Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are wealthy parents ever prosecuted for child abuse?

117 replies

Lemonsugarhigh · 03/10/2023 13:21

Have seen about a lot of neglectful parents in court recently who have abused their kids. Almost all the cases covered in the press are about very poor families, generally living in pretty dire conditions. But abuse goes on in wealthy homes too, why does this seem to go under the radar? Is it just that SS overlook suffering kids if their parents have cash? Or is it that the parents are better at hiding abuse? Or does the press have a preference for covering the neglect and poverty combination?

OP posts:
Goldbar · 03/10/2023 14:50

Imo there are different types of abuse. Some are linked to poverty, some aren't.

Some types of abuse, such as CSA, seem to cross all social and economic classes in terms of perpetrators. Poverty makes children more vulnerable to this type of abuse (less safeguards in place, safe places to go), but all children are at risk. Likewise, you find emotionally abusive or neglectful parents at all income levels. Some well-off parents are abusive to their families and exploit their position of privilege to get away with this.

But other types of abuse are linked with poverty and neglect. It is much harder to find the emotional bandwidth to be a compassionate, emotionally responsive parent if you yourself are stressed, at the end of your resources and ground down by life. Particularly where parents have themselves grown up in abusive and neglectful homes, it can be very difficult for them to break the cycle.

sleepismyhobby · 03/10/2023 14:47

Sadly abuse can happen in rich or poor families

MoulinPouge · 03/10/2023 14:45

nosocialinteraction · 03/10/2023 14:36

The threshold for what is acceptable is different dependant on various factors. Look at the mcCanns as a prime example - imagine if a single parent in a council flat had popped to the takeaway across the road and left children unattended and one was abducted- the others would be taken away and a case for neglect would be looming

I don't actually think that's true. The threshold for removing children from their parents care is very high and prosecutions for child neglect even higher.

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 14:44

CakeInAJar · 03/10/2023 14:03

Wealthy people are educated enough to put in a good front to neighbours friends and authorities. Please don’t get into the ‘not on my street’ attitude. It does happen. All the time.

Just far less often than in poorer families.

It’s disappointing that people deny the science because they dislike the data.

https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/news/relationship-between-poverty-and-child-abuse-and-neglect

New evidence on the relationship between poverty and child abuse and neglect - Nuffield Foundation

New evidence review shoes changes in family income have a major impact on the numbers of children being harmed.

https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/news/relationship-between-poverty-and-child-abuse-and-neglect

Gerrataere · 03/10/2023 14:43

I have found (somewhat from personal experience) that the more ‘well to do’ a family is the more the abuse is excusable. Especially mental/verbal abuse. I heard so many times ‘but look how much stuff you’ve got! Look at all the opportunities you’ve had! Just ignore the bad, you’re luckier than most’.

Bit of a sidestep but this is one reason I feel awful for Prince Harry. He evidently felt and tried to say despite the wealth and glory that came with being a Royal, it didn’t mean he didn’t have a very horrid, cold childhood/adolescents at times. Went through things no child should have. Yet he’s always shown to be some sort of ungrateful brat…

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 14:39

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 14:00

They’re better at hiding it and are often more intelligent. Kids are well fed, clothed and often do nice activities. Some are shipped off to boarding school which is the higher class equivalent of a children’s home. Their abuse tends to be more covert than overt. It’s as simple as that.

It’s not as simple as that though. All the research shows that poor families are more likely to abuse their children than wealthy ones.

https://repository.stcloudstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1020&context=cfs_etds

https://repository.stcloudstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1020&context=cfs_etds

nosocialinteraction · 03/10/2023 14:36

The threshold for what is acceptable is different dependant on various factors. Look at the mcCanns as a prime example - imagine if a single parent in a council flat had popped to the takeaway across the road and left children unattended and one was abducted- the others would be taken away and a case for neglect would be looming

rumred · 03/10/2023 14:35

I worked in child protection for many years. It was very difficult to reach richer families often because they knew we couldn't get through their door without their agreement and quite often suspicions initially won't meet a criminal threshold so the police and courts won't get involved at that point.

Also as pps have said money buys you stress release, nannies etc.

The poor are more vulnerable in many ways.

It was an impossible job on many levels

Leah5678 · 03/10/2023 14:33

Like if a poor parent stopped bothering the house would descend into an unhygienic shithole, the kids would have lice, no food etc etc a rich parent stops bothering they can just pay for cleaners boarding schools etc.
Just wanted to expand more on what I said. Neglect is probably the most common type of abuse but when it comes to physical or sexual abuse it spans all levels of wealth

HernesEgg · 03/10/2023 14:31

Isittimeformynapyet · 03/10/2023 14:20

Oh! During the holidays! Sorry @HernesEgg

Yes, holidays, non-term time. Oxford terms are only eight weeks, so having somewhere to stay out of termtime if you can’t/won’t go home is key — not possible at all colleges, as some host conference accommodation in the vacs.

AlienatedChildGrown · 03/10/2023 14:26

I think the social worker was caught off guard by the lovely home, the tea served in china (tray and everything, I was the one trying not to drop it) and the dignified, articulate parent.

Not knocking her. I couldn’t do her job. The pressure must be immense and the body keeps score. So she probably relaxed out of relief & tiredness.

And I kept the more obvious red flags under my hat. You might want things to stop, but getting a parent into deep shit kind of trouble, and the reality of being plonked on the alternative parent, can look like a fire compared to a frying pan.

I was trained from birth to have my game face on when out or when company was around. Not because any of us anticipated it all going to shit in our family. Just because of “what would the neighbours think !” normal middle class “nice & polite” child rearing.

Wouldn’t have called us wealthy though. Just normal middle classed (not upper !) well off enough for all needs and enough wants to not become bad for you.

Bigoldmachine · 03/10/2023 14:26

Private schools absolutely definitely do report abuse through the proper channels / to social services! Although in the majority of cases I’ve been told about the parents then withdrew the child from the school. Obviously their file and the history of abuse being reported goes with them to their new school. Rich and intelligent abusers will and do get away with it more.

Isittimeformynapyet · 03/10/2023 14:22

Ted27 · 03/10/2023 14:20

@Isittimeformynapyet

I think vac means the vacations/holidays,

I think you're right 😳

Pigeonqueen · 03/10/2023 14:21

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 14:12

@KvotheTheBloodless

In terms of abuse, neglect spans all classes fairly equally. It is even easier to check out of parenting with money so I would say neglect is a safeguarding issue that can quite easily be swept under the carpet if you have the funds. Plenty of young people in private schools suffer tremendously with their mental health but it’s always, always blamed on external factors (mainly academic stress). Whilst this is a factor for many, for some it’s simply due to having no support network at home which leads to loneliness. The latter doesn’t get questioned.

Having worked in adult MH services I often feel quite sorry for those who came from neglectful middle class families as they invalidate their struggles and it often takes years of therapy to uncover that actually their childhood was abusive.

I am a working class lady myself who was physically abused by my father. There was never any doubt in my mind that what I experienced as a child was abuse. Therefore there was no confusion. I hope that makes sense. It can be terribly confusing for those children once they reach adulthood, in a way, it can sometimes be worse for them.

All of this is so true.

I came from a fairly wealthy family. My dad was the chief executive of a very large multi national lift company. He had a lot of money, think mobile phone as soon as they came out, new BMWs, car phone before anyone had one, trips to Japan for business etc. My mum came from a wealthy background, went to grammar school back when it was posh and selective, but she ended up alcoholic and schizophrenic and my Dad was more interested in his work than caring for me. Both of them were abusive in different ways and I fell well and truly under the radar, living in our very middle class 4 bed house in London. I don’t want to upset anyone so won’t go into details but I’ve seen my Mum try to murder my Dad, I’ve seen my Mum sectioned many times, I’ve been hungry and been physically and emotionally abused. But no one really stepped into help because we were a “posh” family. It was only when my Mum tried to stab my Dad with a fork and the police were called that I went into temporary foster care (which was wonderful by the way) and then when she was “better” I was returned to live with her again. She was good at putting on a front. No one really gives a shit if you live on a good street, attend private school and have an alcoholic mum as lots of rich people drink a lot anyway - wine o clock (every fucking day, all day).

And yes the abuse in private schools and boarding schools is dreadful in many different ways. The pressure, the lack of love. Experienced it first hand.

MoulinPouge · 03/10/2023 14:21

I think, yes this is true to an extent. Wealth makes it easier to conceal abuse and comes with reputational advantages linked to profession etc.

However, there are lots of ways in which child abuse may be linked to (more likely to occur in the context of) poverty, eg:

  1. Those living with a low income or in poverty are under greater strain. They may therefore have fewer personal resources available for managing their own behaviour /parenting because of the mental load associated with being poor and/or may be more likely to experience things which increase the risk of child abuse (eg mental health, eg entering into and then becoming trapped in an abusive relationship)

  2. Some factors exist which may lead both to poverty and to child abuse. For example, care leavers may be traumatised or have poor experiences of parenting that make their own children more at risk of abuse, and are also more likely to be affected by poverty. Same goes for mental health and substance abuse. These things increase the risk of both poverty and child abuse.

It's bad for children to be poor. Most children's circumstances will be elevated if their parents have more wealth.

TotalOverhaul · 03/10/2023 14:20

Bluebelle82 · 03/10/2023 14:02

It definitely happens. My DH and BIL were abandoned by their parents. FIL moved out when they were about 11/12 years old and had no contact with his children. Then MIL moved in with her BF when they were about 14/15 years old. She left them on their own with no food or money in the house. She has considerable mental health issues. DH had to sell some items to buy him and BIL food.

They were both at private school (on scholarships) and there was just no one to talk to about what was going on. They were too ashamed to admit to their peers that there was a problem - they had been 'trained' to keep up appearances or risk being bullied. It had also built towards this point so it wasn't like the abandonment was sudden - it just gradually got to that point with MIL spending more and more time away from home.

That's heartbreaking.

Ted27 · 03/10/2023 14:20

@Isittimeformynapyet

I think vac means the vacations/holidays,

Isittimeformynapyet · 03/10/2023 14:20

Oh! During the holidays! Sorry @HernesEgg

Ted27 · 03/10/2023 14:18

Prosecutions for child abuse/neglect are comparatively rare, unless there is a death.
I'm am adoptive parent of one now grown up child. His birth mother has lost 4 sons to adoption or the care system. She has never been prosecuted for any offences relationship to any of the children. She has been prosecuted and jailed several times for petty crime such as shoplifting.
Dad is not much better, no prosecutions relating to any of his 3 children but has been jailed for DV against a partner and burglary.

Isittimeformynapyet · 03/10/2023 14:18

@HernesEgg what does "stay in the vac" mean? Is it Oxbridge-speak for in halls?

Leah5678 · 03/10/2023 14:15

A lot of people who abuse their kids also have issues that means they can't hold down a proper job so yeah they're more likely to be poor. Another thing is relating to neglect rich people can hire child minders or send then to boarding school. That's not to say there are no rich child abusers. Theres definitely lots of wealthy pedos.

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 14:12

@KvotheTheBloodless

In terms of abuse, neglect spans all classes fairly equally. It is even easier to check out of parenting with money so I would say neglect is a safeguarding issue that can quite easily be swept under the carpet if you have the funds. Plenty of young people in private schools suffer tremendously with their mental health but it’s always, always blamed on external factors (mainly academic stress). Whilst this is a factor for many, for some it’s simply due to having no support network at home which leads to loneliness. The latter doesn’t get questioned.

Having worked in adult MH services I often feel quite sorry for those who came from neglectful middle class families as they invalidate their struggles and it often takes years of therapy to uncover that actually their childhood was abusive.

I am a working class lady myself who was physically abused by my father. There was never any doubt in my mind that what I experienced as a child was abuse. Therefore there was no confusion. I hope that makes sense. It can be terribly confusing for those children once they reach adulthood, in a way, it can sometimes be worse for them.

HernesEgg · 03/10/2023 14:12

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 14:00

They’re better at hiding it and are often more intelligent. Kids are well fed, clothed and often do nice activities. Some are shipped off to boarding school which is the higher class equivalent of a children’s home. Their abuse tends to be more covert than overt. It’s as simple as that.

This, largely, I think. The evidence of abuse/neglect will be far less obvious without the markers of dirty clothes, insufficient school lunches. If wealthy parents have addictions, they won’t need to shoplift or prostitute themselves to feed it etc.

A good friend of mine was abused, physically and emotionally, by her well-off professional parents. She remembers a GP looking at a bruise in concern and saying nothing, and a teacher at her expensive, academically-rigorous private school and another medical professional, when she was slightly older, both saying ‘Do you want me to report this?’ and concluding, with her own agreement, that ending up in foster care was only going to imperil her planned escape route (Oxford), so better to stay where she was and work hard to get out. She went to Oxford, chose a college that would allow you to stay in the vac, and never went home again.

AnnaMagnani · 03/10/2023 14:12

Depends what you mean by prosecuted.

Men from well off backgrounds are convicted for child sexual abuse, often historic, all the time.

There will be rich families who have children known to Social Services.

However some elements of being rich do protect children from some aspects of abuse from terrible parents. They are less likely to be dirty or in worn out clothing as there is money for shopping and housework is done by a cleaner/housekeeper. Rich drug addicted parents are unlikely to run out of money for food. They can also outsource their parenting to a nanny or a boarding school.

justjeansandanicetop · 03/10/2023 14:09

I'm guessing it may be something to do with the difference between abuse and neglect.

Wealthy families probably don't neglect their kids as much because it's easier for them to adequately feed and clothe their kids and pay for childcare. For families living in poverty this can be much more of a struggle.

When it comes to abuse, yes, you're right, money doesn't / shouldn't have any bearing on this. But it does seem to. I'm not sure of the reasons. I guess issues such as alcoholism and drug abuse go hand in hand with extreme poverty and unemployment, leading to higher levels of abuse in these families. Another factor could be that the involvement of agencies such as health visitor, doctor, social services etc due to issues like these may lead to abuse being picked up on, whereas it might fly under the radar in wealthier families.

Swipe left for the next trending thread