Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS's school trip was offered on a 'first come first serve' basis and is now being drawn at random from a hat

315 replies

Worriedaandconfused · 03/10/2023 11:50

AIBU to think the school should honour the first come first serve basis they initially stated for allocating places on the school trip?

They have, due to a 'huge response' of requested places, decided to draw names at random on Friday.

After promising my child a place and ensuring I handed the form in promptly to the teacher (in fairness, it sounds like a lot of other parents did, too), I'm now going to have to explain to my 4 year old he's unlikely to have a place.

How do your own DC's schools handle situations like this where there's limited places and lots of interest?

OP posts:
Isthisasgoodasitis · 04/10/2023 10:22

I can not believe the amount of people blaming you!!! I’m sure given the post this is the first time you have dealt with this so wouldn’t have known any different sadly this is the norm to come and the first time a school trip was booked it got me too despite me completing the form and submitting it paid in full before we even went home so it was gone the same day and somehow my child didn’t get a place I was enraged it was before this forum as she’s 28 now however I have a 4 year old also so now I don’t promise a place I submit promptly but so as I did with my oldest I took her to the destination on a day that suited me through the week so that she did not miss out we did London zoo the natural history museum and iron bridge together like this and the school had to suck up the absence 🤣

Sartre · 04/10/2023 10:04

I should say my DC’s school (secondary) put it on the app so once the places are all filled, it disappears from the app.

Sartre · 04/10/2023 10:03

Maybe everyone handed the form in straight away so names out of a hat is the only fair way?

Wheelz46 · 04/10/2023 09:33

@Worriedaandconfused It's not really feasible to ask another parent to drop off the permission slip. As the kids are only in reception, not all parents will know each other overly well and even if they do, what if there own kid wants to go and they happen to be number 10 in line with 2 permission slips. Then you have those who are dropped off from wrap around care, who might have multiple children to drop off, you can't expect them to try and get there first.

The school have realised they made a mistake and have rectified that mistake to the fairest way possible, which is pulling names from a hat.

If school regularly choose trips that cannot accommodate the full class, then putting in a hat is the fairest way. Perhaps the children who went on the last trip only enter the hat if there is still spaces available, that way all children may then get the opportunity to attend an out of school activity.

Crazycrazylady · 04/10/2023 08:42

I think everyone will agree that the first come first served was a horrendous idea . I think random allocation is the only fair way but in our school they do it in front of the class so at least everyone can see that it's not fixed in some way.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 04/10/2023 08:05

They should arrange an alternative trip for those who miss out on this one.

RoseAndRose · 04/10/2023 08:01

I think it's poor show to have trips that cannot accommodate everyone.

But when they exist, then it has to be out of a hat.

First come first served is unfair - for the many reasons listed here. Tried once when I was at school, and the parents of those on the bus from the outlying villages (who arrived slightly late as that's how LA set up the bus that served several schools) revolted big time, as it meant their DC would have no chance ever. Decision immediately reversed

And yes it caused some chuntering from those who had been early and organised, but was the right decision.

OP: you explain it to him exactly as you would have explained it if you were one of the ones who returned the form bright and early but not quite early enough. You never had a place, can't be sure you might have done in other circs, so you just tell DC and you all move on.

sockarefootwear · 04/10/2023 07:54

Worriedaandconfused · 03/10/2023 15:06

@PrincessHoneysuckle, I’m interested to know if anyone ever complained and if the school found a fairer alternative?

As PPs have pointed out, drawing names out of a hat can be just as unfair if it’s the same names all of the time. I would really like to suggest an alternative way of allocating places if they aren’t willing to offer to only one class so all the children are given the opportunity to attend.

We had this a couple of times at my DC school. The letters always said FCFS but if the trip was oversubscribed there was always a follow up letter to say that names would be drawn out of a hat. I don't know if this was to make it fairer to those who were not in a position to get their slips in immediately, or (more likely) just that the slips were all collected together and no record made of when each one was handed in. After DD and a few of her friends missed out several times and other groups of children seemed to always get a place, a few parents spoke to the school and it was agreed that children who missed applied for one trip but missed out would be given priority on the next trip they applied for.

BusyMum47 · 04/10/2023 07:48

@Worriedaandconfused
Bloody hell - that's a dreadful (& rare!) approach for a Primary School to take!

Secondary School is often limited numbers, 1st come &/or names from hat etc which is fine - not all kids want the trips, they're more resilient to cope if not chosen & don't feel left out if they don't go as there are loads that don't.

But Primary?? Wow. That should be inclusive - particularly at age 4!! I work in a Primary School & I've never heard of trips being organised that way. It's either all or none. And if it's limited tickets to something, they're allocated to a particular year/class & the kids get their chance to go when they're in that year/class. End of!

3luckystars · 04/10/2023 07:46

She just gave the money to the principal/teacher and let them sort out who needs it. I’d have done it that way anyway.

LargeglassofRosePlease · 04/10/2023 07:38

grass67 · 03/10/2023 17:32

OP, I say this in the kindest way possible, but I think you need an intervention in primary school etiquette. it will save you a whole load of stress and upset. There were too many applicants, and as a pp poster suggested the forms went out electrically a day before, so you weren't first. School choose to "out of a hat" you just have to roll with it.
Is it fair? no do I trust school? no but accepting how shitty school is will save you 6 plus years of anxiety. Start a thread on shitty primary school experiences ...that will include..poorly behaved children getting star of the week ( done to encourage child to be nice) Governors children being house captains etc etc

But I urge to you understand that parents who really want their children to come first (i was one, a SAHM) will be advantaged, they can fill the form in fast, they can afford to pay the fee...they are not the children on free school meals, who's parents can't afford it ,or do not care. Or the parents who are stuck at work and miss the message. WE all wan't our children to be first, but you need to manage your expectations and look around you.

I sent extra eggs and craft items on Easter egg day...why?... because I felt strongly for the children who's parents wouldn't or couldn't help. my children remember this more than winning... I also paid for extra curricular activities for FSMC.

Great post.

I know it’s early and I’ve not slept well but what’s FSMC ? I presume it’s for disadvantaged children and sounds ignorant, but how do you know this information if so? That was very kind of you
but isn’t it confidential?
Apologies for poor grammar and English… I am so tired 🥱

Hummingbird233 · 04/10/2023 00:03

I'd be complaining to the school. Why would they arrange a trip that isn't accessible for all children? That's awful.

Is your 4 year old really that bothered though? Mine wouldn't have known what a school trip was at 4 yrs.

What are they expecting left out children to do?

CrazyHamsterLady · 03/10/2023 23:53

YABU. My daughter’s school always used to do this as they simply didn’t have enough staff to take all the kids.

CharlotteBog · 03/10/2023 23:50

Snkt · 03/10/2023 22:49

Why are there limited places? If you can’t organise something for everyone just don’t. Poor performance from them.
I don’t think names out of the hat is the fairest but whatever way they go with they have to stick it out.
I would speak to other parents see what they think and then maybe speak to the school

I think OP said the school was given a limited number of tickets for an event.

Snkt · 03/10/2023 22:49

Why are there limited places? If you can’t organise something for everyone just don’t. Poor performance from them.
I don’t think names out of the hat is the fairest but whatever way they go with they have to stick it out.
I would speak to other parents see what they think and then maybe speak to the school

AliceMcK · 03/10/2023 18:57

grass67 · 03/10/2023 14:08

Trips should be open to all. School are so shit at managing fairness and kids see straight through it, star of the week, parts in school plays, house captains, class reps etc.

My DD once came home appalled that during voting for class rep, almost every child in the class voted for child A (she was peeking out from under her jumper) Child B became class rep. I had to spend a lot of time explaining and persuading her not to disclose this info. It would have caused a lot of trouble!

This happened when I was at school, everyone voted for head girl and boy, we all voted for the same boy and girl, yet the girl no one voted for was apparently voted in 🤔

Grapewrath · 03/10/2023 17:35

I dislike the idealist fitst come first served as it often also comes with a deposit so discriminates against those on a limited income
Also my DD missed out on a really exciting trip as it was ‘first come first served’ and the places were released at 5pm. I didn’t finish work until 6, so on that basis I think a random draw much fairer

grass67 · 03/10/2023 17:32

OP, I say this in the kindest way possible, but I think you need an intervention in primary school etiquette. it will save you a whole load of stress and upset. There were too many applicants, and as a pp poster suggested the forms went out electrically a day before, so you weren't first. School choose to "out of a hat" you just have to roll with it.
Is it fair? no do I trust school? no but accepting how shitty school is will save you 6 plus years of anxiety. Start a thread on shitty primary school experiences ...that will include..poorly behaved children getting star of the week ( done to encourage child to be nice) Governors children being house captains etc etc

But I urge to you understand that parents who really want their children to come first (i was one, a SAHM) will be advantaged, they can fill the form in fast, they can afford to pay the fee...they are not the children on free school meals, who's parents can't afford it ,or do not care. Or the parents who are stuck at work and miss the message. WE all wan't our children to be first, but you need to manage your expectations and look around you.

I sent extra eggs and craft items on Easter egg day...why?... because I felt strongly for the children who's parents wouldn't or couldn't help. my children remember this more than winning... I also paid for extra curricular activities for FSMC.

CharlotteBog · 03/10/2023 16:39

As PPs have pointed out, drawing names out of a hat can be just as unfair if it’s the same names all of the time.

Some school get around this by not adding previous winners to the hat.

Honestly, I don't know why schools make things harder for themselves though!

Worriedaandconfused · 03/10/2023 16:22

@Starlightstarbright2, the school have said, to make it fair, 10 places will be made available to each class (R, Y1, Y2) for the name draw. I just assume that his chances are slim, especially if the children are going to be 'cherry picked'.

I'm still in two minds about complaining. I actually think it will be better received if I leave it for a while or I think it'll just look like I'm causing a fuss to get DS a place, which would probably have the opposite effect (and wouldn't actually be the reason).

@Oiyouoverthere, that's the only reason I'm posting and wouldn't have minded if they'd decided on this method from the outset.

@Iamalittleteapot I'm also a working parent but currently on mat leave. There's lots of things my son will miss out on because of this, I suspect, so I was trying to make the most of being able to get there early while I still can!

@TulipTuesday, how awful!! I hope the money your mum saved at least went on a nice treat for you both. Fingers crossed you get your abroad holiday soon.

@FUPAgirl, wow!! I know trips are generally in demand but that seems crazy! I hope he's got a few more school years left and gets another opportunity.

OP posts:
FUPAgirl · 03/10/2023 15:34

OP I honestly don't know what the best way is. Except maybe not offering a trip that cannot accommodate everyone!

My DC wanted to go on a residential trip recently that is first come first served. The letter always states that you need to go to X classroom at 8am. My other DC were there at 8am bang on and got a place no problem. This DC attended at 7.45 and did not get a place, turned out children were queuing from 6am! Surely this is crazy?? I honestly think names out of a hat would be fairer and I said that with my older DC too as I thought it was unfair on children who have to travel by public transport and so couldn't come there any earlier, whereas we happen to live nearby so the DC walk.

Anyway, sorry OP but I honestly dunno what is best!

TulipTuesday · 03/10/2023 15:30

This happened to me when I was 11, the school trip to France was first come, first served.

I’d never had a holiday at that point (mum couldn’t afford to take all of us anywhere) but unknown to me my mum had prepared for the trip by saving up, as my brother was 6 years older she knew roughly when to expect it, and one kid was just about affordable.

I was one of the first to hand in my form and payment. I was so excited, my first holiday! As one of the poorer kids in my school it was a huge deal to me.

Of course, they changed the rules to pick out of a hat. I wasn’t picked.

They decided to also offer a trip to Wales, I didn’t get picked for that either.

I still haven’t been abroad at the age of 43. I have been to Wales however.

These things matter to kids. They shouldn’t change the fucking rules. I’m still bitter about it now knowing how my mum scrimped for that holiday.

Iamalittleteapot · 03/10/2023 15:24

As a working parent, I don't have the time to login and book as soon as the trip goes live, so I think it is fairer to all to have a random selection, not first come, first served.

Oiyouoverthere · 03/10/2023 15:20

Drawing out of a hat is fair BUT it should have been given as the method of choosing from the off.

They shouldn't have said FCFS and then gone back on it. I appreciate they may have had all slips returned the following day but that was a foreseeable issue.

YANBU to be annoyed they've moved the goal posts.

Starlightstarbright2 · 03/10/2023 15:09

I have only read your replies .. so not sure but you seem to assume someone else will get the place .

I do think drawing out the hat is fairer ..

my Ds once missed out on a trip because it was first come first serve basis . I couldn’t exactly say I need to go book a trip when it was first day of my new job..

my Ds has Asd so it’s hard for him to get it but life isn’t fair lots of things in school won’t feel fair .

my guess is someone has complained .

save your complaints for the really important stuff.