Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Horrible reaction from boyfriend when sharing secret

129 replies

vesur · 04/10/2023 07:03

I know this will be outside the norm for many but I could do with a shoulder to cry on so to speak.

I'm half Indian/half Greek. And was raised to believe that sex before marriage was wrong. My mother essentially groomed me to believe premarital sex is immoral from a very young age. There were never direct conversations on the matter, just tacit understandings.

I feel like an idiot because it seems like I'm the only person who actually ate up the nonsense my mother spouted. Neither of my brother or sister have "kept themselves" for marriage - same with cousins and friends from similar backgrounds. I've really been struggling with this a lot, as a few years ago I had the realisation I'm the only person naive enough to have gone along with my parents wishes and have denied myself so many experiences. I've been in love in the past and been intimate in ways acceptable to me but have never done the actual deed.

Anyway, have a new British-Indian boyfriend and I explained a number of my parents weird world views. I felt comfortable enough to share my experience with my new boyfriend and his reaction really hurt me as I just had not prepped myself for his non-understanding in the ways I have with previous boyfriends. BF said things like "I'm sorry that's weird" etc. I excused myself to the bathroom and just balled. To me he just confirmed my deepest fears. I left without saying goodbye.

I'm a good looking, successful 30 yo with this absurd secret. I just feel so incredibly damaged tbh.

Where do I even go from here?

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 04/10/2023 10:09

I found my DH's comments about my family being weird ultimately quite liberating.

He was right, they are but it took an outsider to actually say it for me to realise just how much my family's views on many things including sex outside of marriage were controlling and narrow minded.

AmazingSnakeHead · 04/10/2023 10:05

I'm wondering if it would help to reframe this situation as you coming to a realisation. Rather than think in terms of "grooming" try and say it yourself that up until this point you thought that sex before marriage was wrong, but now you've changed your mind. As a result you've not had sex yet. There is nothing wrong with that! You are entilted to change your mind. Your parents' views may not be the majority view in the UK in 2023, but they are the views of many many people around the world, and of course some people here as well. They just passed down their views to you. You've now rejected them and replaced them with your own. That's no shameful secret, it's a natural part of growing up.

I think you reacted that way to your BF because you are still processing it yourself.

rolllofthunder · 04/10/2023 09:59

OP being a virgin at 30 is not 'weird', nor is waiting to have sex until you are married. However in mainstream British culture, there is a media fuelled assumption that every young person is out there having multiple partners, having amazing sexual experiences, and if you have not had sex by the time you are 30, there must be something 'wrong'.

Mix those assumptions with the message you internalised in your formative years, that having sex before marriage is sinful and 'wrong' and you have a heady mix of cultural confusion.

I was 37 (nearly 38) before I had sex. There was nothing 'wrong' with me. There just were just not many sexy men in my area (plenty of leery, beer-filled gropers, and lads who needed a mother), and I had huge issues with my MH and self esteem.

When I met my partner, I thought he would find it really strange and off-putting that I was a nearly 40 year old virgin. I also felt he may expect and desire someone who was more sexually experienced. He was surprised but not freaked out, like I thought he would be. As for the experience bit, well everyone is different and unique, so someone could be tremendously experienced but know nothing about what their partner needed, wanted or preferred.

In my opinion, and it is only my opinion, your problems may actually arise not so much from the message you received in your childhood, but more from the messages that abound in this society, that everyone is happily having lots of lovely sex, and if you are not, there is something wrong with you. There is nothing at all 'weird' about not having sex if you have not met someone you want to have sex with.

As others have said, the boyfriend's comments about being weird are a little ambiguous,

millymog11 · 04/10/2023 09:48

OP not read the whole thread but please

  • don't have sex with your boyfriend because he said "that's weird"
  • don't have sex with your boyfriend because you feel now like your mother brainwashed you
  • don't have sex with your boyfriend because your siblings did not save themselves for marriage and now you feel like the odd one out
  • don't have sex with your boyfriend because you think "everyone does it" so I ought to do it too.
All of the above reasons are reasons which ultimately could end up making matters worse for your own processing in your head. Resist these (false) reasons and wait until you are sure you are doing it for yourself and you are doing it with someone who makes you feel safe and loved.
Alopeciabop · 04/10/2023 09:48

It depends how he said it. If it was flippant and laughy/scoffing at it then yes he’s a child. If it was a soft “I’m sorry but that’s weird…” and he was going to go on to be supportive but you ran away then that’s another thing.

the correct response from a gentleman (and they do still exist so keep hunting if you haven’t found one yet) is something along the lines of oh.. well I’m really glad you’ve told me that. And then some active listening.

people can get awkward and say the wrong thing though so you need to be honest with which one it is.

please go to therapy. Could you consider speaking to your sister about this?

you’ll be fine love. And well done on sharing this secret you’ve held. It’s not a secret any more, it’s a part of your upbringing you’re overcoming. No shame at all

Robotalkingrubbish · 04/10/2023 09:46

Some of the comments on here are unbelievable. Showing some kindness doesn’t cost you anything.

@vesur this man is clearly not for you. There’s nothing wrong with you, you sound really lovely. Move on from this man and hold your head up and carry on being the lovely person that you clearly are.

It’s not necessary to have sex with lots of different men before settling down. That doesn’t make you a better person. Some people would say that women who do that don’t respect themselves.

SwearyBetty · 04/10/2023 09:40

Was his ‘I’m sorry that’s weird’ comment to you about never having had sex -he said you’re weird for being a virgin? Or was it towards your parents views?

Panicking23 · 04/10/2023 09:37

Daffodil18 · 04/10/2023 08:19

I was not brought up that way but I admire anyone who believes in no sex before marriage. I don’t think your parents are bad for telling you this. It’s up to you if you want to carry on that way. But a lot of women just get used by men for sex and then dropped. At least you haven’t been through that.

Plenty of woman end up in sexually abusive marriages, particularly in cultures where no sex before marriage is a common belief.
It's more valuable to teach your children there's no shame around sex but it should always be consensual and enjoyable for both parties regardless of if they're in a committed relationship. Whether they choose to wait for commitment or not because that's what they're most comfortable with is entirely up to them and should be without shame.

notlucreziaborgia · 04/10/2023 09:37

IveHadItUpToHere · 04/10/2023 09:32

The fact his gf is crying in the toilet because of his reaction proves the bf doesn't have a healthy or modern view of sex. A healthy view of sex doesn't involve shaming or upsetting your DP when they share private information about their sexual experiences.
Despite the best attempts of certain groups to push a narrative that everyone has lots of sex from a very young age, the statistics actually show the opposite. Most teens are waiting later to have sex. So he doesn't have 'modern' view of sex either.

No, it doesn’t. OP recognises herself that’s she’s got issues around sex, so it doesn’t follow that it’s her boyfriend’s fault she’s upset because he agreed with her that the attitude of her parents was/is weird.

Again, there’s a difference between holding a belief for yourself, and indoctrinating others with it to the point where they’re crippled with shame, guilt, and anxiety. By your own definition that is unhealthy.

Panicking23 · 04/10/2023 09:33

You described the views your parents shared with you as weird yourself, I think this is more about your own insecurity and issues getting your actual views on sex to marry up with what has been drummed into you since childhood.
I think there's a possibility he's been processing the news his partner hasn't had sex too, he's maybe assumed given your age you've had sex and feels a bit weighed down by the responsibility of potentially being your first sexual partner.

IveHadItUpToHere · 04/10/2023 09:32

Spacemoon · 04/10/2023 08:37

You sound very confused.

Do you want to live a more free and fulfilling life? Or do you want to continue to live by your parents outdated 'rules' even though you don't seem to agree with them?

Are you happy your bf has more modern and healthy views on sex, or are you annoyed that he he think it's weird? It sounds like you can't make up your mind to be honest. If you yourself truly found these rules your mother (and now you) have placed on yourself to be unacceptable, you wouldn't be hurt that he expressed an honest opinion about it. I think most young people in this day and age would find it a little odd, even British Indians.

I think you need to have some counselling and work on what you really want and who you are as an individual. It seems like you are still living for your mother, not yourself and it has left you mixed up and confused with what YOU really want and what YOU think is unacceptable.

The fact his gf is crying in the toilet because of his reaction proves the bf doesn't have a healthy or modern view of sex. A healthy view of sex doesn't involve shaming or upsetting your DP when they share private information about their sexual experiences.
Despite the best attempts of certain groups to push a narrative that everyone has lots of sex from a very young age, the statistics actually show the opposite. Most teens are waiting later to have sex. So he doesn't have 'modern' view of sex either.

Defiantjazz · 04/10/2023 09:24

But he didn't call op weird. He just says "that's weird"

Is there a difference ?

BabyofMine · 04/10/2023 09:02

It’s not weird not to have sex before marriage or at least a deeply committed relationship and I think your current view is as closed minded as your parents. Both are too extreme. You’re basically insulting every woman or man who believes in committed monogamous relationships which could be argued have been a societal norm for most of human history. There’s no shame in someone not wanting to sow their wild oats as they say. I was never interested in that.

When I met my partner he had absolutely no problems with it and was completely understanding though it was different from his world view. I think whatever happens someone who makes you cry in the toilet is not the one for you.

notlucreziaborgia · 04/10/2023 08:49

Daffodil18 · 04/10/2023 08:19

I was not brought up that way but I admire anyone who believes in no sex before marriage. I don’t think your parents are bad for telling you this. It’s up to you if you want to carry on that way. But a lot of women just get used by men for sex and then dropped. At least you haven’t been through that.

How are they not bad? They’ve clearly burdened her with such shame, fear and anxiety that it’s crippling her when she tries to decide for herself.

There's a difference between having a belief, and terrorising someone else with it.

OP - it’s hard to say whether he was insensitive or not tbh. You think your parents beliefs are weird, so did you present it to your boyfriend in such a way that ‘yes, I’m sorry that’s weird’ would actually be him trying to empathise with, and validate, you?

CurlewKate · 04/10/2023 08:42

There are plenty of people worldwide who don't believe in pre marital sex. Not as many as there were, obviously-but it's certainly not weird. He sounds like an arse, to be honest!

thiswasabadone · 04/10/2023 08:41

vesur · 04/10/2023 07:09

He's not wrong, I know.

He is wrong though

Everyone has there own beliefs and own moral compass. Yes your mother made you belives sex before marriage is immoral but you yourself haven't lapped up her beliefs you've only listened and followed what you thought was right at the time. Now your views may or may not be changing and that is up to you.

If you believe that it is immoral that's great, if you don't know that's great too.

Your boyfriend clearly is lacking empathy and you have every right to tell him that

Spacemoon · 04/10/2023 08:37

You sound very confused.

Do you want to live a more free and fulfilling life? Or do you want to continue to live by your parents outdated 'rules' even though you don't seem to agree with them?

Are you happy your bf has more modern and healthy views on sex, or are you annoyed that he he think it's weird? It sounds like you can't make up your mind to be honest. If you yourself truly found these rules your mother (and now you) have placed on yourself to be unacceptable, you wouldn't be hurt that he expressed an honest opinion about it. I think most young people in this day and age would find it a little odd, even British Indians.

I think you need to have some counselling and work on what you really want and who you are as an individual. It seems like you are still living for your mother, not yourself and it has left you mixed up and confused with what YOU really want and what YOU think is unacceptable.

SunsetLazyDays · 04/10/2023 08:34

Are the males in your family expected not to have sex before marriage ? Or just the females ?

Because if males can do what they like, there is the dilemma. One rule for males & a different rule for females

Sparrow7 · 04/10/2023 08:28

I think it is forgiveable in the moment. He didn't know what to say, he wasn't expecting this secret and was put on the spot. How he reacts after this is much more important. Did he see you were upset? Did he message you after you left?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 04/10/2023 08:25

Was he saying that your parents views are 'weird'? Or that you living by it even though you don't agree with it logically is 'weird'?

Either way he is wrong and it sounds like a very immature reaction. No sex before marriage like others have said is not weird it's a cultural and generational difference. Not having sex before marriage isn't weird its unusual. Finding it hard to break away from the way that your parents brought you up is completely normal.

If someone disclosed that their parents beliefs had a profound affect on their lives, its just really rude and comes across ad lacking empathy and intelligence to comment that it's weird.

So I don't think yabu. I do think you need counselling though.

kamboozled · 04/10/2023 08:21

Actually my advice here is to NOT give in and have sex with him while he's even thinking this way........

you're not weird at all! And if you have been through so much of your life and not had sex yet, then tbh if you sleep with him then he soon dumps you, you'll feel crushed.
Find someone you really love (and doesn't be a douche in return) and do the deed with him. x

Daffodil18 · 04/10/2023 08:19

I was not brought up that way but I admire anyone who believes in no sex before marriage. I don’t think your parents are bad for telling you this. It’s up to you if you want to carry on that way. But a lot of women just get used by men for sex and then dropped. At least you haven’t been through that.

horseymum · 04/10/2023 08:12

It's not wrong to wait until marriage. Plenty of people do, they just don't shout about it, so it just sounds like noone does. You do need to find someone on the same page as you though (once you've decided what that page is).

OneLittleFinger · 04/10/2023 08:06

I'm white British, but grew up with very similar rules. My mum was devastated when she realised my sister had had premarital sex and that became almost an extra burden for me to carry. Like you, I missed opportunities due to it.

When I was mid-20s I met a bloke much older than me who was a definite Lothario. We loosely became partners and he was willing to take it slowly, with no pressure. He did think it was weird but was kind about it. We stayed together for 15 years and he's still my only, though he doesn't believe it.

Finlesswonder · 04/10/2023 08:02

@passingshipsoccasionally
If 'your body, your choice' applies then this is the decision you made

OP hasn't made any decision about her body, she is carrying around her parents decision about her body which is why she broke down, walked out on her boyfriend and is now posting on here.

You know its not helpful to try and stifle dissenting opinions when an OP has clearly taken steps to start a debate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread