennies in jar, 1 for good things, 1 off if naughty. Do it for other siblings too. Just be careful with punishment as some may not work well eg no TV. Rewards will work better usually.

Flyhigher · 05/10/2023 19:01

Does he hit at nursery? Or just at home? If it's at both then it's not boredom. If it's just with you then it must be he wants you to himself. Maybe you always do things with other people.
Do you have a close friend he likes, just 1 and you like the mums company too. Maybe try that.

Or more time in nursery.

autiebooklover · 05/10/2023 18:52

I'd pick one consistent discipline. Time out is a good one as can be done anywhere. I'd pick your battles and lower expectations (for now) as if you are constantly telling him off there's little incentive to behave but things like hurting others , snatching etc, I'd give a warning, then if does it again do the time out. Everytime. Try to pre empt/ distract where you can. Try to have a fairly consistent routine at home with lots of opportunity to burn energy. Lots of attention and praise. Good diet,regular meals times and a good bed time routine.

Any concerns speak to nursery senco or hv.

PaprikaPlease · 05/10/2023 17:49

Good advice upthread and sounds like you’re doing a lot of the right things.

fwiw mine could be vicious at nearly 3 too. Ignore the ‘mine would never do that’ smugs! Bright 2 year olds are tough. Everyone knows that. He’s testing you. You’re doing great.

howsaboutit · 05/10/2023 17:47

2/3 year olds don’t respond well to “time outs”, they don’t understand that the action has led to that consequence. You’re better off reinforcing positive behaviour. Our son is around the same age, just slightly younger, and the childminder introduced the phrase “kind hands”, when he started pushing and hitting other children just after he turned 2. We demonstrate “kind hands”, saying the words when we stroked the dog for example. He picked up very quickly that it meant being gentle with others. Whenever he is a bit too boisterous or is too rough with a child or us we remind him we like kind hands and most of the time now he changes his behaviour. When he does this we tell him we are proud of him for using kind hands. It sounds a bit hippy dippy and more passive than I thought I’d be as a parent but after seeing it work at the childminders, we reinforced it at home and it’s really helped him, and us!

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 05/10/2023 17:46

Ladyj84 · 04/10/2023 21:53

Erm we have 3 under 3 and not one acts anything like this. They know no they know it's a sit down for bad behaviour so we very rarely have to tell them off. In sure new issues will appear tho lol. It's not a case of trying you either put your foot down early on or don't bother then of course they will laugh and take the piss as your doing the same taking piss with half hearted telling offs.

Just because your children are perfectly behaved now doesn't mean they'll always be.
My neice was a perfect golden child. But the teenage years hit and she started growing a canibis farm in her bedroom amongst other things.

It's normal for children to go through stages of defiance and pushing boundaries. Which is what OPs child is doing.
Your time will come

ToadOnTheHill · 05/10/2023 17:41

Like a previous poster said, he is allowed to be angry about being punished.

Your job isnt to never make him angry.

I'd be angry if I was stopped from doing something I wanted to do.

It's ok for him to be angry about being corrected.

But he still needs to be corrected.

ToadOnTheHill · 05/10/2023 17:38

You haven't said what you do when you tell him off, put him in time out and he just comes back.

FWIW we used to say

  1. No Thankyou, That Hurts.
  2. Stop It, I've Told You No. Once more and you'll be in time out.
  3. Straight to time out. Put her back over and over until she did her time. Of course she was angry. We stuck it out and she grew out of it.

So, what do you do when your DC comes back before his time out? (I'm assuming you time out for an appropriate amount of time for his age)

Dishwashersaurous · 05/10/2023 17:27

Positive rewards. Star chart etc for small manageable things.

Plus, one thing that often helps is eating every single meal together as a family at the table. So that food time, and then play time are really clearly separate. Then he knows that you can't play or interact because it is meal time

Comedycook · 05/10/2023 17:26

My tip is to praise any good or even just plain ordinary behaviour! So if he's playing with a toy and leaving his brother alone.. "Oh wow, you're playing so nicely, we're all having such a lovely day, well done, maybe we could go to the park later as a treat". If he is sitting quietly listening to a story, praise him. I found this tactic to really work.

caringcarer · 05/10/2023 17:18

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 15:52

@caringcarer i don’t think you understand that there is nothing he would care about so much that its disappearance would make him stop lashing out. In fact, it would make him angry rather than remorseful. I have no desire to sound negative but repeatedly telling me to do something that is not effectIve and actually perpetuates the situation isn’t helpful tbh.

You seem afraid of your 3 year old and making him angry. Have you tried telling him his behaviour is making you angry? So you don't punish him in case he might get angry. No wonder you have a problem with his behaviour. Why would he bother to improve his behaviour if nothing ever happens in case he might get angry?

ChaosAndCrumbs · 05/10/2023 17:12

Does he have a positive reward system? My ds always responded much better to them. He’s older now (mid primary) but still responds well to a token system. We work on roughly 3 things at once, so some people might have ‘being kind and gentle’, ‘listening well’ and ‘going to bed well’ or whatever the issues are that you want to focus on. He sounds like a child who might do better focusing on the reward possible rather than the consequence. Tokens are given straight after a good event, meaning you praise them at the time and look for that opportunity more. It’s useful for children with ADHD, but also works well with toddlers/young children as they get an instant reward as well as a longer one after saving up however many tokens.

I think try to step back and think what hasn’t worked and find some alternative methods. It sounds like you’re concerned, but try to reframe it a bit. I found it helpful to really break down my dc’s behaviour and work out what was triggering the responses. My ds doesn’t cope well with changes of plan and gets fixated on certain things happening in a certain way (not always a great social help). My dd wants to do everything herself and finds loud noises dysregulating. Those are just snippets, but knowing that helps me act in the right way when their behaviour takes a turn.

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 15:52

@caringcarer i don’t think you understand that there is nothing he would care about so much that its disappearance would make him stop lashing out. In fact, it would make him angry rather than remorseful. I have no desire to sound negative but repeatedly telling me to do something that is not effectIve and actually perpetuates the situation isn’t helpful tbh.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 05/10/2023 15:49

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 05/10/2023 15:16

DS went through a phase of hitting other children - mortifying, obviously. Could never do time out with him as he would not co-operate, and constantly returning him ended up feeling like he was getting a lot of attention for bad behaviour. If we were at toddler group, he'd get one warning, then if it happened again we left immediately. At home the only thing that ever had an impact was putting away whatever his favourite toy was, for a set amount of time.

The hitting phase did end, and that seemed to have little to do with anything we did. One day he just didn't do it anymore.

Maybe one day the penny dropped, if I hit X Mum will take my toys away or make us go home. You stood firm and got a good result. This is what OP needs to do for her son's sake. If he carries on he won't have any friends and no one will want to play with him or invite him to parties.

caringcarer · 05/10/2023 15:46

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 15:37

He doesn’t care if you take a toy away @caringcarer. it doesn’t make him stop and think of the consequences of his actions. It would make him angry and then more likely to hit, so not sure it works. I don’t think anything will. I worry alternately I’m too soft, too harsh.

It doesn't have to be a toy. I'd take everything he likes for a short period. It sounds like you are far too soft. You sound lovely like you are afraid of him, "it would make him angry". Remember he is just 3 years old and needs firm guidance from you, his parent. Just because it might make him angry, it certainly doesn't't mean he should avoid punishment. I'd take all his favourite toys for a short period possibly 30 mi Ute's and lock them away in a cupboard. I'd tell him why I had done it and how long he must be calm and behave to get them back. If you don't stamp down on it now, he will just get worse and worse as he gets older. Then, when he is seriously assaulting you and others, you will be asking where did I go wrong? How do you think you have been too harsh? What have you done that might be seen as harsh?

Badparentiam · 05/10/2023 15:37

He doesn’t care if you take a toy away @caringcarer. it doesn’t make him stop and think of the consequences of his actions. It would make him angry and then more likely to hit, so not sure it works. I don’t think anything will. I worry alternately I’m too soft, too harsh.

OP posts: