Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are wealthy parents ever prosecuted for child abuse?

117 replies

Lemonsugarhigh · 03/10/2023 13:21

Have seen about a lot of neglectful parents in court recently who have abused their kids. Almost all the cases covered in the press are about very poor families, generally living in pretty dire conditions. But abuse goes on in wealthy homes too, why does this seem to go under the radar? Is it just that SS overlook suffering kids if their parents have cash? Or is it that the parents are better at hiding abuse? Or does the press have a preference for covering the neglect and poverty combination?

OP posts:
CakeInAJar · 03/10/2023 15:27

NotSuchASmugMarried · 03/10/2023 15:25

I don't think the McCanns are a good example to use because they were in another country at the time the crime was committed and so not subject to British Law.

A better comparison might be made with Hans and Eva Rausings. Imagine if they had been working class.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Kristian_Rausing

Social services don’t only have to look at people who’ve committed acts in the UK. Or even just criminal acts

gotomomo · 03/10/2023 15:27

I suspect that where there's money neglect is far less common, eg parents may be ignoring the dcs needs personally but they hire a babysitter/nanny/au pair/send to boarding school to cover their lack of willingness to parent whereas without money parents may simply put dc in front of tv with junk food and possibly go out and leave them.

I know brothers who were dumped in boarding school from age 7 because their parents split up and neither wanted them, that's emotional neglect but they were safe.

HernesEgg · 03/10/2023 15:26

@HongKongGarden, it’s obvious that poverty exacerbates neglect/abuse, but what several posters have said is that a report like that, however wide-ranging, can only use data about cases that have come to the attention of social services. Meaning that wealthier people and/or people more capable of dealing with authorities, are likely to be under-represented in the stats because they don’t come to SS attention to be investigated in the first place.

NotSuchASmugMarried · 03/10/2023 15:25

I don't think the McCanns are a good example to use because they were in another country at the time the crime was committed and so not subject to British Law.

A better comparison might be made with Hans and Eva Rausings. Imagine if they had been working class.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Kristian_Rausing

Hans Kristian Rausing - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans_Kristian_Rausing

ArcticLingered · 03/10/2023 15:18

It's because people who are facing financial hardship on an on-going basis are more likely to snap, or to act irrationally, or to have mental health issues as they are under so much pressure. Wealthy people who might have the same personality traits may never (or rarely) act in extreme ways as they are not pushed into difficult situations as often (or at all).
Basically - put ordinary, functioning human beings under loads of pressure, and some of them might not always be really "nice" as a result. Especially if it happens generation after generation.

EDIT: I'm not making excuses for poor behaviour on the part of parents... Just giving my view why it happens more often when there are multiple sources of stress in their lives. There are horrible people from all walks of life, unfortunately.

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 15:15

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 15:02

@HongKongGarden

Oh dear….

It isn’t left wing politics to assume that those families living in poverty will be known to services. That data tells us only of the “known” cases.

Do you have any experience in working within adult mental health services whereby you hear peoples stories day in, day out? Have you not actually read this thread at all? Your data doesn’t mean much when families of higher class go under the radar for all of the reasons mentioned above. I don’t know why this has triggered you so much to be honest.

I think we have all agreed that abuse is universal, it’s just highlighted more within working class families. It’s also been stated that various types of abuse such as neglect can actually be even easier the wealthier a family becomes. Money does not protect all children from abuse. Sorry that upsets you/threatens you.

Ah, right, so anecdotes plus political views is better than the huge systematic review that I posted above?

That’s fascinating. Have you published any papers giving the world the benefit of your superior knowledge? If not you really should.

Theyrarelygetcaught · 03/10/2023 15:13

Name change for this.

As my pseudo name suggests, I think they rarely get caught from bitter experience.

I’d from a relatively wealthy family and I used to get beaten by my dad a lot. My legs and arms were often bruised or red from a hand mark and I often had lumps on the back of my head. The one time I threatened to report him he just laughed and said they’d never believe me. Of course I never reported any of it.

HoneyBadgerMom · 03/10/2023 15:13

Rarely. I grew up with money, my father was (is) a monster, and everyone, and I do mean EVERYONE, knew. They did nothing, because he was wealthy and powerful. One person reported the bruises on my younger brother and within a month his business was destroyed and no one in town would work with him. The family had to move out of our town, my father ruined him. Especially in tight-knit, church centered communities, child abuse is at best ignored. Most of the adults at the church that spoke to me about my parents shamed me for "making" them abuse me because I was so bad.

It's definitely different for people with money.

Clarevoyant1 · 03/10/2023 15:12

It happened twice in our local private prep school. One situation where the father was physically abusive to both kids and their mother. Police got involved when another parent saw the father punching his child in the car.

The other incident involved a mother starving and forcing exercise on her son. She had an eating disorder herself and forced it on him. She would make him run 5k before and after school and barely feed him. SS were called because he was so underweight. He was removed and now lives with his grandparents (dad wasn’t around).

I expect it is easier to hush up when you’re rich though - powerful connections, good lawyers, the ‘right image’, etc.

Messyhair321 · 03/10/2023 15:11

Lemonsugarhigh · 03/10/2023 13:21

Have seen about a lot of neglectful parents in court recently who have abused their kids. Almost all the cases covered in the press are about very poor families, generally living in pretty dire conditions. But abuse goes on in wealthy homes too, why does this seem to go under the radar? Is it just that SS overlook suffering kids if their parents have cash? Or is it that the parents are better at hiding abuse? Or does the press have a preference for covering the neglect and poverty combination?

Just to add. professionals can be easily manipulated by parents who are clever with communication, this is what I saw. I am sure the majority of cases often never get to SS, but believe me, social workers do get stuck in oppositional relationships with parents and these get stuck in the system

Sugarfree23 · 03/10/2023 15:10

I think they are just better at hiding it. Or the kids are more frightened to speak up or when they do speak up they aren't believed or people down play it.

Look at the people who turn to the Stately Homes threads. People who have dysfunctional families who from the outside looking in were normally everyday families who had families trips at weekends.

Messyhair321 · 03/10/2023 15:08

TheNameIsDickDarlington · 03/10/2023 15:05

I'll Have to read that article properly after the school run but I always wonder how they get that information?

My family never had any intervention from any social services or similar but my house was incredibly abusive. It was a middle class household, 4 bedroom detached house on a quiet street, new cars, holidays etc (which were always held up as an example of what a nice life we had) so nobody really asked many questions when I came to school with bruises or had panic attacks on the bus home.

I guess I'm just saying the information must be skewed in some way as not all abuse is ever found out by any officials.

Yes you are absolutely right, data is always open to manipulation, social services only get a very small percentage of abuse cases they are often never recorded or picked up, ever. I am sorry you endured what you did by the way, I am hoping you are ok despite this experience with your family.

Lemonsugarhigh · 03/10/2023 15:07

@Whatafustercluck I was thinking about that couple and their poor baby (and their other kids). If I remember correctly the mother seemed to have rejected her wealthy life and had been living in poor conditions in council flats and hostels for the past few years. Although she still had access to cash I think. I guess that's what made the headlines in that story too though, the fact she's essentially aristocracy. It's one extreme or the other that gets attention.

OP posts:
Messyhair321 · 03/10/2023 15:06

Ex social worker here, I agree that most of the cases were often from deprived backgrounds, however, there were also many from more lucrative backgrounds, they were just as likely to hurt their children however being able to communicate with professionals really helps, (I don't agree with this by they way), but if you're able to convince that it won't happen again and it was due to xyz the social services often just closed the case.

I don't want to generalise but often we had people getting angry and upset, and these were often people who just didn't have the professional skills to play the system in the way that wealthier families could.

I do remember a case where a GP used to shut his 2 year old in the cupboard, in the dark for punishment, he really didn't understand how this would impact his son...
Also, there was a case where other professionals were abusing children, for example, in nursery, these were often ignored (one was putting soap in a toddlers mouth as a punishment, another was a teacher who slapped a child). It all goes on, but there's a lot of mismanagement in social services, its always from the top.

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 15:06

@TheNameIsDickDarlington

And that is exactly why it’s flawed.

TheNameIsDickDarlington · 03/10/2023 15:05

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 14:44

Just far less often than in poorer families.

It’s disappointing that people deny the science because they dislike the data.

https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/news/relationship-between-poverty-and-child-abuse-and-neglect

I'll Have to read that article properly after the school run but I always wonder how they get that information?

My family never had any intervention from any social services or similar but my house was incredibly abusive. It was a middle class household, 4 bedroom detached house on a quiet street, new cars, holidays etc (which were always held up as an example of what a nice life we had) so nobody really asked many questions when I came to school with bruises or had panic attacks on the bus home.

I guess I'm just saying the information must be skewed in some way as not all abuse is ever found out by any officials.

NotSuchASmugMarried · 03/10/2023 15:04

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 13:50

Does it go on to the same extent? It’s possible that the sort of parents who’d abuse children are also those unlikely to hold down a professional career, so the offending rates could be quite different.

This. It simply doesn't happen as much. Rich people truly understand that throwing money at a problem nearly always makes it go away.

Blackandwhitemakesgrey · 03/10/2023 15:02

A friend works in child protection. The families she works with are often young//single parents involved with substance abuse/crime/generational involvement (neglect). SS are contacted by the police (crime/drugs) and school (non attendance). SS can be involved for years and years with family members following the same path as previous generations, especially as family members are most likely to be the people the children are placed with.

There are some wealthier families and they tend to know their rights, and are not reluctant to complain through the official channels. This results in a lot of paperwork for SS, causing the SS being switched a number of times until they get one they can 'work with' ie who will do as they are told.

There is usually someone in the wealthier families background who the child can be placed with. The placement isn't always successful but it is often more stable than the child whose family has a history of SS involvement.

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 15:02

@HongKongGarden

Oh dear….

It isn’t left wing politics to assume that those families living in poverty will be known to services. That data tells us only of the “known” cases.

Do you have any experience in working within adult mental health services whereby you hear peoples stories day in, day out? Have you not actually read this thread at all? Your data doesn’t mean much when families of higher class go under the radar for all of the reasons mentioned above. I don’t know why this has triggered you so much to be honest.

I think we have all agreed that abuse is universal, it’s just highlighted more within working class families. It’s also been stated that various types of abuse such as neglect can actually be even easier the wealthier a family becomes. Money does not protect all children from abuse. Sorry that upsets you/threatens you.

MachinesOfGod · 03/10/2023 15:01

Perhaps the wealthier families whose children end up on Child in Need or Child Protection plans have the resources and support networks to get their shit together and fix the issues that are raised during the social services involvement. It doesn’t mean that the issues stay fixed once the involvement of social care has ended, but they can probably gather enough support/help together to satisfy the bare minimum requirements.

Constance Marten is an example of wealth not being able mitigate everything though!

AnnaMagnani · 03/10/2023 14:57

@CakeInAJar if there were no other concerns, I think it's very unlikely there would be an emergency care order.

The bar for taking children into care is so high this wouldn't be enough. There might be Social Work input for a while but taking into care? Absolutely not.

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 14:55

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 14:52

@HongKongGarden

It is as simple as that. There are many who will not even make that data. They enter therapy in adulthood. It’s got nothing to do with disliking data, but there are huge limitations there. There have been some very sensible replies on this thread. Poverty will increase the likelihood of a child suffering from abuse in a way that makes that child known to services. Known being the key word here.

Edited

Provide your data then, to show that the large-scale research that I gave is flawed.

Assertion based on left-wing student politics doesn’t cut it.

CakeInAJar · 03/10/2023 14:53

MoulinPouge · 03/10/2023 14:45

I don't actually think that's true. The threshold for removing children from their parents care is very high and prosecutions for child neglect even higher.

The comparison would be more like
A working class couple leave their 3yo and 18mo twins in their council house asleep to go to the local working men’s club to drink pints around the corner. They meet their mates who are doing the same thing. They supposedly check on each others kids every 30 minutes and one child goes missing.

I have a very hard time believing that an emergency care order wouldn’t be sought for for the remaining twins.

Tribevibes · 03/10/2023 14:52

@HongKongGarden

It is as simple as that. There are many who will not even make that data. They enter therapy in adulthood. It’s got nothing to do with disliking data, but there are huge limitations there. There have been some very sensible replies on this thread. Poverty will increase the likelihood of a child suffering from abuse in a way that makes that child known to services. Known being the key word here.

CakeInAJar · 03/10/2023 14:50

HongKongGarden · 03/10/2023 14:44

Just far less often than in poorer families.

It’s disappointing that people deny the science because they dislike the data.

https://www.nuffieldfoundation.org/news/relationship-between-poverty-and-child-abuse-and-neglect

Who’s denied the science?