Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the high volume of male abusers means some people find it hard to see when a female is an abuser?

534 replies

BraykeDance · 03/10/2023 18:27

Having experienced first hand fairly extreme abuse from a female, I feel a bit like even in 2023 some people struggle to believe women are capable of extreme psychological, emotional and even physical abuse.

I find often people want to victim blame by implying the man must have deserved it or driven her to it. Amber Heard being a great example of an abuser where I think if she were a man people would see much more clearly that she is an abuser.

I understand men (for reasons I don't understand) have a greater tendency to be abusers in the sense of power and control; but women do this too sometimes.

I found, as someone recovering from such am abuser, that many people minimised it and almost normalised behaviour that would certainly mean prison for a man.

Which made healing as a victim a lot harder. And also made it far easier for the abuser to continue.

AIBU to think we hold women to a different standard and sometimes reframe abusive behaviour or coercive control to fit with the idea of the female victim?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
16
Katypp · 09/10/2023 11:43

I think there's just a general feeling that women are always victims and nothing is ever their fault when a men can be blamed.
My husband was a victim of parental alienation syndrome when his ex utterly poisoned his sons - we know he was because the family court, CAFCAS and the contact centre all said so. So I usually contribute to threads about contact centres, dads not seeing their children etc etc when no-one is ever prepared to even consider any of the agencies might actually have a point and maybe, just maybe, the mother might actually be in the wrong.
I am inevitably told I am lying or that my husband is lying.
I was even described as a 'shiny-eyed new wife' once - we have been married for nearly 20 years and have two teenage kids fgs.
But my favourite response ever, when I said my husband had spend £20k+ on court fees, travelled a 200-mile round trip every weekend for a year to be told' the children don't want to see you', continued to pay maintenance well, well over the CMS amount and finally gave up when his ex ran out of legal aid and wanted to apply for more funding in their 10-year-old son's name and threatened to bring the children into court, was 'Well, he sounds like a Prince OP"
I think that was the point when I thought there's no reasoning with some people

FrippEnos · 07/10/2023 19:22

Beefcurtains79 · 07/10/2023 06:48

“A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.”

This just sounds like someone who simply just no longer has time to do all the activities that they did when he didn’t have any children, a spouse or responsibilities?
Also, if he was 34 at the time, why were you ‘pretending to be grown ups’?!
He was an actual grown up no? And he’d be in his 40’s now.
How utterly bizarre.

I would tell you of several of the people that I know, but no doubt your response will be just as scathing.

And I have no doubt that several posters would claim that I am making it all up.

trainboundfornowhere · 07/10/2023 16:50

Beefcurtains79 · 07/10/2023 06:48

“A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.”

This just sounds like someone who simply just no longer has time to do all the activities that they did when he didn’t have any children, a spouse or responsibilities?
Also, if he was 34 at the time, why were you ‘pretending to be grown ups’?!
He was an actual grown up no? And he’d be in his 40’s now.
How utterly bizarre.

He is now 50 and I am 39. Yes we are and were then adults but that doesn’t mean we constantly had to be grown up. Of course we have responsibilities, he is married and a father of two and I’m married and a stepmother of four.

He isn’t even allowed 1 day to do anything. He gave up his job because his wife didn’t like him being away 12 hours a day and making deliveries to shops that were predominantly staffed by women. He does everything for his children whilst his wife does nothing but complain.

Catsafterme · 07/10/2023 16:34

@Ilovebudgies Agree. Having experienced isolation it's not that you don't want to go out and continue as you were but more of a case of everyone you know is deemed a threat and are kept at a distance or cut off. Previous things you enjoyed doing are deemed a waste of time, your priorities should be them and not being able to enjoy yourself.

Any attempt to continue as you were and ignore it was met with belittling and rage with the only thing that lessens that is to lower contact and stop what you enjoy. After being isolated for long periods of time, you fall out of sync with everyone and life in general, you don't want to go out any more or see people. If you do happen to go out, even just to the shop you have to be hasty because one they are timing/waiting and two generally everything explodes while you are gone.

1dayatatime · 07/10/2023 15:54

@Ilovebudgies
@BraykeDance
@AdamRyan

Can you all please stop posting about pissing AH and JD - you are derailing and crowding out real posts from real women about real examples of abuse by females.

This is an under reported important issue and your annoying posts about a B list celebrity court case is causing these real examples to be ignored (again).

Just stop it.

Ilovebudgies · 07/10/2023 13:14

FloydPepper · 07/10/2023 10:51

If you ever needed an example of how people respond to male victims by blaming them, this is it…

You are so right!
Literally first response is to assume he is a useless man who can't be arsed to take care of his kids.

FloydPepper · 07/10/2023 10:51

Beefcurtains79 · 07/10/2023 06:48

“A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.”

This just sounds like someone who simply just no longer has time to do all the activities that they did when he didn’t have any children, a spouse or responsibilities?
Also, if he was 34 at the time, why were you ‘pretending to be grown ups’?!
He was an actual grown up no? And he’d be in his 40’s now.
How utterly bizarre.

If you ever needed an example of how people respond to male victims by blaming them, this is it…

Ilovebudgies · 07/10/2023 08:24

Beefcurtains79 · 07/10/2023 06:48

“A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.”

This just sounds like someone who simply just no longer has time to do all the activities that they did when he didn’t have any children, a spouse or responsibilities?
Also, if he was 34 at the time, why were you ‘pretending to be grown ups’?!
He was an actual grown up no? And he’d be in his 40’s now.
How utterly bizarre.

I don't think it's normal to not be allowed out and be scared that your wife will 'make the children suffer' if you're not there. This is actually quite classic abuse, using children as a weapon in order to control someone.

Beefcurtains79 · 07/10/2023 06:48

“A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.”

This just sounds like someone who simply just no longer has time to do all the activities that they did when he didn’t have any children, a spouse or responsibilities?
Also, if he was 34 at the time, why were you ‘pretending to be grown ups’?!
He was an actual grown up no? And he’d be in his 40’s now.
How utterly bizarre.

Ilovebudgies · 07/10/2023 00:42

trainboundfornowhere · 07/10/2023 00:12

Women can absolutely be abusers. Mine ended in SA. I then found the courage and spoke up. I am so sorry your DP and yourself experienced such pain and fear. Hopefully now you are both able to start moving on but you never forget.

A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.

Im so sorry to hear this, it sounds very scary!
When there are children involved abusers can exert total control, it makes it so hard to escape the cycle of abuse.

Ilovebudgies · 07/10/2023 00:40

AdamRyan · 07/10/2023 00:18

😂

I did watch it - I just don't agree with you. Which is allowed. I found the testimony of her friends on the night he smashed up the apartment very compelling. I found the testimony from the surgeon who said his finger injury couldn't have been caused by the bottle very compelling. I found the testimony of his ex about the bottle being thrown compelling. I found the testimony from his agent about why he was let go from films compelling. I have no doubt he is a nasty piece of work, drunk often, abuses drugs, disrespectful to those around him and potentially violent.

But anyway, in respect of the court case:

Waldman said her claiming to be abused and her friends statements the apartment was smashed up and she was abused were "a hoax" - this was found defamatory aka her friends and her were not colluding and making stuff up when they said Jonny smashed her house up and was abusive, he was abusive.

Heard said she was a "spokesperson for abuse" - this was found defamatory to Depp aka he was not an abuser.

These are contradictory verdicts. So the courts haven't helped settle whether or not he's an abuser.

She has never been on trial, so any evidence she's abusive hasnt been tested in court.

I really don't understand how anyone can be so adamant it's black and white - abuser and victim. She must be the abuser and he must be the victim.

I think it was an unhealthy relationship and they both behaved badly.

This was the defamatory statement
'Quite simply this was an ambush, a hoax. They set Mr. Depp up by calling the cops but the first attempt didn't do the trick,"
Said by his lawyer (not Depp) to the daily mail. And the punitive damages which is the compensation figure was £0!

The rest of the entire 6 week trial was to establish whether she was right in her op ed to call him an abuser.

But hey, believe what you want, but if they both won the case, someone should tell Amber and her lawyers because they all seemed pretty pissed off 😂

To me it is very black and white, abuser and victim, but I don't have anything left to say on it so I'll let everyone is else crack on.

Jux · 07/10/2023 00:26

I know a lad who was raped by a woman; she even admitted on paper that she knew he didn't want when he was sober so she got him so drunk he didn't really have any idea what he doing.

Her defence was if he didn't want to he wouldn't have got hard. Sadly, the cop he reported to seemed to think that was a reasonable statement despite everything else, and the whole thing was shelved. Shocking. Hope this has improved in the 25+ years since then.

AdamRyan · 07/10/2023 00:18

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 23:37

What on earth are you talking about?! He won the case, she was found guilty of defaming him by calling him an abuser and that she did it knowingly with malice.

He was found to have made one defamatory statement and it wasn't even his statement, it was his lawyers. It was in relation to one incident where the police were called by Heard and his lawyer claimed it was a hoax.
So he was guilty of defaming her by saying that ONE incident was a hoax. It was nothing to do with her being an abuser in general.

You clearly know very little about this case, and haven't listened to the audios or watched the whole trial.

i saw that video, I watched the trial, maybe try that yourself.

😂

I did watch it - I just don't agree with you. Which is allowed. I found the testimony of her friends on the night he smashed up the apartment very compelling. I found the testimony from the surgeon who said his finger injury couldn't have been caused by the bottle very compelling. I found the testimony of his ex about the bottle being thrown compelling. I found the testimony from his agent about why he was let go from films compelling. I have no doubt he is a nasty piece of work, drunk often, abuses drugs, disrespectful to those around him and potentially violent.

But anyway, in respect of the court case:

Waldman said her claiming to be abused and her friends statements the apartment was smashed up and she was abused were "a hoax" - this was found defamatory aka her friends and her were not colluding and making stuff up when they said Jonny smashed her house up and was abusive, he was abusive.

Heard said she was a "spokesperson for abuse" - this was found defamatory to Depp aka he was not an abuser.

These are contradictory verdicts. So the courts haven't helped settle whether or not he's an abuser.

She has never been on trial, so any evidence she's abusive hasnt been tested in court.

I really don't understand how anyone can be so adamant it's black and white - abuser and victim. She must be the abuser and he must be the victim.

I think it was an unhealthy relationship and they both behaved badly.

trainboundfornowhere · 07/10/2023 00:12

Women can absolutely be abusers. Mine ended in SA. I then found the courage and spoke up. I am so sorry your DP and yourself experienced such pain and fear. Hopefully now you are both able to start moving on but you never forget.

A dear friend of mine used to be so outgoing. He loved rock climbing, abseiling, bungee jumping and fire walking. We went Segway racing and tobogganing and would then pretend we were grownups (I was 25 and he was 34) and visit an art gallery or exhibition. Then he met his wife. We don’t do anything anymore as she will barely let him out and he is terrified of leaving the children with her incase she makes them suffer because he isn’t there. We can all see it but he won’t admit anything so nothing is ever done to help them.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 23:44

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 23:12

You admitted that you've hit an ex in a fight and your partner removed his ex from his space using force.
Without any context, those actions could both be perceived as "abuse".

The tape everyone is referring to also has limited context. Depp says nothing. Amber says she was scared he was going to hurt her, last time she did nothing and he really hurt her.

Without context it is impossible to tell if she's abusive or if she was reacting to his abuse.

My point is saying people are "abusive" on the basis of a snapshot means nothing. Based on what you've said about your partner, you should understand that.

I actually can't believe you posted this to OP I'm gobsmacked.
Which audio has no context? Mine? There are loads of audios, all showing a similar thing, her getting annoyed when he runs away, her admitting to hitting him and belittling him and goading him. I don't think you even believe what you are saying, you are just purely here to argue, and actually upsetting OP in the process.

You just compared her partner who is a victim of horrific abuse to Amber Heard who you know she (and a lot of others) believe is a vile and prolific abuser.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 23:37

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 23:06

In the US trial, it was found it was defamatory to imply Depp was abusive. (He won his suit)
But it was also defamatory to imply Heard made it up (she won her countersuit)
Those are mutually exclusive positions so it doesn't move things forward.

I find this video terrifying (it reminds me of an ex). Me finding it terrifying is irrelevant really but my opinionbthat Depp is scary and reminds me of abusers I know is no more or less valid than other peoples opinions on Heard

What on earth are you talking about?! He won the case, she was found guilty of defaming him by calling him an abuser and that she did it knowingly with malice.

He was found to have made one defamatory statement and it wasn't even his statement, it was his lawyers. It was in relation to one incident where the police were called by Heard and his lawyer claimed it was a hoax.
So he was guilty of defaming her by saying that ONE incident was a hoax. It was nothing to do with her being an abuser in general.

You clearly know very little about this case, and haven't listened to the audios or watched the whole trial.

i saw that video, I watched the trial, maybe try that yourself.

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 23:36

This is very desperate Adam. Multiple recordings admitting you lose control, "get physical" and repeatedly physically hit an intimate partner while they repeatedly try and get away can't possibly have any context that makes it not abuse.

Please don't get so sucked into defending this woman that you try and compare victims fighting off an attacker to what she was doing.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 23:12

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 21:19

@AdamRyan

NO!

I'm not going to rehash all the evidence, suffice to say I don't agree she was "admitting she was abuser" on those tapes. Or if she was, then braykehas also admitted both her and her husband are abusers on this thread by saying both of them have been physical with partners in the past

My DP dragging an abuser out of his home, whilst she refused to leave, went for him with a knife and smashed his belonging is NOT remotely similar on ANY level to what Amber Heard was doing. For goodness sake! Stop taking things too far here!!!! My DP is an abuse survivor and you've just compared us both to an abuser! TOO FAR

You admitted that you've hit an ex in a fight and your partner removed his ex from his space using force.
Without any context, those actions could both be perceived as "abuse".

The tape everyone is referring to also has limited context. Depp says nothing. Amber says she was scared he was going to hurt her, last time she did nothing and he really hurt her.

Without context it is impossible to tell if she's abusive or if she was reacting to his abuse.

My point is saying people are "abusive" on the basis of a snapshot means nothing. Based on what you've said about your partner, you should understand that.

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 23:06

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 21:04

What do you mean they both won?

"The jury unanimously found that Heard could not substantiate her allegations against Depp and that she knew her claims of abuse were false when she published her 2018 essay"

'The jury determined that Heard acted with actual malice when writing her op-ed. The jury awarded Depp $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages in his defamation suit'

Not only did they find her guilty of lying about abuse but that she did it with actual malice.
It doesn't get much more conclusive than that.

There was only one statement they found to be defamation from depps side and that was just one statement that was made by his lawyer.
'The jury found that Depp, through Waldman, defamed Heard on one count'

I agree with you that the texts were awful, I don't like the man, I never said otherwise.

That last quote of mine possibly came across as too personal and offensive, and I apologise if so as it wasn't my intention, but you come across very biased against male victims and that's what I meant by that point - I'm glad the jury were unbiased and could see the truth.

I think I'm done with this argument now, I agree it's been derailed but I just feel so strongly about this topic I find it hard not to respond.

In the US trial, it was found it was defamatory to imply Depp was abusive. (He won his suit)
But it was also defamatory to imply Heard made it up (she won her countersuit)
Those are mutually exclusive positions so it doesn't move things forward.

I find this video terrifying (it reminds me of an ex). Me finding it terrifying is irrelevant really but my opinionbthat Depp is scary and reminds me of abusers I know is no more or less valid than other peoples opinions on Heard

Video Shows Johnny Depp Angrily Slamming Cabinets During Argument with Amber Heard

During cross-examination on Thursday, the defense presented a video to the jury showing Johnny Depp angrily slamming cabinets during an argument with Amber H...

https://youtu.be/xsBN_7vUP0U?si=NnFiuxu5dROUUC90

BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 21:19

@AdamRyan

NO!

I'm not going to rehash all the evidence, suffice to say I don't agree she was "admitting she was abuser" on those tapes. Or if she was, then braykehas also admitted both her and her husband are abusers on this thread by saying both of them have been physical with partners in the past

My DP dragging an abuser out of his home, whilst she refused to leave, went for him with a knife and smashed his belonging is NOT remotely similar on ANY level to what Amber Heard was doing. For goodness sake! Stop taking things too far here!!!! My DP is an abuse survivor and you've just compared us both to an abuser! TOO FAR

OP posts:
BraykeDance · 06/10/2023 21:14

@1dayatatime

Perfect, I'll hand you over the thread police mantle.

As a note to all, I'll be out all day tomorrow so won't be online but if you post here as an abuse survivor I promise I will hear you and will respond once I'm back

OP posts:
Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 21:04

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 20:32

She was never on trial. It wasn't about who was the "victim". Both the UK and US trials were about whether it was fair to imply he was an abuser. And don't forget they both won. The court ruled it was defamatory to say he was an abuser, but also defamatory to say she made it up.

Those texts were rank misogyny. It actually doesn't matter whether or not he was a victim. That doesn't excuse those texts (or the ones where he joked he had her rotting corpse in his boot).

I'm not going to rehash all the evidence, suffice to say I don't agree she was "admitting she was abuser" on those tapes. Or if she was, then brayke has also admitted both her and her husband are abusers on this thread by saying both of them have been physical with partners in the past.

My feelings about the Depp/Heard trial are in no way indicative of my broader opinions and that "it can NEVER be the woman's fault in your eyes". You don't know me and that's just a ridiculous thing to say.

Honestly. This thread is bonkers. Pointing out incel logic is "bullying" but this is fine: "I'm so glad there wasn't anyone like you in that jury and they were able to take an unbiased and fair view of the evidence".

What do you mean they both won?

"The jury unanimously found that Heard could not substantiate her allegations against Depp and that she knew her claims of abuse were false when she published her 2018 essay"

'The jury determined that Heard acted with actual malice when writing her op-ed. The jury awarded Depp $10 million in compensatory damages and $5 million in punitive damages in his defamation suit'

Not only did they find her guilty of lying about abuse but that she did it with actual malice.
It doesn't get much more conclusive than that.

There was only one statement they found to be defamation from depps side and that was just one statement that was made by his lawyer.
'The jury found that Depp, through Waldman, defamed Heard on one count'

I agree with you that the texts were awful, I don't like the man, I never said otherwise.

That last quote of mine possibly came across as too personal and offensive, and I apologise if so as it wasn't my intention, but you come across very biased against male victims and that's what I meant by that point - I'm glad the jury were unbiased and could see the truth.

I think I'm done with this argument now, I agree it's been derailed but I just feel so strongly about this topic I find it hard not to respond.

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 20:47

She is literally berating him relentlessly for splitting AKA leaving or running away, for booking extra rooms. It is constant. He can't win, if he stays and things get heated she will claim he hit her (like where he says he couldnt escape on the plane so pushed her), but if he runs she claims he is a baby.
I honestly can't imagine how it would feel to be in that position. To know you can't hit back and you can't run away, totally trapped unless you end the marriage, and then she claims she is a victim and wrecks his life.

Heated Arguments Between Johnny Depp & Amber Heard (Audio Recordings)

Two audio recordings released in the Johnny Depp v Amber Heard case demonstrate heated arguments between the two ex-partners. The Depp and Heard defamation t...

https://youtu.be/-WEIIl5u8FE?si=cVOuW9ztiW8l-dFp

1dayatatime · 06/10/2023 20:41

@BraykeDance

"I completely agree with you and it's a shame. I tried initially to ask people to stay off that topic and was accussed of policing the thread.

Can't win."

+++

It's simple and I'll happily be the thread police given how serious I think this topic is. So if anyone raises a post referring or mentioning to AH and JD in anyway then just ignore it and don't respond.

Then maybe just maybe we can get to the point of this thread.

AdamRyan · 06/10/2023 20:32

Ilovebudgies · 06/10/2023 19:25

But again you distract from the real damning evidence that shows her literally admitting to being an abuser by focussing on his private text messages and making it all about women and the patriarchy and misogyny. It always goes back to women being victims, it can NEVER be the woman's fault in your eyes.
You'd always find something not to like about a male victim in a trial, whether it be texts or comments, or behaviour. There is never a perfect victim and he was FAR from perfect, but a victim nonetheless.
I'm so glad there wasn't anyone like you in that jury and they were able to take an unbiased and fair view of the evidence.

She was never on trial. It wasn't about who was the "victim". Both the UK and US trials were about whether it was fair to imply he was an abuser. And don't forget they both won. The court ruled it was defamatory to say he was an abuser, but also defamatory to say she made it up.

Those texts were rank misogyny. It actually doesn't matter whether or not he was a victim. That doesn't excuse those texts (or the ones where he joked he had her rotting corpse in his boot).

I'm not going to rehash all the evidence, suffice to say I don't agree she was "admitting she was abuser" on those tapes. Or if she was, then brayke has also admitted both her and her husband are abusers on this thread by saying both of them have been physical with partners in the past.

My feelings about the Depp/Heard trial are in no way indicative of my broader opinions and that "it can NEVER be the woman's fault in your eyes". You don't know me and that's just a ridiculous thing to say.

Honestly. This thread is bonkers. Pointing out incel logic is "bullying" but this is fine: "I'm so glad there wasn't anyone like you in that jury and they were able to take an unbiased and fair view of the evidence".