Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 5 year old injured a child

384 replies

Soworriedtoday · 04/10/2023 09:28

Posting for traffic. Name changed. Feeling sick.

My 5 year has injured another child at school. Other child has required urgent hospital treatment and is requiring ongoing treatment.

I don't know who the other child is and I imagine that the last thing the parents want is anything to do with us.

I don't know what to do. What am I supposed to do? My child "lashed out". We are a caring family, lots of opportunities, not exposed to anything like violence or substance, travel around the world.

What do I do? Will anything happen to my child?

OP posts:
HuckleberryJam · 06/10/2023 10:05

Sounds like self defence. Your ds couldn't have got away as he was surrounded. He felt threatened and tried to protect himself poor lad. No need to feel guilty any more.

HotApplePiePunch · 06/10/2023 09:41

Leftlegwest · 06/10/2023 07:32

This is concerning about the behaviour of the other children. It doesn't seem typical to me for a group of 9 year olds to surround and taunt a 5 year old.

Is your child year R or year 1?

This - in both primaries my DC went to reception kids were not with older children anyway - on different playgrounds and there was adult supervision and a crowd would attract attention.

First school has ethos of looking our for each other and being kind which did seem to work and second rougher one even there older kids would look our for younger ones even standing up to few bullies there were when they'd normally avoid.

It doesn't say good things about this school IMO.

saraclara · 06/10/2023 09:30

The school has not punished your boy, and don't want you to. That speaks volumes to me about what happened.

I would be concerned for your child, not for the boy he injured, and I'm glad that the school is handling it so sensitively.

Saschka · 06/10/2023 09:23

JustAMinutePleass · 06/10/2023 09:01

Girls who hit aren’t treated in the same way as boys who do. Teachers would always deliver harsher punishments to me (despite my being provoked) as I’d hit my bullies. Whereas with boys they were told to shake hands and it’d be sorted. There is such an inherent sexism on the playground and it doesn’t get much better in girls schools.

It can go either way - I never got into trouble for hitting boys (who were bullying me) partly because I was a goody two shoes aside from that, but the boys were also explicitly shamed by the rest of the class for “crying because a little girl kicked your arse”.

Boys hitting other boys was seen as far more serious (which, in terms of potential injury, it is).

Fuckthatguy · 06/10/2023 09:22

Alway are* and I mean always are excuses

Fuckthatguy · 06/10/2023 09:06

So there were have it, another school allowing behavioural policy failures resulting in a physical escalation.

9 year old has hopefully learned a lesson here because god know what he will do next.

To the poster saying the 5 year old should have walked away and found a teacher, please, the 5 year old was so scared he instinctively defending himself physically. That I’m even having to explain that shows no understanding of bullying.

The 9 year old should be apologising as should the other children crowding round a 5 year in order to deliberately intimidate him.

Feral behaviour and no doubt these children will end up delinquents unless there is early intervention. Whatever that even means at this point.

I’ll wait for the excuses and justifications for this sort of behaviour of course. There are are by some.

OP I’d be concerned this is an ongoing issue, so talk to your son, although he may be reluctant.

JustAMinutePleass · 06/10/2023 09:01

Puffinsandcreeks · 06/10/2023 08:44

*FFS! Gentle parenting but a Dc can whack someone? It’s utter rubbish!

Please teach children to find an adult and walk away. Recognise and leave a boiling up situation if they possibly can. I would say that the op’s child couldn’t do this and certainly isn’t to blame at 5. However if a Dc is upset, find an adult. The school doesn’t have to share which Dc were involved. They should be dealing with them via their bullying snd behaviour policy too. As a parent, I’d leave it there.*

We are known as the weirdo parents in our circles because of the amount of respectful communication we encourage. We don't do time outs, don't shout, have conversations about our feelings and work through them. Allow our children to hold their boundaries and respect their feelings. We are the only people we know who parent this way.
However.
As a child I was bullied from age 6 until about age 13. Talking to teachers did absolutely nothing, they didn't care, I have terrible self esteem issues as an adult because of what went on in the playground. I ALWAYS went to look for a teacher. One time the police were called in to school because of something that occurred on the playground, that in adults would have seen the offending adult arrested for sexual assault. The other child received one on one counselling because of their actions. I got fuck all support at school and this child was not removed from my class or group play sessions as they ABSOLUTELY should have been. What did I do in this situation? Tell a teacher.

Somebody tried to pick on my DH once when he was in primary and wouldn't back off, provoked him, so he hit them. They didn't do it again and in to secondary, it was remembered that he wasn't somebody to target. School didn't care and said he was provoked by the other child.
Guess who is more well rounded as an adult? I've had to reparent myself completely.

I don't encourage violence AT ALL but I do encourage kids standing up for themselves, and if a 5 year old was being surrounded by a group of 9 year olds taunting them (how scary?!) Would I be annoyed for the 5 year old doing what they did? No. It's self defence, and some would argue that self defence is a reasonable time to lash out.

It sounds like the school acknowledges poor supervision in the playground, this shouldn't have even been allowed to happen and that is where the blame lies. Not with the children.

Girls who hit aren’t treated in the same way as boys who do. Teachers would always deliver harsher punishments to me (despite my being provoked) as I’d hit my bullies. Whereas with boys they were told to shake hands and it’d be sorted. There is such an inherent sexism on the playground and it doesn’t get much better in girls schools.

JustAMinutePleass · 06/10/2023 08:54

Soworriedtoday · 06/10/2023 06:41

Thank you to everyone who has commented. I am over the initial shock. I am still very sorry for the other child because no one should get hurt. However I have now spoken to my own child and the school.

My child is a normal sized 5 year old. My child does not know the name of the other child. I have found out through school that other child is 9 years old, but nothing more in terms of name etc.

On the day of the incident, my child was upset in the playground about something unrelated and got teary. A group of 9 year olds surrounded my child. There was a lot of name calling and taunting.

My child got more and more upset. The ring leader got in his face and my child lashed out, and injured the other child. I'm not excusing my child's behaviour but I now have some context.

School has investigated. I was informed. School is not punishing my child. School have asked me not to carry out punishment at home about something which happened at school. They have a great pastoral care and my child is spending some class time (not lunch time) with the person who does role play and talks about emotions.

I am teaching my child to walk away from situations like this, but in this case my child was surrounded by a group. I can only imagine how threatened my child must have felt.

It seemed like it was well deserved then.

I’ve had similar situations with my 3 yo. He’s the biggest in the class, the most developed socially and in terms of communications, and hates unkind behaviour. Latest one - he was hit by older kids (they play with Reception) for protecting his friends & went crazy. Took on 3 boys at once and had to be lifted off them. The PE teacher who intervened has recommended a sport to channel his emotions - they want to put him in year 1 rugby and hockey after he turns 4.

Puffinsandcreeks · 06/10/2023 08:44

*FFS! Gentle parenting but a Dc can whack someone? It’s utter rubbish!

Please teach children to find an adult and walk away. Recognise and leave a boiling up situation if they possibly can. I would say that the op’s child couldn’t do this and certainly isn’t to blame at 5. However if a Dc is upset, find an adult. The school doesn’t have to share which Dc were involved. They should be dealing with them via their bullying snd behaviour policy too. As a parent, I’d leave it there.*

We are known as the weirdo parents in our circles because of the amount of respectful communication we encourage. We don't do time outs, don't shout, have conversations about our feelings and work through them. Allow our children to hold their boundaries and respect their feelings. We are the only people we know who parent this way.
However.
As a child I was bullied from age 6 until about age 13. Talking to teachers did absolutely nothing, they didn't care, I have terrible self esteem issues as an adult because of what went on in the playground. I ALWAYS went to look for a teacher. One time the police were called in to school because of something that occurred on the playground, that in adults would have seen the offending adult arrested for sexual assault. The other child received one on one counselling because of their actions. I got fuck all support at school and this child was not removed from my class or group play sessions as they ABSOLUTELY should have been. What did I do in this situation? Tell a teacher.

Somebody tried to pick on my DH once when he was in primary and wouldn't back off, provoked him, so he hit them. They didn't do it again and in to secondary, it was remembered that he wasn't somebody to target. School didn't care and said he was provoked by the other child.
Guess who is more well rounded as an adult? I've had to reparent myself completely.

I don't encourage violence AT ALL but I do encourage kids standing up for themselves, and if a 5 year old was being surrounded by a group of 9 year olds taunting them (how scary?!) Would I be annoyed for the 5 year old doing what they did? No. It's self defence, and some would argue that self defence is a reasonable time to lash out.

It sounds like the school acknowledges poor supervision in the playground, this shouldn't have even been allowed to happen and that is where the blame lies. Not with the children.

Mesoavocado · 06/10/2023 08:32

Sounds like your school is being more reasonable than ours. My child is often picked on and provoked and I always get the call with no context. And context is important especially in this case

try not to worry too much about ongoing issues and support your child which sounds like you are doing

TizerorFizz · 06/10/2023 08:06

FFS! Gentle parenting but a Dc can whack someone? It’s utter rubbish!

Please teach children to find an adult and walk away. Recognise and leave a boiling up situation if they possibly can. I would say that the op’s child couldn’t do this and certainly isn’t to blame at 5. However if a Dc is upset, find an adult. The school doesn’t have to share which Dc were involved. They should be dealing with them via their bullying snd behaviour policy too. As a parent, I’d leave it there.

My big issue is why a school has 9 year olds with access to 5 year olds. The school is partly to blame by allowing older Dc to be around young ones. Even we were separated in the 60s! It’s too trusting and clearly the older Dc should have their own space.

HelpWhatIf · 06/10/2023 07:55

Oh OP I bet your child was so scared! Well deserved to the 9 year old… how awful. Please do not contact their parents to apologise as your child did NOTHING except act in self defence!!

Puffinsandcreeks · 06/10/2023 07:38

From your update OP it sounds like the other children were completely provoking your DS who acted in self defence.

We do not promote violence in this household at all and gentle parent, but I have no issues telling my child to whack another child if they are bullying them, surrounding them and getting in their face.
I wouldn't take any further action based on what has been said.

Leftlegwest · 06/10/2023 07:32

This is concerning about the behaviour of the other children. It doesn't seem typical to me for a group of 9 year olds to surround and taunt a 5 year old.

Is your child year R or year 1?

JerryGiraffe · 06/10/2023 07:29

OP I'm sorry this has happened and that you have received so many bitchy and self-righteous comments!
My son get a hospital treatable injury form a child in school aged 5. No history of aggression there either, and they were friends. Another child had pushed that child (playing and laughing) so he decided to involve mine and pushed him. Unfortunately mine fell forward and headbutted a concrete pillar. Cue a&e visit.
Find out what happened and why, then you have a starting point.
Make it clear to the school that you want to work with them to resolve issues
Be prepared ro apologise, it doesn't change what happened but it would have made me feel better at the time.
School might also need to consider whether the children were adequately supervised that the incident happened ed in the first place, and maybe the other child's history. They might have form for inciting incidents?
Good luck

HelpMeGetThrough · 06/10/2023 07:18

School have asked me not to carry out punishment at home about something which happened at school.

Regardless of whether anything at home is required and based on what you've said happened, the 9 year old had it coming, so I wouldn't, I'd be telling the school that I'll be the judge of what happens at home and not them.

Buttons232 · 06/10/2023 06:49

OP this isn’t your child’s fault. It seems like there was a (big) failure on the school’s part to intervene and keep all of those children safe. By the sounds of it they’re aware of that failure and someone, somewhere is likely shitting themselves somewhat! You need to stop questioning your child’s involvement because something has gone quite wrong there, I think. In the wrong circumstances all kids are capable of acting like that xxx

BBQchickensalad · 06/10/2023 06:47

Honestly sounds like it might be a well earned lesson for the 9 year old.

Soworriedtoday · 06/10/2023 06:41

Thank you to everyone who has commented. I am over the initial shock. I am still very sorry for the other child because no one should get hurt. However I have now spoken to my own child and the school.

My child is a normal sized 5 year old. My child does not know the name of the other child. I have found out through school that other child is 9 years old, but nothing more in terms of name etc.

On the day of the incident, my child was upset in the playground about something unrelated and got teary. A group of 9 year olds surrounded my child. There was a lot of name calling and taunting.

My child got more and more upset. The ring leader got in his face and my child lashed out, and injured the other child. I'm not excusing my child's behaviour but I now have some context.

School has investigated. I was informed. School is not punishing my child. School have asked me not to carry out punishment at home about something which happened at school. They have a great pastoral care and my child is spending some class time (not lunch time) with the person who does role play and talks about emotions.

I am teaching my child to walk away from situations like this, but in this case my child was surrounded by a group. I can only imagine how threatened my child must have felt.

OP posts:
NCtooPersonal · 06/10/2023 00:13

You should be supporting your child.

The other child was much bigger. Maybe your child used the minimum force he felt needed in self defence and misjudged it. Maybe he didn’t misjudge. A big child can cause much pain to a small child without big movements, noise or crashes.

Its easy for everyone else to blame your child rather than the hurt child or their own failures. But it’s most unreasonable for you to be doing the same.

BettyBunMaker · 05/10/2023 23:44

If your child wasn't punished the school obviously don't think he was at fault.

Worriedmotheroftwo · 05/10/2023 23:38

OP I'm so sorry. I experienced something similar at nursery and I know how you feel - it is horrendous. You need to establish the facts so I think a meeting with the school is ideal. Take a pen and paper and write everything down.

Ignore those who say it didn't come out of nowhere. My son's did. I was completely blindsided one random day.

What has your son said about it?

T1Dmama · 05/10/2023 23:31

It’s also very possible that your son was playing with the kid when he injured himself but wasn’t actually responsible at all…. My DD’s school had tyres that kids played on. A little girl slipped on them and broke her wrist…. It’s easily done.

T1Dmama · 05/10/2023 23:29

Don’t beat yourself up. My brother pushed someone off a slide at preschool and they broke an arm… he was provoked because they were hogging the slide and wouldn’t go down and he was 3 or 4 and got frustrated ….. my mum cried all the way home !! My brother has never been involved in fights since, is a really gentle guy and has lots of friends, a beautiful wife and 2 lovely children….

I suspect that the older child was encouraging the violent play, maybe teasing your son, gooding him ‘go on hit me, hit me’ kind of stuff … or they were just chasing around the playground and the other kid tripped or your son just nudged him and he fell…. It’s even possible the other kid was being mean to your son, bullying him, and your son just gave him a shove….
‘I’d get your son to write him a little get well soon card and write in it that he’s sorry he got injured and that the play got too rough. And ask school to pass it onto whoever the child is! Then just ask your son to play with kids his own age.
hope you’re ok @Soworriedtoday

BernadetteBigStick · 05/10/2023 23:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.