Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Coffeaddict · 04/10/2023 10:46

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 07:57

How can you possibly know they're better at it than males?! You do know that even in physically abusive cases the men are coercively controlling? It doesn't go from a happy healthy relationship to him randomly battering her one day.

And the number of female abusers might have jumped up but it's still nowhere near the number of men, and there are tons of men out there who have never been caught or prosecuted for abuse. I know of a few personally myself.

I think all abusers are scum, regardless of gender. But female abusers aren't "better" at it.

I have said several times that of course males are capable of this. I have never denied that coercive control is a major component of domestic abuse.

What you seem incapable of seeing is that this aspect of abuse is something that women are just as capable of. This is the major problem in this thread and society I general. To perceive that a woman is incapable of these behaviours undermines victims regardless of their sex.

The pp who mentions the links in lesbian relationships absolutely highlights this.

And once again to be clear I never said that males are not the main perpetrators. they absolutely are however the automatic discounting of females as perpetrators of abuse is wrong

TotalOverhaul · 04/10/2023 10:44

I have known a few men who were abused by women. One was not believed at all until he was at a friend's house and his wife rang them, screaming and banging furniture, to tell them he was beating her up. They finally believed his story. Another man I know had to sneak down the road and hide for days in a friend's house to avoid being beaten up. he was so ashamed, he refused to go to the police. And someone I know has an ongoing absolutely terrifying ordeal with a female stalker, including threats on her life, having to move to safe houses, being unsafe to go into work. The woman was imprisoned for her stalking but is out now and back at it.

Treatment of reporting of abuse should not be different according to sex. There may be different ways of operating but they are no less of an ordeal to the victim.

JellyGrownUps · 04/10/2023 10:43

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 04/10/2023 10:32

Someone mentioned abuse in lesbian couples so I had a look

And it seems to be a huge problem. One I wasn't aware of. Wow

It was me! And yes, massive problem.

Which is why the posters who always say men commit 90+ % of violent crime and 95+% of sexual crime are ignoring that those statistics are based on Police reports, charging, and conviction rates.

We already know male on female rape Police reports, charges and convictions are not in any way reflective of the actual scale of rape in this country.

And the same applies to female perpetrators of abuse, violence and sexual abuse/violence who are even less likely to be reported than men in many instances.

There are a huge number of female abuse perpetrators out there who aren't 'officially' recognised or documented.

As much as men? No. But a significant number? More than the crime statistics tell us? Absolutely.

hamstersarse · 04/10/2023 10:42

BurntToastAgain88 · 04/10/2023 10:35

But all of this takes place against a backdrop of millennia of misogyny where women have been painted as liars, deceitful, weak and prone to corruption (Eve anyone? Delilah?) and so men have an inherent advantage in our society in that they are naturally seen as more truthful, honest and morally strong and the voices of authority. Most judges, police officers etc are men. Power matters.

I understand where you are coming from, but I am not sure it is helpful.

I think the point is that women do claim power even in these circumstances - my experience is that they work just on the fringes and using these power structures for their own gain. They manipulate children, play the victim with false accusations (I hate that phrase but is is a tactic used in these abusive circumstances), conduct smear campaigns, harass people etc. It seemed to me that when you come across one of these women, you can see that they understand the power dynamics perfectly and are still able to use them to their advantage - i.e. through smear campaigns, through how we regard children etc.

PhantomUnicorn · 04/10/2023 10:37

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

BurntToastAgain88 · 04/10/2023 10:35

But all of this takes place against a backdrop of millennia of misogyny where women have been painted as liars, deceitful, weak and prone to corruption (Eve anyone? Delilah?) and so men have an inherent advantage in our society in that they are naturally seen as more truthful, honest and morally strong and the voices of authority. Most judges, police officers etc are men. Power matters.

Mustardseed86 · 04/10/2023 10:34

FrippEnos · 04/10/2023 10:15

Civil standards are the balance of probability and note the "substantially" not "true" as in he may have done this on the balance of probabilities.

Substantially true means the 'essential' or 'substantial' truth of the claim has been proven, to the civil standard. The balance of probabilities doesn't mean it's not proven, it just means the bar isn't as high as for a criminal case. There still has to be strong evidence! Defamation cases in the UK are weighted towards the claimant, so the fact that this case was won on a truth defence is not something you can just shrug off.

hamstersarse · 04/10/2023 10:34

Pancakefam · 04/10/2023 10:33

FFS, if people keep describing abusive women as crazy, then they're more likely to be excused as their behaviour can be blamed on poor mental health. Ironically it seems to be those agreeing with the OP that are using the term most.

Fair point

I am using that term mainly because that seems to be the code word in culture for an abusive woman

Pancakefam · 04/10/2023 10:33

FFS, if people keep describing abusive women as crazy, then they're more likely to be excused as their behaviour can be blamed on poor mental health. Ironically it seems to be those agreeing with the OP that are using the term most.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 04/10/2023 10:32

Someone mentioned abuse in lesbian couples so I had a look

And it seems to be a huge problem. One I wasn't aware of. Wow

hamstersarse · 04/10/2023 10:31

The amount of people that believed my ex when he said that all three of his exes (including me) were "crazy" and had banded together to make up all these allegations and take his children from him is madness. And they really truly believe him.

That is a serious problem in all of this

Abusive men will blame their 'crazy ex's' and generally be pretty good at convincing people that they were indeed crazy

Men who have genuinely been subjected to a 'crazy ex' are then put in that category, or in my experience, are not very good at convincing people they were actually crazy, perhaps because they feel some shame?

And then you have the real 'crazy ex' woman playing the victim and smearing the non-abusive man, and generally being quite convincing

And we are all left wondering what the hell to believe!

In summary though, abusers tend to be quite good at convincing people it is the other person's fault. This is programmed into the operating system, and makes it all very difficult to work out what is going on

Tandora · 04/10/2023 10:30

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:25

The amount of people that believed my ex when he said that all three of his exes (including me) were "crazy" and had banded together to make up all these allegations and take his children from him is madness. And they really truly believe him.

Exactly

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:29

JellyGrownUps · 04/10/2023 10:27

We know.

But that shouldn't equal that female on male violence should be minimised or excused and it so often is, including on MN.

I've seen threads on MN where a poster says they 'lost their shit' with their DP/DH and hit him, kicked him or threw something and you get a lot of responses saying "not great OP but it probably didn't hurt him, get some therapy but can you go somewhere to cool off?"

If a woman posts that her partner hit her, kicked her or threw something there are immediate calls to call the Police and get out now, run...LTB this will only get worse.

Which is good advice. But also should apply to a female poster admitting she's assaulted her male partner. And some posters will say that but many will also say "she's not an abuser FFS, she lost her shit because x, y, z, she feels bad about it so people need to stop making her feel worse"

I can't say I've ever seen a thread like that but I will take your word for it and in those cases yes it should be treated as an abusive situation. But it still matters that there's a physical power imbalance.

Tandora · 04/10/2023 10:29

YABU . Johnny Depp is an abuser, not a victim. And your example demonstrates how the bias in fact goes the other way. As for female stalking , why do you think the term “bunny boiler” is so popular and the film fatal attraction considered such a classic?

TLDR: YABU

BurntToastAgain88 · 04/10/2023 10:28

But victims aren’t disbelieved when they are male. We are, because of patriarchy inclined to believe men over women. Look at the worst rapist in British history, Reynard Singa, who is thought to have raped over 200 men. I never saw anything but sympathy and compassion for his victims (rightly so) despite many of them being incapacitated due to drugs and alcohol. In contrast, women victims of rape are routinely questioned and disbelieved because they drank, took drugs, were promiscuous or knew/had slept with their rapist previously. There is a horrendous double standard going on there.

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:27

FloydPepper · 04/10/2023 10:22

You may be right. The previous post said size is irrelevant, when they probably should have said size CAN be irrelevant.

I think in some cases it can have nothing to do with it. In others it will. Blanket statements either way probably aren’t helpful

Yes, it is irrelevant if the case is purely psychological abuse, but as soon as it turns physical or even just the threat of physical abuse it can massively affect the dynamics.

JellyGrownUps · 04/10/2023 10:27

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:18

I don't think she's saying it's the only way someone can be a perpetrator, but that you can't say it has nothing to do with the dynamic if the abuser is in fact bigger and stronger.

We know.

But that shouldn't equal that female on male violence should be minimised or excused and it so often is, including on MN.

I've seen threads on MN where a poster says they 'lost their shit' with their DP/DH and hit him, kicked him or threw something and you get a lot of responses saying "not great OP but it probably didn't hurt him, get some therapy but can you go somewhere to cool off?"

If a woman posts that her partner hit her, kicked her or threw something there are immediate calls to call the Police and get out now, run...LTB this will only get worse.

Which is good advice. But also should apply to a female poster admitting she's assaulted her male partner. And some posters will say that but many will also say "she's not an abuser FFS, she lost her shit because x, y, z, she feels bad about it so people need to stop making her feel worse"

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:25

BurntToastAgain88 · 04/10/2023 10:21

My DH was a victim of domestic violence. His ex fiancée was horrendous- violent, vicious, emotionally and financially abusive (she stole £10k from him), but he says he never felt afraid for his life the way I did when my violent ex tried to throw me down the stairs.

I also think the fact people are defending Depp and still trying to assign blame to Amber Heard, clearly demonstrates that male victims of domestic violence are taken seriously and believed and this really undermines the OP’s argument (although I would argue Depp isn’t a victim of domestic violence). I think men are more often believed these days when they say an ex was abusive and this is not minimised as the OP claims. unfortunately many abusive men know this and try to twist the facts to present themselves as victims - my abusive ex did, it was always the awful women who had treated him poorly, never that he was controlling and violent.

I don’t think any rational person believes that women can’t also be abusive. They can and they are but not usually to the same extent or intensity that men are.

The amount of people that believed my ex when he said that all three of his exes (including me) were "crazy" and had banded together to make up all these allegations and take his children from him is madness. And they really truly believe him.

PhantomUnicorn · 04/10/2023 10:25

good lord, can we stop using JD/AH to derail the point of the thread. I couldn't give a flying fuck about either of them, and they're not what i'm here to discuss.

FloydPepper · 04/10/2023 10:24

BurntToastAgain88 · 04/10/2023 10:21

My DH was a victim of domestic violence. His ex fiancée was horrendous- violent, vicious, emotionally and financially abusive (she stole £10k from him), but he says he never felt afraid for his life the way I did when my violent ex tried to throw me down the stairs.

I also think the fact people are defending Depp and still trying to assign blame to Amber Heard, clearly demonstrates that male victims of domestic violence are taken seriously and believed and this really undermines the OP’s argument (although I would argue Depp isn’t a victim of domestic violence). I think men are more often believed these days when they say an ex was abusive and this is not minimised as the OP claims. unfortunately many abusive men know this and try to twist the facts to present themselves as victims - my abusive ex did, it was always the awful women who had treated him poorly, never that he was controlling and violent.

I don’t think any rational person believes that women can’t also be abusive. They can and they are but not usually to the same extent or intensity that men are.

And the substantive point of the original post was agreeing that yes, it’s not to the same extent and that can be what leads to the victims being disbelieved.

Catsafterme · 04/10/2023 10:23

I mean size and strength wise yes there is a imbalance there but that depends on the person. A man that is large that is aggressive and utilizes that strength can cause more damage but that's not always the case, it comes down to the person.

Like a lot of people you may look at a small woman and think, there's no way she could be abusive or dangerous, especially not against a man who is larger and stronger.

In my case I was taller but I'm not large framed or built and I'm not aggressive, certainly not towards women but people would still look at it that I must be the problem. Wherein reality I wasn't the one being aggressive or violent behind closed doors and I wasn't the one neglecting or abusive towards our children.

As I said before I think you'll run into way more abusive men than women but they are out there, just rarer I think. I for one have found that all the behaviors women post about on here about abusive husbands or partners is the exactly same behavior I have received, it's strangely similar. I can relate to what people are experiencing and others here have helped me understand too.

It's just not seen or believed the same as it's not the norm. As I said I've only ran into one abusive woman in my time but plenty of abusive men.

Just like with abusive men, mine is still continuing now after separation. I am out but it is not over by a long shot.

FloydPepper · 04/10/2023 10:22

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:18

I don't think she's saying it's the only way someone can be a perpetrator, but that you can't say it has nothing to do with the dynamic if the abuser is in fact bigger and stronger.

You may be right. The previous post said size is irrelevant, when they probably should have said size CAN be irrelevant.

I think in some cases it can have nothing to do with it. In others it will. Blanket statements either way probably aren’t helpful

BurntToastAgain88 · 04/10/2023 10:21

My DH was a victim of domestic violence. His ex fiancée was horrendous- violent, vicious, emotionally and financially abusive (she stole £10k from him), but he says he never felt afraid for his life the way I did when my violent ex tried to throw me down the stairs.

I also think the fact people are defending Depp and still trying to assign blame to Amber Heard, clearly demonstrates that male victims of domestic violence are taken seriously and believed and this really undermines the OP’s argument (although I would argue Depp isn’t a victim of domestic violence). I think men are more often believed these days when they say an ex was abusive and this is not minimised as the OP claims. unfortunately many abusive men know this and try to twist the facts to present themselves as victims - my abusive ex did, it was always the awful women who had treated him poorly, never that he was controlling and violent.

I don’t think any rational person believes that women can’t also be abusive. They can and they are but not usually to the same extent or intensity that men are.

hamstersarse · 04/10/2023 10:21

Incorrect. Twelve separate assaults were proven to the civil standard and the claim Depp was a wifebeater was found to be 'substantially true'.

This is clutching at straws. It in no way demonstrates that Amber Heard was not an abuser. Like pp has highlighted - did you hear the tapes of the things she said to him? It is clear abuse, but that was not what was on trial.

The crazy ex of my partner once started screaming, crying and pushing him in a hotel corridor shouting "RAPE RAPE, he's just RAPED me". People find that hard to believe and probably think I am some sort of denial about my partner, but she was very pissed and very pissed off that he had wanted to leave the function and that was it, nothing more. Women exist like this, and my feel on JD and AH is that she pushed every button known to man, gaslighted if you like, and he occasionally flipped - no, I am not excusing that, but having been in an abusive relationship myself, part of the dynamic is that you are pushed quite regularly to nearly flipping out so they can then accuse you of what they are.

Dramatic · 04/10/2023 10:18

FloydPepper · 04/10/2023 10:13

With respect, if you believe that only someone with a physical size advantage, or some other form of status, can be a perpetrator then you are wrong.

again, to be clear, I’m not saying that’s not true for the majority of cases. But to say it’s always the case is not correct

I don't think she's saying it's the only way someone can be a perpetrator, but that you can't say it has nothing to do with the dynamic if the abuser is in fact bigger and stronger.