Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 20:23

@1dayatatime

I completely agree with you and its a shame. I tried initially to ask people to stay off that topic and was accussed of policing the thread.

Can't win.

I'vtried d to engage every single person who's come here to actually talk about their horrible experiences, but I think maybe this just isn't the forum for it.

I can certainly understand why some people take this issue to heart, as its a projection in a way of their life experiences.

Victims of female abuse who haven't been believed, probably find it hard to see a celebrity example of that (that's certainly true for me).

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 20:15

@Mustardseed86

Yes, let's agree to disagree. But evidence that was excluded was excluded for a reason. If she has such evidence and makes it public and I found it to be credible then I'd take it on board.

Credible would mean some sort of proof (recordings or credible witness statements) and a story which made logical sense. Eg: going to get a restraining order against someone who you're simultaneously texting incessantly begging to see them isn't credible.

A makeup artist covering up bruises doesn't prove anything to me. The woman who abused us probably had bruises from bring physically removed from our property . She also had bruises once from falling drunk off a bar stool that she tried to say my DP gave her (thankfully there were witnesses). At one point she was drunk and stood in our garden repeatedly punching herself in the face. So unless there's proof he gave her bruises, it doesn't persuade me of anything.

If credible evidence was shown to me, and I was shown concrete proof that he also engaged in a pattern of abusive behaviour, psychological and / or physical then I might have a different view. I just haven't seen anything at all credible that indicates that. Her word insufficient- just as his would be had I not heard her confessing to it.

I don't believe, as a rational human being that if he had beaten her up for years on end, raped her with a broken bottle and so on that she would not have mentioned this in the recordings. I heard more than one recordings which go similar to this:

HIM: You hit me
HER: yes I did, but you keep "splitting"
HIM: Yes I'm leaving because I dont want to fight physically

Or
HIM: You hit me!
HER: (Lengthy confessions to repetitive hitting/ calling him a baby)

My logical brain can't conceive of any situation where if he had done a single thing she says he did that those conversations would have gone like that. They would have been like:

HIM: You hit me
HER: Maybe but you've hit me, kicked me, ripped my hair out, tried to kill me and raped me with a bottle.

As a logical person, there is no way I can conceive of that not being how those conversations would go. Hence I don't really believe he ever hit her.

I've never said she confessed to cutting his finger off. I said it was implied. As @Ilovebudgies says, during a conversation about her violence, he says "Amber I lost my finger man. I am having jars etc thrown at me" and she doesn't say "you didn't lose your finger because of me"; which makes sense surely? Hence I think his story that she chucked a bottle at him and he covered for her adds up.

This is based on logic. It has nothing to do with patriarchy or misogyny or PR campaigns. It's just adding up the facts

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 06/10/2023 19:47

FloydPepper · 06/10/2023 11:12

This thread is a mess. Op raised an interesting point and it was broadly being discussed until it all got derailed (op, sorry you did kind of start that) and then deteriorated into the usual arguing that always happens on threads about male victims.

a cynic might think that’s what some parties want

Sadly I have to fully agree with you. Several posters have mentioned about being physically abused by their mothers, partners ex's even sexually abused by their own mother.

In each case at the time when they tried to tell someone about it they were either ignored, minimised or simply not believed.

Regretfully on this thread those poor women are again being ignored because a limited number of posters want to bang on about pissing Amber Heard and Johnny Depp and their media circus trial which is not in any way central to the purpose of this thread.

And meanwhile real women and men with real horrific experiences of being abused mentally or physically by other women get ignored AGAIN.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 19:25

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 18:47

I agree
It does show the insidious nature of the patriarchy, that horrendous stiff like this can be written off as a "private joke"

But again you distract from the real damning evidence that shows her literally admitting to being an abuser by focussing on his private text messages and making it all about women and the patriarchy and misogyny. It always goes back to women being victims, it can NEVER be the woman's fault in your eyes.
You'd always find something not to like about a male victim in a trial, whether it be texts or comments, or behaviour. There is never a perfect victim and he was FAR from perfect, but a victim nonetheless.
I'm so glad there wasn't anyone like you in that jury and they were able to take an unbiased and fair view of the evidence.

Mustardseed86 · 06/10/2023 18:56

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 15:24

@mustard

She was proven to have lied...because you don't believe her?

I watched her on the witness stand. I didn't believe her, because nothing she said correlated with

  • Other witness accounts
  • The evidence (eg: tapes and texts)
  • Basic logic (eg: her claims made no sense)

One very obvious lie is going public as a domestic abuse victim when you've been routinely hitting your husband.

If the sex abuse story was debunked, I was unaware and apologise. But I think she's a liar because I've seen her with my eyes completely misrepresent truth.

There's a reason hundreds of acknowledged domestic abuse specialists and experts signed an open letter in support of her after the trial in Virginia

"Hundreds" = 130
"Acknowledged domestic abuse experts" is doing very heavy lifting here. A few organisations, yes. The list I read was stars, journalists and mostly feminist organisations. And yes, I think I know more about female abuse than most of those people who've unlikely experienced it. The "reason" they signed it is probably the same reason you are posting: they have a bias against male victims.

"No abuser would..." "No real victim would..."
Just STOP. You are NOT an expert on domestic violence/ abuse. You are an expert onyourexperience only

If you can find me any "expert" who says the victim is sometimes the one chasing their abuser around the house to hit them, or telling them for hours on end that they're a worthless person, I'd be happy to take that on.

and apparently projecting that onto Amber Heard based on a few snapshots at the very end of the relationship

I honestly think this is you. I think, as the thread suggests, that for some reason people project onto this case because she is a woman. I dont believe if she were a man that a soul on earth would be defending him.

My opinion is just that.

Yours is just that.

Ok, well as I said I wouldn't post anymore on your thread let's just agree to disagree. I don't think she isn't abusive because she's a woman though FYI, I heard the tapes and thought she came across very badly but the fact remains she has a lot of evidence (much of which was excluded due to some batshit interpretations of the hearsay rule) going back to very early in the relationship that she was a victim of pretty standard domestic abuse by a far more powerful partner.

Most of his witnesses were on his payroll, have demonstrated they're willing to overlook and cover up criminal activity for Depp, and several were swapped out between the UK and US trials to literally give what was previously another witness's testimony. So I'm not going to judge the entire relationship by some of her behaviour years into that scenario. I have zero doubts about the statements of e.g. her makeup artist who covered up bruises, or the situation in Australia when he was clearly psychotic and you keep falsely claiming she confessed to being responsible for his finger injury.

Whether she's a likeable or nice person is separate to the issue of whether she was a victim in that relationship who got to the point where felt it was better to stay and fight, for whatever reason.

As I've said I won't post anymore, I really won't this time and obviously I won't have changed your opinion and I'm sure you will continue to share your views on this as you see fit!

FrippEnos · 06/10/2023 18:49

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 12:37

I quoted your whole post. Can you clarify what you meant when you said "market forces" and "most women ridicule those same men until they are either ready to settle down or are done with the bad boys and want some emotional back up to bring up the children that the bad boys have abandoned."

Clearly its not reading how you intended it to.

A few things.
Other people understood well enough, one even found research to back up what I was saying.
So why should I try to explain when you are going to gaslight me again?
And just FYI, another trait of abusers is that they separate people out from friends, family and supporters. Why am I saying this? because this is what you tried to do with your 'look a man' stunt.
But enough about maybe you would like to discuss the OP's point.
It would make a change.

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 18:47

I agree
It does show the insidious nature of the patriarchy, that horrendous stiff like this can be written off as a "private joke"

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 17:33

Tandora · 06/10/2023 17:29

Can’t believe you are seriously defending a man saying he wants to fuck his partners burnt corpse.
horrifying.

You love a reaction like this don't you!
Taking something out of context and being oh so shocked. Just looking for an argument, I won't rise to it.

Tandora · 06/10/2023 17:29

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 16:39

🙄 I now truly give up.

Can’t believe you are seriously defending a man saying he wants to fuck his partners burnt corpse.
horrifying.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 16:39

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 16:18

If I message my friend and tell her my husband has been an absolute prick and I want to use his balls in a game of cricket would that make me an abuser?

If he accused you of being abusive and it went to court, that type of thing could be used as evidence, yes Confused

🙄 I now truly give up.

Twighlight55 · 06/10/2023 16:34

Stalking anyone, regardless of gender, is not acceptable behaviour, the charm offensive, is a common trait in abuse cases.

I lived for a while with someone of another sexual persuasion, I should add we were just house sharers, and she was being stalked by her x lover, it was truly frightening, a bit like a female version of psycho, however, it gets worse here, Jane, not her real name, made the situation worse by facilitating this individual, to the extent of inviting her over for tea and may I add, a bit of rumpy pumpy in between., instead of just cutting her off.

So, it ended up becoming a nightmare, as I never knew, when she might turn up, in the house, truly 😨 to say, the least.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 16:30

@Ilovebudgies

She could literally have video'd herself standing over him and punching him and in your eyes she would be a victim...because she's a woman

This.

I didn't want the thread to be about this celebrity couple, but I think people putting forward their arguments and reasoning was kind of helpful actually as its a good test case where the facts are all known and you can observe the way people think.

I wonder if what makes the difference is seeing the profound effect on a male victim for yourself. When we went through this together (obviously much worse for him), I healed better.

I watched what it did to him. Just a short fling with this woman and he went from happy and healthy to heavy drinking, mentally unstable, anxiety, paranoia, days off work.

Later were the night terrors, shaking in corners if the door went, sexual dysfunction, chronic illnesses, and profound depression.

It took him almost three years to be able to say "she was an abuser". Despite being hit, blackmailed, almost run over, stalked, blah blah. It didn't fit with his idea of what a "man" went through.

She was just "emotional" or "mentally unstable" or "a heavy drinker".

It reached a point of a complete breakdown 3 years on from life altering PTSD for him to say he wanted to feel joy and feel safe again and he finally sought help.

Once he was able to see it and get support from a counsellor he started to get well again, but she damaged us both and our lives no different to a natural disaster. For years we were shadows.

I think if men are able to speak out and be believed and be supported without being laughed at our dismissed it might make it easier to recover.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 16:18

If I message my friend and tell her my husband has been an absolute prick and I want to use his balls in a game of cricket would that make me an abuser?

If he accused you of being abusive and it went to court, that type of thing could be used as evidence, yes Confused

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 16:16

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 16:07

You're making assumptions about what an abuser looks like. That isn't evidence. A man showing signs of being a misogynist doesn't make him an abuser.
Have you seen the film's that he was referencing in his texts? Do you know where the references came from? Probably not, so you are taking it completely out of context. It was a private conversation between friends.
If I message my friend and tell her my husband has been an absolute prick and I want to use his balls in a game of cricket would that make me an abuser?

It is similar to my example because it is making an assumption that 'the type of person' who dresses like that is more likely to be up for it, therefore more likely to have consented and 'wanted it', more likely to not be a victim.
You are saying that a the "type of man' who acts like that is more likely to be a misogynist and less likely to be a victim. It is just a distraction from the evidence.

Her defence dragged in his text messages to diminish his character, but he never denied any of it. He was never trying to paint himself as being a stand up man or perfect, just that he was a victim of her abuse.

I didn't say it did.
Research shows male abuse is often underpinned by entitled and misogynistic attitudes of the man (read "Why does he do that?")

Johnny's texts show he has an entitled and misogynistic attitude (she's wronged me, therefore deserves to be murdered and sexually degraded)

That's consistent with an abusers attitude. It doesn't mean he is definitely abusively but it is relevant to the case.

Remember, the case was about whether it was accurate to describe him as an abuser, not whether she was the abuser.

To go back to your example, if a woman was being prosecuted for wasting police time by making false allegations of sexual assault, then maybe her clothes and attitude could be relevant.

If its a case where a man is being prosecuted and she's a victim of assault, then they aren't.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 16:13

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 16:09

You need to look into the effects of stonewalling in relationships

See... always finding an excuse. There MUST be a reason she did it, must be some convoluted theory to why she repeatedly hit him chased after him belittled him and threw things at him and started fights with him.
She could literally have video'd herself standing over him and punching him and in your eyes she would be a victim...because she's a woman.
I give up.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 16:12

@AdamRyan

I understand what stonewalling is. I also understand it is NOT taking space during a fight. Particularly if you're being repeatedly hit during those fights.

OP posts:
Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 16:07

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 15:41

Jokes about raping and murdering women are consistent with a man who is misogynistic and thinks using sex and violence to get what you want is OK.

Abusive men also commonly have those attitudes.

We were not meant to see or hear any of the stuff presented in court, that's kind of the point.

It's exactly the same as when a man doesn't want to believe a woman and says 'well look at her, she's a slut anyway, who would dress like that' to diminish her character. It's irrelevant.

It's nothing like that at all. That's usually used to discredit victims of sex assault, by claiming they brought it on themselves/its "regretful".
Depps texts just expose his attitudes to women.

Anyway that's irrelevant because the thread is about female abusers, using AH as an example. I don't believe there is strong evidence she was abusive and I think we should apply "innocent until proven guilty" equally to men and women.

You're making assumptions about what an abuser looks like. That isn't evidence. A man showing signs of being a misogynist doesn't make him an abuser.
Have you seen the film's that he was referencing in his texts? Do you know where the references came from? Probably not, so you are taking it completely out of context. It was a private conversation between friends.
If I message my friend and tell her my husband has been an absolute prick and I want to use his balls in a game of cricket would that make me an abuser?

It is similar to my example because it is making an assumption that 'the type of person' who dresses like that is more likely to be up for it, therefore more likely to have consented and 'wanted it', more likely to not be a victim.
You are saying that a the "type of man' who acts like that is more likely to be a misogynist and less likely to be a victim. It is just a distraction from the evidence.

Her defence dragged in his text messages to diminish his character, but he never denied any of it. He was never trying to paint himself as being a stand up man or perfect, just that he was a victim of her abuse.

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 16:04

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 15:58

@AdamRyan

I didn't say that. I said we don't know if she was "driven to it", which is a common defence to male violence. One you have used for Depp and for your own male partner

No, defending yourself when someone is physically attacking you is self defence. Assaulting a sleeping partner is not self defence and I can't see how you'd be driven to it.

She said he wasn't asleep he was texting a girl.
We don't know because it never went to court.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 15:58

@AdamRyan

I didn't say that. I said we don't know if she was "driven to it", which is a common defence to male violence. One you have used for Depp and for your own male partner

No, defending yourself when someone is physically attacking you is self defence. Assaulting a sleeping partner is not self defence and I can't see how you'd be driven to it.

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 15:56

@AdamRyan

She says she was worried he would seriously hurt her. Why are you minimising that?

I do not believe that if you are seriously worried someone will seriously hurt you that you sit there taunting them, belittling them, laughing at them and bullying them verbally. I think if you're scared someone will seriously hurt you, that's the last thing you'd do.

I do not believe that if you are seriously worried someone will seriously hurt you that you would repeatedly physically attack them, chase after them when they are trying to escape, or call them a "baby" because they won't fight you.

I think those things are a clear indication she knew he would definitely not hurt her, no matter how much she provoked him.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 15:55

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 15:29

@AdamRyan

braykesomeone did call CF an abuser.
I think she was abusive but not an abuser. When I said that you said I was implying how your husband was treated was OK and I was minimising DV

Now you are agreeing with me

No, I was just calling out that you said she was driven to it. I can't see how anyone is driven to that. Its not self defence if they're asleep.

But I know little about it so I reserve judgement on who she was. I simply have no idea as I've never heard her story or the full facts.

I didn't say that. I said we don't know if she was "driven to it", which is a common defence to male violence. One you have used for Depp and for your own male partner.

You might want to reflect on why you think men can be driven to violence, and that's acceptable. But if a woman is violent, its because she is an abuser.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 15:51

@AdamRyan

He wasn't "asking for space" he was saying nothing at all. You are projecting

Yes he does. He literally says repeatedly to her that they need a physical separation to calm down and he will come back and talk to her.

He says "you can call me a coward, you can call me anything you like, but I am NOT getting into a physical fight with you Amber"

He was doing the right thing.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 15:49

And as I said, your partners ex could probably have got him to admit his "abuse" on tape while they were together, that shows nothing if the "abuse" is actually a result of extreme provocation from an abusive partner.

She says she was worried he would seriously hurt her. Why are you minimising that?

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 15:46

He wasn't "asking for space" he was saying nothing at all. You are projecting.

I cannot imagine what texts you could send that would be worse to be honest. The minimisation of that is appalling.