Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take my 3.5 year old travelling for 2 months?

118 replies

travellingwithatoddler · 03/10/2023 07:07

Me and my partner are taking our 3.5 year old travelling around Asia for 2 months split into two trips - one month in January, one month in June)

We’re going to India, Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore, Indonesia and Japan for a total of 9 weeks.

From every angle I have people telling me that I am selfish, I’m only doing this for myself, he won’t remember it blah blah.

Just because he won’t remember it, doesn’t mean he won’t enjoy it at the time! He is a fab little traveller and absolutely thrives on being outdoors exploring new places. I know my child better than anyone and wouldn’t put myself through the stress if I thought he’d hate it! I have also travelled extensively so I'm not naive to this.

My family have actually said that I am a terrible mother for taking him ‘somewhere so dangerous like India’ - we’re only doing the Golden triangle fgs! And we have a private driver taking us from A to B.

Thoughts? It’s actually starting to get me a little bit down, I just want to look forward to it!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Motomum23 · 07/10/2023 08:53

Not at all selfish - I took my kids abroad for 3 months when they were 12, 6, 3 and newborn - the 3 year old was chatting in Spanish to the local kids by the end of the holiday! Gutted he's forgotten a lot of it now but such an amazing experience for them all.

Calc123 · 07/10/2023 08:48

It will be an amazing family bonding experience. There is potential danger everywhere in this world but living in fear and not doing something because of that would be a pretty sad way to live.

I would imagine the naysayers are secretly jealous. I'd be interested to know if people telling you 'you're being selfish and only doing for yourself because he won't remember it' if they ever do anything fun or nice with young kids....because by their logic there'd be no point doing anything apart from sitting in an empty room staring at a blank wall until a child is "old enough to remember" which if course is BS.

Bon Voyage!

AudentesFortunaIuvat · 07/10/2023 02:55

Colourfulponderings · 03/10/2023 07:23

It’s a wonderful experience. You know a lot of small minded, opinionated and bizarre people.

Exactly this. It’s truly frightening how some people’s worlds are so small. To be that well travelled at such a young age does wonders for a child’s wider education - take him and just tell anyone who objects that you believe in offering your child the very best opportunities you can afford. Watch them disagree…

Mitchlou84 · 06/10/2023 13:44

I have been to most of those countries including India extensively.
I probably would not take a small child. The jabs can really knock you for six and my ex partner ended up with an untreatable E-coli infection that he was hospitalised for whilst they created an antidote for him, that was India.
I go and stay in 5 star hotels in India with work and still get horrendously poorly with D&V each time. I wouldn’t put a small child through that

Nurselifex · 05/10/2023 21:13

Take him! Yes he won’t remember the whole trip but you will remember the time you got to spend with him!

RafaThisAndRogerThat · 05/10/2023 14:12

Jealousy makes people say all kinds of crap!

Ignore them and enjoy it, OP. It sounds wonderful.

maxandru · 05/10/2023 13:36

Please don’t listen to people criticising - it sounds absolutely amazing! What a lucky kid!!

CharlieRight · 05/10/2023 13:18

We just did six weeks away from home with our 4yo and I think it was a little bit too much towards the end. Especially with the last couple of weeks being 2 or 3 night stays and then moving on. I got the feeling that he felt a bit disorientated or insecure during that section.

That said I think it was worthwhile for us we made great memories and it pushed us all forward.

Julimia · 05/10/2023 12:53

Ignore it all, just do it , now. Enjoy every minute

Sennelier1 · 04/10/2023 21:49

Your son would not remember Blackpool beach either, so why not take him to India? You, your partner and your child will make lots of great memories - and pictures! Enjoy your travels, enjoy being together ❣️

Mostlyoblivious · 04/10/2023 16:56

Sounds amazing!

Ignore anyone not in possession of your own free will..!

Ange211 · 04/10/2023 16:17

It sounds amazing! Enjoy.

Anna79ishere · 04/10/2023 15:42

The only issue I see it is for you more than the kid. I love travelling and travelled all around had lived in 6 countries before having kids. My husband lived in 10 countries speak 4 languages and still travel everywhere for work. We are not travelling at the moment with our kids as we actually do not enjoy that much. I am sure they will love it and have fun, but the extra planning, the scheduling around them, the fact they really do not walk, are not adventurous in food and need a lot of play time is not compatible with our view of travelling and how we like to do it. I am waiting for the youngest to be 7/8 yo to re-start. i don’t feel like spending a lot of money for experiences which would be half baked due to work around their current needs.
but if you are ok with it and enjoy it, I can’t see why not. Or maybe your kid is super easy and actually really does not need any change of your plan.
I feel you are less selfish for willing to travel with a small kid, not more, for the amount of accommodating you will need to make (depending on the kid obvs!)

Bumbers · 04/10/2023 15:17

That sounds amazing! They will learn so much - much more than those same months at home. Enjoy it! What a lucky child.

RomeoRivers · 04/10/2023 14:06

This sounds amazing! Ignore the negativity, people are most likely jealous; either that they cannot give their own children such experiences, or that a child is going to have the experience when they, as adults, can’t afford to.

We frequently travel with our two little ones (nearly 3 + 1) and have also had some weird comments from family. My eldest constantly talks about the things we did on holiday from up to 6 months ago, so yours will certainly have some memories from it.

Our walls are covered in photos of all the places we’ve been and experiences we’ve had and she loves to point at all the pictures and tell me what we were doing and who we were with.

And whilst I’m under no illusion that trips to the Caribbean are purely for their benefit 😂 DC are both keen water babies, excellent sleepers, love aeroplanes and are happy to try new foods.

I hope you have a fantastic time and take lots of photos!

EaudeJavel · 04/10/2023 12:29

You’re going because you and DH want to go, not because your DS will get anything out of it because he obviously won’t.

he's 3.5 years old, not 3 months old, of course he will!

He won't get the same as an adult will, but they get so much more out of a trip with their parents than a child staying home, or going full time to nursery even.

If the only thing he was gaining (and it won't be) was the early habit of travelling and going to other countries, hearing different languages and trying different food, it would be so worth it.

Bluedabadeeba · 04/10/2023 11:57

This is hilarious that you've got this kind of ridiculous reaction from friends and family. It shows their ignorance of that part of the world AND ANYONE questioning my capacity as a mother based on something like that (actually, ANYTHING AT ALL) would be immediately ejected from my close circle. How ridiculous. Kids are brought up in a million different ways with a million different experiences- who are they to judge!?!

Anyway, I actually LIVE in one of the countries you mentioned - yes with a toddler who was born here!! And it's great. We've not done a long trip with DC yet, but have done plenty of shorter ones (10 days/2weeks) around the area. It's obviously different to backpacking pre-kids, more forward planning involved (we used to rock up and go with the flow) and obviously a bit of a slower pace, but our kid LOVES it too.

Oh, also for peace of mind (our kid is a bit younger), I also always research the closest hospital/emergency procedure/Dengue threats etc! Maybe that's just me being a FTM though!

PM me if you want any local travelling-with-kids suggestions. I'd be happy to help @travellingwithatoddler

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 04/10/2023 11:44

So are you just not supposed to do anything fun with your child while they're young because they won't remember it? Have fun sitting at home twiddling your thumbs for 4+ years!
Even if it was more for your benefit than your child's, as long as its not negatively impacting them, does it matter? We bang on as a society about the importance of maintaining positive mental health, particularly in parents e.g happy mum = happy baby, and as soon as a parent does anything for themselves, they're deemed selfish.

What an amazing experience for you all and even if your child doesn't have any memory of it when they're older, what a great story to be able to tell them! Your family sound like mine where they deem every country that isn't England to be dangerous so personally I'd just roll my eyes and ignore them.

Trakand01 · 04/10/2023 11:15

He’ll have an amazing time and you’re teaching him invaluable life skills. What an awesome adventure for you all. If he’s a good traveller then go for it. He’ll be a more resilient and capable boy as a result. We didn’t travel anywhere like India with our daughter at that age but we’ve certainly made sure to expose her to a variety of different ways of travelling and taught her how to navigate an airport, explained different cultures, experienced different climates etc.

Ignore them all, they’re narrow minded and wrong.

Happilyobtuse · 04/10/2023 10:51

Fabulous idea! You are going to have so much fun and make amazing memories! We travelled quite a bit when my DC was below school age. Covered about 9 countries. Never did 9 weeks at a stretch but it should be fine. Hope you have a wonderful time!

Claraclouds · 04/10/2023 10:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

WhatapityWapiti · 04/10/2023 10:21

I cross posted with your update explaining that you had been to a lot of the places before- that’s perfect then as you’ve done the kid free stuff already and have a good idea of how things work and what will and won’t suit him. That said, if it’s a case of showing him all your favourite places you might be a bit disappointed that he can’t quite grasp how special/different they are, and then forgets most of it in a couple of years.

We’re planning to take DS to Japan and I’m toying with when would be the “perfect” age. My current feeling is about 9.

WhatapityWapiti · 04/10/2023 10:07

I had a 3.5 year old 3.5 years ago, so can recall quite clearly what they are like and also talk to my now seven year old about what he remembers from being that age.

I have also been to all those places as we used to live in Asia. Not with a child though.

My take is this:

He won’t be unhappy while away as they are too young to be attached to “home” or a routine. As long as he is with you he will be happy.

The heat might be a bit hard going for him, but not much more than for you. Air con is very effective if you are staying in non-budget accommodation.

You won’t have any semblance of a routine but that will likely bother you more than him.

He might not be familiar with the food but will probably be happy to try more things than a 4 or 5 year-old would be.

You’ll need to be very careful to avoid tummy bugs, and watch out for him sticking his hands in his mouth after touching things out and about.

He will enjoy the colours, sounds and being in the moment but he will not have any concept of how it is different to home, more “exotic”, an unusual culture etc.

He will remember none of it by the time he is 7.

You will miss out a bit because you have a toddler in tow eg we enjoyed cycling, diving, boat trips, multi day hikes with overnight camping, temples where you need be quiet, hours shopping in markets, beach parties, long lazy boozy lunches and eating in the street perched on tiny plastic stools very late at night. Just like at home you’ll need to accept that you have to do kid-friendly stuff.

However Asians do love kids and he will be welcomed with open arms, no need for example to worry about child menus or people feeling disturbed by him running about.

Have a great time!

Wolvesart · 04/10/2023 09:57

It sounds great and it does not matter if he remembers it or not. Once school starts, life and holidays work around it so it’s great to enjoy this time as a family. We lived in NYC when our DC was this sort of age. He does not remember but does see it as part of his identity.

Caspianberg · 04/10/2023 09:49

@LukesDiner - agree. We also are overseas, and family and friends talk like it’s remote 1910s Mongolia or something. Somehow they are amazed it’s developed country, often with more facilities that they get back in uk.

Swipe left for the next trending thread