Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS's school trip was offered on a 'first come first serve' basis and is now being drawn at random from a hat

315 replies

Worriedaandconfused · 03/10/2023 11:50

AIBU to think the school should honour the first come first serve basis they initially stated for allocating places on the school trip?

They have, due to a 'huge response' of requested places, decided to draw names at random on Friday.

After promising my child a place and ensuring I handed the form in promptly to the teacher (in fairness, it sounds like a lot of other parents did, too), I'm now going to have to explain to my 4 year old he's unlikely to have a place.

How do your own DC's schools handle situations like this where there's limited places and lots of interest?

OP posts:
toobusymummy · 05/10/2023 14:35

Oh my gosh, I'm reading this thinking it was a secondary school trip, not a 4 year olds trip! If they've had that big of a response, they should organised either a bigger trip or a second trip so everyone gets to go. With regard to who should get to go, if it said on the letter 'first come first served' then they should honour that, what lesson is it for the children that the people 'in charge' can change the rules when it suits them? Now I know its only 4 year olds but they do remember that kind of thing!

Imisssleep2 · 05/10/2023 14:23

Out of a hat is more fair tbh but what kind of school offers up a trip that can not include everyone?

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 13:33

@SiousieSoo, I cannot see how a functioning adult can be so judgmental to someone about something so 'trivial'. It's bizarre how triggered you are but a harmless discussion. A woeful attitude to have, you might say? 🤔

And, just to clarify, I got the message from school, felt a TINY bit peeved and decided to vent on MN. It's really not as deep as your making it seem to be. We all vent about things that really aren't much of a big deal, normally in person, where the conversation is acknowledged and discussed and then we move on. Only I've posted on here which has opened a wider discussion for people to share their own thoughts and opinions.

And contacting the school with constructive suggestions isn't a bad thing and just way to hopefully improve children's experience within school. It isn't fair that some kids will inevitably miss out. Obviously it's not going to cause long lasting psychological damage but it's disappointing for them (which I do not view to be trivial or irrelevant). It just so happens that this situation was VERY easily preventable should the school have organised it better.

OP posts:
Mumof2teens79 · 05/10/2023 13:17

First come FS isn't really fair on certain families either. It's just a bad system.

There may be families where parents work late, work shifts, are away (with work/at a funeral even) and haven't had chance to fill in the slip.

One of my kids would lose every letter.....

Often the teachers don't necessarily them out on the same day. Or kids could easily be ill.

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 13:15

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 13:05

@SiousieSoo, wow! This is a massive overreaction on your part. Why do people on this site constantly name call when they and act so childish when they ready something they don't agree with? Have an opinion but please learn how to express it politely. Manners really do cost nothing. I sincerely hope you're not like this is real life. 🙈

Talk of emails to the school, impassioned debates about how upsetting it is for a four year old not to go on the trip, and an over indulged sense of outrage about how unfair this is... I literally cannot understand how people function like this rather than just a shrug of the shoulders and 'that is the way the cookie crumbles'. To me this is a woeful way for a parent to react to something so mindnumbingly trivial.

Mumof2teens79 · 05/10/2023 13:12

T1Dmama · 05/10/2023 12:44

@Mumof2teens79 my daughters school says that although payments are voluntary they don’t have the funds so if people don’t pay the trip will be cancelled.

Yes they always say that...its never happened in my experience because almost all pay, but its still not a condition of being one of the ones allowed to go

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 13:11

@T1Dmama, I was thinking the same as @pollymere's suggestion; offer it to Y2 and open out to other years if palaces aren't filled. I will suggest this to the school (not now as I think it might just look like I'm making a fuss to ensure my son's place) so hopefully future year groups don't have the same issues!

OP posts:
Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 13:05

@SiousieSoo, wow! This is a massive overreaction on your part. Why do people on this site constantly name call when they and act so childish when they ready something they don't agree with? Have an opinion but please learn how to express it politely. Manners really do cost nothing. I sincerely hope you're not like this is real life. 🙈

OP posts:
T1Dmama · 05/10/2023 12:58

the school have said, to make it fair, 10 places will be made available to each class (R, Y1, Y2) for the name draw. I just assume that his chances are slim, especially if the children are going to be 'cherry picked'.

@Worriedaandconfused I would send in an email. Next year they should ensure the ones that didn’t go this year have priority next year… so Atleast by the end of infants they’ve all had a choice to go

SiousieSoo · 05/10/2023 12:50

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 10:27

@MrsRaspberry, I would assume the payments will be returned to the children to don't get chosen. The letter does say payment is non-refundable but assume that's for the parents that change this mind or whose children are unwell on the day and can't make it.

@AllstarFacilier, I think it's quite different when the children are old enough to know it's their own behaviour that's resulted in them not having/attending trips. The children in my son's class are 4 and 5 so slightly different set of circumstances.

@BookSuperWorm, I completely understand that names at random is the fairest way to decide on names at this point, but think that's how it should have been organised from the start so parents know where they stand. It's annoying, as others have pointed out, that they've changed the goal post after the fact.

Then there's the element of R/KS1 parents having an extended deadline to hand in forms whereas KS2 children are still only being offered places for their theatre visit on a FCFS basis.

@Spinet, a few people have suggested on the thread that, at 4, he won't remember the trips even happening so wanted to address that. Only 10 children from each class will be going so the others will presumably will have their normal day as over 2/3 of the class will still be there. As they are in reception, it's usually lots of play-based/explorative activities anyway.

I literally do not understand how people hand wring about non events like this...Honestly get a grip, this is so pathetic in the scheme of things that relate to life and school. A four year old not going on a trip triggering an emotional and lengthy debate is just woeful behaviour.

T1Dmama · 05/10/2023 12:44

@Mumof2teens79 my daughters school says that although payments are voluntary they don’t have the funds so if people don’t pay the trip will be cancelled.

T1Dmama · 05/10/2023 12:42

threatmatrix · 04/10/2023 23:46

Did you read it properly? She said he had a place.

That’s not been said at all

Mumof2teens79 · 05/10/2023 12:36

Worriedaandconfused · 03/10/2023 14:26

@whatnot929, this wouldn’t be the the benefit of all of those families, but children who qualify for pupil premium only had to hand the slip in - no payment was required.

Fortunately for us, we are in a position to pay the costs at a moments notice and won’t apologise for that 🤷🏻‍♀️

Are you in England? Schools (state schools at least) are not allowed to restrict trips based on payment as far as I know. Schools should have a charging policy and while they rely on most people paying they aren't allowed to exclude someone because they can't pay...pupil premium or not

Mumof2teens79 · 05/10/2023 12:33

I have never experienced a "limited" trip for a 4yr old. Primary school everyone could go unless they didn't want to.

At secondary they have limited numbers and have had to restrict. And have switched from first come first served to random allocation (presumably because everyone got in on day 1) and I have been able to explain that to me kids as they are older.

pollymere · 05/10/2023 12:30

I think they should've probably just offered it to Y2, then any spaces left could've been offered to Y1 rather than disappointing two thirds of KS1.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 05/10/2023 11:10

Redlarge · 04/10/2023 11:48

First come first served is grossly unfair and literally prejudices certain children from a chance.
My youngests school used to do this... first to pay on app all get to go.
Great if you arent working and can make yourself instantly available to sign up. Also great if you have the money there and then. I had to wait to pay until payday and was basically told, sorry but the parents who paid got the trip/music lessons/afterschool clubs. Needless to say it was the same fecking kids getting everything. All of the time.
They have scrapped it now.

I think that sort of first come first served is unfair - it very clearly disadvantages a lot of people.

At my (secondary) school, back in the Dark Ages, you took in the form with a cheque for the deposit, but crucially it wasn't banked until later so it didn't matter if it wasn't payday.

What annoyed me about the aforementioned history trip was that we handed in cheques for a "names out of the hat" process and they WERE banked and then the school took it on themselves to use the money for another camping trip which ds didn't want to go on but was "compulsory". I did think that was out of order.

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 10:27

@MrsRaspberry, I would assume the payments will be returned to the children to don't get chosen. The letter does say payment is non-refundable but assume that's for the parents that change this mind or whose children are unwell on the day and can't make it.

@AllstarFacilier, I think it's quite different when the children are old enough to know it's their own behaviour that's resulted in them not having/attending trips. The children in my son's class are 4 and 5 so slightly different set of circumstances.

@BookSuperWorm, I completely understand that names at random is the fairest way to decide on names at this point, but think that's how it should have been organised from the start so parents know where they stand. It's annoying, as others have pointed out, that they've changed the goal post after the fact.

Then there's the element of R/KS1 parents having an extended deadline to hand in forms whereas KS2 children are still only being offered places for their theatre visit on a FCFS basis.

@Spinet, a few people have suggested on the thread that, at 4, he won't remember the trips even happening so wanted to address that. Only 10 children from each class will be going so the others will presumably will have their normal day as over 2/3 of the class will still be there. As they are in reception, it's usually lots of play-based/explorative activities anyway.

OP posts:
Spinet · 05/10/2023 10:01

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 07:34

@stichguru, there's really no need for name calling, is there? 🙄 You clearly haven't read any of my most up to date posts where I explained I never actually 'promised' him as such, but after discussing the trip with him said that we'll let him go. He was aware that we put the money in the envelope and that I handed it to the teacher. So, like all the other 4 year olds whose parents did that, they all think they have a place. Now it's down to us as parents to explain they're missing out and only some children from the class will be going.

And for those who say they won't even notice, yes they will. They're going into school as normal in the morning and will be back by 12:30, so will be able to tell the children left behind all about before the end of the day. 👍🏻

They will notice, of course. Hopefully the teachers can plan something really fun for the few kids at school that morning.

BookSuperWorm · 05/10/2023 09:45

Out of a hat is obviously fairer for everyone, and should have been the default from the start. But it is what it is. Don't get so worked up about it - the outcomes are (1) your child gets a place on the trip and has a fab time; (2) your child doesn't get picked, along with many others I expect so they won't be left out anyway - just part of another cohort of kids that also aren't going.

The school will likely put on something fun in school for those kids that aren't picked for the trip (if it is during school hours) and they will make it fun for all.

FCFS is an awful way of working it. I work FT as does DH and we are not on the playground often as we have to rely on breakfast and ASC. It means things like handing in forms to the teacher is hard for us - we have to hope DS will remember to hand it in following breakfast club, but he's only small and it typically ends up in his school bag for days on end! I equally can't reply to emails to school as quickly - I'm in meetings most of the day, and DH is a teacher so doesn't have access to his phone for his contact hours. FCFS is harder for working families, and families that are lower income and can't commit to a deposit until payday etc.

MrsRaspberry · 05/10/2023 09:41

Do they not ask parent volunteers to attend the trips for year olds so they can accommodate every child in the year group? It is pretty unfair of them to offer a trip if they can't manage to take the whole class. I get some kids may not want to go or parents who can't afford the cost. Are they going to reimburse the parents who have paid if their kid isn't chosen to go?

AllstarFacilier · 05/10/2023 08:29

We once offered trips on a first come first served basis at school, handed the letters out during the day and students texted home and parents brought money in at lunchtime and the end of the day. Some kids whose parents were at work didn’t even get the chance to hand the letters to their parents that night, never mind bring the money in the next morning. And some parents needed to wait until payday to be able to get the cash out. I know they should have said names first, but unless you were bringing the money in on the day the letters were given out, you really can’t rely on being the first handing them back in. Plus when it’s names out of the hat, the school gets some control over who goes which I know some people won’t like, but I won’t run trips now as I can’t trust some of my pupils not to truant and be abusive in school, so I don’t trust taking them out of school. Our school won’t allow us to stop poorly behaved students from attending, and so the lovely kids miss out as I’m not willing to take the badly behaved ones. It’s me that would be responsible for them, and I honestly think some would run away.

Rosejasmine · 05/10/2023 08:22

It’s normal to draw the names out of a hat for popular trips. They should have said a random draw at the start but maybe they didn’t realise it would be so popular. I guess you’ll need to manage expectations and explain to your DS that everyone put the form in early - lesson learned…. Hopefully he’ll get a place on the trip.

Worriedaandconfused · 05/10/2023 07:34

@stichguru, there's really no need for name calling, is there? 🙄 You clearly haven't read any of my most up to date posts where I explained I never actually 'promised' him as such, but after discussing the trip with him said that we'll let him go. He was aware that we put the money in the envelope and that I handed it to the teacher. So, like all the other 4 year olds whose parents did that, they all think they have a place. Now it's down to us as parents to explain they're missing out and only some children from the class will be going.

And for those who say they won't even notice, yes they will. They're going into school as normal in the morning and will be back by 12:30, so will be able to tell the children left behind all about before the end of the day. 👍🏻

OP posts:
CelestiaNoctis · 05/10/2023 01:16

Yanbu because they should all go. They shouldn't organise a trip that only a few can go on.

threatmatrix · 04/10/2023 23:46

Did you read it properly? She said he had a place.