Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s not my fault he didn’t knock?!

486 replies

PottyPet · 03/10/2023 09:31

We’re trying to sell our house and DP organised someone to come and do a valuation today. There was no specified time. At 7.50am, I get a string of text messages from DP saying the valuer was coming between 8am - 9am. We have a 4 week old baby who was up all night and I hadn’t even got out of bed yet. The house was in no way tidy, clean or suitable for anyone to value or view! I asked if it was possible that the valuer could rearrange for later, DP said he could not.

I then start running around trying to tidy the house whilst having a screaming crying baby who wants feeding and a nappy change in between. At 8am I get a text from DP saying the valuer is there (there was no knock at the door, only DP letting me know). I ask DP if the valuer can come back a bit later as the baby needs sorting out and the house is in no way ready. He says the valuer needs to do it this morning but will wait a bit and I’m to let him in.

45 minutes later, I’m still running around trying to get things in the house sorted (thankfully baby is fed and changed by this point)! DP comes back from the school run and goes mad saying the valuer has been waiting since 8am and is very angry and annoyed… except he never knocked at the door! He didn’t knock when he arrived at 8am or any of the duration where he was waiting and getting annoyed. Apparently I was supposed to just let him in when I and the house was ready.

AIBU to think this is ridiculous and it’s the valuers own fault for not knocking?!

OP posts:
Nicknacky · 04/10/2023 19:49

Nanny0gg · 04/10/2023 19:07

But you aren't the OP and you didn't have her surgeon, who she's quite rightly, listening to

Apologies, I missed where the op said she couldn’t do light housework and open the door. ……Oh hang on, she didn’t say that.

Her surgeon told her not to drive. She has not said she was physically unable to do light house work or not open a door, other posters have decided she can’t.

Pablova · 04/10/2023 19:48

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 19:02

Another person who hasn’t bothered to read the full thread. The husband booked the appointment for 1pm. The estate agent put it in for 8-9am. The husband didn’t bother to look at the email they sent to confirm the time and assumed it was still on for 1pm. The estate agents who can’t book in a client properly sent the agent around for 8am. The husband who can’t read an email properly then involves the op in both their cock up, wants her to sort the house and show the man in (who hasn’t made himself known at any point to the op) despite recovering from major surgery, being sleep deprived and dealing with a newborn.

So of all the people involved, no one is perfect but the husband and the agent are both inconsiderate twits who couldn’t arrange anything sensible or reasonable between them.

Seems you didn’t bother to read the thread yourself.

The husband booked the appointment for 1pm. The estate agent put it in for 8-9am. The husband didn’t bother to look at the email they sent to confirm the time and assumed it was still on for 1pm. The estate agents who can’t book in a client properly sent the agent around for 8am. The husband who can’t read an email properly then involves the op in both their cock up,

PottyPet · Yesterday 10:15
Spoken to DP again.

So yesterday, the valuer phoned and asked what appointment he wanted. He mentioned around 1pm. Then an automated booking system gave us the appointment of 8am. DP only saw the appointment at 7.50am
this morning and because their offices don’t open until 8.30am, there was nothing he could do to change it

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 19:47

chalkup · 04/10/2023 19:38

@Gerrataere ok your posts are getting increasingly ridiculous... At some point you have to leave it, instead of twisting yourself into contrived fits of logic to absolve all new mums from any form of fault whatsoever.

Faced with possibly unreasonable circumstances (early last min appointment), she panicked and did something stupid and rude. We've all been there. No need to maliciously twist it into the other person's fault.

It's very typical for EAs and other house-related professions to wait in a car, so take it up with those entire industries I suppose?

Plus, I imagine the EA was also on the fence about physically going up there and knocking (given what he'd been told about her needing time for the baby etc). If he had knocked, no doubt you would have said he was harrassing a poor new mother. You would have said he had already been told she was getting ready, he has no idea how busy a new mother can get, she was possibly undressed... How dare he harangue and pressure her physically, the male bully!!!111

I (as an ordinary guest, am not an EA) would wait in the car too, rather than hanging outside their door like an idiot, if someone told me they needed some time to get ready.

And I have often texted/called rather than knocked – very odd thing for you and others to nitpick about. Who cares as long as the message has gone through? I really don't expect people to be that literal – "you texted that you're outside my door, and I said I'd need a bit of time then would let you in... But then the lack of knock knocks magically invalidated our entire previous conversation"???

Actually if you actually read my posts I’ve said more than once that I think the op should have opened the door. I actually am more inclined to have done what another poster said and told my partner to fuck off the moment he told me to sort the house and open the door, but that’s neither here nor there…

The EA was partially at fault. He was getting second hand information from the home owner who wasn’t even in, had no contact number for the person supposedly in the house and made no attempt in 45 minutes to either knock or contact the actual home owner to find out what the delay was. He was parked down the road as the op has said, so not even in direct view. Nobody is perfect in this situation, but this whole ‘poor agent’ line is nonsense. He didn’t contact the op at all, and she was the one who needed to know if he was immediately outside or not.

chalkup · 04/10/2023 19:38

@Gerrataere ok your posts are getting increasingly ridiculous... At some point you have to leave it, instead of twisting yourself into contrived fits of logic to absolve all new mums from any form of fault whatsoever.

Faced with possibly unreasonable circumstances (early last min appointment), she panicked and did something stupid and rude. We've all been there. No need to maliciously twist it into the other person's fault.

It's very typical for EAs and other house-related professions to wait in a car, so take it up with those entire industries I suppose?

Plus, I imagine the EA was also on the fence about physically going up there and knocking (given what he'd been told about her needing time for the baby etc). If he had knocked, no doubt you would have said he was harrassing a poor new mother. You would have said he had already been told she was getting ready, he has no idea how busy a new mother can get, she was possibly undressed... How dare he harangue and pressure her physically, the male bully!!!111

I (as an ordinary guest, am not an EA) would wait in the car too, rather than hanging outside their door like an idiot, if someone told me they needed some time to get ready.

And I have often texted/called rather than knocked – very odd thing for you and others to nitpick about. Who cares as long as the message has gone through? I really don't expect people to be that literal – "you texted that you're outside my door, and I said I'd need a bit of time then would let you in... But then the lack of knock knocks magically invalidated our entire previous conversation"???

Ryeman · 04/10/2023 19:31

I think ball was in your court to tell him when you were ready. You knew he was ready and waiting because he was already there, outside. Was he meant to knock every 5 mins with a “Ready yet?”.

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 19:23

Why would he knock when he was told she wasn’t ready and would let him in when she was?

Well it seemed more reasonable than buggering off to his car down the road. If I could see someone stood outside my door I probably would have opened it to say come in/sod off. If I couldn’t gather there was someone physically stood outside, didn’t have a number for them and had a baby to attend to, looking out for the agent would be the least of my cares. If he really needed to come in and I hadn’t been opening the door hoping he’d be nearby enough to see me, he would have knocked. But of course if he had any sense at all he’d have realised there had simply been a miscommunication about the time and rearranged the appointment instead of waiting 45 minutes without making any attempt to make his presence known.

The agent definitely showed a lack of initiative and common sense, if I was his boss I’d certainly be questioning what exactly he was doing for 45 minutes and why he hadn’t made any attempt to knock or call the house owner in that time…

Frostyloz · 04/10/2023 19:14

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 19:02

Another person who hasn’t bothered to read the full thread. The husband booked the appointment for 1pm. The estate agent put it in for 8-9am. The husband didn’t bother to look at the email they sent to confirm the time and assumed it was still on for 1pm. The estate agents who can’t book in a client properly sent the agent around for 8am. The husband who can’t read an email properly then involves the op in both their cock up, wants her to sort the house and show the man in (who hasn’t made himself known at any point to the op) despite recovering from major surgery, being sleep deprived and dealing with a newborn.

So of all the people involved, no one is perfect but the husband and the agent are both inconsiderate twits who couldn’t arrange anything sensible or reasonable between them.

I have read the whole thread and still have the same opinion. She’s literally typed that her DP said the agent would wait a while and she was to let him in when ready. The agent was told ‘can you wait a bit and she’ll let you in when she’s ready.’ OP is saying it’s the agent’s fault for not knocking. Why would he knock when he was told she wasn’t ready and would let him in when she was?

Yes, we can wax lyrical about what her partner did wrong and how the agent shouldn’t have offered such an early appointment at short notice, but that’s not what she’s asked.

masterblaster · 04/10/2023 19:12

Just so you know, the estate agent gives you an estimate of the value. You can tell them that you disagree and you want to put it on at whatever you like. Obviously if you suggest an insane value they might not bother with you as a client, but if you think they have lowballed it because the valuer was annoyed with you, add on 5 %.

Nanny0gg · 04/10/2023 19:07

Nicknacky · 03/10/2023 12:27

I’ve had too so well aware of recover. I would say that most (not all obviously) women are capable of light housework and door opening by 4 weeks and the op has not said she was physically unable to do so .

But you aren't the OP and you didn't have her surgeon, who she's quite rightly, listening to

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 19:02

JudgeRudy · 04/10/2023 18:56

Sorry, I'm with the valuer on this one. They had an appointment made with your husband. They arrived as agreed and contacted your husband who let you know. You said Eeek, I'm not ready...husband relays message n he says he'll wait a bit.
In the valuers position I'd expect to wait 15mins, maybe 20 if you poked your head out half way and yelled Nearly there, just getting dressed.
He could have knocked. ...at 810....or 820 but you still would not have been ready.
Tbh though the fault is with your husband who's arranged something at an unsuitable time with no discussion.
The surveyor is the injured party.

Another person who hasn’t bothered to read the full thread. The husband booked the appointment for 1pm. The estate agent put it in for 8-9am. The husband didn’t bother to look at the email they sent to confirm the time and assumed it was still on for 1pm. The estate agents who can’t book in a client properly sent the agent around for 8am. The husband who can’t read an email properly then involves the op in both their cock up, wants her to sort the house and show the man in (who hasn’t made himself known at any point to the op) despite recovering from major surgery, being sleep deprived and dealing with a newborn.

So of all the people involved, no one is perfect but the husband and the agent are both inconsiderate twits who couldn’t arrange anything sensible or reasonable between them.

JudgeRudy · 04/10/2023 18:56

Sorry, I'm with the valuer on this one. They had an appointment made with your husband. They arrived as agreed and contacted your husband who let you know. You said Eeek, I'm not ready...husband relays message n he says he'll wait a bit.
In the valuers position I'd expect to wait 15mins, maybe 20 if you poked your head out half way and yelled Nearly there, just getting dressed.
He could have knocked. ...at 810....or 820 but you still would not have been ready.
Tbh though the fault is with your husband who's arranged something at an unsuitable time with no discussion.
The surveyor is the injured party.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 04/10/2023 18:50

But you knew he was outside at 8! You should have just let him in, he’s not there to judge mess, he wants to see size and layout. You left him outside for 45 mins? That’s ridiculous!

SqueakyRadish · 04/10/2023 18:16

Ok I'm a seasoned avoider-of-people and have done some pretty extreme things in the past. I also hate things being sprung on me unexpectedly, but this is beyond even me!

Your DP told you he was there, and you said you needed a few minutes.
Forty five is NOT a few!

I honestly cannot believe that you didn't either tell DO to let the guy know that it wasn't convenient, or just open the bloody door and say "really sorry, but now isn't a good time, can we rearrange?"

No judgement here about the state of the house or whether or not you should have been up and dressed already... I know what it's like with a newborn.
But it's no excuse for poor manners.

Ladyvgc · 04/10/2023 16:50

Because he wasn't home?? Sorry but if I was visiting someone's house and was communicating with someone not there, and felt it was taking a long time, I'd go knock on the door and just see how much longer to wait - ask the person whose actually going to see me!

partypant · 04/10/2023 16:47

Ladyvgc · 04/10/2023 16:43

I find it absolutely baffling that he wouldn't knock? Did he have religious grounds for it being able interact with you as a woman maybe? Maybe he can only deal with the head of the house and you were to leave the door open and not communicate with him at all?!

Why would he knock. He and DP were communicating and he knew DP notified the OP. Knocking would be superfluous and could seem haranguing.

Ladyvgc · 04/10/2023 16:43

I find it absolutely baffling that he wouldn't knock? Did he have religious grounds for it being able interact with you as a woman maybe? Maybe he can only deal with the head of the house and you were to leave the door open and not communicate with him at all?!

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 13:49

londonrach · 04/10/2023 13:06

Yabu. You knew he was outside. He being kind not wanting to wake up baby. You were rude

If he was ‘being kind’ he would have used his brain to realise there had been a cock up with the time and should have come back later. He should have offered to rearrange and have a better chance of earning a commission rather than wasting his own time waiting around when he knew the op had a newborn and was running around the house like a mad thing trying to get it together for him and dealing with a baby whilst he didn’t even make himself known. I mean an ounce of common sense between the partner and the EA rather than thinking ‘this needs doing right this moment’ would have avoided the whole ridiculous situation.

wayyour · 04/10/2023 13:24

I've lost your earlier post to quote, OP, but I think part of the problem is that you said there that your DP was insisting it had to be done now and wouldn't allow you to ask the valuer to come back at a more convenient time.

In your position I'd have thrown some clothes on and gone out to speak to the valuer to ask him to come back at a more convenient time as you'd only received 10 minutes notice of the appointment. I know your DP said not to do this, but really!

londonrach · 04/10/2023 13:06

Yabu. You knew he was outside. He being kind not wanting to wake up baby. You were rude

Katypp · 04/10/2023 13:00

jamjar3 · 04/10/2023 08:17

Well who else is going to do the school run looks like she was too busy laying in with a newborn while her DP done the school run.

She knew valuers were coming so make sure house is clean previous day not the morning of.

She knew valuer was outside but yet ignored him. I'm sure the full house wasn't a mess she could have let him in and told him areas to go check on first and while doing that she can feed and change which doesn't take long and a quick tidy up in the areas needed.

Shes an arsehole and even she knows it that's why she's here asking.

You crossed a MN line there @jamjar3 .
New mothers are NEVER to blame for anything, regardless of how ridiculous they are behaving.
They inhabit a very special uper plain and have a free pass on any unreasonable behavior for the first six months at least.

partypant · 04/10/2023 12:30

@Gerrataere @MrsMorseEndeavour I use asshole all the time. Not as in an attack 'you're an asshole'. More like 'I would feel like a bit of an asshole if I did that...'

partypant · 04/10/2023 12:27

@Gerrataere I agree with much of what you have said except this..

She knew valuer was arriving between 8-9am but he hadn’t made himself known and was sat in his car.

She did know the valuer was there because her DP told her he was there. The guy probably didn't knock because he HAD made it known he was there via the DP and the DP told the OP.
The valuer knew tge OP knew because the DP got back to him and told him she would be a few minutes and to please wait.

He would have been an arse to keep knocking when he knew the person in the house knew he was waiting outside.

Bluela18 · 04/10/2023 10:16

I don't think you are being unreasonable here. As a new mum with 4 week old baby up all night, it's difficult anyway. For the house not to be ready and you running around whilst trying to look after a small baby sounds stressful. Your partner should have arranged a more suitable time, wouldn't do any harm for him to come by a bit later when you , baby and house were ready!!

Battytriker · 04/10/2023 10:08

porridgedilema · 03/10/2023 09:47

Some of these posts are unnecessarily harsh. The OP has a 4 week old baby, hadn't slept and got a text on the morning while still in bed. None of you remember the chaos and exhaustion of the early days? Your husband was inconsiderate and arranged it for a really silly time, he should have got the house ready for it. I would have asked the valuer to come back another time as it wasn't convenient.

Exactly this!

Gerrataere · 04/10/2023 09:22

MrsMorseEndeavour · 04/10/2023 09:14

@Gerrataere It isn't if you don't go on reddit, been on mn for a decade so used to the actual abbreviations and don't actually use asshole in any sentence ever 🤷🏻‍♀️

don't actually use asshole in any sentence ever

Somehow I don’t quite believe you on that one, but abbreviations and mocking people on them is really not the point of the thread so let’s just move on?