Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 5 year old injured a child

384 replies

Soworriedtoday · 04/10/2023 09:28

Posting for traffic. Name changed. Feeling sick.

My 5 year has injured another child at school. Other child has required urgent hospital treatment and is requiring ongoing treatment.

I don't know who the other child is and I imagine that the last thing the parents want is anything to do with us.

I don't know what to do. What am I supposed to do? My child "lashed out". We are a caring family, lots of opportunities, not exposed to anything like violence or substance, travel around the world.

What do I do? Will anything happen to my child?

OP posts:
Rachie1973 · 04/10/2023 22:51

Omg the angst.

Hes 5! He has no history of aggression and the school seem unperturbed.

Yes, issue the apology, if only to teach about empathy.

Then let it go!

Roseinbloom20 · 04/10/2023 22:40

When I was about 9, me and my school friend were playing in the street together (it was the 90s) and I was pulling her along on her rollerblades and she fell and actually broke her arm. I remember her falling and then rolling home holding her arm and then later being told that she actually had broken her arm, I felt sick with worry about being told off but it was a genuine accident (she confirmed it) and apart from her having a cast for a while nothing came of it - as in I didn't get in trouble! Sometimes accidents happen - depending on the circumstances of course! But still if your child has caused harm, intentionally or not then it's natural to feel bad. Aged 5 I can't imagine it was intentional thought.

autiebooklover · 04/10/2023 22:35

TizerorFizz · 04/10/2023 19:21

@Soworriedtoday The school must investigate this accident in terms of an injury to a child and health and safety. If your DC had been violent they WOULD have been excluded. Your Dc hasn’t been, so from that, it’s hard to draw the conclusion that your DC was violent. It’s difficult to apportion blame at this stage too.

I would leave the school to investigate but you can ask them what happened. Other dc should have been asked for their observations. An adult might have seen what happened. The school
meeds to piece it together.

I can see this has shocked you but I think you might need to consider how you parent for a bit. Your DC took part in play of some description that’s injured a child but we don’t know if it was of his free will or if he was coerced. Whatever it was, he didn’t see anything wrong in the play. He didn’t have antennae about staying with his own age group. Talking about issues and reasoning with Dc doesn’t always equip them for the scenario he found himself in. What was his reaction afterwards? You are upset, but what about him? I think learning when to walk away is now very important. Make it clear what he needs to do and don’t explain in great detail.

The other issue for the school is why an older child is playing with a younger one. Was the other dc KS2? I’m assuming yours is Y1 or even YR? Many schools separate KS2 from KS1. They immediately stop any rough play. Football is not desirable with 5 year olds and 9 year olds mixing for example. Size and ability matter. So you do need to find out what happened and why Dc of very different age groups were playing. It is highly likely to be an accident. I’m not sure how anyone knows it’s your DCs fault and you don’t know what happened because the school hasn’t been clear. Ask for facts and agree a play strategy. Don’t rush to apportion blame.

Excellent advice here

autiebooklover · 04/10/2023 22:33

This sounds like an accident, don't beat yourself up. It's also highly likely it was initiated by the older child (or at least should have been stopped by the older child) School won't tell you who it is, you will only find out if another child or parent knows, or if the child parents confront you. If you do find out I would buy an age appropriate toy and do a apology card.

Make sure your child is ok it will have been scary seeing another child hurt like that.

OnceUponATimeInChristmasTime · 04/10/2023 20:40

If there were any concerns, you would have been told. Even at 5 years old, the staff would have called/ spoken to you and would certainly have said something to the child, even if it's missing 5 minutes of break time or similar.
I understand the stress and guilt you are feeling but you need to be careful not to make this into something it's not.

TizerorFizz · 04/10/2023 19:23

The school should talk to Dc as part of the investigation. They need to know if it was rough play, equipment at fault, coercion, lack of supervision etc.

TizerorFizz · 04/10/2023 19:21

@Soworriedtoday The school must investigate this accident in terms of an injury to a child and health and safety. If your DC had been violent they WOULD have been excluded. Your Dc hasn’t been, so from that, it’s hard to draw the conclusion that your DC was violent. It’s difficult to apportion blame at this stage too.

I would leave the school to investigate but you can ask them what happened. Other dc should have been asked for their observations. An adult might have seen what happened. The school
meeds to piece it together.

I can see this has shocked you but I think you might need to consider how you parent for a bit. Your DC took part in play of some description that’s injured a child but we don’t know if it was of his free will or if he was coerced. Whatever it was, he didn’t see anything wrong in the play. He didn’t have antennae about staying with his own age group. Talking about issues and reasoning with Dc doesn’t always equip them for the scenario he found himself in. What was his reaction afterwards? You are upset, but what about him? I think learning when to walk away is now very important. Make it clear what he needs to do and don’t explain in great detail.

The other issue for the school is why an older child is playing with a younger one. Was the other dc KS2? I’m assuming yours is Y1 or even YR? Many schools separate KS2 from KS1. They immediately stop any rough play. Football is not desirable with 5 year olds and 9 year olds mixing for example. Size and ability matter. So you do need to find out what happened and why Dc of very different age groups were playing. It is highly likely to be an accident. I’m not sure how anyone knows it’s your DCs fault and you don’t know what happened because the school hasn’t been clear. Ask for facts and agree a play strategy. Don’t rush to apportion blame.

Lovemusic82 · 04/10/2023 19:11

I think you (and a few others on here) are overthinking this. Have a meeting with the school and get the full details, talk to your DS for his side of the story.

When I was 7 I hit an older child in the face with a rock (from a sling shot). I didn’t grow up to be a criminal 😉

ThreeLocusts · 04/10/2023 19:02

Gosh OP you're getting quite a kicking from some while you sound shocked and concerned.

I think the only thing that is clear at this stage is that you need to know more. A lot more. You need a meeting with school.

And remember that no, this does not mean your DC is at the beginning of a life of crime. Once you know more you can work out what kind of response/intervention is required.

It's an awful situation, but you'll get through.

mandlerparr · 04/10/2023 19:02

If your child was not punished and they aren't giving you more information besides your child being involved, it is most certain that whatever violence was occurring was on the side of the other child and their actions led to their injury.
I can see no reason for them not to explain how your child was involved beyond protecting the other family from your ire if you find out what really happened or protecting the school from your ire when you find out they weren't watching or that the older child has a history of bullying or something.
And multiple visits could just mean getting stitches put in and then later removed.
Schools are pretty low tolerance for violence and have been known to suspend or expel the victims who never even raised their hands in defense. And they didn't even punish your son at all.
I get concern, but I don't think that your son exhibited any untoward violence based on the information given.
frankly, the kid could have been coming up behind your son to kick him in the ass, missed, fell backwards, hit his or her head and since your son was the potential victim, but never touched, they don't want to say more.
They would have to give you details if your son touched someone or someone touched him.

Livelovebehappy · 04/10/2023 18:57

’Much older’ does sound like the other child may be 8, 9, 10? I would expect (hope) that if it took place during play time, that there was adequate supervision outside. It could be that the older child was instigating something which provoked some sort of knee jerk, defensive action from your dc. Don’t automatically think your child is 100% to blame for the older child’s injury. It all depends on the context of what the altercation was about. Try not to worry, and wait for the discussion with the head teacher etc before reaching out to the parents of the other child. I wouldn’t be making any judgement on the situation yet, until you’re in receipt of all the facts.

Gillypie23 · 04/10/2023 18:44

Hard to say not given a lot of details. How badly injured is the child. Who's your kid rambo!

JoinInBetty · 04/10/2023 18:33

It doesn't matter what life your child has they will still know how to hurt someone.

if it were my child they'd be consequences.

the school will deal with it as a school and as a parent you should to.

YouJustDoYou · 04/10/2023 18:18

My ds age 10 snapped after years of bullying and punched a kid back in the face (after being kicked and punched and verbally abused on the floor), but even that wasn't enough to warrant extended medical check ups for the other kid. This is crazy that a 5 year old could do THAT kind of damage that warrants that?

Ireallydontwantto · 04/10/2023 18:14

Soworriedtoday · 04/10/2023 13:51

School did not say anything the day the incident occurred. My DC also didn't say anything.

I've been informed only this morning in a 10 mins conversation. I spoke to my own DC only briefly as it was register time.

I only know this much:

other child is much older
injury required hospital visit and repeat visits
my child has not been punished

I am shocked and sad that a child has been injured. I feel guilty that my own child has been involved with this.

I have requested a meeting with school to find out more.

My child has never hurt anyone before, very caring with pets.

Sounds like an accident then?
logically from what you’ve described that has to be what’s happened??
presumably if it was severe and intentional they’d have to put something in place at least in the short term incase it happened again to another child??

We were at a kids soft play area in the toddler section at Cheltenham racecourse.
A group of us all stood right next to it but talking (not eyes directly on little ones)

I go to the toilet, when I got back everyone looked really stressed. My 3 yo ds had bitten a boy on the knee I was mortified! This was the first (and only) time he’s bitten someone.
I took him out of the soft play (husband was like a rabbit in headlights) and told him that was not ok we don’t bite he’s really hurt someone and he was no longer aloud to play in the soft play we’d go and do something else.
I picked up ds and found the family of the boy who had been bitten. The boy looked about 10 years old. The Family went mental at us swearing just going wild said they didn’t want apology that we should leave because his mum would give me a good hiding! This was the boys grandad shouting as us whilst I’d got ds in my arms.

Once things calmed down the family moved on, another lady came over and explained what had happened.
The older boy had been pushing my ds by his head under the balls in the ball pit. As soon as my ds popped back up he pushed and held him down. The lady thought they were brothers. I was in the loo husband chatting had no idea this was happening. The lady said my son bit the boy whilst being held under the balls.
I feel like that was self defence (or just blind rage!) however we still reinforced With our ds not to bite but we understood he must of been scared. We should of been watching we were at fault.
You need to find out the full story. The fact the other boy is much older is fishy to me why was an older boy playing rough with a little boy??

SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 04/10/2023 18:04

Crumpleton · 04/10/2023 17:34

But you don't make much sense tbh, did he play, violently played, lashed out or attacked the other kid? Because you have said all of those things...

TBF it sounds like the OP has been told very little of what happened in the incident themselves and is just thinking all types of scenarios.

That is such an over reaction?

Sure enough the first thing you do is ask to see the HT when you are told or call during the day to find out what happened.

My first reaction would be "it was an accident while playing", not "why did he violently lash out, I took him on holidays?".

I'm confused.

Annasoror · 04/10/2023 17:58

I too think you're catastrophising. This is very understandable and it must be very upsetting for you, but it's likely that this was a bad accident. I broke someone's nose once when I was about 10 by spinning round and catching her in the face with my elbow. I was heedless and careless but not deliberately violent. You've had some extremely unhelpful responses on here, which will be making you feel worse as well, I expect.

Mumofsend · 04/10/2023 17:56

Soworriedtoday · 04/10/2023 13:51

School did not say anything the day the incident occurred. My DC also didn't say anything.

I've been informed only this morning in a 10 mins conversation. I spoke to my own DC only briefly as it was register time.

I only know this much:

other child is much older
injury required hospital visit and repeat visits
my child has not been punished

I am shocked and sad that a child has been injured. I feel guilty that my own child has been involved with this.

I have requested a meeting with school to find out more.

My child has never hurt anyone before, very caring with pets.

Their response very clearly indicates they have seen it as an accident.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 04/10/2023 17:47

I once broke a classmates wrist. He was calling me names, I pushed him, he fell backwards and broke his wrist. I was twice your sons age and still didn’t get punished for it, it was an accident. Your son is so young, it is okay for children to lash out, I assume he didn’t mean to seriously hurt this child, even if he did he is too young to really be able to understand the consequences of his actions.

Do you know what the injury is? The way the school have described it as needing urgent and ongoing treatment sounds bad, but a broken bone would require urgent hospital treatment and some ongoing treatment in terms of having the cast removed etc. It doesn’t mean it is a catastrophic injury!

I wouldn’t be panicking or feeling awful about it until you know the actual facts around the incident.

Crumpleton · 04/10/2023 17:34

But you don't make much sense tbh, did he play, violently played, lashed out or attacked the other kid? Because you have said all of those things...

TBF it sounds like the OP has been told very little of what happened in the incident themselves and is just thinking all types of scenarios.

Crumpleton · 04/10/2023 17:31

I was a HoD in a secondary school. Our boys were playing something called 'snips'. One stood with his hand together as in prayer and the other would slap his hands as hard as he could.

Oh gosh, we used to play that along with red rover/British bulldog, and a game where you'd gather on the end of a line of playmates and all 'fling' the last one off as fast/far as you could...

Was talking to someone recently about things we did growing up/in the work place, nothing violent or vandalism and how we got to this age (60's) we all decide it was pure luck.

SurpriseItsMeHorseyNeighNeigh · 04/10/2023 17:13

Soworriedtoday · 04/10/2023 11:03

I am in shock, trust me. We are gentle parents, lots of positive reinforcement.

i'll wait to hear back from school.

I am probably get flamed for saying this, but the children of gentle parents who only do positove reinforcement (and think they are better because their little cherub travels the world) are always the roughest/badest behaved to all the playgroups I have been (and I have been to a lot in the last 12 years) and at school.

But you don't make much sense tbh, did he play, violently played, lashed out or attacked the other kid? Because you have said all of those things...

WearyAuldWumman · 04/10/2023 17:13

Agree with everything that Swg said.

I was a HoD in a secondary school. Our boys were playing something called 'snips'. One stood with his hand together as in prayer and the other would slap his hands as hard as he could.

Boys were coming in from break unable to hold pencils.

Another time, they were stomping on one another's hands...

Bleuuuughhh · 04/10/2023 17:04

I pushed my cousin through a plate glass door, after he stuffed my Teddy Ruxspin down the toilet. Neither of us grew up to be serial killers.

grassverge · 04/10/2023 16:51

When my autistic child was four he pushed a child off the play equipment and the child was badly hurt. I was mortified. The child’s parents approached me in the playground and I apologised to them. The said they were going to sue me and the school. Lunatics. Nothing happened.