Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To visit in-laws twice a year

117 replies

SheDrivesMeCrazy · 04/10/2023 11:33

DH and I have two DC aged 4 and 1. DH works full time and I'm a SAHM. DH's parents live just over 200 miles away and are self-employed. My own parents are retired, live 40 mins away and see me and DC about once a week, usually during the working day but occasionally at a weekend, in which case DH is there too.

We visited PILs at the end of June for the first time in nearly two years (previous time was just before I was pregnant with DD). We stayed at their house as they have two spare rooms and we couldn't afford to stay at a hotel/Airbnb in any case. We were away for 5 days, 4 nights, with the first and last days mostly spent travelling (6.5 hrs each way thanks to DC's endless toilet stops and protracted meals!) It was the longest stay that we could manage with DH's available annual leave. However, MIL was deeply disappointed that we weren't coming for at least a whole week and kept saying that there wouldn't be time to do half the things she had planned. (It did not please her to learn that we'd booked a two week summer holiday, the first since DD's birth. She felt we ought to be using that time to visit them.) She also said repeatedly that we'd better not leave it another two years before we visit again. We have no intention of doing so. We're not planning to have any more DC, and I hope we will all be in a fit state to make the trip from now on.

PILs generally come to see us two or three times a year, for 1 or 2 nights over a weekend. They usually bring SIL too and they all stay in a hotel as we don't have any space to put them up.

DH gets 30 days of annual leave and DS has just started school. Going forward, I could see us visiting PILs twice a year, in school holidays, for maybe 4 or 5 nights at a time. DH thinks this sounds fair, although he would be happy to go for a few nights longer if I were up for it and if he had enough annual leave.

For me, a week is too long to be under PIL's roof and I know DH would feel the same about spending that much time with my parents. However, I realise that I am very fortunate to live so close to my parents and to be able to see them regularly.

AIBU? How often would you make a trip of this distance to see family and how long would you stay for each time?

OP posts:
iatealltheminieggs · 07/10/2023 09:31

My mum lives 250miles away. It would take us about 6 hours with 1 stop (country roads and M6) We last visited in July 2022. She came here in Easter. Its much easier for her to come here on the train by herself than us go down to her.

I'm amazed people have enough annual leave together to allow for several trips a year.

TheHouseonHauntedHill · 07/10/2023 09:30

Well if it comes to seeing her gc at all she needs to compromise?

Meeting half way in a nice place for a break.
Alternatively op can you make a mini break out of the journey and stop somewhere on the way up and down.

I agree if everyone gets on its good to see them but I strongly dislike ths selfish aspect that it has to be in her house?

redastherose · 07/10/2023 09:22

Don't know if anyone else has suggested it but we lived a long way away from my grandparents and my parents used to do the drive at night frequently. My dad would finish work, we'd all have dinner, us kids would get into pjs and dressing gowns and have pillows etc in the back of the car and they'd set off late evening for the drive. We'd sleep most of the way down and be transferred into the house asleep and wake up at my nanna's house. It saved wasting a day travelling too.

Muddywalks34 · 07/10/2023 09:12

My in laws are 150 miles away my own parents 130 miles away. Going to the in-laws takes about 3 hours and we generally do it there and back in a day once every few months, they then come to us every couple
od months either day trip or an overnight. My parents I will generally go during school hols and do and overnight stay, 2 nights max or sometimes we meet in the middle for a day out, they also visit us but just as a day trip As my mum doesn’t like being away from home. We all get on, all pretty close, speak regularly on the phone and I find it to be a nice balance. I wouldn’t want to spend more than a couple of nights in anyone’s house so I think what you are suggesting is more than reasonable

SheDrivesMeCrazy · 07/10/2023 08:59

@AnniSparkles I think there is a lot of truth in this. DH feels he has to appease me in this matter and I have been calling the shots with regard to how long we stay for and when we go. I know this is not fair and that now we no longer have a tiny baby I will have to suck it up and go more.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 07/10/2023 01:55

i don’t think a few days twice a year is a lot really, and you haven’t even managed that as it’s been 2 years since you went! I’m not surprised MIL was a bit upset you couldn’t manage a week. Can’t you get a train? Or leave early morning/ travel overnight? Have a snack in the car? 6.5 hours to travel 200 miles is about 30 mph! I’d cut down on time spent at stops and travel in less busy times and you should be able to cut that down considerably. Or can’t you have children in with you and PIL stay at your house? You don’t want to spend money on accommodation but they are having to!

comfyshoes2022 · 07/10/2023 01:14

I wouldn’t want to stay with anyone for longer than five days at a time, either, and I think two visits a year is not awful. However, I can understand why MIL was upset that you all took a two week holiday at the same time as saying that you couldn’t stay longer because of the limits on annual leave.

GodspeedJune · 07/10/2023 00:39

I have a DC a similar age to your youngest and wouldn’t put them through long journeys more than a couple of times a year. Mainly because she hates her car seats and screams, then the guidance is to take them out and give them a break from the car seats every couple of hours. They can’t shuffle around and get comfortable like we can, and even then I get a numb bum from sitting in the same position for too long!

While DC are young the onus is on visitors to come to you IMO.

saraclara · 07/10/2023 00:08

Sconehenge · 06/10/2023 23:34

2 visits to them a year plus them visiting you 4 times is PLENTY! Can’t believe the posters saying you should be travelling 6 hours each way more than twice a year! Also 4/5 nights is a perfect amount of time - a week is painful under anyone else’s roof.

Where do you get the four times a year from? The OP says two or three.

And the journey is a four hour one, which OP managed to make into 6.5 hours by stopping for a long lunch among other things. She's had lots of advice from those of us who frequently made journeys like that with children, which will make it infinitely easier and quicker. The feeding first and setting off at bedtime thing is obvious, for starters. I think virtually all of us have said that's how we did it.

saraclara · 07/10/2023 00:02

My own family think two trips a year is plenty and that even one would be sufficient

Wow. I missed this nugget of parental selfishness and complete lack of empathy.

My instant reaction to that was "well they would, wouldn't they?"
They should have absolutely no input into this decision. They're clearly enjoying #1 status in the grandparent stakes, and see you making more visits north as a threat. If the tables were turned I suspect that they would be very unhappy with one visit a year.

wellandtruly · 07/10/2023 00:00

My parents are about 220 miles away. We virtually always go by train- sometimes even there and back in a day, or just an overnight stay.

Womencanlift · 06/10/2023 23:50

My own family think two trips a year is plenty and that even one would be sufficient (I don't agree with that) but they're also biased and they get to see the kids all the time.

Your parents should butt out. I wonder how they would feel seeing you less than a handful of times a year. Even if you and your DH can’t be bothered seeing his parents, it’s a bit shitty to deprive your kids of a relationship with all GPs while they are here

If it’s your DH’s childhood home then obviously he moved away so he should make the effort to go home rather than making them come to you. You could decide whether you go or not

But this is MN where most posters hate their PILs so you are always going to get a skewed view

Sconehenge · 06/10/2023 23:34

2 visits to them a year plus them visiting you 4 times is PLENTY! Can’t believe the posters saying you should be travelling 6 hours each way more than twice a year! Also 4/5 nights is a perfect amount of time - a week is painful under anyone else’s roof.

Maryamlouise · 06/10/2023 23:30

Don't have PILs but parents live about 7-8hr drive away and see them 2-3 times a year for up to a week (they usually travel to us or meet halfway) but they are divorced and remarried that is actually quite a lot of visits. Would love to see them more but we want some holidays as just us and to do the things we enjoy that parents wouldn't like/aren't able to do and then there are other things on on the weekends that the kids want to do or sometimes I have to work a weekend so I struggle to fit it in. I think they still have a good relationship and we do zoom calls etc

I think 2 trips plus them visiting you sounds fine

AnniSparkles · 06/10/2023 22:39

converseandjeans · 06/10/2023 00:04

I feel sorry for MIL who misses her son & wants to get to know grandchildren.

Why don't you set off at bedtime - 7pm. I think you would arrive around 10.30. Put children straight to bed. The journey sounds like a complete faff with a full meal at lunch.

You sound quite unsympathetic tbh. & unwilling to compromise.

I feel a bit sorry for your partner too. You say he's being realistic about visits but would like to go for longer if possible. To me it sounds though he's trying to take your negative feelings about visits into account and maybe feels he has to minimize how much you go as a family. Some part of you obviously feels that you should try to go more if you're posting on AIBU. You are putting him in a bit of an impossible situation. He is probably trying to balance your feelings as his partner against his desire and his parents’ wish to see his young family more. It is not as though he can drop by to visit them for an afternoon if he misses them. Such a trip needs to be planned in advance and realistically will be for at least one weekend. But it does not need to take 6.5 hours each way. Other posters have offered some sensible ideas about how to shorten that journey time.

A strong, adult relationship is built on mutual respect and compromise. Since you see your parents so often it's obvious he respects that for you. And I'm sure you don't arrange to see yours each time without letting him know about it and also checking in that he is happy to go visit or have them visit you. But with his family, how much choice are you actually giving him in the matter? I think you should just talk to him about it. You definitely don't need to go with him every time. But your kids deserve to see his family as much as they deserve to see yours.

saraclara · 06/10/2023 00:17

Another one that set off at about 7pm. Stopping for proper meals is madness. Feed them and yourselves before you set off. Drinks and snacks available in the car.

I don't think we had perfect children, but I don't remember those journeys ever being an issue. Yes you have fifty miles more than we did, but you'd also being going less often than we did.

converseandjeans · 06/10/2023 00:04

I feel sorry for MIL who misses her son & wants to get to know grandchildren.

Why don't you set off at bedtime - 7pm. I think you would arrive around 10.30. Put children straight to bed. The journey sounds like a complete faff with a full meal at lunch.

You sound quite unsympathetic tbh. & unwilling to compromise.

ElfZwolf · 06/10/2023 00:03

WhatAPalaverer · 04/10/2023 17:08

We used to get the kids ready for bed then put them in the car and drive for longer journeys. Or go at 4.30am and they’d sleep until 7ish. Made it more bearable! Not unreasonable to go twice a year and presumably there’s nothing stopping them coming more often?

Driving there at bedtime was the answer for us aswell !

Much easier driving with them asleep in the back seat, then you just dump them into bed when you arrive. You can do 200 miles straight through.

If you're lucky PILs get up with the kids the next morning and give at least one of you a lie in !

saraclara · 06/10/2023 00:02

theduchessofspork · 05/10/2023 23:57

Right.. you seem to be ignoring the fact the OP’s DH isn’t bothered. It isn’t the OP’s job to keep up relationships with his parents.

He can lead that and go up a couple times a year just him and the kids.

OP has an equal responsibility to her children though. And children need a relationship with both sets of grandparents and aunts/uncles.

mayorofcasterbridge · 06/10/2023 00:01

Hbh17 · 04/10/2023 12:22

Twice a year is fine for seeing your own parents OR your in laws - it doesn't need to be more often.

Come back and say that when you are the grandparent....

Obviously there are huge distances between families but personally I would be gutted to only see my children/grandchildren twice a year!

saraclara · 06/10/2023 00:01

DH's sister and aunts also live locally so we see them too.

Yep. Your children are not going to form bonds with the other half of their family if you only see them twice a year. Sorry, I know it's hard work, but it's a responsibility that you have to your children as well as your in laws.

theduchessofspork · 05/10/2023 23:57

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 05/10/2023 23:47

You appear to have zero interest in a relationship with your in laws. Poor people. You’re content because you can see your own parents. Do you have a boy? Imagine what you would feel like if in time his partner didn’t want to see you particularly.

Right.. you seem to be ignoring the fact the OP’s DH isn’t bothered. It isn’t the OP’s job to keep up relationships with his parents.

He can lead that and go up a couple times a year just him and the kids.

saraclara · 05/10/2023 23:56

My in-laws lived 150 miles away. We visited them every six to eight weeks including weekends/Christmas.period/Easter. And that was from when our first child was just a few weeks old (there was no guidance back then for how long babies could be in a car seat).

I don't know how 200 miles translates to over six hours of travel. It seems as though you're making a bit of a meal of it really. Or you've just been unlucky with the one trip you've done.

But yes, assuming that you/ your DH are the ones who moved away, and as they make the effort to visit you, I'd say that double the number of visits that you're planning would be fairer. Long weekends are totally feasible. You just would rather not go for a short time. I suspect that you would if it was your parents.

theduchessofspork · 05/10/2023 23:53

Marblessolveeverything · 04/10/2023 11:45

If you both want the children to have a relationship then more effort will be required. This could be increased visits, online zoom calls etc.

I know you didn't ask - but given your comment about accommodation being not an option due to finances. Can you secure a part time role to supplement this? this may make the breaks easier and longer?

You’re suggesting she get a PT job to fund trips to the in laws?!

I’d try and see them every 2 months for a relationship with the kids. If they come to you 2 to 3 times and you go twice as a family, just sent DH with the kids once or twice a year.

The visits don’t need to be longer, or guests like fish start to stink…

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 05/10/2023 23:47

You appear to have zero interest in a relationship with your in laws. Poor people. You’re content because you can see your own parents. Do you have a boy? Imagine what you would feel like if in time his partner didn’t want to see you particularly.