Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When kids and partners clash

61 replies

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 10:05

I have a ds12 from previous relationship and have been with current dh for 7 years (so since ds was about 5). We also have a toddler together.

Dh is helpful with ds (happy to do lifts, cook meals, pay for family holidays, all the usual stuff) but also maintains a respectable distance when needed as ds dad very much involved.

The thing is as ds has gotten older him and dh seem to argue more. It often starts with dh winding him up in a good natured way but sometimes taking it too far which then leads to ds telling him to shut up or being otherwise rude. This rudeness and attitude has escalated since ds started secondary school and we've even had some swearing from him.

I know ds behaviour is unacceptable but I also get frustrated with dh because he does wind him up and seemingly doesn't know when to stop, then when ds loses his rag he's very quick to come down hard on him and demand respect. I am frequently caught in the middle of them and acting as mediator which is draining.

I can only see this getting worse as ds gets older and hits the teenage years. It's very sad as they do love each other but they just clash. We had a big row last night and when ds was in bed I laid it on the line with dh and said if they can't get along and it gets too much we will end up having to live separately. Bit dramatic perhaps.

I have spoken to ds about his attitude and language, his reply "he just gets me so angry". Overall he is a sensible, trustworthy, kind and respectful lad who I've never really had to discipline because he's never been a problem. How do I navigate this? I just want them to get on.

OP posts:
LifeExperience · 04/10/2023 15:45

Winding a child up is completely unacceptable behavior. Saying something nasty and then pretending it was just good fun is how mean people get away with being mean.

Your "d"h needs to stop, immediately, and you need to take your son's side. He should not have to put up with such immature, bullying behavior.

Ffsnotaconference · 04/10/2023 15:38

The thing is you don’t have to break up your family.

if it broke up it would be dh who broke it up. I am a step parent so all this ‘mn hates step parents and therefore shouldn’t ever be listened to’ is weird.

Your adult husband keeps repeating behaviours he knows upsets your son and drives your son to lash out. That’s not ok. It’s really that simple.

If you family, including your son, is as important to your husband as it is to you he will stop it.

The whole ‘men always have banter so it’s not bully’ is cliched toxic male behaviour. Many men don’t like banter. And this isn’t behaviour between 2 men or equal development, power etc.

It’s one fully grown man, winding a child up then getting angry because the child reacted.

You don’t have to break up the family. You can simply tell your husband it’s not acceptable, that’s it’s bullying and it’s provoking a response. Since he is provoking the response he has no right to get angry or feel disrespected when he gets that response.

If he doesn’t change, then I would leave. Because there’s 2 outcomes. He also does it to the children you share, meaning teenage years with all of them will be more difficult and upsetting than it needs to be. Or he doesn’t do it to his own children, singling your ds out even more.

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 15:36

lunar1 · 04/10/2023 14:58

I can't actually see what your DS is doing wrong.

Grown man deliberately pushes his buttons, DS responds appropriately. Your husband keeps doing it, so your sons response gets bigger.

Is this man to stupid to understand cause and effect?

You don't want your DS just staying quiet when these things happen, what would that teach him about his value?

Of course but the issue is that dh doesn't intend to cause upset. In his mind he thinks he's having a joke and quite often ds does laugh along and they get on fine. On the odd occasion he misjudges it or catches ds is in a bad mood so he turns around and swears at dh or tells him to shut up dh is understandably a bit 'huh?'

Those suggesting this is deliberate, targeted abuse are so far off the mark its unreal but there is no point trying to argue because they clearly know more about my life and family than I do.

I would say that ds is free to be himself in our home and his shitty attitude and behaviour actually demonstrates that. At school or even at his dads (who is very strict) he doesn't behave like this. So although I don't relish the disagreements and fallouts I do believe that ds is comfortable to be his true self with dh and I, warts and all.

Aside from these arguments they have a solid relationship, often go out together just the two of them to play football or watch a lads film at the cinema. This isn't abuse, it's a clash of old man personality versus teen boy personality.

OP posts:
Hubblebubble · 04/10/2023 15:01

You, as an adult, have the power to leave or make your husband leave. Your son is stuck until he's old enough to leave

Hubblebubble · 04/10/2023 15:01

Just remember that your son will remember when he's a grown adult, if you failed to make sure his home was a safe place for him. Not all abuse is physical. Constant put downs and 'teasing' is emotional abuse.

Quartz2208 · 04/10/2023 14:58

Your DH needs to be the adult here. There is no need to try and get the last word or do banter anymore.

he stops any banter or is more careful when he does (it is banter or unnecessarily mean - your example was the latter). If he does something that hits wrong he walks away and defuses the situation. There is no need to stay and stand his ground.

if you pick a scab/spot accidentally you don’t keep picking at it you leave it. He doesn’t need to win or get the last word. He can and needs to stop. It is clear from your post that your DH is perfectly capable of modifying his behaviour and stop causing it so he needs to.

actually parent or step parent it doesn’t matter if he doesn’t know when to stop when it is clearly having a negative affect that is verging on bullying. Instead he either needs to not escalate or walk away and give space

lunar1 · 04/10/2023 14:58

I can't actually see what your DS is doing wrong.

Grown man deliberately pushes his buttons, DS responds appropriately. Your husband keeps doing it, so your sons response gets bigger.

Is this man to stupid to understand cause and effect?

You don't want your DS just staying quiet when these things happen, what would that teach him about his value?

takealettermsjones · 04/10/2023 14:56

I would have said it's bullying whether he was a step parent, biological parent, or the bloody gardener tbh.

It's not about men/boys "ribbing" each other. Your son is a child. He's dealing with the start of the hormone-heavy teenage years and he has no idea how to take comments like this on the chin, brush them off etc. How is he ever going to learn how to do that if he's not shown? As soon as he says something back to your husband, your husband "comes down hard" on him. Hardly modelling the best way to receive "banter" is he?

I never said to break up your family, but I said your instinct to be harsh with your husband and give him an ultimatum was a good one, because if it were me, I'd be demanding this stop in no uncertain terms.

It's only fun if everyone's laughing. It is upsetting your son.

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 14:45

Sapphire387 · 04/10/2023 14:16

Your DH is getting more of a pasting on here because he's a step parent, I think. It always happens on mumsnet.

If he's generally a good guy, you have shared DC, and he's been in your DS' life for many years, I think it would be madness to break the family up at this stage.

It sounds more like DH is getting it a bit wrong and not adapting his behaviour to parenting a teen. There's a good book we read called 'Get out of my life (but first take me and Alex into town)'. Also - TALK to him about it.

I'm really not sure where everyone is getting this 'bullying' thing from - men/boys often rib each other, it doesn't sound like anything really nasty tbh.

DS' behaviour needs nipping in the bud if he is swearing. DH needs to learn to be more sensitive to him now he is getting older and more hormonal.

My thoughts exactly. I am certain that the bullying comments wouldn't be happening if he wasn't a step parent. This is the man who has paid for family holidays, christmases, stood in the cold and watched ds play football, given him lifts, entertained his friends. He is far from a bully but I agree he is getting it wrong at the moment.

Parenting a tween/teen is a minefield. I get it wrong sometimes too. I've never done it before. But I have no intention of breaking up our family over this, I just hoped for some useful guidance or advice from people who have maybe been through something similar.

MN and AIBU specifically is wild at the moment. So much nastiness.

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 04/10/2023 14:16

Your DH is getting more of a pasting on here because he's a step parent, I think. It always happens on mumsnet.

If he's generally a good guy, you have shared DC, and he's been in your DS' life for many years, I think it would be madness to break the family up at this stage.

It sounds more like DH is getting it a bit wrong and not adapting his behaviour to parenting a teen. There's a good book we read called 'Get out of my life (but first take me and Alex into town)'. Also - TALK to him about it.

I'm really not sure where everyone is getting this 'bullying' thing from - men/boys often rib each other, it doesn't sound like anything really nasty tbh.

DS' behaviour needs nipping in the bud if he is swearing. DH needs to learn to be more sensitive to him now he is getting older and more hormonal.

Marblessolveeverything · 04/10/2023 14:00

Your example is at best immature, and at worst nasty. Why would any adult rile a child? Be he the bio father or not I would be having a serious think about his behaviour as the next few years are about to become a rollercoaster.

I have a teen son and my partner would never intervene in this way. His behaviour provides an excellent male role model - ask you partner is that what he would want to be seen as?

Furryrug · 04/10/2023 13:38

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 13:13

An example...

So me and ds are debating something. I make a point that proves he's wrong (not in a nasty way, just factual). Dh interjects with something like "oh your mums owned you there mate".

Cue ds telling dh to shut up. Angry probably at the fact he's been proven wrong but directing it at dh.

Clearly an unnecessary comment from dh but hardly bullying.

Maybe not bullying but definitely jeering, which isn't nice.

rookiemere · 04/10/2023 13:29

You're right @honeybun24 this could happen with an actual DF as well.

But you just need to tell your DH to back off and have less of the bantz. In the example you gave, there was zero need for him to interject and I can imagine most teens - in fact actually most adults as well - reacting badly to it. DS got it wrong, you pointed it out, he hardly needs a Greek chorus to remind him of his shortcomings at every point.

Beezknees · 04/10/2023 13:28

Tell your dh to stop winding him up.

My stepdad did this to me. I ended up leaving home when I was 17 because it got too much and even now my relationship with my mum is strained. It needs nipping in the bud.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 04/10/2023 13:16

It's only 'banter' and 'teasing' if both parties find it funny. If your partner is constantly 'joking' with your son when he has made clear that he doesn't like it to the point where he eventually snaps. Then it is bullying. You asked what the point would be - the same with any bullying, to feel good about himself, to show who is in charge etc

rantinglunatic · 04/10/2023 13:16

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 13:11

Excellent idea. All families should break up when there are occasional rows. Genius.

yep sorry I got my threads mixed up there!! ignore!

ScarlettSunset · 04/10/2023 13:16

Your DH is winding your son up and provoking the outbursts. I don't see how that can not be deliberate.
I agree with the others, that is bullying and your DS shouldn't be e subjected to that in his own home where he should feel safe and secure. Even if is was 'fun banter' before, it clearly isn't now and that should be the end of it.
If your DH doesn't stop that would suggest he doesn't respect your son or you.

Ffsnotaconference · 04/10/2023 13:15

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 13:03

I created the dynamic? How? By being with dh? Would you say the same if he were ds bio dad? Because I'm sure biological parents argue with their kids too.

I do think dh needs to stop winding up ds up and also demanding respect and perfect behaviour. It's not realistic. And he probably doesn't have the name level of empathy and protectiveness over ds as I do. I would always take my kids side, always.

However it isn't bullying. Bullying is cruel and callous, and targeted. Dh gets it wrong sometimes and he needs to stop. I don't think it's deliberate at all though. What would be the benefit of it?

Your dh behaviour is cruel and callous and targeted.

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 13:13

RedHelenB · 04/10/2023 12:33

Can you give an example?

An example...

So me and ds are debating something. I make a point that proves he's wrong (not in a nasty way, just factual). Dh interjects with something like "oh your mums owned you there mate".

Cue ds telling dh to shut up. Angry probably at the fact he's been proven wrong but directing it at dh.

Clearly an unnecessary comment from dh but hardly bullying.

OP posts:
honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 13:11

rantinglunatic · 04/10/2023 13:04

you need to get rid of your partner unfortunately

Excellent idea. All families should break up when there are occasional rows. Genius.

OP posts:
rantinglunatic · 04/10/2023 13:04

you need to get rid of your partner unfortunately

honeybun24 · 04/10/2023 13:03

rookiemere · 04/10/2023 12:43

You need to sit down calmly with your DH and tell him to stop winding up DS. He may think it's funny and DS needs to toughen up, but teens are notoriously thin skinned and prone to angry outbursts due to being unable to control all their new hormones and emotions.

Be very specific about the behaviour you don't want to see.

Also you don't get to be neutral Switzerland in this. You created this dynamic so you need to stand up for your DS. Teens are horrible creatures but they need to know they are always loved.

I created the dynamic? How? By being with dh? Would you say the same if he were ds bio dad? Because I'm sure biological parents argue with their kids too.

I do think dh needs to stop winding up ds up and also demanding respect and perfect behaviour. It's not realistic. And he probably doesn't have the name level of empathy and protectiveness over ds as I do. I would always take my kids side, always.

However it isn't bullying. Bullying is cruel and callous, and targeted. Dh gets it wrong sometimes and he needs to stop. I don't think it's deliberate at all though. What would be the benefit of it?

OP posts:
rookiemere · 04/10/2023 12:43

You need to sit down calmly with your DH and tell him to stop winding up DS. He may think it's funny and DS needs to toughen up, but teens are notoriously thin skinned and prone to angry outbursts due to being unable to control all their new hormones and emotions.

Be very specific about the behaviour you don't want to see.

Also you don't get to be neutral Switzerland in this. You created this dynamic so you need to stand up for your DS. Teens are horrible creatures but they need to know they are always loved.

Ffsnotaconference · 04/10/2023 12:41

The sad thing is if it did get to the point where we had to separate ds would be gutted. This man has been in his life since he was 5, it's not some random new boyfriend. I would lose a good husband and our shared dc would have all the upheaval too.

and yet your husband Simple’s can’t help behaving in the way that he does.

MrsSkylerWhite · 04/10/2023 12:40

Why does an adult feel the need to wind a child up? Banter? Oh, please.

he needs to grow up and treat your son with respect. Maybe he’ll get some back, then.

Swipe left for the next trending thread