Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 12:33

@Catsafterme

Just a thought here. Maybe you can make a thread about this. I've got no knowledge of child custody situations. A lot of people here do, and can give sound, practical advice.

I would caution against saying your ex wife is abusive as you will probably end up with a lot of people assuming that you must be the abusive one, but you can still basically say your ex won't let your children have contact with anyone.

It might be worth a shot. I'm not sure if there are any other support groups or organisations that help with this. Maybe others will know more than me.

I know not every situation is the same but I learned a fair bit about the history of the woman who abused us.

She told DP when they met that her ex husband abused her. I understand abusers generally have a "my ex was crazy" backstory and with the knowledge we have now we think it was the other way around.

But she did have a son. Now I never met the son, but I do remember thinking "how the fuck can this raging abusive psycho have a child?" And I was genuinely worried for the kid (who was around 14 at the time).

I looked quite often at her FB to make sure mostly that she hadn't moved and that we were still physically safe, and the son (now 21 probably) seeks fine and interacts with her a lot.

So maybe despite the way she was a terrifying abuser to us, she was fine as a Mum. I really don't know, for all I know she might have screwed the kid up mentally. I am just saying I do not believe she was violent to the child.

Again no idea if this is a common thing. So I am really just wondering if it might be the same here? I hope so. I hope your kids are safe and well.

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 12:20

@Catsafterme

It's hard as well when you have no evidence of what's occured during the relationship as well. I've spoken to the police regarding other matters going on at the moment and they said whether I want to report the abuse and they would support and investigate but like I said to the officer, I don't have any proof and I don't know whether it would make things worse because she currently has the children isolated

I really want to talk to you about this, but as has been pointed out, this thread is a mess. So I'm going to try, if you can ignore the background noise.

Is she abusive to the children? Are they safe, and just isolated? How old are they? Have you got legal access? Can you apply for it if you don't?

I am really not sure where you go from here :( I've known of two messy divorces where both parents claimed the other one was insane or abusive (neither were) so presumably this is a hard situation because people do lie.

What contact do you have with her? Can you write or speak to her and record it?

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 12:14

@FloydPepper

This thread is a mess. Op raised an interesting point and it was broadly being discussed until it all got derailed (op, sorry you did kind of start that)

I really didn't :/ as shown on my post on page 12 there are people here who showed up only to attack / goad / bait anyone for saying Amber Heard was an abuser. They were spoiling for a fight.

I was happy actually to debate the AH point, because as @Ilovebudgies has said, it's central to the topic: if people can't believe someone literally on tape saying they repeatedly hit their husband, then how can any victim be believed?

It's actually pretty central to the point we are trying to discuss. My DP started heavily drinking when it happened to him. He behaved in funny ways that made him probably look unhinged. He pushed her and even dragged her out of the house by her arm when she wouldn't let him escape her. Does that mean he also isn't a victim?

He was also bigger, stronger, more powerful. Does that mean he also wasn't a victim? These are the questions I was really hoping to discuss. Although that's quite hard to do if people came here with very different intentions.

@5128gap

If she hoped to convince people women are as bad as men, again by simply telling us so and shaming those who disagree as not caring for victims; I very much there will have been much movement from people's original stance on that either

As @FloydPepper said "I think it was a genuine attempt to discuss why male victims, who are a minority, find it hard to get heard. Unfortunately a fair few people automatically feel it’s an attempt to say women are as bad as men and forcefully defend against that argument. However, that’s not what was said"

That's what it was. It wasn't a competition:( Admitting females can also be perpetrators doesn't diminish female victims. Thanks @FloydPepper for saying it so well.

OP posts:
FloydPepper · 06/10/2023 11:45

5128gap · 06/10/2023 11:41

Its always going to get messy when a less powerful group who have collectively suffered greatly from the abuse of a more powerful one, are being encouraged to see the powerful as having equal victim status.
Its a hugely sensitive, controversial topic that needs to be approached with a great deal more nuance than merely repeating over and over that something (Women are abusers! Men are victims!) is true, attacking anyone who doesn't offer enthusiastic agreement, and leading us down a rabbit hole of one celebrity couple about whom there is no consensus.
If the OP hoped from this thread to increase the level of belief for male victims by exploring why they are currently not taken seriously, as suggested by the title, I think its been a resounding fail, as I doubt a single person is any the wiser. Simply hammering home over and again that the abuse happens doesn't touch upon that.
If she hoped to convince people women are as bad as men, again by simply telling us so and shaming those who disagree as not caring for victims; I very much there will have been much movement from people's original stance on that either.

I think it was a genuine attempt to discuss why male victims, who are a minority, find it hard to get heard.

unfortunately a fair few people automatically feel it’s an attempt to say women are as bad as men and forcefully defend against that argument. However, that’s not what was said.

that and the whole JD/AH thing means the substantive point is lost

5128gap · 06/10/2023 11:41

Its always going to get messy when a less powerful group who have collectively suffered greatly from the abuse of a more powerful one, are being encouraged to see the powerful as having equal victim status.
Its a hugely sensitive, controversial topic that needs to be approached with a great deal more nuance than merely repeating over and over that something (Women are abusers! Men are victims!) is true, attacking anyone who doesn't offer enthusiastic agreement, and leading us down a rabbit hole of one celebrity couple about whom there is no consensus.
If the OP hoped from this thread to increase the level of belief for male victims by exploring why they are currently not taken seriously, as suggested by the title, I think its been a resounding fail, as I doubt a single person is any the wiser. Simply hammering home over and again that the abuse happens doesn't touch upon that.
If she hoped to convince people women are as bad as men, again by simply telling us so and shaming those who disagree as not caring for victims; I very much there will have been much movement from people's original stance on that either.

FloydPepper · 06/10/2023 11:12

This thread is a mess. Op raised an interesting point and it was broadly being discussed until it all got derailed (op, sorry you did kind of start that) and then deteriorated into the usual arguing that always happens on threads about male victims.

a cynic might think that’s what some parties want

Catsafterme · 06/10/2023 09:34

It's hard as well when you have no evidence of what's occured during the relationship as well. I've spoken to the police regarding other matters going on at the moment and they said whether I want to report the abuse and they would support and investigate but like I said to the officer, I don't have any proof and I don't know whether it would make things worse because she currently has the children isolated.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 09:10

@Ilovebudgies

For evidence you've got the audios, pictures, testimonies, injuries, witnesses, hospital report and abusers confession that were watched by a jury in court who ALL found her guilty of defamation, but congrats for picking the one part of my paragraph that isn't evidence but just a valid observation

The thing about this that makes me hyperventilate is that it proves beyond all doubt that if a female abuser you, demonstrably, in every sense and you gather iron clad evidence..... you will still be dismissed by some

It's similar to my younger years where women colony speak out on rape or sexual harassment, because some people would hold these views which put then at high risk of not only being dismissed, but perhaps being twisted into the guilty one!

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 09:05

@piscofrisco

I agree with you op. But this is the wrong forum to ask the question. I've given up asking for advice on our situation with dh's highly abusive and manipulative ex wife. Because all the responses are 'well he must have done something wrong to her' and 'you must be an idiot to believe his version of events'. I've literally witnessed her in action. And her version of events was unpicked and found to be false-lots of evidence-in court. Yet still I'm told here that I'm wrong to believe him, and he's the abuser-because he's a man. It's staggering

It's a strange phenomenon, but what this thread has illuminated for me is how strong gender bias can be. People need to be much better educated on abuse. They need to recognise things like manipulation and devaluing and understand the impact on the victim far better than they do.

It's obvious to me almost every abuser makes counter allegations against the victim, and the rather true stereotype is the male abuser who acusses the female victim of being crazy or unstable. That possibly makes it very difficult to discern the difference.

It's great that they criminalised coercive control. I think we need to seriously modernise and update understanding of abuse and the process of more or less breaking another person down.

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 08:58

@FrippEnos

I find it somewhat amusing that you are trying to gaslight me on a thread about abuse

I completely agree with you. A number of users on this thread have showed up to it to try and bully. Interesting! But I'm sure not a bloody coincidence.

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 08:54

No you're not @Tandora . You've come to this thread to deliberately derail it, behaved appallingly, tried to accuse other people of what you yourself are doing and are trying to bait / goad and play silly gotcha games with abuse victims.

Take @1dayatatime very good advice.

"This thread is dealing with an important, under
discussed and often dismissed issue of female DV to male or female (as mentioned in lesbian relationships)"

Grow up.

OP posts:
Tandora · 06/10/2023 08:28

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 01:22

@Tandora Grow up.

Just, again, pointing out the hypocrisy.

Iwasafool · 06/10/2023 08:14

I don't think the credibility of people experiencing abuse should be tied to JD or AH. They are just one case and whoever you believe about them it shouldn't mean you assume that speaks for all men or all women.

Personally I know women are abused as I know a woman who was frequently hurt and in the end only got away when he broke her arm. I also know men can be abused as I know a man who was punched in the face while he was holding their baby in his arms.

I don't know JD or AH and their case doesn't convince me of anything.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 07:51

Sigmama · 06/10/2023 07:40

'He's nearly 60 years old and no previous partner has come forward', - jesus that's your evidence? Yeah climate change doesn't exist either.

No that isn't evidence. For evidence you've got the audios, pictures, testimonies, injuries, witnesses, hospital report and abusers confession that were watched by a jury in court who ALL found her guilty of defamation, but congrats for picking the one part of my paragraph that isn't evidence but just a valid observation.

Sigmama · 06/10/2023 07:40

'He's nearly 60 years old and no previous partner has come forward', - jesus that's your evidence? Yeah climate change doesn't exist either.

piscofrisco · 06/10/2023 06:11

I agree with you op. But this is the wrong forum to ask the question. I've given up asking for advice on our situation with dh's highly abusive and manipulative ex wife. Because all the responses are 'well he must have done something wrong to her' and 'you must be an idiot to believe his version of events'. I've literally witnessed her in action. And her version of events was unpicked and found to be false-lots of evidence-in court. Yet still I'm told here that I'm wrong to believe him, and he's the abuser-because he's a man. It's staggering.

FrippEnos · 06/10/2023 05:17

AdamRyan

what you did was give an opinion, not a fact,
That I have corrected you and pointed out that you and your friend have had to rewrite what I wrote several times whilst still claiming that I am wrong says alot about you,

I find it somewhat amusing that you are trying to gaslight me on a thread about abuse.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 01:45

Oh @Scottishdreams1991 I am so sorry :( Have you managed to get support?

OP posts:
Scottishdreams1991 · 06/10/2023 01:39

My mum sexually abused me for years. I wasn't believed or given help. Even now she gets sympathy

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 01:22

@Tandora Grow up.

OP posts:
Tandora · 06/10/2023 00:59

BraykeDance · 05/10/2023 23:59

@Ilovebudgies

Bravo 👏

I thought you didn’t want people discussing AH? 🙄 I thought it was “derailing”
your thread.

BraykeDance · 05/10/2023 23:59

@Ilovebudgies

Bravo 👏

OP posts:
Ilovebudgies · 05/10/2023 23:52

Mustardseed86 · 05/10/2023 17:30

The correct wording is "tell them I'm a victim too of domestic violence." In other words, that it's a given fact between them that he was also violent towards her.

This was a conversation about his assault on her, which he has admitted to (although obviously minimising it). In the same conversation, she said she asked her friend Io to call the police because she really thought she was going to lose her life, and he would do it by accident.

Further context from a little later in the conversation:

"I'm just trying to point out the fact of why I said call 911 was because you had your hands on me after you threw a phone in my face, and it has gotten crazy in the past, and I truly thought, I need to stop this madness before I get hurt."

You can debate about reactive violence but you need to take into account that she had been in therapy for years at this point and her therapist was trying to help Amber Heard to leave because she was scared for her safety, based on Heard's description of the relationship over that time period, mainly based on Depp's jealousy and his behaviour while taking drugs and drinking. She didn't want to leave and she didn't want to get him in trouble or see herself as a victim. Which is very common.

Case in point re jealousy: the messages he wrote on the walls in Australia in blood, which show he was paranoid about her co-stars (Billy Bob Thornton)

So we know that Depp was violent, jealous and paranoid from an early point in the relationship. We also know he sent texts early in their relationship because she was 'nagging' him about his drug habits, expressing a desire to drown, burn and rape her corpse.

In other recordings, he says he headbutted her in the forehead, in another one she says she left for a while after he "beat the shit out of" her, and there's a whole text conversation with his assistant about Depp kicking her in front of a group of onlookers while blackout drunk/high on a private plane.

The conversation about her hitting him, she explains she hit him because he'd hurt her toes and she freaked out thinking they were "going there".

All of which is very normal in relationships where there is violence and trauma bonding.

Basing your view of an entire relationship on a few recordings made after years of being conditioned by domestic abuse, and her being argumentative rather than meek and cowed, is ridiculous.

Anyway, I just wanted to put that out there because while I don't doubt women can be abusive, I'm sick of the misogynistic narrative about Amber Heard, and the way snippets of recordings are presented out of context to further that. At least other people can see there is a lot more to it than that, since you seem to have omitted those facts.

I'm not going to post here anymore, I wish you the best OP with your healing.

Edited

She said 'too' because she had already told (lied to) the world she was a victim, this was after it was in the media. It wasn't because it was a 'given'

Quite the opposite. She was desperately trying to give a reason why she called the police, she said things get 'crazy'. He then says 'come on I lost a finger, I had jars and cans thrown at my nose'
Notice how she never denied that's how he lost his finger.

Now at that point, where he shows that her abuse was worse than his by listing things she has thrown at him, don't you think she would say 'but you've punched me repeatedly and raped me with a shattered vodka bottle? Or listed ANYTHING that he has ever done that matched up to what he said.
There is no way he would list those things she did if he knew he had done far worse, it wouldn't make any logical sense.

We know things got 'crazy' between them, there are audios where she admits hitting, hittING (plural) him, where she admits she starts physical fights, where she accuses him of always 'running away' when it gets heated, him hiding in bathrooms and her admitting she was annoyed he had locked himself in, calling him a baby for always running away, not a real man.

And she repeatedly hit him because he opened a door on her toes? Really? You do realise she had time to invent stories before the trial! She's not going to say 'yeah I kept hitting him as I am a vile abuser' is she?
He said the headbutt was accidental during one of her attacks which can be believed as it was mentioned so casually in the audio between them, and there was no evidence of him beating the shit out of her, none whatsoever.

There are audios of her relentlessly belittling him and he stays calm despite not even knowing he's being recorded.
His sister claiming she had to book two rooms so he had somewhere to escape to, and so much testimony that she was volatile and unpredictable. And she wasn't 'in therapy' she had a therapist, most rich Americans do.

There is never any evidence of this extreme abuse that she lays claim to. This big man that repeatedly punches her with a fist full of rings.

He's nearly 60 years old and no previous partner has come forward to say he physically abused them, which is so rare, normally at least someone somewhere comes out the woodwork if someone is a violent woman beater.

Amber Heard is an abuser is it clear as day and it frightens me that people can't see through her.
And that's the last I'll say on the topic.

1dayatatime · 05/10/2023 23:23

@AdamRyan

Will you please stop the bullying .

This thread is dealing with an important, under discussed and often dismissed issue of female DV to male or female (as mentioned in lesbian relationships).

The derailing and bullying has to stop.

AdamRyan · 05/10/2023 22:56

FrippEnos · 05/10/2023 10:54

5128gap

Many of those stereotypes are supported by women.
Look at who has more relationships in their younger years. Is it the nice men that will treat women right and look after them or is it the exciting bad boys?
We all know that its the bad boys. So what do those that want a relationship do? They mirror the market.
For all that some women say they want a man that shows his emotions etc. most will ridicule those same men until they are either ready to settle down or are done with the bad boys and want some emotional back up to bring up the children that the bad boys have abandoned.

Neither side comes out of this well.

This was the initial post, it says nothing like "the fair point that in order to deconstruct stereotypes, both men and women would need to be on board, and she/he thinks women are often drawn to the most masculine bad boy, which reinforces it."

The "both sides" blah came after the misogyny and incel logic were pointed out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread