Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS's school trip was offered on a 'first come first serve' basis and is now being drawn at random from a hat

315 replies

Worriedaandconfused · 03/10/2023 11:50

AIBU to think the school should honour the first come first serve basis they initially stated for allocating places on the school trip?

They have, due to a 'huge response' of requested places, decided to draw names at random on Friday.

After promising my child a place and ensuring I handed the form in promptly to the teacher (in fairness, it sounds like a lot of other parents did, too), I'm now going to have to explain to my 4 year old he's unlikely to have a place.

How do your own DC's schools handle situations like this where there's limited places and lots of interest?

OP posts:
TrustyRusty68 · 04/10/2023 13:05

Seems pretty bad planning from the school to have insufficient places for all! But your child is 4! Pretty sure you can just say sorry, you can’t go this time. It’ll be your turn next time. Or do something else with them instead. Guess next time don’t promise something that’s out of your control. Schools pull stuff like this all the time!

Sunandsea26 · 04/10/2023 12:20

Redlarge · 04/10/2023 11:48

First come first served is grossly unfair and literally prejudices certain children from a chance.
My youngests school used to do this... first to pay on app all get to go.
Great if you arent working and can make yourself instantly available to sign up. Also great if you have the money there and then. I had to wait to pay until payday and was basically told, sorry but the parents who paid got the trip/music lessons/afterschool clubs. Needless to say it was the same fecking kids getting everything. All of the time.
They have scrapped it now.

That is so so horrible 😢 not surprised they scrapped it!!!

Mothership4two · 04/10/2023 11:59

Anyotherdude · 04/10/2023 11:41

@Mothership4two IME, splitting hairs doesn’t help. OP told her DC something based on what the school originally said. It’s the school that has changed the rules, so whatever she said, or didn’t, is moot, and the OP is not necessarily at fault for believing the terms as they were presented…

Yes I know I have RTWT. Was just clarifying what you said. Personally wouldn't have promised something that was a possibility but not definitely happening. Not that this helps the OP now.

Sunandsea26 · 04/10/2023 11:52

Agree they shouldn’t have changed it, that’s not fair. I think I’d have done the same as you with my 4 year old but then again you didn’t 100% know he had a space I guess.

Redlarge · 04/10/2023 11:48

First come first served is grossly unfair and literally prejudices certain children from a chance.
My youngests school used to do this... first to pay on app all get to go.
Great if you arent working and can make yourself instantly available to sign up. Also great if you have the money there and then. I had to wait to pay until payday and was basically told, sorry but the parents who paid got the trip/music lessons/afterschool clubs. Needless to say it was the same fecking kids getting everything. All of the time.
They have scrapped it now.

babyproblems · 04/10/2023 11:41

NameChange30 · 03/10/2023 11:55

They're doing a school trip for 4yos and can't accommodate everyone? That's shit. It should be for all of none. They're 4 FFS.

This. I’d consider taking my child wherever they’re going myself or asking if I volunteered for the day could my child come or could we organise a private trip for whatever it is for anyone that wasn’t included. They should include all of course it’s ridiculous

Anyotherdude · 04/10/2023 11:41

@Mothership4two IME, splitting hairs doesn’t help. OP told her DC something based on what the school originally said. It’s the school that has changed the rules, so whatever she said, or didn’t, is moot, and the OP is not necessarily at fault for believing the terms as they were presented…

stayathomer · 04/10/2023 11:32

NameChange30

They're doing a school trip for 4yos and can't accommodate everyone? That's shit. It should be for all of none. They're 4 FFS.

Absolutely this!! So ridiculous-if they didn’t have places for everyone they shouldn’t have organised it

BadgerBeedon · 04/10/2023 11:30

Ever so slightly tangental, but I’m reminded of the time a school mum complained when her child missed out on an oversubscribed school activity. Her reasoning was that because her child didn’t go to wraparound care, her kid should be a priority. (Regardless of the school’s ‘names out of a hat’ approach.) Cos free childcare innit?
That was in reception year, and she’s been ‘that’ parent ever since.

Mothership4two · 04/10/2023 11:13

@Anyotherdude

I don’t think that OP was wrong to promise her 4-year old that she would get the form in as quickly as possible to make sure they would get on the activity!

She didn't though, she said she promised him a place. And now has to explain to him he might not get one.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/10/2023 11:11

BungleandGeorge · 04/10/2023 11:01

i hate these selective trips at any age. Either it’s part of the curriculum and would be wrong to exclude some kids or it’s a jolly and shouldn’t take place in school time. I don’t know why anyone thinks this type of thing is ok. What’s probably happened is the vast majority of children handed them in on the first morning, too many for the places available so they’ve had to change it.

I agree.

My ds still moans about the fact he missed out on a history trip in Y8 to people who didn't do it for GCSE or A level Grin

I also think that teachers can choose who they want "randomly". That said, they can "accidentally" lose a first come first served slip too.

OhwhyOY · 04/10/2023 11:10

I'd be annoyed by this too. When I was 8 my school did a week-long seaside trip and only ever had enough spaces for two thirds if the class to go. The names were selected 'at random'. Yet all of the teacher's pets were selected and all of the more behaviourally challenging (and for the most part poorer) children were not selected, including my best friend. The excluded kids were devastated. My mum and others complained about it as the school chose the accommodation, trips etc so could easily have chosen somewhere the whole class could go. The trip went ahead that year but from the following year they changed the trip so that it was to a different place and the whole class could go. I would definitely complain, even if it is in a gentle 'in future it would be great to do X as this doesn't feel fair '.

AmazingSnakeHead · 04/10/2023 11:09

Everyone should be allowed to go at 4, that's really bad of the school.

Fink · 04/10/2023 11:04

Names out of hat is fairer for everyone: working parents, children who live between two households, and poorer families are all penalised by FCFS. And if it's the parents queuing up to hand the forms in then anyone with more than one child to drop off is also penalised.

If they weren't expecting a huge response, then FCFS could have worked. But if 60 children brought in the reply slips on the first day for a 30 person trip, then how to you judge who was first? There are lots of ways they could have done FCFS which wouldn't actually work for a massive oversubscription - what if parents were expected to hand the forms in as they hand over their child at the door, or children to hand it in as their names were called in the register? In both cases that just means that the people who are higher up the alphabetical order get more of a chance (or whatever order the children line up in), not to mention that if there's more than a one form entry you would then have to judge who was called at what time across different classes.

In short, ideally they should have a trip available to everyone. If that's not possible then names out of a hat is the best way. It wasn't ideal to advertise one system and then have to use another, but that's just what happens in real life when things don't turn out according to how the planners expected.

BungleandGeorge · 04/10/2023 11:01

i hate these selective trips at any age. Either it’s part of the curriculum and would be wrong to exclude some kids or it’s a jolly and shouldn’t take place in school time. I don’t know why anyone thinks this type of thing is ok. What’s probably happened is the vast majority of children handed them in on the first morning, too many for the places available so they’ve had to change it.

Ippagoggy · 04/10/2023 11:00

I think the school should cancel the trip and find somewhere that can accommodate everyone. Maybe the parents can club together to make this happen?

If that fails, then a hat is probably fairer than FCFS. Unfortunately, think the best you can do is use this as a 'learning experience' that sometimes things are out of control and we just have to deal with it. This kind of rubbish will keep happening in life so may as well build up little one's resilience.

celticprincess · 04/10/2023 11:00

I hate first come first served as if your child goes to breakfast club they’re school earlier than the child arriving at normal time. And if they’re off sick that day I’d basically tough luck. Names out of a hat is fairer but I’m surprised at reception doing this. Usually it’s expensive residential type trips that come to names out of a hat. They shouldn’t be organising something for some reception and not all. We’ve had club spaces being first come first served or names from a hat.

Anyotherdude · 04/10/2023 10:51

I agree that pulling names from a hat is fairer, but since it was initially offered on the basis of first come first served, I don’t think that OP was wrong to promise her 4-year old that she would get the form in as quickly as possible to make sure they would get on the activity!
However, after explaining the reason for the change to DC (unfortunately, all the other mummies and daddies did the same), she should keep this experience in mind going forward, and remember that school rules and decisions are as capricious as the teachers who make them!

Wheresmypal · 04/10/2023 10:50

NameChange30 · 03/10/2023 11:55

They're doing a school trip for 4yos and can't accommodate everyone? That's shit. It should be for all of none. They're 4 FFS.

Exactly this. I’ve never heard of such a thing!

WimbyAce · 04/10/2023 10:47

This sounds awful, a school trip where they can't all go is not on in my book.

IndysMamaRex · 04/10/2023 10:42

Not good for the school to offer a trip if all the kids in class can’t attend. I’m make a complaint. Sadly name out of hat seems to be the fairest way I’m this situation but that whole thing could have easily been avoided by the school actually thinking it through

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 04/10/2023 10:39

I’m so glad I’m passed all this. My kids would definitely have missed out however on the ball I was as they were transported in because of distance.
Hat done properly is fairer
but its all awful and no school should be only taking some 4 year olds anyway.

Mothership4two · 04/10/2023 10:37

Sounds like this trip was unexpectedly oversubscribed. Maybe too many forms were handed in at the same time and so the only fair way to do it is a random draw? You might have been envelope number 31 opened and not got a place anyway. I'm not sure why you thought your child would be guaranteed a place OP (and told them) or how they will cherry-pick names out of a hat? Of course all the children should have been offered a place, but maybe in the past not all the spaces were filled on similar trips so they don't want to waste any? I'm sure a four year old would get over being in the disappointed group pretty quickly and, as others have said on this thread, you or a family member could take him along yourselves if you feel really strongly about him seeing it.

Ultravox · 04/10/2023 10:35

First come first served is never a good system. What if someone is off ill the day the forms are handed out?
Best system is to give a reasonable deadline and then names out of a hat.

ILoveCats89 · 04/10/2023 10:34

So if he doesn't get to go, and you've paid, do you get your money back??