Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
IslaWinds · 05/10/2023 11:45

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 11:33

It is a more complex scenario than that. There is evidence supportive of the Chivalry theory (that women receive more lenient sentences) but this is complicated by race, class and whether they have children and a history of offending. There is also evidence supportive of the double deviance/Evil woman theory (that women who commit sexual or violent crime, outside the norm are more harshly punished than a man would be) see: https://crimsoc.hull.ac.uk/2020/06/18/gender-differences-and-sentencing/

Really interesting read drawing on data from the US.

Ilovebudgies · 05/10/2023 11:41

5128gap · 05/10/2023 10:48

You don't hear many men challenging the stereotypes though, do you? Until a minority of them come up against one of the very few ways they may not work to their interests, they tend to either endorse them or at best move through life oblivious to the privileges they afford them.
In truth I think the idea of men and women working together to break down sex stereotypes to avoid a few men being collateral damage is a pipe dream.
You might be able to convince some women to 'be kind' and to adopt men's causes (there is a lot of predisposition amongst women to do this) but I can't imagine how you'd ever get the men on board. After all, the vast majority of them will never encounter this issue and tend to be very quick to sneer at and other those who do.

I'm sorry but I totally disagree with pretty much everything you said there.
I think most men definitely wish to challenge those stereotypes.
In my experience most men want to challenge this stereotype that they shouldn't cry, don't have emotions, don't talk about their problems, are meant to be macho and strong and in control, especially the generation coming through now.
I have sons and they are very emotional, but I can already see my eldest realised that he shouldn't cry anymore because boys don't cry, he's not even at secondary school yet.
Its amazing how when you look at toddlers and small kids, you see equal amounts of boys and girls dissolving in tears, but suddenly by adulthood men don't appear to cry or talk about their problems.

Also as I think someone has alluded to upthread, being masculine and tough appeals to women, so that enforces this view that they need to be tough and manly in order to get a girlfriend, so women are reinforcing that stereotype too.

Depending on the data it appears that between 1 in 6 and 1 in 4 men report to be the victims of domestic abuse at some point in their life (not crime stats as they are different due to low reporting) so it's not small and it means that most people will know someone who is a victim and be compelled to do something about it.

I absolutely think women and men can work together to challenge abuse (both male and female) and i actually think that's the best way to approach it rather than battling it out over who has it worse.

AdamRyan · 05/10/2023 11:38

IslaWinds · 05/10/2023 11:21

I don’t think women do get stiffer penalties. They are more likely to avoid a custodial sentence and a disproportionate % are sent to a psychiatric facility instead of prison which mirrors society’s thinking that only mad (unnatural) women are violent.

Does it mirror society's thinking?
Or does it reflect that women are much less likely to be violent on the whole, so the numbers who are violent through illness is proportionately higher?

And yes serious mental illness can make people behave violently.
E.g.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/roller-skate-stabbing-bristol-benjamin-bridgeman-knowle-sentence-b402749.html

Just Google stabbing detained under mental health act and there are loads. Mainly men, again, I think

CrazyHamsterLady · 05/10/2023 11:34

When I worked in a DV charity, the admin team would often put the female perpetrators in as the victim because they hadn’t read the referral properly. They just ‘assumed’ it was that way round. As many times as I told them, they never listened and it happened time and time again. For reference, it was only about 5% of our clients who were female perpetrators. Not saying that the actual percentage isn’t higher but those were the ones where the victim came forward or the Police reported it (with consent)

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 11:33

IslaWinds · 05/10/2023 11:21

I don’t think women do get stiffer penalties. They are more likely to avoid a custodial sentence and a disproportionate % are sent to a psychiatric facility instead of prison which mirrors society’s thinking that only mad (unnatural) women are violent.

It is a more complex scenario than that. There is evidence supportive of the Chivalry theory (that women receive more lenient sentences) but this is complicated by race, class and whether they have children and a history of offending. There is also evidence supportive of the double deviance/Evil woman theory (that women who commit sexual or violent crime, outside the norm are more harshly punished than a man would be) see: https://crimsoc.hull.ac.uk/2020/06/18/gender-differences-and-sentencing/

IslaWinds · 05/10/2023 11:31

Tandora · 05/10/2023 11:29

and a disproportionate % are sent to a psychiatric facility instead of prison which mirrors society’s thinking that only mad (unnatural) women are violent

Whereas when it comes to men, abuse is normal(ised)/a natural expression of masculinity perhaps? Nothing to see here, afterall boys will be boys...

Yes exactly. It’s “natural” although bad for men to be violent. Violence is always portrayed as something men are naturally born with the tendency towards and have to fight against by being civilised.

Tandora · 05/10/2023 11:29

and a disproportionate % are sent to a psychiatric facility instead of prison which mirrors society’s thinking that only mad (unnatural) women are violent

Whereas when it comes to men, abuse is normal(ised)/a natural expression of masculinity perhaps? Nothing to see here, afterall boys will be boys...

IslaWinds · 05/10/2023 11:21

CinnabarRed · 03/10/2023 20:34

I’m sure I read somewhere that - you’re absolutely right - women are given the benefit of the doubt in these situations where men wouldn’t be. But, conversely, when sentenced they get stiffer penalties than men would for the same behaviour because offending women are seen as “unnatural”.

I don’t think women do get stiffer penalties. They are more likely to avoid a custodial sentence and a disproportionate % are sent to a psychiatric facility instead of prison which mirrors society’s thinking that only mad (unnatural) women are violent.

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 11:21

AdamRyan · 05/10/2023 11:09

This is a very interesting female centred evolution psych view

https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/sex-and-the-female-agenda

Yes and a much more plausible one. I’ve never understood those, predominantly men, who push the human males are not monogamous theory. Ok, but then human females aren’t monogamous either. You don’t get get half a species being monogamous and the other half not, it’s counterproductive as an evolutionary strategy. But a lot of men don’t like to consider the implications of that.

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 11:09

AdamRyan · 05/10/2023 11:06

We all know that its the bad boys. So what do those that want a relationship do? They mirror the market.

Oh my god what a load of misogynistic twaddle.
You could equally say "Look at the behaviour of boys on their teenage years. We all know most of them are unempathetic, self centred, risk taking "bad boys" (this is based on actual research into teenage brains). So what do those (girls) that want a relationship do? They mirror the market"

Women's behaviour is not the driver for men's misogyny.

A thousands times this!

AdamRyan · 05/10/2023 11:06

FrippEnos · 05/10/2023 10:54

5128gap

Many of those stereotypes are supported by women.
Look at who has more relationships in their younger years. Is it the nice men that will treat women right and look after them or is it the exciting bad boys?
We all know that its the bad boys. So what do those that want a relationship do? They mirror the market.
For all that some women say they want a man that shows his emotions etc. most will ridicule those same men until they are either ready to settle down or are done with the bad boys and want some emotional back up to bring up the children that the bad boys have abandoned.

Neither side comes out of this well.

We all know that its the bad boys. So what do those that want a relationship do? They mirror the market.

Oh my god what a load of misogynistic twaddle.
You could equally say "Look at the behaviour of boys on their teenage years. We all know most of them are unempathetic, self centred, risk taking "bad boys" (this is based on actual research into teenage brains). So what do those (girls) that want a relationship do? They mirror the market"

Women's behaviour is not the driver for men's misogyny.

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 11:05

I don’t believe that the OP or others are posting in good faith. Multiple other posters have stated that they believe men can be victims of abuse, but OP is on a crusade to claim that women are “worse” abusers than men and that just is not the case. There is also a massive amount of under reporting of abuse by women when men are the perpetrators.

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 11:02

To be transparent these are from a specialist domestic violence organisation, Women’s Aid and not plucked from Wikipedia like @Natalya123 ‘a and so will instantly be dismissed as from a “feminist” organisation and then invalid. Presumably the ONS statistics showing between 2-3 women a week on average being killed by a current or former partner are also suspect and “feminist”.

Like I said, so transparent as is the dubious revisionist evolutionary biology of women competing for the best men. Think on geniuses - in every mammalian species (of which we are one) males compete for fertile females not the other way around. Ask yourself why, if women compete for men, do men produce millions of sperm with each ejaculation, when there is only one egg to fertilise?! In biology when an organism produces lots of its gametes - it’s either because so few will survive (not the case in humans) or because they have to overcome a lot of competition.

asAs for men work better collaboratively in teams, I mean do you actually know any history? Virtually ever war in history has been started by and fought by men. The perpetrators of almost ever genocide have been men. I mean I can’t even countenance such stupidity. Women cannotgive birth alone. It’s incrediblydangerous. They had to have other female midwives and birth attendants helping them throughout history and have done so very very successfully.

FrippEnos · 05/10/2023 10:54

5128gap

Many of those stereotypes are supported by women.
Look at who has more relationships in their younger years. Is it the nice men that will treat women right and look after them or is it the exciting bad boys?
We all know that its the bad boys. So what do those that want a relationship do? They mirror the market.
For all that some women say they want a man that shows his emotions etc. most will ridicule those same men until they are either ready to settle down or are done with the bad boys and want some emotional back up to bring up the children that the bad boys have abandoned.

Neither side comes out of this well.

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 10:53

ReferencesDobash, R.P. and Dobash, R.E. (2004) ‘Women’s violence to men in intimate relationships. Working on a Puzzle’, British Journal of Criminology, 44(3), pp. 324–349
Hester, M. (2013) ‘Who Does What to Whom? Gender and Domestic Violence Perpetrators in English Police Records’, European Journal of Criminology, 10: 623- 637
Myhill, A. (2015) ‘Measuring coercive control: what can we learn from national population surveys?’ Violence Against Women. 21(3), pp. 355-375
Myhill, A. (2017) ‘Measuring domestic violence: context is everything.’ Journal of Gender-Based Violence, vol 1, no 1, 33–44
Office for National Statistics (ONS). (2020A). Domestic abuse victim characteristics, England and Wales: year ending March 2020. Published online: ONS
Office for National Statistics (ONS). (2020B). Appendix tables: Homicide in England and Wales. Published online: ONS
Office for National Statistics (ONS). (2020C). Domestic abuse and the criminal justice system, England and Wales: November 2020 Published online: ONS
Walby, S. and Allen, J. (2004) Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Stalking: Findings from the British Crime Survey. Home Office Research Study 276. London: Home Office
Walby, S. and Towers, J. (May 2017) ‘Measuring violence to end violence: mainstreaming gender’, Journal of Gender-Based Violence, vol. 1, no.
Walby, S. and Towers, J. (2018) ‘Untangling the concept of coercive control: Theorizing domestic violent crime’, Criminology & Criminal Justice, Vol 18, Issue 1, pp 7-28
Women’s Aid, Hester, M., Walker, S-J., and Williamson, E. (2021) Gendered experiences of justice and domestic abuse. Evidence for policy and practice. Bristol: Women’s Aid

Appendix tables: homicide in England and Wales - Office for National Statistics

Findings from the analyses based on the Homicide Index recorded by the Home Office, including long-term trends, sex of the victim, apparent method of killing and relationship to victim.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/datasets/appendixtableshomicideinenglandandwales

BestMemberOfTheFratellis · 05/10/2023 10:53

There is some real disinformation being pushed on this thread and a really transparent MRA agenda, that no one who works in the criminal justice system, or with victims of domestic violence (both sexes) (me included) recognises.

Some counterpoints and studies:

  • The majority of domestic homicide victims (killed by ex/partner or a family member) for the year ending March 2017 to the year ending March 2019 were female (77% or 274 victims) and most of the suspects were male (263 out of 274; 96%). Of the 83 male victims of domestic homicide, the suspect was female in 39 cases, and male in 44 cases. (ONS, 2020A)
  • Over the three-year period April 2016 to March 2019, a total of 222 women were killed by a partner or ex-partner. The majority of suspects were male (218, 98%). This means that during this time period, an average of three women every fortnight were murdered by their male partner or ex-partner. (ONS, 2020B)
  • One study of 96 cases of domestic abuse recorded by the police found that men are significantly more likely to be repeat perpetrators and significantly more likely than women to use physical violence, threats, and harassment. In a six year tracking period the majority of recorded male perpetrators (83%) had at least two incidents of recorded abuse, with many having a lot more than two and one man having 52 repeat incidents. Whereas in cases where women were recorded as the perpetrator the majority (62%) had only one incident of abuse recorded and the highest number of repeat incidents for any female perpetrator was eight. The study also found that men’s violence tended to create a context of fear and control; which was not the case when women were perpetrators. (Hester, 2013)
  • Over 80% (83%) of high frequency victims (more than 10 crimes) are women. (From a study of data from the Crime Survey for England and Wales, a nationally representative household survey.) (Walby & Towers, 2018)
  • The large majority of defendants in domestic abuse-related prosecutions in the year ending March 2020 were recorded as male (92%) and the majority of the victims recorded as female (77%, compared with compared with 16% who were male). The sex of the victim was not recorded in 7% of prosecutions. If these missing data were excluded from analysis, then it would be 82% female victims and 18% male victims (ONS, 2020C).
5128gap · 05/10/2023 10:48

You don't hear many men challenging the stereotypes though, do you? Until a minority of them come up against one of the very few ways they may not work to their interests, they tend to either endorse them or at best move through life oblivious to the privileges they afford them.
In truth I think the idea of men and women working together to break down sex stereotypes to avoid a few men being collateral damage is a pipe dream.
You might be able to convince some women to 'be kind' and to adopt men's causes (there is a lot of predisposition amongst women to do this) but I can't imagine how you'd ever get the men on board. After all, the vast majority of them will never encounter this issue and tend to be very quick to sneer at and other those who do.

Hellaweirdhuh · 05/10/2023 10:37

Snoozysnoozy · 05/10/2023 06:45

No it isn't, it's about how men are is likely to be believed of they are the victims of abuse from their female partners.

It does make me wonder what the stats are for abusive relationships within LGBT couples though.

Highest rates are for lesbian and bisexual women.

Ilovebudgies · 05/10/2023 10:33

5128gap · 05/10/2023 10:22

Do you think then @Ilovebudgies that it was women who created the sex based stereotypes that lead people to believe that a 'real man' couldn't be abused by a woman? That a 'real man' is strong, powerful, master in his own home and should be perfectly capable of controlling a woman, his inferior in every way?
And do you really believe that because women are now employed within the institutions that run society this means their influence in those spheres is equal to that of men?
Your own figures demonstrate only that women are a minority in these roles, and you have given no weight to where they typically stand in the hierarchy, or to their comparatively recent inclusion in male dominated spheres where the culture has been fixed for centuries.

No I'm not saying it's equal by any stretch, especially in the upper echelons, but it is far from this total male dominance society that people try to insinuate.

The fact is if a man goes to the police, there is probably a high chance he will be met by a female, if he is in court there is a decent chance he will be faced with a female judge.

I agree with you on the development of sex based stereotypes but these were developed far before any modern man was born. They are entrenched in society and affect the current attitudes of both men and women today and can be challenged by both men and women today.

Like the OP is saying, many people think abuse of men isn't a big deal, evidence is showing that domestic abuse appears to be two way, but people just will not believe it, they shut down the evidence without even reading it.
That isn't a male issue, that is actually usually a female one. Women feel that discussions around male victims of abuse somehow detracts from their feminist fight against 'man on woman' abuse, so they attempt to dismiss it and shut it down, start throwing MRA at people and listing all the ways in which women suffer at the hands of men.
It is perfectly possible to champion both causes but it's almost impossible to have a debate on it, and I can see why few politicians want to even go near it.

FrippEnos · 05/10/2023 10:25

Beefcurtains79 · 05/10/2023 10:18

How? They are both proven liars.

We have 5 posters on here denying that from the start, any evidence from the trial is not believed and those arguing the point are told that they must are supporting an abuser and an MRA.

JD must be guilty.

I'm surprised that we haven't had handmaiden and the other favourite slurs that are often banded about

5128gap · 05/10/2023 10:22

Do you think then @Ilovebudgies that it was women who created the sex based stereotypes that lead people to believe that a 'real man' couldn't be abused by a woman? That a 'real man' is strong, powerful, master in his own home and should be perfectly capable of controlling a woman, his inferior in every way?
And do you really believe that because women are now employed within the institutions that run society this means their influence in those spheres is equal to that of men?
Your own figures demonstrate only that women are a minority in these roles, and you have given no weight to where they typically stand in the hierarchy, or to their comparatively recent inclusion in male dominated spheres where the culture has been fixed for centuries.

Beefcurtains79 · 05/10/2023 10:18

FrippEnos · 05/10/2023 10:13

And yet Heard vs Depp is a prime example of what the OP is saying.

How? They are both proven liars.

FrippEnos · 05/10/2023 10:13

Sigmama · 05/10/2023 07:04

If you wanted a serious discussion about this issue perhaps you shouldn't have mentioned herd depp

And yet Heard vs Depp is a prime example of what the OP is saying.

Ilovebudgies · 05/10/2023 10:10

5128gap · 05/10/2023 09:59

No @Ilovebudgies I'm not shifting the narrative. I'm staying strictly within the remit of the question posed by the OP. The OP asked specifically if we thought male abuse victims were taken less seriously because far more men are abusers. The post you quoted is my response to that question. My opinion being that if they are, then here is a possible reason for that.
I couldn't be more focused on the issue at hand if I tried.
If that involves stating the rather obvious point that the treatment of abuse victims is controlled by men, so any complaints about that apect of male abuse cant really be laid at womens doors, and that doesn't fit comfortably on a thread designed to turn a spot light on evil women, well, that's too bad.
If the OP is serious about changing perceptions of male abuse victims, she needs to focus on or at least acknowledge the role of the men with the power to effect that change.
If she merely wants to tell us that men are victims of women, she needs a new thread title that doesn't contain a question she may not like the answers to.

Why do you think the treatment (and likelihood of being believed) of male abuse victims is controlled solely by men?
38% of the police force is now female, 35% of judges are female, and most councils have both men and women on the boards making local decisions. Most newspapers have a fairly even distribution of male and females writing articles, which influences public perception and our culture.
I think it's a cop out to just say 'men up there, hello up there, can you hear me? Can you sort this out please' as a response to every issue.
I think the attitude of some women on here (that it's not really an issue for men, dismissing it etc) is pervasive in society. Both men and women are responsible for the culture we exist in, for newspaper articles, for tweets, for news reports etc, it isn't all in the hands of men.

Swipe left for the next trending thread