Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a cleaner that will pick my clothes up off the floor?

770 replies

Zamphina · 03/10/2023 22:19

Dp and I work very long hours during the week. We’re out of the house 9-10 minimum. We eat dinner in the office. When we get home we’re exhausted and just want to sleep. So often the kitchen has our breakfast stuff. We’ve left clothes on the floor. There might be sunday’s dishes on the table. The laundry has been left out drying.

We earn an OK salary and have a tiny flat to save money, so a cleaner coming 2-3 times a week for two hours a time won’t be an issue.

But obviously I’m slightly embarrassed for someone to see my home in such a mess. Are there any cleaners who will sort all of this? Pick up the clothes, put them on to wash, load the dishwasher, and clean the bathroom etc?

OP posts:
vapesareforsnakes · 05/10/2023 12:22

You made a ridiculous comparison of valeting your car and going to the dentist and getting your windows washed...they don't compare at all with stepping out of dirty clothes and expecting someone else to pick them up.

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 12:12

vapesareforsnakes · 05/10/2023 12:02

We are not talking about someone hoovering your stairs, we are talking about stepping out of your dirty clothes and throwing them on the floor and expecting someone else to come in and pick them up and wash them. It's the height of ignorance, it's the epitome of laziness and it is not on. Bend down pick up your dirty clothes and underwear and out them in the laundry basket for the cleaner to wash. She's already coming in to yesterdays dinner dishes still on the table and not even in the sink, or on the side. HOW long does it take to put your clothes in a feckin hamper. 2 seconds. No, she wants the cleaner to pick them up where she stood out of them. My 4 year old wouldn't do that.

Actually @Goldenbear was saying that and it was the overarching perspective of 'I'd never have a cleaner' that I was responding to because some people do have that view.

vapesareforsnakes · 05/10/2023 12:04

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:59

Im not saying your life is easy, Im saying it's different. If you came here saying 'I'm exhausted with my workload and at home responsibilities. I know I should eat healthier and exercise more for my health but I just keep defaulting to the take aways and collapsing on the couch. Can I get someone to come into the house and cook for me each week?'. Would you like support and encouragement about how to achieve that or to be told you're lazy and disgusting and hear about all the people who can do all you do and more and home cook every day and work out 3 times a week. I see that as equivalent, because I don't attach a higher moral value to cleaning than any other responsibility that we have as an adult.

Picking up someone's dirty laundry that has been discarded on the floor is not cleaning. It's rude, disrespectful, entitled and lazy.

vapesareforsnakes · 05/10/2023 12:02

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:52

But you're talking about having a cleaner, and in the vast majority of cases what a cleaner is doing is dusting, hoovering, washing floors etc. I personally think it's more disgusting to not floss and expect your dentist to scrape that build up off your teeth than someone hoovering my stairs. The 'picking up dirty knickers' has just entered this conversation as a way to cast even more judgement on the OP I reckon. But we won't convince each other and that's okay.

We are not talking about someone hoovering your stairs, we are talking about stepping out of your dirty clothes and throwing them on the floor and expecting someone else to come in and pick them up and wash them. It's the height of ignorance, it's the epitome of laziness and it is not on. Bend down pick up your dirty clothes and underwear and out them in the laundry basket for the cleaner to wash. She's already coming in to yesterdays dinner dishes still on the table and not even in the sink, or on the side. HOW long does it take to put your clothes in a feckin hamper. 2 seconds. No, she wants the cleaner to pick them up where she stood out of them. My 4 year old wouldn't do that.

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:59

Beezknees · 05/10/2023 11:50

No, but I'm dealing with a child on my own with no support from a partner while working full time. That's just as much work as a 13 hour job.

Im not saying your life is easy, Im saying it's different. If you came here saying 'I'm exhausted with my workload and at home responsibilities. I know I should eat healthier and exercise more for my health but I just keep defaulting to the take aways and collapsing on the couch. Can I get someone to come into the house and cook for me each week?'. Would you like support and encouragement about how to achieve that or to be told you're lazy and disgusting and hear about all the people who can do all you do and more and home cook every day and work out 3 times a week. I see that as equivalent, because I don't attach a higher moral value to cleaning than any other responsibility that we have as an adult.

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:52

Goldenbear · 05/10/2023 11:40

Those jobs aren't the same as picking up someone's pants from the floor. Equally, I clean my own car for this very reason. A Dentist is a medical professional that has had years of training to provide that medical care, how is that the same as cleaning. It doesn't take any training to be able to clean up your own mess. A window cleaner will be using a ladder and that is most likely something many people don't own or it is unsafe to do due to who they are. The dirt on windows is not dirt made by you the person. I find it a bit entitled I suppose to expect someone to pick up and clean up a mess I made, extenuating circumstances being the exception.

But you're talking about having a cleaner, and in the vast majority of cases what a cleaner is doing is dusting, hoovering, washing floors etc. I personally think it's more disgusting to not floss and expect your dentist to scrape that build up off your teeth than someone hoovering my stairs. The 'picking up dirty knickers' has just entered this conversation as a way to cast even more judgement on the OP I reckon. But we won't convince each other and that's okay.

Beezknees · 05/10/2023 11:50

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 09:09

Are you working 13-15 hrs days 5 days a week in an early in career role? Working full time is not the same.

No, but I'm dealing with a child on my own with no support from a partner while working full time. That's just as much work as a 13 hour job.

Branster · 05/10/2023 11:49

I don't understand what is the point of working hard all hours, being at home hardly ever and with zero energy left to function in your own home.
You're better off living in a hotel with a full daily cleaning and laundry on a B&B basis.
Zero stress regarding cleaning, washing, cooking etc.
Rent out your current residence and stay in a hotel until work schedules settle down.

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 11:49

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:35

Where did the OP say she wanted someone to pick dirty knickers off the floor? She said clothes - you are making quite the leap.

Like I just said to another poster. If OP specifically wants to pay someone to pick up their clothes off the floor, that's going to include underwear.

Unless OP is saying she can manage to pick up underwear to put in a basket but not other clothes at the same time? Which makes no sense at all. If she's already there picking up underwear from the floor and can put her knickers in a basket she can pick up the other clothes as it doesn't take additional time.

It's not 'a leap' at all. If someone claims they need to pay someone to pick up their clothes from the floor because they're just too tired or lazy, its going to include underwear.

milkywinterdisorder · 05/10/2023 11:48

@LolaSmiles But there’s a huge difference between thinking “I’ll just leave that for someone else to do” and asking “would it be possible to pay someone to do that for me”, isn’t there?

I guess I just can’t see why wanting to pay someone to do something you don’t want to do makes you inherently lazy, regardless of what that thing is. I can’t understand why we outsource some things and no-one bats an eyelid but we ask whether it’s possible to outsource something else and suddenly we’re lazy and entitled and have no respect for other people?

vapesareforsnakes · 05/10/2023 11:46

No, just no. Slovenly, dirty and totally unreasonable to expect someone to come into your house and pick up your dirty clothes that you step out off and throw on the floor. Takes 2 seconds to put them in a laundry hamper. No excuse under the sun to justify that level of laziness. I'd expect more from a toddler.

Goldenbear · 05/10/2023 11:43

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:35

Where did the OP say she wanted someone to pick dirty knickers off the floor? She said clothes - you are making quite the leap.

It's not really a leap, underwear is clothing , some dirty socks stuck at the bottom of trousers that have been chucked on tje floor - not exactly a leap.

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 11:41

ladykale · 05/10/2023 10:58

So do I have to make sure I load the dishwasher before work, before my cleaner comes, just because it's lazy not to have rinsed and put it in the dishwasher?

People are turning the debate into leaving dirty undies on the floor, which is a bit gross, but taking clothes off and leaving them on a chair in your room, which a cleaner subsequently puts in the laundry or folds, is part of why most people hire a cleaner,

No wonder it is so hard to hire a decent cleaner, when so many in this thread seem to think many elements of basic tidying are "demeaning" and above what a cleaner should be asked to do!

The thread title is literally 'Am I unreasonable to want a cleaner to pick my clothes up off the floor?'.

Not 'Am I unreasonable to leave my clothes on a chair for a cleaner to fold or launder'.

So that's why so many people were commenting on the OP wanting to pay someone to pick up their dirty clothes, including dirty knickers from the floor.

Because if the OP could manage to pick up their knickers and put them in a basket, they could pick up the rest of the clothes at the same time. So obviously, 'pick up my clothes off the floor' includes dirty knickers and pants of the DP.

That's why people are talking about underwear.

Goldenbear · 05/10/2023 11:40

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:29

I find this perspective so interesting. Do you apply it to everything, e.g. you wouldn't dream of going to the dentist to get your teeth cleaned because you should be flossing religiously every day? Or get your car valeted because you should be cleaning it yourself? Or get the windows washed because you should do it yourself? There's a value judgement applied to cleaning that is not applied to other jobs.

Those jobs aren't the same as picking up someone's pants from the floor. Equally, I clean my own car for this very reason. A Dentist is a medical professional that has had years of training to provide that medical care, how is that the same as cleaning. It doesn't take any training to be able to clean up your own mess. A window cleaner will be using a ladder and that is most likely something many people don't own or it is unsafe to do due to who they are. The dirt on windows is not dirt made by you the person. I find it a bit entitled I suppose to expect someone to pick up and clean up a mess I made, extenuating circumstances being the exception.

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:35

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 11:30

Working long hours doesn't mean someone can't be lazy. It just means they work long hours.

That's it.

You can be lazy in different areas of your life and not lazy in others. It's not a blanket statement about someone's life or character.

I just had a coffee and pastry delivered to me because I was too lazy to go to the shop 10 mins away. I'm not lazy at work because that's the job I get paid to do.

But I've never been so lazy that I'd be wanting to pay someone to pick up my dirty knickers off the floor because I do have some self-respect and respect for other people that I may employ.

Where did the OP say she wanted someone to pick dirty knickers off the floor? She said clothes - you are making quite the leap.

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 11:30

Comtesse · 05/10/2023 10:57

OP is not lazy - she and her partner are busting their butts working hard, working long long hours. Clothes in the laundry bin would make sense, but when I’m working 16 hours a day everything goes to pot. And that’s fair enough. No judgement here.

Working long hours doesn't mean someone can't be lazy. It just means they work long hours.

That's it.

You can be lazy in different areas of your life and not lazy in others. It's not a blanket statement about someone's life or character.

I just had a coffee and pastry delivered to me because I was too lazy to go to the shop 10 mins away. I'm not lazy at work because that's the job I get paid to do.

But I've never been so lazy that I'd be wanting to pay someone to pick up my dirty knickers off the floor because I do have some self-respect and respect for other people that I may employ.

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:29

Goldenbear · 05/10/2023 11:06

I'm not sure about 'better person' as that's contextual but I think morally it is correct to clean up your own mess - you made it why should others be your scivvy. I don't and won't employ a cleaner for this reason even though DH is keen. I think our DC should learn this lesson as well. Particularly as one is a 16 year old DS and he feels the same as me.

I find this perspective so interesting. Do you apply it to everything, e.g. you wouldn't dream of going to the dentist to get your teeth cleaned because you should be flossing religiously every day? Or get your car valeted because you should be cleaning it yourself? Or get the windows washed because you should do it yourself? There's a value judgement applied to cleaning that is not applied to other jobs.

LumiB · 05/10/2023 11:27

You're not exhausted in the morning though? You're not that exhausted to have laundry baskets next to where you keep dropping your clothes on the floor so even at night if you still can't pick them up off the floor and sling in it in the basket right next to it, you can in the morning. Im sorry its just sheer laziness you don't have 2 seconds to do that

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:25

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 09:24

Why are you acting like putting clothes in a wash basket, putting dishes in the dishwasher and picking up after oneself are complicated erroneous tasks so it's completely understandable that OP doesn't bother?

They're really easy, simple things that take very little time for the combined effort of 2 adults to do.

They'll still have time to do everything else they want to do. Taking 5 seconds to walk to a basket and put the clothes in then every few days walk to the washing machine and take 30 seconds to put the clothes in and switch it on shouldn't be a struggle. It's not like they have to wash it in a tub with a stick then put it through a mangle.

Especially easy between two of them.

Because the OP is exhausted and asked for help. I'm trying to counter the personalised attacks and the 'just do the thing' responses that she's clearly struggling to do. I can empathise with the OP, I had a similar overwhelm when I started work and I wasn't a lazy spoiled brat.

Taketurn · 05/10/2023 11:23

Comtesse · 05/10/2023 10:59

Plenty of MN posters are married to men who leave their clothes on the floor - and don’t work 14 hour days! It’s hardly a catastrophic character failing!

Ha 😂

Resentful2023 · 05/10/2023 11:22

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 09:14

No it's not you're right.

A full-time working lone parent has a tonne more to do and numerous more responsibilities and things to organise and do than a childless couple working long days 5 days a week.

And doesn't get weekends off from any of that.

I'm not saying your life is easy, I'm saying it's different. And it doesn't help the OP by saying 'well I can do x,y,z'. None of us know how difficult each other's life is, or what coping skills we bring into it. Some people had to learn the hard way but that doesn't mean we have to be so hard on those who didn't.

CharlotteRumpling · 05/10/2023 11:12

I didn't know floordrobe was a word! Must be less hard on DD who definitely has one going.

saffy2 · 05/10/2023 11:07

Why does the term floordrobe exist if it’s not a thing that people do…
I can’t believe this thread. People should be ashamed of themselves. It’s not a competition, people finding things hard for whatever reason shouldn’t be told ‘well I did it/do it/could so it so why can’t you’
rhere is a thread currently about the worst pain you’ve ever experienced, I read it and nearly all of the posts are childbirth. For me childbirth is a breeze, I enjoy it…but it’s not about me and my experience it’s about what other people are experiencing and feeling. My worst pain wasn’t childbirth, that doesn’t mean someone else’s can’t be childbirth. This is the same, you find it easy, good on you, don’t pick on people who don’t find it easy and don’t make out like she’s the only one who is finding it hard!!! Literally there is books/magazines/podcasts/blogs/apps/tv shows out there SOLELY to help with this kind of issue. It’s a huge industry. BECAUSE OP IS NOT THE ONLY ONE IN THE WORLD WHO STRUGGLES TO KEEP HER HOUSE IN ORDER.
stop bigging yourselves up and leave her alone. You should all be ashamed of yourselves.

drspouse · 05/10/2023 11:07

I am one of the few people who voted YANBU because we have a great cleaner who picks up the DCs Lego/tidies the sofa/does the dishes. We made sure she was OK with this.
We don't work such long hours but we have two DC and one has SEN so often things don't get done.
But the "closing shift" idea (probably similar to the Evening Clean) has helped me a lot - the things that get done before going to bed. For us, it's put the dishwasher on (even if not full), dirty washing in basket (that's not that hard!), hang up any towels the DCs haven't done, make sure landing/hallway are clear (may mean putting things in side rooms/on top of things) for those stumbling to the loo in the middle of the night.

Goldenbear · 05/10/2023 11:06

Mourningmorningsleep · 05/10/2023 10:16

People are being over the top judgy here. Contact some housekeepers/cleaners, explain the job honestly, they might say yes they might say no. Independent ones can make their own rules about the service they offer. Make sure to put your own knickers in the laundry basket (though it's weird everyone assumes you wouldn't). Be kind to them (I'm sure you would). Sorted. You sound very busy. Doing your own cleaning and tidying doesn't actually mean that you're a better person than everyone else. Leaving clothes on the floor doesn't make you morally defective of lazy wtf they're just your clothes, they're not bothering other people. I'm amazed at the harsh comments. I have my own small floordrobe going, I prioritise work and playing with my child when I'm not working.

I'm not sure about 'better person' as that's contextual but I think morally it is correct to clean up your own mess - you made it why should others be your scivvy. I don't and won't employ a cleaner for this reason even though DH is keen. I think our DC should learn this lesson as well. Particularly as one is a 16 year old DS and he feels the same as me.