Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 02:02

@Lavender14

Just to say @AnObserverInThisDarkWorldthere is a difference in a mutually toxic relationship and a domestic violence/stalking relationship

Read my lost above. Ms Heard was not "toxic". She was a domestic abuser and was psychologically, emotionally and physically abusing Mr Depp.

there will be very real power and control on one side and very real fear and loss of control on the other

Yes, and the person hiding in the bathroom is unlikely to be the one exerting the power and fear.

So as others have said the AH JD case is not a clear cut example as they both acted abusively

Many abuse victims can act abusively. My DP pushed his abuser and left bruises on her arms. Why? Because she had been in his house for over 4 hours, smashing his belongings, refusing to leave and threatening him with knives. That doesn't make HIM an abuser.

That doesn't make her an abuser and him just a victim as in the cases op is referencing

I am staying he was not an abuser because ive seen no evidence he was. I listened to all of it, read all the messages, heard all the testimonies and didn't hear either of them reference any abuse from him at all. There are tapes from the end of the marriage where he says "you cut off my finger" and she says "yes, but you made me do angry". Similarly he says "you keep getting physical. You punched me" and she says "I didn't punch you, I hit you" and excuses herself by saying it's his fault for walking away and "being a baby"

Do you HONESTLY believe that if he had done what she said he'd done that the conversations would not have sounded more like this?

Him: you cut off my finger
Her: yes but you raped me with a wine bottle, ripped out my hair and constantly punched me

Of course she would have done!!!

So therefore it's not an appropriate example as JD was also highly abusive towards AH which I believe was proved in the closed court case

It's a perfect example, because people really struggle to accept the obvious just because she's a woman. And no, it was never proved he was abusive AT ALL to her. For a start because it was a civil and not criminal case. For a second because it was a defamation suit against a newspaper and all they needed to prove is that they believed what they printed was true. In those circumstances, she can say whatever she likes. And most astonishingly, they had a live televised US trial where she failed to produce a shred of evidence that he ever abused her AT ALL.

OP posts:
supplycaptain · 04/10/2023 01:59

almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

what a ridiculous statement, men can literally rape or murder and avoid prison. The legal process is shit for victims of crime regardless of gender

Chickenkeev · 04/10/2023 01:54

A 'female' can abuse absolutely. But the fact is that it's much less likely for the 'female' to be the abuser. The odds are vanishingly small. But if you're being abused, seek help and get out.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 01:47

@MaryShelleysMonster

I also think it's not a coincidence that the OP came to MN AIBU and deliberately misrepresented the Depp case

I'm very confused by this post. What are you implying exactly? And what did I "misrepresent" deliberately or otherwise.

This is a thread about female abusers. Amber Heard is a female abuser.

There are tapes of the woman telling him to stop being a baby about him hitting her. She cut off his finger. There are tapes showing the man was literally locking himself in the bathroom or moving to different hotel rooms to escape from her. She is heard ON TAPE saying "Tell the world Jonny, tell them! No one will believe you!". She was also arrested for physically assaulting a previous partner. The tapes clearly showed a pattern of manipulative abuse, where she guilt tripped him, told him he wasn't a real man and so on. It was horrendous.

The only evidence he abused her comes from her mouth: the same woman who was proved a liar multiple times on the stand. She even tried to pass off an abuse story someone else gave her as her own! Not only is she an abuser and pathological liar: she is also responsible for making REAL female abuse sufferers harder to believe.

OP posts:
FloydPepper · 04/10/2023 00:49

I think you raise a good point op regarding the fact that the majority of abusers are men (which is a fact no-one is denying) meaning the minority of cases the other way round get disbelieved.

this thread, in places, is following thenusual
pattern on here of excusing the abuser and blaming the victim. One poster I think said “I’m sorry that happened, but…” twice in the same post, and there are others too. I also think the derailing (must talk about abusive men) is par for the course

I think the post about patriarchy’s own goal is interesting and has some truth in it. I’d frame it more that men can be victims of toxic masculinity too (must be strong and brave, can’t be a victim). Is that self inflicted? No, but it is inflicted by “men” on other men.

Lavender14 · 04/10/2023 00:22

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 03/10/2023 21:34

Did she cut off part of his finger and blatantly say she would get away with it because no one would believe him?

She is an abuser. There's no question there. She also didn't suffer anywhere near the ruin to her career JD has. So it's relevant

Just to say @AnObserverInThisDarkWorld there is a difference in a mutually toxic relationship and a domestic violence/stalking relationship - there will be very real power and control on one side and very real fear and loss of control on the other. So as others have said the AH JD case is not a clear cut example as they both acted abusively. That doesn't make her an abuser and him just a victim as in the cases op is referencing. So therefore it's not an appropriate example as JD was also highly abusive towards AH which I believe was proved in the closed court case. Funnily enough in cases involving a jury the majority of abusers get off with it using all the techniques jds counsel employed.

MaryShelleysMonster · 03/10/2023 23:16

Psychosis can be present in abusive relationships. It wasn't a PP's fault that OP used the term incorrectly.
I also think it's not a coincidence that the OP came to MN AIBU and deliberately misrepresented the Depp case.
Abusive relationships need to be taken seriously and policed accordingly.
Whataboutery that dimishes the statistics on abuse enables authorities and society to continue to ignore it.

Invalidusername88 · 03/10/2023 23:15

I think we hold women to a different standard because they do usually fit that standard! However there are some that don't and this should be taken into account. On the whole though men are more abusive and this is where the standard comes from in the first place. We didn't just decide we were going to term men as more abusive. Everybody knows it. To pretend otherwise invites misogyny. Women have a hard enough time as it is.

Coffeaddict · 03/10/2023 23:12

Dramatic · 03/10/2023 21:48

Some women are better at it than males, yeah better at it than non-abusive males 🙄 abusive women are not more manipulative and controlling than abusive men.

Some abusive women can be as good as if not more so manipulative and controlling than males. But like I said obviously abusive males can also be.

Have you encountered all abusers that you can definitely say this. Because the the number of female perpetrators lf domestic abuse jumped massively when coercive control was included in the definition

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 23:09

@1dayatatime that's sad, but at the same time I think it's a terrible advert. Abuse isn't really about pushing someone :( it's a pattern of psychological complete destruction. I wish they would educate the public much more on the emotional and psychological abuse that is often the worst element and what keeps abuse victims silent. As @Dramatic said, the sheer terror inflicted through manipulation and grinding you down and telling everyone you're crazy

OP posts:
Catsafterme · 03/10/2023 23:08

My view is that there are abusive people across the board. However, out of the two I would say there are far more abusive men than women and they would have the tendency to pose a greater risk, or capability of it, maybe.

Having experienced abuse from a woman I know myself that it happens and in my case it was violent at times but mostly psychological and emotional. It's hard trying to prove that because it isn't the norm, people don't generally think of that scenario being possible.

Regardless of my experience, I've come across far more abusive, creepy or potentially dangerous men in my time than I have women. In fact I've only come across one, so.

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 03/10/2023 23:04

The op brought male abusers into it with her thread title and question...

The comparison was there at the outset, the whole question was based on it.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 03/10/2023 23:04

Dramatic · 03/10/2023 22:58

I guess the lack of people intervening is probably because they can clearly see that the man is physically able to defend himself whereas the woman isn't. The laughing is awful though, but I wonder if people could tell it was set up.

Really?

I don't see a man able to defend himself. I see a scared man backing away from abuse. And I bet if the man had pushed her away or reacted physically then people would have been rushing to HER defence...

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 03/10/2023 23:01

Its telling that this thread asking about female abusers has become talking about male abuse and stories about suffering at the hands of females and feeling helpless because they are female and aren't thought to be capable of abuse have become "but men do that too...."

If this thread was the other way around, or rather when, and female abusers are mentioned when talking about male abuse then the outcry is huge....

Dramatic · 03/10/2023 22:58

1dayatatime · 03/10/2023 22:44

I remember seeing this advert sometime ago showing the difference in how ordinary people view domestic violence depending whether the victim is female or male.

What was sad is seeing passers by actually laughing about w.

I guess the lack of people intervening is probably because they can clearly see that the man is physically able to defend himself whereas the woman isn't. The laughing is awful though, but I wonder if people could tell it was set up.

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 03/10/2023 22:56

The abuse by men is frequent and a majority of us have been affected by both low level and more intrusive abuses by males.

Men seem driven by their male sex hormones and porn addled sexual desires to attack, pester and subjugate women. Obviously bot all men are like this. But many are, and many are obviously good at hiding their true desires and what they are capable of.

I'm sorry for what happened to you. I'm sorry you felt your life was in danger. The odd woman is abusive and terrifying.

But men are far more commonly capable of actually causing bodily harm. They frequently do.

I hope you get justice and peace from what youve suffered.

But men are more often the abusers. Both in frequency and severity.

Women are more often the victims. And when a women does act in an abusive way, her history is almost always chequered with male abuse. I think that deserves some acknowledgement. And consideration when considering her actions.

Redlarge · 03/10/2023 22:49

Maybe they do. Maybe the woman was displaying reactive abuse and is the victim really. Maybe men are most likely to abuse women more so than men.
Maybe men abusing woman is so desensitised and accepted that when a woman does it to a man she is demonised far more.

1dayatatime · 03/10/2023 22:44

I remember seeing this advert sometime ago showing the difference in how ordinary people view domestic violence depending whether the victim is female or male.

What was sad is seeing passers by actually laughing about w.

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 22:25

@Dramatic I dont think anyone is at all suggesting male abusers aren't as bad. Even the title of the thread explicitly says they are predominantly the gender responsible for these abuse dynamics.

This is just about the fact many people struggle to accept female abuse exists, or that it can be as bad. Which is tragic. The horror you've suffered happens to men too.

OP posts:
Dramatic · 03/10/2023 22:22

SeulementUneFois · 03/10/2023 22:16

You are so right OP.
My DP was abused by his ex for over a decade. Physically, punches to the head, kicked, but also psychological abuse and control, and extreme verbal abuse. Every couple of weeks, for over a decade.
No one gives a damn.
She's there presenting herself as the victim because he eventually left - because he left and 'destroyed her vision of the rest of their lives'. (This is although he's supporting her and will be for life.)
It didn't matter a jot to anybody else, all her friends, acquaintances and relatives don't give a damn.
This is despite the fact that it's all known, there's even a recording of her admitting to it but of course saying that it wasn't that bad.
His kids don't care (actually they've both gone onto punch him in the face over the years - not surprising, since they were always in the house when she was assaulting him).
Even his mother said she didn't want to take sides.
The ex is an abuser, but it's been completely swiped under the carpet.

Edited

Again, this happens with male abusers too. None of what's been said here is because the abuser was female, this is how DV relationships are and it's often how they end. Also people around male abusers act the same, most families will "not take sides" and the abuser goes on to other people how the victim ruined their life.

SeulementUneFois · 03/10/2023 22:16

You are so right OP.
My DP was abused by his ex for over a decade. Physically, punches to the head, kicked, but also psychological abuse and control, and extreme verbal abuse. Every couple of weeks, for over a decade.
No one gives a damn.
She's there presenting herself as the victim because he eventually left - because he left and 'destroyed her vision of the rest of their lives'. (This is although he's supporting her and will be for life.)
It didn't matter a jot to anybody else, all her friends, acquaintances and relatives don't give a damn.
This is despite the fact that it's all known, there's even a recording of her admitting to it but of course saying that it wasn't that bad.
His kids don't care (actually they've both gone onto punch him in the face over the years - not surprising, since they were always in the house when she was assaulting him).
Even his mother said she didn't want to take sides.
The ex is an abuser, but it's been completely swiped under the carpet.

Sigmama · 03/10/2023 22:15

I fear/have feared men far more than women in my life, on a purely physical basis - female's don't even come close, but accept that is just my experience

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 21:50

@Dramatic

My male abuser psychologically tortured me. As well as physically strangled me (on top of pretty much every type of abuse you can think of) he made me feel like I was going insane. And threatened me will all sorts if I dared to report him/leave him. He had other people thinking I was the crazy one too. That is NOT exclusive to female abusers and it's incredibly insulting to say that

I am so sorry you experienced that and you're quite right. I think the point being made (poorly) is that physical size and strength isn't required to abuse someone.

What you describe is exactly what this woman did to DP, and obviously its some pattern of behaviour with abusers of both sexes

OP posts:
Dramatic · 03/10/2023 21:48

Coffeaddict · 03/10/2023 21:37

I am so sorry you went through that.

I just want to clarify what I meant I did not mean males are not able to or do not psycholicically torture their victims. They of course do and it is a huge component to domestic abuse.
What I meant was that in this component of domestic abuse ie the non physical side of it that women can be incredibly manipulative and controlling. And some women are often better at it then males. I didn't mean that males don't also use psychological means to control

Some women are better at it than males, yeah better at it than non-abusive males 🙄 abusive women are not more manipulative and controlling than abusive men.

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 21:42

@Lavender14

Firstly, to go through your points. Johnny Depp was abusive to Amber Heard, so you can't use that as an example

See this is where the unconscious bias plats in. Amber Heard was the abuser. There was evidence of manipulation, gaslighting, grooming, lovebombing, isolating, coercive control, FOG, DARVO and even serious physical violence. There are tapes of her gloating, telling him no one will believe him and him - quite literally - hiding in the bathroom to get away. No victim of abuse is chasing their abuser around hiding in the bathroom!

He might or might not have been violent, but I doubt it given the recorded conversations I heard where she admitted it and called him a baby. But even if there was, she was DEFINITELY the abuser. You can't have mutual abuse. One person is scared and trapped in the cycle of abuse, and the other person is controlling it.

It's often portrayed in court as a 'crime of passion', of jealousy or anger and the male in question was simply unable to control his emotions because he was- a man. And it glazes over details that to me prove that he was actually in full control and it was a highly controlled and intentional act

Absolutely, but grooming and coercive control is a pattern! Courts should look at the power dynamic as a whole and understand abuse isn't about jealousy or passion. It's about control and scaring someone.

We have to protect women from this and we need to believe women when they ask for help because every 21 seconds police respond to a dv incident and every 2 weeks a woman is killed in the UK by a known partner

I completely agree and I'm not for a minute diminishing this.

OP posts: