Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 09:01

@5128gap

You cannot claim that greater physical strength, status and resources has 'nothing to do with the dynamics of an abusive relationship'. All of those things serve to not only reduce ones liklihood of becoming a victim, but also provide invaluable protection and exit opportunities from abusive situations that are unavailable to those who lack them

Sorry but these thought patterns play into why male victims are so often not taken seriously.

Abuse victims aren't unable to leave because they're too physically small or don't have money. They are groomed, then devalued, then trapped in an abuse cycle that often takes years to fully understand.

Being physically bigger that his abuser didn't stop my DPs abuser from abusing him. It just made it less possible for him to defend himself without being vilified.

It also did nothing to stop the psychological abuse, which was far worse than any bruises on him. He was not weak, he was not poor, he was not physically vulnerable- but he was a victim of abuse.

Exit opportunity is not generally why DV and abuse victims dont leave. They are much more likely to stay because they're in trauma bonds and have been groomed and then psychologically broken down.

Add to that, female abusers typically use threats to terrify a man. "I will say you raped me" and "I will say you hit me" and quite often if the man has a good job or a powerful position in life he had even more to lose when such threats are made.

My DP worked in law enforcement in a high up rope when this happened to him, and despite that he felt there was nothing he could do to stop her- so he tried to appease her.

OP posts:
JellyGrownUps · 04/10/2023 09:00

Definitely.

Some people seem to think women are either incapable of it or must have been driven to it by a man or have some kind of emotional problem, mental illness or trauma

Which is usually the case with male offenders too but they are thought about very, very differently.

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 08:52

5128gap · 04/10/2023 08:41

You cannot claim that greater physical strength, status and resources has 'nothing to do with the dynamics of an abusive relationship'. All of those things serve to not only reduce ones liklihood of becoming a victim, but also provide invaluable protection and exit opportunities from abusive situations that are unavailable to those who lack them.
Cases where abuse is carried out by someone smaller, weaker, with fewer resources, less privelege, less power on someone with a great deal more, are by no means the norm; so should be explored as the anonimily they are, rather than misrepresented as demonstrating a behavioural pattern, for no apparant reason than to argue that women are as bad as men.

You've worded this really well. I wanted to reply to that but didn't know how to word it. There's an extra layer of terror when your abuser is a foot taller than you, almost double your weight and can send you flying across a room with a small push when you know if you tried to push back with all your weight their feet wouldn't even move. Knowing they could strangle you, smash your head against a wall, repeatedly punch you or physically stop you from escaping and there's absolutely nothing you can do about any of it definitely has a bearing on the dynamics of the relationship.

itsmyp4rty · 04/10/2023 08:51

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 08:13

@Sigmama

Your defence of Johnny Depp is disturbing. Abuse can happen on both sides in a relationship

Only one person is the "abuser" in a true abusive relationship. I think Jonny Depp is an alcoholic, unfaithful, weak and generally unpleasant man. I have also heard evidence that demonstrates beyond all doubt that he is a victim of an abusive Amber Heard.

When it comes to power dynamics, Depp wins hands down in both physicality and status. Having been the victim of abuse, it is the superior physical power of men that has been the clincher

Physical strength, size, and money or status have absolutely nothing to do with the dynamics of an abusive relationship.

My DP was bigger, stronger, superior in status and wealth to his abuser and that made absolutely no difference.

I'm with you OP, I've no time for JD he's certainly not good BF material, he's got addictions left right and centre and pretty messed up. But AH is a whole other level and I think probably ticks a lot of boxes for Narcisistic personality disorder, most of the attributes you list in one of your posts. The one thing that nailed it for me though was her chameleon nature - meeting JD and immediately liking everything he liked, it's how people with NPD get you to like them IME, they become a reflection of you. It all seems super, super perfect and then you fall of the pedestal and the devaluation starts.

I think though what it comes down to at the end of the day is that emotional abuse is not viewed in any where near the same light as physical abuse. And if there is physical abuse by a woman then there is generally the view that they must have been driven to it or it is down played.

All that said of course 99 times out of 100 the man is the perpetrator - but that doesn't mean it's not possible for women to be capable of going to the same lengths.

5128gap · 04/10/2023 08:41

You cannot claim that greater physical strength, status and resources has 'nothing to do with the dynamics of an abusive relationship'. All of those things serve to not only reduce ones liklihood of becoming a victim, but also provide invaluable protection and exit opportunities from abusive situations that are unavailable to those who lack them.
Cases where abuse is carried out by someone smaller, weaker, with fewer resources, less privelege, less power on someone with a great deal more, are by no means the norm; so should be explored as the anonimily they are, rather than misrepresented as demonstrating a behavioural pattern, for no apparant reason than to argue that women are as bad as men.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 08:40

Perhaps those here to defend a proven, self confessed female abuser, can remember this thread is full of victims of female abuse. Perhaps instead of derailing it to defend a celebrity, you can instead allow them the room and space to speak. Maybe listen and learn from their experience if this is a topic that interests you.

OP posts:
BrokeAsABone · 04/10/2023 08:21

Jonny Depp is abusive ffs. You stress about female abusers being excused then do it yourself about male abusers. Such a hypocrite.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 08:13

@Sigmama

Your defence of Johnny Depp is disturbing. Abuse can happen on both sides in a relationship

Only one person is the "abuser" in a true abusive relationship. I think Jonny Depp is an alcoholic, unfaithful, weak and generally unpleasant man. I have also heard evidence that demonstrates beyond all doubt that he is a victim of an abusive Amber Heard.

When it comes to power dynamics, Depp wins hands down in both physicality and status. Having been the victim of abuse, it is the superior physical power of men that has been the clincher

Physical strength, size, and money or status have absolutely nothing to do with the dynamics of an abusive relationship.

My DP was bigger, stronger, superior in status and wealth to his abuser and that made absolutely no difference.

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 08:07

@MaryShelleysMonster

My very first post on this thread, in case you missed it - 'Abusive relationships need to be taken seriously and policed accordingly. Whataboutery that dimishes the statistics on abuse enables authorities and society to continue to ignore it.'

As has been clearly pointed out to you, YOU have not read the content of the thread. Talking about male victims is not "whataboutery".

Don't bother replying to me. I won't be back. I've replied throughout in good faith

No, you've not replied in good faith. You've said things which aren't true, and then three times now tried to silence us from discussing female abuse. Pointing me twice to Reddit, despite this thread being full of female abuse victims telling their very painful real life stories.

OP posts:
Sigmama · 04/10/2023 08:05

Your defence of Johnny Depp is disturbing. Abuse can happen on both sides in a relationship. When it comes to power dynamics, Depp wins hands down in both physicality and status. Having been the victim of abuse, it is the superior physical power of men that has been the clincher.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 08:02

@x2boys

Wwll.youonly have to look at the Lucy Letby,threads whilst most people accept she was guilty ,there is a very vocal minority who are determined she isn't and if she is it's everybody's fault but hers

Yes... I also felt her age, gender, looks, class etc
played into this. As if she'd been 50+, poor, or "weird" people would have believed it, but their opinion is so blinded by their perceived notion of what a pretty young blonde girl might be, they can't see what she actually IS.

OP posts:
MaryShelleysMonster · 04/10/2023 08:00

My very first post on this thread, in case you missed it - 'Abusive relationships need to be taken seriously and policed accordingly. Whataboutery that dimishes the statistics on abuse enables authorities and society to continue to ignore it.'

Don't bother replying to me. I won't be back. I've replied throughout in good faith and have worked with charities working on DV in RL. I hope you get whatever you're looking for out of this thread. But if your expectation is rehashing the Depp case in a way that suits you, then it's unlikely you will. As I pointed out Reddit or X/Twitter would suit you better for that.

wafflyversatile · 04/10/2023 08:00

Something I've noticed on here over the years is womens behaviour being more likely to be described as toxic rather than abusive.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 07:58

Obviously, she was. There are audio tapes of her admitting physical abuse and engaging in psychological abuse.

I am not here to debate that case. Anyone wishing to deny the evidence of their eyes and ears is exactly the type of person this thread is about.

If people can quite literally hear tapes of people admitting cutting off someone's finger, hitting them, devaluing them, threatening them and telling them no one will believe them if they speak out, then it rather proves why its so hard for men to speak up.

OP posts:
Dramatic · 04/10/2023 07:57

Coffeaddict · 03/10/2023 23:12

Some abusive women can be as good as if not more so manipulative and controlling than males. But like I said obviously abusive males can also be.

Have you encountered all abusers that you can definitely say this. Because the the number of female perpetrators lf domestic abuse jumped massively when coercive control was included in the definition

How can you possibly know they're better at it than males?! You do know that even in physically abusive cases the men are coercively controlling? It doesn't go from a happy healthy relationship to him randomly battering her one day.

And the number of female abusers might have jumped up but it's still nowhere near the number of men, and there are tons of men out there who have never been caught or prosecuted for abuse. I know of a few personally myself.

I think all abusers are scum, regardless of gender. But female abusers aren't "better" at it.

Mustardseed86 · 04/10/2023 07:54

Amber Heard was not an abuser.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 07:54

@nobodysdaughternow

I am so terribly sorry x

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 07:53

@MaryShelleysMonster

As I've clearly said all the way through the thread, I am a woman.

I understand the cases very well, no need to jump to patronising or trying to silence me because you've not got any evidence.

I've formed my view on evidence heard with my own ears out of Ms Heards mouth.

I think your leap to ignore my clearly stated gender, to levy clearly untrue accusations towards me, as well as the clearly observable facts of what you're discussing is a good indication of the desperation of some to be wilfully obtuse around female to male abuse.

OP posts:
x2boys · 04/10/2023 07:46

Wwll.you only have to look at the Lucy Letby,threads whilst most people accept she was guilty ,there is a very vocal minority who are determined she isn't and if she is it's everybody's fault but hers .

MaryShelleysMonster · 04/10/2023 07:38

If you want to rehash the Depp case, you can search for one of the many threads that already exist on here. You'll find both the cases discussed in depth and possibly (although I'm guessing not) see what you have misunderstood about the UK case and its findings.
If you're looking for support for yourself, then the NHS runs a men's advice line. Plus there is the ManKind initiative.
If you simply want to 'debate' about celebrity abuse cases then Reddit is probably better for that.

nobodysdaughternow · 04/10/2023 07:36

As was abused by a female as a child. It is rarely taken seriously when an abuser is female.

My FiL was recently astonished when I said dh and I are physically afraid of my Mother.

I had to remind him that she physically abused me and dh has seen her angry and physically aggressive.

I am at peace that some jump to defend a woman because she's 'just a Mum, trying her best'. I moved 200 miles away, changed my name and will never see her again, so I don't need to convince anyone of anything.

BraykeDance · 04/10/2023 07:29

@MaryShelleysMonster

The UK findings in the Depp case were clear

The UK Depp case was a defamation trial. Answering only one question:

"Could the newspaper have REASONABLY BELIEVED what they printed was true"

Answer: yes (because they had a supposed victim claiming it was true)

It was never "proven" to be true. That is not how defamation legislation works in the courts of England and Wales.

Similarly I could tell a newspaper YOU abused ME, and unless someone can prove you didn't (which is generally impossible as its one word against the other), it would not be defamation.

That's why newspapers are allowed to print almost anything - including many allegations later proved false. Unless you can prove they KNEW it was false.

Please think here. If Heard had a shred of evidence to support her claims, they would have been presented in the US trial.

OP posts:
MaryShelleysMonster · 04/10/2023 07:14

The UK findings in the Depp case were clear including that Depp's team paid for posters to inundate social media pushing 'his' narrative.

1Step2Step · 04/10/2023 02:04

I thought that as a whole, women are more prevalent as the perpetrators of both physical abuse and neglect towards children. Statistically it makes sense as they tend to be the primary caregivers.

For abuse that is considered severe physical abuse it leans more towards men.

For sexual abuse it is predominantly men.

For emotional abuse (which is hard to categorise ) it’s about 50/50.

Swipe left for the next trending thread