Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a cleaner that will pick my clothes up off the floor?

770 replies

Zamphina · 03/10/2023 22:19

Dp and I work very long hours during the week. We’re out of the house 9-10 minimum. We eat dinner in the office. When we get home we’re exhausted and just want to sleep. So often the kitchen has our breakfast stuff. We’ve left clothes on the floor. There might be sunday’s dishes on the table. The laundry has been left out drying.

We earn an OK salary and have a tiny flat to save money, so a cleaner coming 2-3 times a week for two hours a time won’t be an issue.

But obviously I’m slightly embarrassed for someone to see my home in such a mess. Are there any cleaners who will sort all of this? Pick up the clothes, put them on to wash, load the dishwasher, and clean the bathroom etc?

OP posts:
zozueme · 06/10/2023 12:26

WrongSwanson · 06/10/2023 11:19

I'm trying to conceptually understand why a cleaner picking up clothes off the floor is so much worse that asking a cleaner to get unload dirty clothes from a laundry basket?

I don't know why everyone piled on the op.
She's struggling to manage everything, for whatever reason, if someone is happy to do the work then that suits her and gives someone a job.

I agree. I'd rather pick clothes up than clean the toilet 😄 However I suppose it just feels unnecessary as you don't have to drop them on the floor in the first place.

WrongSwanson · 06/10/2023 11:19

I'm trying to conceptually understand why a cleaner picking up clothes off the floor is so much worse that asking a cleaner to get unload dirty clothes from a laundry basket?

I don't know why everyone piled on the op.
She's struggling to manage everything, for whatever reason, if someone is happy to do the work then that suits her and gives someone a job.

milkywinterdisorder · 06/10/2023 09:42

Genuine question: do people with cats expect cleaners to deal with their litterboxes? To me that’s a far worse job than picking up clothes off the floor…

Shortstufflady · 06/10/2023 09:17

My partner works in London and is out of the house for 14 hours. I work 12 hour days. He still comes in and helps me cook tea and puts his dirty clothes in the wash basket and dishes in the dishwasher! I unload washer and do laundry and housework. We are in our fifties too. Not sure why Op and husband can’t manage. General laziness unless they have a disability, which before I get jumped on, my partner has. Just tidy as you go.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 06/10/2023 08:31

LaviniasBigBloomers · 03/10/2023 22:44

Get a dishwasher
Get a laundry basket
Set an hour with a timer every Sunday and run round like idiots getting things picked up and put away
Book a cleaner for a Monday morning, put your laundry in before you leave for work and ask her to hang it out and do some ironing.

You need a system, but you also need a wee bit more pride in yourself than expecting a woman to run around behind you picking up your skiddy knicks.

This. With bells on.

Get a decent set of laundry baskets - whites, darks, dry cleaning and if you both put stuff in the right place you or a housekeeper can get it sorted quickly. Lots of dry cleaning places will pick up if someone is in so again assuming lots of smart work gear/client entertaining etc then you need to turn that stuff around quickly. And hang it up when you get in if it’s still clean.

Sunnydays60 · 06/10/2023 07:24

The amount of sanctimonious people on this thread wasn't surprising. If OP is willing to pay someone to do a job, what on earth is the problem? I don't employ a cleaner, but I wouldn't judge people who do! I often think I'd like to if I had more money! Lots of people considering it lazy but I wonder where that stops? I mean lots of jobs "take 2 seconds" to do, so by this kind of reasoning, you'd probably never employ anyone to do anything for you and a lot of people would be out of work. The idea that cleaning someone's actual dirt isn't as demeaning as picking up some clothes is just bizarre.

LolaSmiles · 06/10/2023 06:41

milkywinterdisorder
That's very interesting.

GodDammitCecil
You make a good point about people and choices, agreeing but still quietly judging/being inconvenienced.
It does seem to come down to how people perceive behaviour and attitudes.

I suspect that's why although there's generally an agreement that it's not unreasonable to outsource jobs, the act of leaving stuff lying around differs

Some people think a house should be totally tidy back to clean surfaces for a cleaner to come in.

Some people, like me, think it should be broadly neat unless you have included light tidying, but if you have a coffee mug or plate in the sink some days when you've rushed out it's not a big deal.

Some people think that it's fine to leave dishes to build up, drop clothes all over, and have a house in any state, just make sure that the cleaner knows what you're asking.

On the purely business transaction side of things, I'd agree with the last group. But I'd also say that 2 adults taking that attitude are lazy, regardless of how much money they earn. Whilst they're free to have whatever business transaction they want, the mentality of "I could put a wash basket here, but I won't, I'll throw it on the floor and pay someone to walk around and pick up after me" is an outlook I find lazy.

LJ125 · 06/10/2023 00:35

By pick up clothes, are you including used underwear? Surely not. So if you can manage the 2 second job to pick up your used underwear and throw it in the wash basket, then you can manage an additional 5 seconds to pick up the remaining items.

Mary1234567 · 05/10/2023 23:10

They’re clearly not lazy if they’re working 13 hour days

GarlicGrace · 05/10/2023 23:04

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/10/2023 21:37

I have more than enough time to keep my house tidy, but I don't want to. I want to lounge around enjoying my free time. Lazy? Almost certainly. But so what? Confused

If I could afford a housekeeper I'd bloody well have one. But I can't. So I don't.

Me too! Actually, I now have a disease that stops me doing it ... and no money to pay a helper. When I worked long hours and had plenty of money, I paid people to do it all. If I were healthy, not working much and still had money, I would still pay people to do it all. I hate housework and am not good at it. Professionals are brilliant at it and enjoy it!

Seems perfectly logical to me.

GarlicGrace · 05/10/2023 22:59

Milkand2sugarsplease · 05/10/2023 18:59

You don't want a cleaner, you want a work/life balance. Unless you're just chasing money.

I'd be sad if i didn't see my husband because he was out 6.45 - 10. When do you have a life??
I'm not saying it meanly, it's meant nicely. When do you see each other or have time to share the home you're building with family etc.

Well, they get about two hours together. And they don't want emptying the dishwasher, clearing up and folding the laundry to eat into that time.

Wisely, I think.

GodDammitCecil · 05/10/2023 22:53

Katbum · 05/10/2023 22:30

Ok read that wrong - out the house from 9am to 10pm is a lot. Why do
you need £300k per year if you can’t enjoy a life away from work? My husband and I earn about £90k combined and live in London, have a lovely life with holidays etc…I don’t see why you’d sacrifice your life for all that money. I know a couple on £400k pa and they are so wealthy now they have asked relatives if they can give them some money to be rid of it (relatives refused on the basis no such thing as a free lunch). My advice is think about your priorities

I think you’ve read it wrong again, still.

They’re on £60K each at the moment.

One day they’ll be on £150K each, with the idea being they’ve paid their pound of flesh early on, and will have more flexibility (and a better work/life balance) as they go up the pay scale.

This is perfect normal, even if not a choice some people would make.

Katbum · 05/10/2023 22:30

Ok read that wrong - out the house from 9am to 10pm is a lot. Why do
you need £300k per year if you can’t enjoy a life away from work? My husband and I earn about £90k combined and live in London, have a lovely life with holidays etc…I don’t see why you’d sacrifice your life for all that money. I know a couple on £400k pa and they are so wealthy now they have asked relatives if they can give them some money to be rid of it (relatives refused on the basis no such thing as a free lunch). My advice is think about your priorities

Katbum · 05/10/2023 22:19

I don’t think 10 Hours out of the house is unusual for full time work. As others have said, it is not that difficult to pick clothes off the floor and wash breakfast dishes (we can’t be talking much here, a cereal bowl, or plate and knife and and a mug? Literally under 3 mins to wash) - the a cleaner can manage the cleaning.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 05/10/2023 21:37

I have more than enough time to keep my house tidy, but I don't want to. I want to lounge around enjoying my free time. Lazy? Almost certainly. But so what? Confused

If I could afford a housekeeper I'd bloody well have one. But I can't. So I don't.

WombatChocolate · 05/10/2023 21:21

Look, people pay others to clean their skiddy toilet sad empty sanitary bins.

People voluntarily enter into a paid contract to provide services that you require. As long as you specify clearly what you want and pay the market rate for it, what OP is wanting isnt particularly strange unusual or shocking.

Why all the shock and horror. If OP wants to leave clothes on the floor and if someone is prepared to pick them up for money…that’s fine. There are far worse things you could be asked to do in a job.

Is the issue that people don’t like the thought that pretty much every task can be outsourced? I’m honestly not sure why there’s such an outcry and sense of disgust.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 05/10/2023 21:14

I think most cleaners/housekeepers would probably do this if you pay them enough. But more to the point (and I mean this in a kind way), if you don't have time to pick your clothes up off the floor then it might be worth addressing your work life balance before employing someone.

GodDammitCecil · 05/10/2023 21:12

That’s really interesting @milkywinterdisorder, and does make sense.

I mean, you can pay anyone to do literally anything - you’re basically buying their consent to do something they otherwise definitely would not want to do.

And that goes right up the line to selling your body. NOTE: I am not equating prostitution to cleaning before those with low comprehension skills pile on - it’s an analogy, showing a similarity between things at different ends of a spectrum.

That is, just because you can pay someone to do something - or throw money at a situation, as per the nursery late fine scenario - it doesn’t mean the person receiving the payment is happy / willing / genuinely enthusiastic / not inconvenienced and/or secretly judging you / etc. about doing it.

These erring-on-the-grim-side tasks that you have to pay people extra to do are usually (not always) picked up by people with fewer options / choices / skills / etc.

Anyway - the OP has had some constructive suggestions on here in amongst the vitriol, and is long gone anyway….

milkywinterdisorder · 05/10/2023 21:02

@LolaSmiles I read it in Freakonomics - it summarises it here:

https://econlife.com/2018/09/unintended-consequences-from-fines/

I actually think it’s kind of heartening that people are more discouraged by the idea of inconveniencing someone than by having to pay for something, which I guess is what’s happening here: the fine takes the guilt out of it, but at least the guilt was there in the first place. I suspect your book-hogging friend would have kept hold of the book whether the fine was in place or not.

It clearly doesn’t always work like that, though, because look at how much the 5p carrier bag charge reduced carrier bag usage. I suppose in that case the perception was that no harm was being caused by taking a carrier bag in the first place so a financial disincentive was the only thing that would work…?

Whatifitallgoesright · 05/10/2023 20:59

Jeez people what's with all the accusations of laziness. OP just needs to advertise clearly what she wants and pay over the odds for a cleaner who agrees on tasks required at the outset. She either is successful in her recruitment or not. 26 pages my lord.

Penguinmouse · 05/10/2023 20:49

Just get a laundry basket 🙄

Straightupmom · 05/10/2023 20:46

I am not going to slate you like everyone else has….because SAME..!!

I’m not lazy, I have ADHD and issues with executive function. I often feel overwhelmed and dive from task to task for hours and the result is that only half the jobs are half done. I do the washing and drying but then it sits in baskets for weeks because I can’t bring myself to put it away. It doesn’t help with having kids who are like the Tasmanian devil 🫠

I have often thought of getting a housekeeper, but I would be utterly mortified.

I feel your pain..!!

LolaSmiles · 05/10/2023 20:32

milkywinterdisorder
That's shocking, but on reflection not surprising.
If you remember the name of the phenomenon then I'd like to know more.

I remember at university an acquaintance taking out books and keeping at least one popular book that was on short loan for a long time after it was recalled because they'd just pay the fine. They had no sense that other students would equally need the book and that's why the recall system was in place. A day or two late whilst working on an assignment I could understand, but accepting a large fine because you'd rather hog a book for a long period of time is an entitlement and attitude problem. There was no consideration that other students might need the book. The solution was to chuck money at the situation as if that somehow made the behaviour acceptable.

HoneycrispApple · 05/10/2023 19:53

Milkand2sugarsplease · 05/10/2023 18:59

You don't want a cleaner, you want a work/life balance. Unless you're just chasing money.

I'd be sad if i didn't see my husband because he was out 6.45 - 10. When do you have a life??
I'm not saying it meanly, it's meant nicely. When do you see each other or have time to share the home you're building with family etc.

Not everyone wants the same things.

milkywinterdisorder · 05/10/2023 19:38

LolaSmiles · 05/10/2023 15:37

You can buy almost anything in this world if you have the money but you cannot buy courtesy and decency it seems in the case of the OP.
You've put it better than me.

Speaking more generally than this thread, I think there's a sliding scale where some people seem to think that as long as they can throw money at something their conduct and attitude doesn't matter.

For example, like pp said up thread about the state of some student properties at the end of rentals. To me basic courtesy says you don't leave somewhere a shit tip for someone else to sort, but evidently some students think that if they lose their deposit they don't mind. To me, it's basic decency to remove my items and leave the place clean. After that the landlord can arrange professional deep cleans and renovations. The idea that I'd leave my junk and the house a tip because the landlord will sort it would be an attitude problem to me. Evidently others feel differently and think the lost deposit is worth it for being scruffy and/or lazy.

Ah, this is interesting! There’s a phenomenon whose name I’ve forgotten where introducing a fine for something actually makes people do it more.

I think the original story was a nursery that was having issues with people picking up their kids after closing time, so they introduced a fine to discourage people from doing it. What actually happened was that people then felt that they weren’t inconveniencing the staff any more, they were simply paying for an extra service. Late pick-ups increased dramatically - it became a transactional issue rather than a moral one.

What I don’t know is whether the usual offenders starting picking their kids up late more often, or whether more people started doing it…

Swipe left for the next trending thread