Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My 5 year old injured a child

384 replies

Soworriedtoday · 04/10/2023 09:28

Posting for traffic. Name changed. Feeling sick.

My 5 year has injured another child at school. Other child has required urgent hospital treatment and is requiring ongoing treatment.

I don't know who the other child is and I imagine that the last thing the parents want is anything to do with us.

I don't know what to do. What am I supposed to do? My child "lashed out". We are a caring family, lots of opportunities, not exposed to anything like violence or substance, travel around the world.

What do I do? Will anything happen to my child?

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 07/10/2023 12:32

Maxus · 07/10/2023 12:07

I have read OPs post. She seems to be concerned about how travelled her kid is. Where is the empathy? Her kid hurt a child so badly they needed hospital care and continued appointments. Yet she is more concerned about herself and how it could affect her kid 😡

The kid that stood in a group taunting an upset 5 year old? That one? Have you read the posts at all really?

saraclara · 07/10/2023 12:28

Maxus · 07/10/2023 12:07

I have read OPs post. She seems to be concerned about how travelled her kid is. Where is the empathy? Her kid hurt a child so badly they needed hospital care and continued appointments. Yet she is more concerned about herself and how it could affect her kid 😡

Maybe you could read her other posts. How she has apologised to the parents via the school (which rightly has not disclosed the name of the other child, so she can't make a more personal apology). You're ignoring how horrified she is that her son has hurt this much older child. You're ignoring how she intended punishing him but the school has asked her not to. And multiple other posts where she has demonstrated empathy and deep concern.

Maxus · 07/10/2023 12:07

I have read OPs post. She seems to be concerned about how travelled her kid is. Where is the empathy? Her kid hurt a child so badly they needed hospital care and continued appointments. Yet she is more concerned about herself and how it could affect her kid 😡

saraclara · 07/10/2023 10:17

Maxus · 07/10/2023 08:47

For a start you can stop making excuses such as my child is well travelled and apologise to the child and parents.

Not only have you not read the thread, you've not even read the OP's posts.

MyNumber1Rule · 07/10/2023 10:10

Maxus · 07/10/2023 08:47

For a start you can stop making excuses such as my child is well travelled and apologise to the child and parents.

Or for a start you could actually read the full thread

Maxus · 07/10/2023 08:47

For a start you can stop making excuses such as my child is well travelled and apologise to the child and parents.

Justhereforthebabynames · 07/10/2023 08:40

I think it is quite odd for a 5 year old to injure another child on purpose so badly they require multiple hospital visits to have a wound redressed. I think it strange that lots of adults think it was a good move as the child may have called him names.

tiggergoesbounce · 06/10/2023 23:05

I am glad you got to the bottom of it.
Pastoral care for your child to talk about emotions when picked on by a group of 9 year olds, ridiculous.
In reality, your DS did the right thing, he felt threatened amd was surrounded so he couldn't get help and made his way out the only way he felt he could. Perfectly fine, ley school follow their policy and tell him he is not in trouble at all.

TizerorFizz · 06/10/2023 22:07

I’m saying it’s best to have antennae and not get near Dc you don’t know and are 4 years older. All schools can separate a single playground. I’m quite sure the DS doesn’t know these Dc but the big question is how did they surround him and why wasn’t he playing with his age group and why didn’t anyone notice?

I share the concerns of @Boomboom22 . The Dc should not have access to each other unsupervised.

m@Soworriedtoday Its a cut. Not great but a playground injury. I would now move on and try to get DS friendly with Dc who might be longer term friends.

Puffinsandcreeks · 06/10/2023 20:54

My earlier comment was to a poster who is a gentle parent but tells Dc to retaliate. I don’t see this as sensible. It means Dc get hurt. It’s best to have antennae and recognise that your own age group is a safer place and to avoid difficult Dc within that cohort.

To make it clear, I haven't told my child to reliate and hurt anyone. We encourage talking and respectful, empathetic communication. But I would say we are in the minority - shouting, belittling, name calling, and even smacking is VERY common in many households. I hear the way other parents speak to their children at drop off and it is unsurprising the children lack emotional intelligence. The world isn't all roses. I fucking wish it was.
If they ever communicate to me that they feel threatened, I will encourage self defense. We used to do karate as self defence as kids. Would this be frowned upon now?
If a 5 year old is being surrounded and scared by a group of 9 year olds, setting aside, what do you suggest that 9 year old does in that exact moment? Kids aren't always able to get away from the antagonists, hence why bullying is a thing. My school bullies were always older than me.

Also, saying children shouldn't play with older children at all is just idealism and it won't be upheld. My DC has 3 older cousins at school. Of course they end up together on the playground. You can't tell a child "you can play with xxx at home but never at school".

LovelyIssues · 06/10/2023 18:39

The school will contact you if it's that severe OP. They're 5 years old, I wouldn't worry too much.

Motnight · 06/10/2023 18:35

Sounds like a great outcome, Op.

Skodacool · 06/10/2023 17:38

BBQchickensalad · 06/10/2023 06:47

Honestly sounds like it might be a well earned lesson for the 9 year old.

This.

Soworriedtoday · 06/10/2023 17:34

I have repeatedly asked my child and they simply do not know older child's name. They say they are not friends or anything.

Older child has suffered a very nasty cut and this will need redressing.

We have 2 playgrounds with age appropriate equipment. The smaller kids are allowed to go on big playground on occasion as "a treat." School have reassured me that this will not happen again.

I have apologised through school to the parents but I won't apologise further.

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 06/10/2023 17:01

Usually playtime is separate even in one form entry schools. But they do a lot of supervised integration in my kids school, so every week when they walk to church the year 6s partner the Yr r's and hold their hands. They go into higher classes to show off a good piece of work, or year 5 and year 6 who are sensible act as play leaders and help supervise on the ks1 playground. I don't think we should send a message that 5 year olds should be scared of or not ever talk to 9 year olds but playtime is not the best medium.
In this case as was clear from the school reaction this was a group of year 5 surrounding and taunting an upset year r which would make me concerned for the general culture of the school. I'd expect most 9 year olds would help an upset 5 year old not bully them!

Dramatic · 06/10/2023 16:51

TizerorFizz · 06/10/2023 08:06

FFS! Gentle parenting but a Dc can whack someone? It’s utter rubbish!

Please teach children to find an adult and walk away. Recognise and leave a boiling up situation if they possibly can. I would say that the op’s child couldn’t do this and certainly isn’t to blame at 5. However if a Dc is upset, find an adult. The school doesn’t have to share which Dc were involved. They should be dealing with them via their bullying snd behaviour policy too. As a parent, I’d leave it there.

My big issue is why a school has 9 year olds with access to 5 year olds. The school is partly to blame by allowing older Dc to be around young ones. Even we were separated in the 60s! It’s too trusting and clearly the older Dc should have their own space.

Plenty of schools only have one playground and years 1-6 all play out in the same playground.

amusedbush · 06/10/2023 16:49

Sounds like a well-deserved lesson from the school of "fuck around and find out" to me.

CowboyJoanna · 06/10/2023 16:35

Soworriedtoday · 06/10/2023 06:41

Thank you to everyone who has commented. I am over the initial shock. I am still very sorry for the other child because no one should get hurt. However I have now spoken to my own child and the school.

My child is a normal sized 5 year old. My child does not know the name of the other child. I have found out through school that other child is 9 years old, but nothing more in terms of name etc.

On the day of the incident, my child was upset in the playground about something unrelated and got teary. A group of 9 year olds surrounded my child. There was a lot of name calling and taunting.

My child got more and more upset. The ring leader got in his face and my child lashed out, and injured the other child. I'm not excusing my child's behaviour but I now have some context.

School has investigated. I was informed. School is not punishing my child. School have asked me not to carry out punishment at home about something which happened at school. They have a great pastoral care and my child is spending some class time (not lunch time) with the person who does role play and talks about emotions.

I am teaching my child to walk away from situations like this, but in this case my child was surrounded by a group. I can only imagine how threatened my child must have felt.

Ok now that I have read the update, I am so so sorry for your initial judgment. I just wish you made this more clear from the getgo rather than shroud us all in mystery.

Very well deserved for the 9-year-old, and kudos to your son for being a tough little cookie!

Fuckthatguy · 06/10/2023 16:30

@TizerorFizz I have been wondering why something had felt off with your responses because overall you have valid points but there it is…why should any child have to avoid anywhere?

Im fairly realistic - we don’t live in Utopia but this narrative is bullshit I’m afraid, nobody should be afraid to go anywhere. Again I understand what you’re trying to say but it’s not right.

Gentle parenting at home is great, but because there is such subversive behaviour outside the home, of course teaching a child to defend themselves is sensible and seems necessary for that poster. Shame gentle parenting isn’t standard - maybe less violence everywhere.

Sallywag134 · 06/10/2023 16:07

My son (now an adult) has ADHD and I was forever called into school due to his impulsive behaviour, but I remember the first time he pushed someone, they stumbled, fell and broke their glasses. He was 5. I asked him how it happened, he told me, we spoke to the parents of the other child, replaced the glasses and put steps in place to ensure this wouldn’t happen again. At 5 years old, your child should be able to tell you at least who it was so you can contact the parents. What exactly has happened that they would need ongoing treatment? Does the child have a cut that will need redressing once in a while? Does the child have a head injury that will need to be operated on? Has the child broken a bone? Ongoing treatment can mean anything, it does not necessarily mean the child is seriously injured. At 5 years old it is unlikely that anything will happen to them, maybe miss a week of playtimes but there won’t be any formal punishment through the courts.

TizerorFizz · 06/10/2023 14:11

Pushed them away probably and they fell. It’s a case where the school must record and report it.

My earlier comment was to a poster who is a gentle parent but tells Dc to retaliate. I don’t see this as sensible. It means Dc get hurt. It’s best to have antennae and recognise that your own age group is a safer place and to avoid difficult Dc within that cohort.

Mikimoto · 06/10/2023 12:21

Still wondering what the 5-yr old did to hospitalise the 9-yr old and warrant their ongoing treatment...

TizerorFizz · 06/10/2023 12:02

For clarity. I didn’t say Dc in this instance could have walked away. I’ve clearly said 5 year olds and 9 year olds should not be together in the playground. The school need to evaluate their playground policy and keep ks1 separate. It’s really not possible for 5 year olds to “discuss “ issues and feelings with 9 year olds so they need another mechanism to avoid them get help. Recognising a threat is the first thing and staying with your own friends always helps. Another child will then get help. This is a failure of playground policy and supervision.

There is now safeguarding. @Puffinsandcreeks Teachers have legal obligations. I don’t recognise all this dreadful behaviour and schools not dealing with it. In this case the school needs to look at how it keeps ALL Dc safe and separates older Dc from younger ones. It has clear obligations to do this. Younger Dc should not have access to older Dc (and vice versa) and all must stay with their own age group usually via separate play areas. The school must reinforce this. It’s pretty standard playground policy for exactly the reasons we have been discussing.

Fuckthatguy · 06/10/2023 10:16

@Puffinsandcreeks reading your post has made me so angry for primary school and teenage you.

There is no excuse for teachers to ignore bullying and they do it because they are too scared (yes, there are unparented children everywhere causing sheer chaos and upset), lazy, inept, insert whatever you want, to put in the work. Similarly most of the state services eg CAHMS or social services are in the same predicament.

I’m truly not interested in the excuses for this either I’m really not because so many people involved with children are not fit to be within a 100 mile radius of them. That is the issue, the calibre of person, yes I’ll hear state funding and the Tory’s and the this and the that, but there are people are are currently in these positions right now and they are doing sweet fuck or at best the bare minimum. Teachers turn a blind eye because to actually give a damn and enforce school policy beyond their pay grade.

Of course this doesn’t apply to all schools or mental health workers but it does apply to too many.

There have been threads of the decline of the UK, teenage knife crime, you name it and it starts here in the formative years, primary school is supposed to be a joy and cultivate a love of learning. Wtf is going on.

ProudMummyOfFour · 06/10/2023 10:15

Please elaborate. What exactly did your DC do, and what exactly are the injuries? You're being quite guarded about the whole thing, which makes it hard to give advice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread